Image credit: Isaiah J. Downing - USA TODAY Sports

Welcome to The FAAB Review, the series that looks at FAAB bidding in expert leagues to help you, the Baseball Prospectus reader, with your fantasy baseball bidding needs. Tim McCullough covers the FAAB bidding in the Tout Wars Mixed Draft league, while I cover LABR Mixed and all four NL-only and AL-only leagues. LABR uses a $100 FAAB budget with one-dollar minimum bids, while Tout Wars uses a $1,000 budget with zero-dollar minimum bids.

Tout Wars’ free agent deadline is at 8 pm ET on Sunday, while LABR’s deadline is Sunday at midnight ET.

All statistics in this article are through Sunday’s games.


Sean Manaea $88 (Other Bids: $47) (DET)
Manaea returned to the mound Sunday after year-long recovery from shoulder surgery. He was superb against the Yankees, tossing five scoreless innings with five strikeouts. He was also dominant during his four-game rehab assignment, compiling an ERA of 1.90 with a 0.68 WHIP and 13.7 K/9. Manaea will likely make another four or five starts in September and is worthy of a FAAB investment in all leagues.

Cavan Biggio $57 (Other Bids: $21, $0)
Biggio has struggled during the second half with a .199/.331/.358 slash line, six homers, and four stolen bases. He hasn’t made anywhere near the same splash as fellow rookie teammates Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Bo Bichette but has occasionally flashed the solid hitting skills that he exhibited throughout his minor-league career. He’ll continue to play regularly, but don’t count on him suddenly turning things around after a rough rookie campaign to date.

Nate Lowe $23

Andrew Kittredge $17
Kittredge has served as the opener at five times this season with mixed results. Over his last 15 innings he has compiled a 7.20 ERA with opposing batters hitting .333/.382/.517 off him. He’s not worth adding at this point considering his recent struggles and the way he is used by the Rays.

Jake Bauers $17
Bauers showed little improvement over his 2018 debut season, hitting just .234/.307/.382 this year and striking out at a 27 percent clip. After he hit just one homer in July, Cleveland sent him back to Triple-A for the month of August. The injury to Tyler Naquin opened a spot for Bauers, who will get a second chance to show that he belongs.

Wilmer Flores $15

John Means $11 (Other Bids: $0) (@TB, TEX)
After putting together a good enough first half to represent Baltimore in the All-Star Game, Means hit a wall during the second half. His ERA was a stellar 2.50 at the end of the first half, but his eight second-half starts have yielded a 5.62 ERA that has raised his season mark to 3.55. He has been better over his last three starts (19 IP, 2.37 ERA), but two of those were against the Royals. Means could be a streaming option against the right opponents in September.

Seth Brown $8 (Other Bids: $3)
Sam Hilliard $4
(Other Bids: $3)

Travis d’Arnaud $4 (Other Bids: $2, $0)
After a red-hot start where he batted .281 and hit 13 home runs over just 199 PA with the Rays, d’Arnaud has cooled considerably. Since August 1, he’s batting .259 with just two dingers. Given the dearth of catchers who can hit, it is possible that d’Arnaud catches fire again, but don’t bet the rent on it.

Travis Shaw $3
Abraham Toro $3
Will Harris $3

Mauricio Dubon $0
Dubon has nothing left to prove in the minors, so it’s nice to see the Giants giving him a chance to see some major-league pitching in September. Dubon offers the ability to hit for both average and power, and he could provide some stolen bases. He’ll be sought after to round out fantasy infields next season and could give your team a little boost if you can get him on the cheap.

Tyler Flowers $0


Seth Brown $197 (Other Bids: $90)
In the latest edition of Small Sample Sizes Can Be Fun, we marvel at how Brown’s prodigious Triple-A power (37 home runs in 500 Triple-A plate appearances) hasn’t translated to the majors in his first six games. This is obviously a tongue-in-cheek observation, although Brown’s decreased strikeout rate and lack of walks are interesting to note. Brown is your typical late blooming, left-handed masher, and he’s on the right team to give him an opportunity to run with a job regardless of the lack of pedigree. Brown could play full time down the stretch, although he sat against the last two southpaws the A’s have faced.

Mike Freeman $90 (Other Bids: $1, $0)
We have reached the “I can’t believe I’m writing about Mike Freeman” portion of the season in the FAAB Review. Jason Kipnis was removed from Saturday’s game with a sore right wrist, and an examination by a hand specialist on Monday revealed tendonitis. Kipnis could be back by the end of the week, although it’s possible Cleveland plays it relatively safe, which would mean that Freeman gets a fair share of at-bats. Freeman has been surprisingly productive at the plate this season, although most of the fantasy benefit comes because of an average fueled by a .384 BABIP. Seeing Freeman potentially get a full-time opportunity down the stretch for a Cleveland team in a playoff race is a great story, but one that’s only fantasy relevant in AL-only.

Emmanuel Clase $29

Ronald Guzmán $25 (Other Bids: $8)
Even before the rabbit ball completely altered the game, Guzmán’s lack of big-time power made him a suboptimal option at first base in most fantasy formats. This season, Guzmán took a step backwards and eventually was demoted to Triple-A. Called up on Sunday as part of the Rangers’ roster expansion, Guzmán could see regular action down the stretch, but he remains an unexciting play. There is also some risk that he gets stuck in a platoon or part-time role.

Sheldon Neuse $8 (Other Bids: $4)
Trevor May $3
Meibrys Viloria $0
Jalen Beeks $0 (TOR)
Ross Detwiler $0 (@CLE, LAA)
Eric Skoglund $0 (@MIA)
Nick Wittgren $0
Cy Sneed $0
Richie Martin $0
Marco Hernández $0
Reese McGuire $0


Sam Hilliard $124 (Other Bids: $71, $24, $3)

Travis Shaw $50 (Other Bids: $4)
Barring a September outburst, Shaw is easily going to be the most disappointing hitter in NL-only, based on his average salary in expert-league auctions last March. Shaw’s batting average had always been a minor concern, but his plate discipline collapsed this season and everything went with it. The Brewers finally (and understandably) pulled the plug, optioning Shaw to the minors. Shaw was punishing the ball at Triple-A, and while the usual PCL caveats apply, I do like that Shaw’s BB/SO rate improved in the minors. If he does tap into his power, he’s a sneaky source of value in deep mixed. Keston Hiura’s injury is likely a season-ender, giving Shaw plenty of opportunity in a lineup that has been decimated by injuries—although Mike Moustakas returned from a day-to-day injury yesterday and Corey Spangenberg got the start at second base.

Ian Anderson $35
Addison Russell $7 (Other Bids: $2, $0)
Jairo Díaz $6
Edward Olivares $6
Jay Jackson $3
(Other Bids: $0)
Yimi García $3
Paul Sewald $3
Brandon Kintzler $3
Justin Wilson $1
Travis Jankowski $0
Dario Agrazal $0 (MIA)
Manny Piña $0
Rafael Ortega $0


Sean Manaea $7 (DET)
Mike Ford $1
Mitch Keller $1 (MIA, STL)
Sam Hilliard $1
Victor Reyes $1


Sam Hilliard $10 (Other Bids: $4, $3)
Hilliard is the prototypical example of a player who excites the fantasy crowd while doing little for the prospect experts. Hilliard’s raw Triple-A numbers are absurd (35 home runs, 109 runs, 101 RBI and 22 steals), but in addition to the PCL warning label those numbers also come with a .262 batting average and a 98 DRC+, neither of which inspire confidence. The hope is that Hilliard will play regularly in the Rockies’ outfield, while benefiting from Coors and stealing bases in September. The worry is advanced pitchers will eat him alive, taking advantage of what has been described as a stiff approach that gives Hilliard limited plate coverage and hampers his ability to drive anything unless it’s a cookie down the middle or a mistake pitch.

Seth Lugo $2
Rafael Ortega $2
Yonathan Daza $1
Austin Allen $1
Jairo Díaz $1
Tony Gonsolin $1 (SF)


Seth Brown $2 (Other Bids: $1, $1, $1)
Jake Marisnick $1
Ronny Rodríguez $1
Jurickson Profar $1 
(Other Bids: $1, $1)
Sheldon Neuse $1 (Other Bids: $1)
Austin Pruitt $1 (BAL)

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe