This week we assembled the Baseball Prospectus fantasy crew to gather their ballots for the BP Preseason Fantasy Baseball Awards.  Each writer was asked to give his opinion on which players were in for good seasons, bad seasons, and surprising seasons.  We'd happy to hear your take in the comments.


Derek Carty

Jason Collette

Michael Jong

Rob McQuown

Michael Street

Fantasy MVP (Hitter)

Albert Pujols

Albert Pujols

Miguel Cabrera

Matt Kemp

Ryan Braun

Fantasy MVP (Pitcher)

Roy Halladay

Zack Greinke

Roy Halladay

Justin Verlander

Roy Halladay

Sleeper (Hitter)

Edwin Encarnacion

Edwin Encarnacion

Danny Espinosa

Dayan Viciedo

Chris Davis

Sleeper (Pitcher)

Danny Duffy

Jeff Niemann

Anibal Sanchez

Frank Francisco

Hisashi Iwakuma

Impact Prospect,
Non-Darvish/Moore Division

Jesus Montero

Addison Reed

Jesus Montero

Yoenis Cespedes

Yoenis Cespedes

Comeback Player of the Year

Adam Dunn

Homer Bailey

Hanley Ramirez

Adam Dunn

Justin Morneau

Sophomore Slump

Josh Collmenter

Josh Collmenter

Jeremy Hellickson

Mark Trumbo

Dustin Ackley

Sophomore Breakout

Desmond Jennings

Kenley Jansen

Jason Kipnis

 J.D. Martinez

Mike Moustakas

Most Likely to Disappoint

Mat Latos

Tommy Hanson

Josh Hamilton

Brett Lawrie

Jered Weaver

Most Overrated

Brett Lawrie

Desmond Jennings

Hunter Pence

Ryan Braun (#1 ADP?)

Evan Longoria

Best $1 Pitcher

Ryan Dempster

Philip Humber

Jhoulys Chacin

Danny Duffy

Chris Capuano

Ryan Franklin Award
(Closer Most Likely to Lose His
9th Inning Role)

Jim Johnson

Javy Guerra

Grant Balfour

Joe Nathan

Chris Perez

Most likely to be traded to AL,
breaking hearts of NL-only owners

Andre Ethier

Matt Garza

David Wright

Joel Hanrahan

David Wright

Most likely to be traded to NL,
breaking hearts of AL-only owners

B.J. Upton

Jonathan Broxton

James Shields

Gavin Floyd

Mark Reynolds


Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
What exactly is Homer coming back for? Doesn't a player need to get there before they can come back? Not to discredit his skill-set, but he hasn't put together a full season yet. Maybe the out of options player of the year?
The abyss? Much like Alex Gordon last season
Would Dunn have a shot at CBPOY if he put up a .230/.340/.470 line? I guess when the starting point is a .569 OPS, the answer is probably a "yes" sadly.
So (regarding the 'traded out of league' categories) there are still leagues that force an owner to drop a player who's traded out of the league?--odd. If those leagues still exist and their owners are reading this, may I gently suggest keeping those traded players and ignoring the players traded into the league?
It's not that they are forced to be dropped, but they are no longer accumulating stats for their league-only team. I would personally hold on to a keeper player traded out of the league in the event he is traded back or signs back as a FA.
We still do it in our 20-year-old 4x4 Rotisserie Ultra-based league. We actually like the trade deadline upheaval every once in a while, and over an infinite number of years, it evens out. Sure, you lose a Teixeira every once in a while, but sometimes you get a free Matt Holliday or Gio Gonzalez. The real kicker in our league is that one of our owners last season had these three minor leaguers: CHC Chris Carpenter, FLA Ozzie Martinez, and FLA Jhan Marinez. Two were traded for manager Ozzie Guillen and one was traded for GM Theo Epstein. That owner now has the best front office in our league. ;-)
deadhead - I'm in one of those leagues - NL only, 10 teams as well as a mixed league. the NL only requires a lot more attention as you can't just pick up a solid starting player if someone goes down. I can play the mixed league just picking up whoever's that week to fill an outfield spot which I find a little ridiculous. as for your suggestion, i'm not sure the yahoo setup, in my experience, allows for you to keep accumulating stats in the customized manner you suggest. plus, it's fun, figuring out who might be traded, jockeying for the #1 waiver pick, just like the real deal. I picked up CC upon his trade to the brewers and his second half helped my team a ton. It also teaches you to put a little less value in a player who's, say an aging star at the end of a contract on a team that isn't going anywhere. I don't think I've lost anyone meaningful to a trade, but I've picked up some nice parts over the years
Interesting. I started an league way back when (tomorrow is our 25th auction!), and we keep it at AL-only percentages, in terms of the player pool, but we expand and contract as people come and go. Tomorrow we'll have 16 owners, so we'll use the entire AL plus the NL West teams. Anyway, losing players who were traded to a team we weren't using drove us nuts, so we very early on went to a system wherein you keep anyone who is traded out of the pool, and for the entire season we ignore players who weren't on an MLB team we used on Draft Day. Seems like it would ruin a season for an owner to pay $30 for King Felix, only to lose him in July when he is traded to the Reds, but to each his own. Good luck this year!
p.s. CBS has no problem allowing stats to accumulate for a player who isn't on one of our "approved" teams. If my Soria gets traded to the Cards, CBS still puts his stats on my team's total.