Let’s start by stating the obvious, or at least what should be obvious to anyone reading this at Baseball Prospectus: Joe Mauer is by far the most qualified player for the 2009 AL Most Valuable Player Award. You know it, I know it, even many enlightened sportswriters know it. Despite a few recent rumblings in the mainstream media putting forward a slew of other possibilities, most of them clad in the throwback uniforms of “run producer” and “winner,” Mauer’s numbers are so compelling that even Joe Sheehan has expressed little doubt that voters will get this one right in the end.
I, for one, am not so sure. Mauer’s case is so strong that even the law firm of Sebben & Sebben should be able to successfully argue it. BP readers can be easily wooed by Mauer’s commanding lead in EqA, VORP, and WARP-but those unlikely to sway many actual voters. However, it should be hard for even the casual fan to miss the fact that Mauer is currently leading the league in batting average, on-base percentage, and slugging percentage, clocking in at a robust .378/.449/.635 through Sunday’s action. The last time a catcher managed to win this “Slash Stat Triple Crown”, or SSTC, was… well, actually, no catcher has ever done that before. Only nine players have managed it in the last 70 years, seven of them corner outfielders or first basemen. Clearly, such production from a player at a premium defensive position is extremely rare. So how likely is it that Mauer will win the SSTC?
To get some sense of how likely Mauer is to keep his leads in all three stats, I’m going to stand on the shoulders of giants and appropriate the method Eric Seidman recently used to roughly gauge the chances of Albert Pujols winning the standard AVG/HR/RBI Triple Crown. Eric’s method was to look at Pujols’ current number in a given stat (say, RBI), use his updated PECOTA forecast to determine what his final RBI number is projected to be, and then apply a binomial distribution calculation to determine the chance that each other player competing for the title would wind up with more RBI than Pujols, based on their projection for the rest of the season. Summing these chances for each player and subtracting the sum from one approximates the percentage chance Pujols has of winning the RBI crown, while performing the same calculation for the other two categories and multiplying the three results gives a rough idea of the likelihood of winning the Triple Crown.
The charts below show similar calculations for Mauer in each leg of the Slash Stat Triple Crown. I’ve modified Eric’s method slightly to be even more pessimistic by calculating the chance that Mauer would drop down to the current level of his closest pursuer, not that player’s (lower) end of season forecast-essentially, what would happen if the player in second place continued at his current level. I did this mostly because of Ichiro; PECOTA is notoriously bearish on his ability to sustain such high batting averages, but for this purpose I’d rather assume that he can:
Slash Stat Forecasts Forecast Current Ending Player OBP OBP % Chance of Rank Change Joe Mauer .449 .439 3.4% Drop to .420 Kevin Youkilis .420 .412 0.4% Raise to .439 Total 1 - 3.8% = 96.2% chance of winning OBP Forecast Current Ending Player AVG AVG % Chance of Rank Change Joe Mauer .378 .364 30.5% Drop to .359 Ichiro Suzuki .359 .349 4.6% Raise to .364 Total 1 -35.1% = 64.9% chance of winning AVG Forecast Current Ending Player SLG SLG % Chance of Rank Change Joe Mauer .635 .599 0.7% Drop to .572 Kendry Morales .572 .551 0.0% Raise to .599 Kevin Youkilis .570 .557 0.0% Raise to .599 Total 1 - 0.7% = 99.3% chance of winning SLG Likelihood of Slash Stat Triple Crown: 62% (96.2% * 64.9% * 99.3%)
With such large leads in each category, even using a slightly more pessimistic version of Eric’s calculation leaves Mauer with a 62 percent chance of winning the Slash Stat Triple Crown-the biggest threat, as expected, is Ichiro winning the batting title.
But does winning the SSTC ensure winning the MVP trophy? Given the checkered history of MVP voting, there are likely no guarantees. To get a better idea, let’s take a look at the 15 previous SSTC-winning seasons since the outbreak of World War II and how they fared with MVP voters:
Slash Stat Triple Crown Winners (since 1939) MVP MVP MVP RBI Team RBI Team Player Team YEAR Rank Rank Finish Rank Finish MVP Barry Bonds Giants 2004 1 17 2nd -- -- -- Barry Bonds Giants 2002 1 6 2nd -- -- -- Todd Helton Rockies 2000 5 1 4th 4 1st Jeff Kent Larry Walker Rockies 1999 10 10 5th 17 1st Chipper Jones George Brett Royals 1980 1 2 1st -- -- -- Fred Lynn Red Sox 1979 4 4 3rd 1 1st Don Baylor Carl Yastrzemski* Red Sox 1967 1 1 1st -- -- -- Frank Robinson* Orioles 1966 1 1 1st -- -- -- Ted Williams Red Sox 1957 2 10 3rd 5 1st Mickey Mantle Ted Williams Red Sox 1948 3 3 2nd 8 1st Lou Boudreau Stan Musial Cardinals 1948 1 1 2nd -- -- -- Ted Williams* Red Sox 1947 2 1 3rd 3 1st Joe DiMaggio Stan Musial Cardinals 1943 1 5 1st -- -- -- Ted Williams* Red Sox 1942 2 1 2nd 4 1st Joe Gordon Ted Williams Red Sox 1941 2 4 2nd 1 1st Joe DiMaggio *: Won Standard Triple Crown
Here we see each SSTC season, how the player ranked in MVP voting and in that season’s RBI counts, where the player’s team finished in the standings, and (if applicable) the actual MVP’s rank in RBI and his team’s finish. Since the conventional wisdom is that high RBI totals and playing for a division winner are given disproportionate weight by the voters, including those columns might provide some anecdotal evidence to that effect.
Of the 15 SSTC seasons listed above, only seven actually resulted in an MVP Award. The remainder had one thing in common: the SSTC winner’s team didn’t finish first, while the MVP’s team did. This certainly lends credence to the idea that MVP voters often look for the best player on the best team, rather than the best player overall. With the Twins struggling to gain any traction in the AL Central race, this may be bad news for Joe Mauer’s MVP chances. Interestingly, only twice did the MVP tally more RBI than the SSTC winner-perhaps winning is given more weight than driving in runs in the hearts and minds of the voters.
Recent members of this list may point towards more nuance in the selections of contemporary voters. Barry Bonds was able to overcome second-place finishes, pedestrian RBI totals, and a chilly relationship with the media to win MVP Awards in his two SSTC seasons-all he had to do was log a half-decade of otherworldly production. The bad showings by Helton and Walker, however, indicate that voters have shown themselves capable of looking beyond ballpark-inflated raw numbers. Brett’s 1980 season, when he flirted with .400, was the last SSTC winner in the American League, and a deserved slam-dunk for MVP voters.
On the other hand, the 1979 vote, with Fred Lynn finishing fourth, defies explanation. In addition to the three slash stats, Lynn paced the American League that season in EqA (.343) and VORP (82.9). His 39 dingers were only surpassed by Gorman Thomas, his 122 RBI placed a solid fourth in the league, and he won a Gold Glove in center field. But the voters saw fit to bestow the MVP on Don Baylor and his .313 EqA, earned while spending significant time at DH. Baylor did lead the league in RBI, and his Angels squad managed to win a weak AL West-albeit with three fewer wins than Lynn’s Red Sox, who finished third behind dynasties in New York and Baltimore. Brett and Ken Singleton also finished ahead of Lynn that year-defensible choices, those-but Don Baylor? I guess disco made the whole world crazy.
Yaz and Robby each won MVPs after pulling off the rare “Triple Crown Royal,” winning both the standard Triple Crown and the SSTC for their pennant-winning squads, although Yastrzemski deserves an asterisk for sharing the home run title with Harmon Killebrew. But Ted Williams, as usual, has a story all his own. At what should we most marvel? The fact that Teddy Ballgame led the AL in all three slash stats five times over a 16-year span, while fighting two wars? Or that he never won the MVP in any of those five seasons, despite also winning the standard Triple Crown in two of them? Each time, Williams was beaten by a player at a premium defensive position on a team that finished first in the standings. Losing twice to DiMaggio and once to Mantle is understandable, as is Lou Boudreau’s win as Cleveland’s shortstop/manager in 1948. But winning the Triple Crown in 1942 but losing the MVP vote to Joe Gordon? That had to sting. Williams won an MVP in 1946 when Boston won the pennant, and again in 1949 when DiMaggio was injured for much of the year and no single Yankee garnered enough support. But the message is clear-being the dominant hitter in a given season does not guarantee you any hardware unless you’re still playing in October.
If Joe Mauer stays reasonably healthy and productive for the next month, there’s little doubt he’ll have been the most valuable player in the American League. But that doesn’t guarantee he’ll be the Most Valuable Player. How productive his teammates are over the next month may have just as much say, whether we like it or not.
Thank you for reading
This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.Subscribe now
The opening salvo was from Harold Kaese from the Boston Transcript, who wrote that Williams was jealous of his batterymate Jimmy Foxx (for batting fourth while Williams swapped to third), he didn't like Fenway Park, and, possibly worst of all, insinuated that he had questionable moral character as he did not visit his parents back in San Diego over the winter.
From there things became much worse.
That being said, I think the second half of the article is extremely interesting and Ted Williams' struggles probably highlight the importance of personality/sucking up to sportswriters.
According to this, he has a 63.53% chance of winning the SSTC.
Listed below are the 11 players I simulated the rest of the season for and how many times they led the league in each category. It turns out that Miguel Cabrera won it 19 times out of 10,000.
Player BA OBP SLG SSTC
Ben Zobrist 0 28 77 0
Bobby Abreu 0 5 0 0
Chone Figgins 0 7 0 0
Derek Jeter 10 4 0 0
Ichiro Suzuki 1658 0 0 0
Jason Bartlett 78 0 0 0
Joe Mauer 8135 9490 7299 6353
Justin Morneau 0 0 286 0
Kendry Morales 0 0 307 0
Kevin Youkilis 0 427 239 0
Miguel Cabrera 120 39 1795 19
If Mauer continues his current pace of .373/.442/.622, he will win it all in 9762 of the simulations. If he exactly performs as projected the rest of the year by ZiPS (no random variation .364/.437/.598), he will win 7612 of them.
I also suspect that in the wild card era finishing first is not as crucial to voters as it once was. My impression is that playing on a team that finished well is sufficient--i.e., to be in consideration of an MVP your team has to be in contention late into the season. Sammy Sosa essentially won the 1998 MVP on the basis of the Cubs winning the wild card.
Of course, these are just my impressions. Anyone else feel (or have evidence) that there is a difference in voters' attitudes these days?
Lastly, I find it very interesting (and somewhat pleasing, as a fan) that Ted Williams' legacy has exceeded that of his peers (Mantle and DiMaggio stick out in my mind) who were viewed more positively in their playing days.
During a FOX broadcast of a recent NY-BOS game I had to suffer the Buck-McCarver Campaign for Jeter Annointment. They even argued that Jeter's hard work in going from bad to average on defense (they actually cited advanced metrics) was more MVP-worthy than Mauer simply being great on defense already. And all those replays of Jeter diving into the stands! Perhaps they forgot that wasn't 2009. Where was the replay of Mauer's 2009 gem?
Sorry to vent to the choir here, but Mauer's season makes my jaw drop every time I see what he's doing. Plus, he has better sideburns than Jeter. :)
Guess that means the Twins will need to overtake the ChiSox.
But that inconvenient truth undermines the more compelling narrative that has become conventional ignorance and hero worship. Seems to me that a surefire Hall of Famer doesn't need his reputation burnished beyond reality.
If you want to get all pissy about Yankee MVP talk, Teixiera's the guy to focus on. He's got as much of a case as Morneau had in '06, which is to say he shouldn't get more than a few downballot votes.
After that the next best contenders are Chris Hoiles in 1993 (11th/4th/4th) and Carlton Fisk's rookie year in 1972 (8th/7th/2nd). Hoiles finished 15th in the MVP balloting (!), while Fisk won the Rookie of the Year and finished 4th in the MVP race. Don't ask me how he finished behind Joe Rudi.
Johnny Bench never hit for enough average to be a serious SSTC contender, in case you're wondering.