CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
  
  
Click here to log in Click here for forgotten password Click here to subscribe

<< Previous Article
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: ... (01/02)
<< Previous Column
Premium Article Skewed Left: The Quiet... (12/26)
Next Column >>
Premium Article Skewed Left: What the ... (01/07)
Next Article >>
The BP Wayback Machine... (01/03)

January 2, 2014

Skewed Left

Better Versions of Bad Hall of Fame Arguments

by Zachary Levine


You probably don’t have to do much guesswork to figure out what my Hall of Fame ballot will look like when the staff puts out its hypotheticals. You’d probably think that as a Baseball Prospectus writer and general citizen of the baseball internet, my ballot would be predictable down to that last spot or two, and for the most part, you’d be right. I’m not far off from the consensus saberballot.

As such, I get a little annoyed when I see an outlandish outlier ballot. But I really don’t want to. I want to banter in a space where contrary opinions are well thought out and lead to good, respectful debate, not dismissal and name-calling. To be frank and overgeneralizing, I hold the opinions for the undeserving candidates and against the deserving candidates to be bad opinions. And that could be as much on me as it is on the opinions themselves.

It made me think about whether I am—or whether we as the sarcastic internet are—able to draw any distinctions between a bad argument and an argument that we just disagree with.

So I tried my hardest to come up with some arguments for the other side that I would respect and would see as a jumping-off point for good discussion. You might find these terrible and laugh them all down like you do with those Sunday columns we all hate. None of these is taking a stance for someone like Ryan Klesko to make the Hall of Fame because nobody would ever argue that.

But if I were reading columns against Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens, for Lee Smith, against Alan Trammell and for Jack Morris, to pick a few contrary arguments, I’d like to think I can come up with bits of reasoning I would disagree with but would respect and try to debate constructively.

***

Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens are Hall of Famers. I mean, look at them. You have one of the two or three (or maybe one) best hitters of all time and a top-five pitcher who was voted best in his league seven times. Let’s not overthink this. But here’s what I would like to read from somebody who does not vote for them:

The rest of this article is restricted to Baseball Prospectus Subscribers.

Not a subscriber?

Click here for more information on Baseball Prospectus subscriptions or use the buttons to the right to subscribe and get access to the best baseball content on the web.


Cancel anytime.


That's a 33% savings over the monthly price!


That's a 33% savings over the monthly price!

Already a subscriber? Click here and use the blue login bar to log in.

25 comments have been left for this article.

<< Previous Article
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: ... (01/02)
<< Previous Column
Premium Article Skewed Left: The Quiet... (12/26)
Next Column >>
Premium Article Skewed Left: What the ... (01/07)
Next Article >>
The BP Wayback Machine... (01/03)

RECENTLY AT BASEBALL PROSPECTUS
Premium Article Playoff Prospectus: A Three-Act Tragedy, A T...
Fantasy Article Fantasy Freestyle: My Personal Scorecard: Pa...
Premium Article Minor League Update: Games of October 17-18,...
The Week in Quotes: October 13-19, 2014
Pebble Hunting: The Best Teams Should Make T...
Transaction Analysis: Silverman's Kohn Job
Premium Article Playoff Prospectus: World Series Preview: Gi...

MORE FROM JANUARY 2, 2014
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Crain So Good Coulda S...
Premium Article Hot Stove Scouting Report: Nelson Cruz
The Lineup Card: Six New Year's Resolutions
Premium Article Rumor Roundup: Ubaldo's Asking Price
Premium Article Minor League Update: International Winter Le...
The Week in Quotes: December 26-January 1

MORE BY ZACHARY LEVINE
2014-01-23 - Premium Article Skewed Left: Bobby Abreu, the Phillies, and ...
2014-01-16 - Premium Article Skewed Left: The Historical Precedent for an...
2014-01-07 - Premium Article Skewed Left: What the 1936 Hall of Fame Ball...
2014-01-02 - Premium Article Skewed Left: Better Versions of Bad Hall of ...
2013-12-26 - Premium Article Skewed Left: The Quiet Offseason in Odds
2013-12-19 - Skewed Left: The Company They Tweet, The Seq...
2013-12-12 - Premium Article Skewed Left: A Cooperstown Party Like it's 1...
More...

MORE SKEWED LEFT
2014-01-23 - Premium Article Skewed Left: Bobby Abreu, the Phillies, and ...
2014-01-16 - Premium Article Skewed Left: The Historical Precedent for an...
2014-01-07 - Premium Article Skewed Left: What the 1936 Hall of Fame Ball...
2014-01-02 - Premium Article Skewed Left: Better Versions of Bad Hall of ...
2013-12-26 - Premium Article Skewed Left: The Quiet Offseason in Odds
2013-12-19 - Skewed Left: The Company They Tweet, The Seq...
2013-12-12 - Premium Article Skewed Left: A Cooperstown Party Like it's 1...
More...