Jurickson Profar first graced the electronic pages of Baseball Prospectus in Kevin Goldstein’s 2011 Top-101 prospect list. He checked in at 78th overall, sandwiched between Jake Odorizzi and one-time teammate Tanner Scheppers. By August of that same year, Jason Parks was listing him neck-and-neck with Manny Machado as the top shortstop prospect in the minors, extolling his five-tool talents and confidence, projecting him as a “first-division starter with All-Star appearances in his future.” We all know Profar’s story from that point on. He slotted in fourth overall by the next year’s list, and was a consensus no. 1 overall prospect on the 2013 iteration.

We also know Profar’s story from that point on: the middling (or worse) debut in 2013; the shoulder injuries; the two years off and the subsequent struggles, with the requisite caveat that we don’t really understand how two years off affects a player. With his recent demotion to Triple-A to get everyday playing time and to re-acquaint himself with the infield dirt, the baseball questions that remain are mostly about efficacy, both in terms of player development and roster maximization.

Profar’s struggles in the majors aren’t exactly unprecedented. Many a prospect has faltered when attempting to find their footing, only to right the ship eventually. But Profar’s elevated status, subsequent failures, and overall skill set call to mind one situation in particular, a situation that might provide a semblance of a path forward.


Brandon Phillips wasn’t always the guy who blocked a trade to Washington, clearing the way for Daniel Murphy to be insanely good and also fix Ryan Zimmerman. He also wasn’t always the guy who yelled at reporters because his on-base percentage stunk, nor was he always the Gold Glove-quality second baseman with a good enough stick to land on three All-Star teams. Before all of that, he was one of the best prospects in baseball, the crown jewel of the deal that sent Bartolo Colon to Montreal for Grady Sizemore, Cliff Lee, Lee Stevens, and Phillips. Baseball America ranked Phillips as the seventh-best prospect entering the 2002 season (a ranking they bestowed upon Profar prior to the 2012 season).

Dat Dude got an extended trial in 2003 for Cleveland, compiling a 48 OPS+ over nearly 400 plate appearances in the process. He managed just 12 games in the majors over the next two years. It wasn’t until a subsequent trade to Cincinnati that Phillips re-emerged on the national scene, fulfilling the lofty promise he had shown in the early aughts. The trade that sent Phillips to Cincinnati was a classic Change of Scenery scenario, with Jeff Stevens (or Steven Jeffs or someone) heading back to Cleveland.

Upon arriving in Cincinnati, Phillips dramatically lowered his strikeout rate, dropping from 19 percent to 15 percent. He also increased his walk rate relative to his one full season by 2.5 percentage points. Along with a more measured approach at the plate, Phillips began to convert his infield fly-ball rate (popups) into line drives and ground balls, while shaving his fly-ball rate slightly. This new mix of batted ball profile suited his ability to run quite well, allowing him to take advantage of the sheer number of balls he put into play. He got better.

Sometimes we need a blank slate, an environment where people err on the side of our positive qualities rather than homing in on the smaller negatives they’ve come to know over the course of years. Sometimes we need a coach who speaks our language (literally or metaphorically), or sometimes we need the realization that we’re the problem more than our circumstance, and thus should listen to the next voice in our ear. Sometimes we need to get the hell out of Northern Ohio. Any one of these is a plausible explanation for why Phillips was able to refine his approach at the plate, allowing his talent to surface in Cincinnati rather than in Cleveland.

My suspicion is that if asked, Phillips himself would provide a narrative along the lines of one of the options mentioned above. But that’s a funny thing about people: when asked to engage in counterfactual thinking—how something might have turned out differently than it did—we tend to imbue the events that took place with additional meaning. In Superforecasting, author Phillip Tetlock discusses an experiment he did with psychologist Laura Kray, wherein the subjects were asked to think of a turning point in their lives. Half of this group were asked to consider how their lives would be now if that point had not occurred. “All participants then judged the degree to which the turning point was a ‘product of fate.’ As expected, those who had contemplated alternative paths in life saw the path taken as meant to be.”

So when we ask Brandon Phillips or any other player who gets traded prior to experiencing a breakout about what unlocked their talent, we’re asking them to engage in counterfactual thinking, and thus, naturally, an emphasis is placed on the fact that they were traded (or cut, or sent to the minors, or what have you) as a crucial part of their success story. We have seen and heard so many of these stories that it can be easy to ascribe this transition as a solution for a struggling player in a similar circumstance.

It’s so simple to look at Jurickson Profar and all his similarities to Brandon Phillips and say: what worked for one might well work for the other—perhaps Profar needs a new voice in his ear, a new backdrop for his success, or a different kind of adversity. But we should also remember that just because Phillips’ story played out the way it did doesn’t mean that it was fated to do so, nor that the trade (or the ensuing changes) was the actual catalyst in finding success. Tetlock goes on to quote economist and Nobel Laureate Robert Shiller saying: “You tend to believe that history played out in a logical sort of sense, that people ought to have foreseen, but it’s not like that. It’s an illusion of hindsight.”


I originally conceived of the idea to write about Profar and Phillips as a means to highlight their similar predicaments and then to suggest that maybe, possibly, Profar could use a change of scenery to jumpstart his once-promising career. But I shouldn’t parade the illusion of hindsight for one individual around like it’s foresight for another.

We know that something worked for Phillips because we saw it unfold before our eyes. We don’t know if that something was the trade, maturing as a person and player, getting more sleep, standing somewhere else in the box, or something else entirely. We don’t know the other ways in which he might have achieved success or experienced failure, so we tend to discount them, when they were just as possible as the events we saw. A probabilistic approach would note that Profar has a great many paths that end in success, either in Texas or elsewhere, on the basis of the core materials at his disposal: talent, work ethic, and so on, and less so due to the background or locational circumstances. There’s every chance that Profar finds success in Arlington.

There’s also every chance that Profar finds failure if he’s dealt. Put another way: I mentioned the Phillips comparison to Jeffrey Paternostro. “Sure,” he said.

“He could also be, like, Gordon Beckham.”

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
You'd be hard pressed to come up with a worse development path for a player than the one the Texas Rangers did for Profar. Bringing him up at 20 with ~700 ABs above high-A ball, having him learn three (!) new positions while expecting him to adjust to ML pitching, then after losing him for two years to a shoulder injury, throwing him right back into the majors without a position or regular at bats.

Add to that the fact Profar doesn't have the hitting profile for left field -- where the Rangers seemed to want him to stick -- which added to the perception that he is a disappointment as a player. He's an above-average fielder at short and second, where he doesn't need to hit 20 homers to add value.

In Round Rock, he's hitting .295/.367/.443 and playing shortstop every day.

I hope for Profar's sake he eventually finds an organization that'll play him at short and give him at bats. He's suck a likable player...

Er...."such a likable player." Freudian slip?
Based on the incredible lack of range of Odor, I'd argue Texas has an opening at 2B.
Profar was on fire early last year when they let him play, but he was off an awful long time...Flaws became exposed, but I still think he's got plenty of ability. Odor made 23 errors at 2B last year if memory serves and that's really hard to do. His free swinging punch first and ask questions later tendencies are catching up to him it would appear, but he too, is very young. Maybe Profar does need a change of scenery, but I'm not counting on Texas to provide it. They'll hold him at Triple A, with the occasional promotion, until he's past his prime I'd wager...They would rather do that than look bad on a deal involving him after all the hype. He's been handled miserably and Texas is boxed in between Odor's 33 homers and the Andrus contract. they say LF or bust, but then they bring back Gomez, fool around with Choo once in awhile, play Rua & Deshields and have no real room for Gallo when Beltre gets back. I'd liken the Profar situation to trying to trade with a fellow fantasy player who has no injuries and no glaring needs. Texas is relatively deep, but what can Profar actually get you with his stock a tad low? A back end bullpen guy? A 4th starter? They just have to let him play down there and hope he makes some noise, but my guess is even if he does it'll take an injury to Andrus or Odor to find space for another real trial at the big league level. As a fantasy player, if and when he plays everyday & hits, he's gold with all the new found position eligibility...I'm not giving up on him, but I'm pessimistic Texas will ever free him up for trade...
Perhaps, Profar's disappointing career so far boils down to a bum shoulder. It is a complex part of the body and very necessary for playing good baseball. Many players never get back to their previous or expected abilities after a serious shoulder injury.