As some of you know, the ToutWars
experts’ rotisserie league held its NL auction on Saturday at New York’s
All-Star Cafe. The 14-team league completed its entire auction in a mere
six hours, thanks to some speedy auctioneering by Mike Bikales, and by
ignoring basic biological necessities for most of the proceedings. The
auction produced a few interesting results worth reviewing for those who
still have auctions to face, or who are pondering new strategies for
next year. (For full rosters, see the
ToutWars Web site.)

  • Top-heavy salaries

    The most significant trend, a continuation of one seen in the AL auction
    from earlier last week, was the high price tag put on marquee roto
    players. A number of $30-$40 prices seemed to exceed reasonable
    projections of the players’ stats: Mike Piazza $41, Mark McGwire $40,
    Matt Williams $31, Sammy Sosa $37, and Curt Schilling $31. Even Ray
    will have a tough time meeting the $35 price tag.

    The inflation even trickled down to second-tier players: Ron Gant $27,
    Rick Reed and Ramon Martinez $19 each, JT Snow $22, and Willie Greene
    (on the BP team) $19. Ellis Burks‘ $27 price tag seems like irrational
    exuberance, as he’s hardly a lock to play 120 games in any given season.

    The likely cause: the tight roto to real ratio (14 owners and 16 NL
    teams = (14*23)/(16*25) = 80.5%) caused people to value "guaranteed"
    statistics very highly, as everyone was going to have to fill the back
    ends of their rosters with "maybes" and "couldas."

  • The fight for playing time

    A second cause of the top-heavy salaries is the paucity of playing time.
    While a tight player pool makes stars more valuable, it also makes guys
    with guaranteed regular jobs valuable, driving up prices for Greene,
    John Jaha ($21 despite the injury risk), Derek Bell ($26), Rico Brogna
    ($16), and Devon White ($16). Given the market, these prices aren’t as
    high as you might think.

    The ramification of the outlays for full-timers is that owners who went
    for playing time gave up on saves – and vice versa:

    Owner			hitters		Closers
    Moyer			11		0
    Zwilling/Melnick	11		0
    Chaby			10		0
    Shandler		9		1
    Faulkner		9		1
    Kulik			9		2
    Law			9		2
    Zipay			8		1
    Patton/Kreutzer		8		2
    Olkin			7		2
    Vogel/Carter		7		1
    Mayo			6		1
    McGee			6		1
    Coleman			6		2

    Obviously, the cost of getting those 10th and 11th hitters with playing
    time forced the owners in question to make a choice between punting wins or
    punting saves. Steve Moyer spent $82 on seven starters; Irwin
    and Lenny Melnick spent $57 on seven starters, $48 on their
    front three (Ramon, Joey Hamilton, Bobby Jones); and Al Chaby spent $70 on
    eight starters, including $44 on his front three.

  • No "whole bullpen" strategies

    With all the NL closer situations that are up in the air, or threaten to
    be so during the season, I expected one or two owners to grab a closer
    plus the likely heir(s) to the job should their closer falter. I was
    wrong. The owners of Rod Beck, Jeff Brantley, Jay Powell, Antonio Osuna,
    Rich Loiselle, and Doug Jones each passed on Terry Adams, John
    , Oscar Henriquez, Scott Radinsky, Ricardo Rincon, and Bob
    . The risk in the whole bullpen strategy is high, as one Hipolito
    can put all your money down the toilet, and the fact that six
    roto experts all passed on the strategy tells me that it’s probably not
    the best of moves.

  • Those damn catchers

    The following catchers went for more than $1: Kelly Stinnett, Tyler
    , Greg Zaun, Bobby Hughes, Tim Spehr, Bobby Estalella, Greg
    . Part of that is the 14-team effect, but part of it is panic over
    getting stuck with Matt Matheny (property of the New York Post’s
    Jonathan Mayo, God bless him). I felt pleased that I managed to snag the
    100 at bats Keith Osik will provide me, and that feeling was a little

  • The ugly truth: The BP team

    The wacky player values early on cause me to deviate from my "never pay
    $30 for a player" strategy, as I jumped at Gary Sheffield at $30 and Ricky
    for $31. I also wound up in the later scuffles for playing time,
    getting Lou Collier at a punitive $8 and Freddy Garcia at $7 in addition
    to Greene; buying early might have actually saved me more money. I also
    think I’ll struggle to hit .270. Here’s the squad; comments are welcome.
    I’ve marked the hitters I considered "starters" with an asterisk.

    c  Scott Servais*   $6
    c  Keith Osik       $1
    1b Ryan Klesko*     $21
    2b Quilvio Veras*   $24
    ss Lou Collier*     $8
    3b Willie Greene*   $19
    ci Freddy Garcia*   $7
    mi Wilton Guerrero  $4
    of Gary Sheffield*  $30
    of Andruw Jones*    $26
    of Bob Abreu*       $10
    of Carl Everett     $7
    of Brent Brede      $4
    ut Andy Fox         $2
    sp Chris Holt       $4
    sp Dustin Hermanson $4
    sp Jason Schmidt    $5
    sp Kent Mercker     $2
    sp Felix Heredia    $2
    rp Curt Leskanic    $2
    rp Ricardo Rincon   $3
    rp Ugueth Urbina    $27
    rp Ricky Bottalico  $31 

Oh yes – still wondering about the title of this column? I believe that
I’ve only got two players on the old side of 30 – Kent Mercker and Scott
. That was hardly intentional, but as Irwin Zwilling mentioned
afterwards, "You always do that." I guess it’s just the BP way.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe