Starting Pitchers

Openings: #2-5
Candidates: Felix Heredia, Eric Ludwick,
Rafael Medina, Kirt Ojala,
Brian Meadows, assorted others

There are a number of other guys who could theoretically end up in this
rotation – Andy Larkin, Antonio Alfonseca, Mark Gardiner, etc. – but
I’ve only listed the ones that seem to be more than longshots, and
they’re in descending order of likelihood. Heredia has a dual advantage:
Leyland knows him well, and thus is more likely to use him; and he has
major-league time under his belt, which increases his chances for
success. Ludwick has had a few starts in the bigs, and probably has the
highest ceiling of this group. He has the full arsenal necessary to be a
major-league starter, with control of all his pitchers, but was jerked
around quite a bit in the past two years – starter to reliever to
starter, then from St. Louis to Oakland in the McGwire deal. Medina came
in the Brown trade, and while he’s also got a high ceiling, his numbers
were hideous at AAA last year (7.56 ERA, bad even in the PCL), and he
was hurt early in the season. He had a great AFL campaign, so his arm is
probably sound, but I foresee an adjustment period if he makes the
rotation. Ojala is no prospect at 29 years old, but is one of the guys
who should have been helped by expansion – and nearly was, as Arizona
claimed him on waivers but lost him back to Florida in the same manner.
There are perhaps two or three teams in the majors who couldn’t use him
right now: in the last four years at AAA, he has pitched 133-149 innings
every year, with no ERA above 3.95 and none below 3.50 and K/BB ratios
around 2:1. He’s good for at least 150 innings of a 4.00 ERA if he makes
the rotation. Meadows looks like little more than a tweener to me, with
204 hits allowed in 174 AA innings last year and a 4.63 ERA, but I
included him because Peter Gammons listed him as a likely member of the
rotation (omitting Ojala from the group above). In roto terms: Heredia’s
worth $3-5, Ludwick is worth up to $2, Medina and Ojala are reserve
picks to $1 max, and Meadows is not worth your time.

Openings: #4-5
Candidates: Marc Valdes, Shawn Boskie, Mike Johnson,
Matt Wagner, Javier Vazquez

The Montreal Gazette seems to think that Boskie’s out of this race,
which is great news for Expo fans. The latest rumblings out of Montreal
have Vazquez leading the pack, with Johnson likely ticketed for AAA and
the last spot coming down to the health of Wagner’s shoulder (coming off
rotator cuff surgery) and Valdes’ ability to throw strikes. Wagner is
the best roto bet of the group; Vazquez has only 42 innings above A-ball
in his career, and Valdes has never posted K/BB or K/IP ratios to give
me any confidence.

Openings: #5
Candidates: Garrett Stephenson, Matt Beech

This will go down to the wire, according to Mr. Francona. Stephenson
should have earned it, based on his performance last year, but the club
has to give Tyler Green his 85th shot. Beech means more to the team
long-term, but you don’t want to suffer through his growing pains, and
this year is likely to include more.

Openings: #4-5
Candidates: Mike Remlinger, Steve Cooke, Mark Hutton,
Gabe White

Cooke threw 5 scoreless innings yesterday to advance his stock; I love
him as a sleeper this year, as he was solid last year with the Bucs
despite missing nearly two years after shoulder surgery. The Pirates
only cut him for salary reasons; they had plenty of other 5th starters,
and didn’t want to pony up. Remlinger was excellent in the rotation last
year, and will probably get the last spot, with Hutton going to the pen
and White on the bubble. Both of the latter two are great $1 gambles;
they will likely see some starts this year, as the Reds are desperate to
trade Burba and Harnisch and Remlinger are not exactly locks to pitch
well. Jim Crowell and Scott Winchester are longshots in this race, and
Jose Rijo probably won’t show up in the majors until June if he can
still pitch.

Openings: #5, plus Chris Holt‘s slot and perhaps Ramon Garcia‘s slot
Candidates: John Halama, Pete Schourek,
Sean Bergman, CJ Nitkowski (?), Jose Lima (?)

The 5th starter race between John Halama and Scott Elarton should have
been over when Elarton was reassigned over the weekend, but the recent
injuries to Holt and Garcia have created two new short-term
openings in the rotation. Barring a trade, which is the Astros’
preferred solution, the team has several not-so-palatable in-house
options. Pete Schourek has yet to make a ST start, and may not be ready
to start the season in the rotation, but is the best bet they have if
and when he is ready. Bergman has been simply awful in the rotation but
acceptable in the pen in the last two seasons, and is only worth $1 as a
starter because of the ‘dome. Nitkowski and Lima, both acquired in the
Detroit trade of last winter, are interesting cases: both have excellent
stuff, and both struggled badly last year, although Nitkowski’s overall
line wasn’t hideous, just bad. You can’t teach stuff, but you can teach
the art of pitching, and you can fix mechanics, so both of these guys
have upside if the team has a compelling reason to put some time in and
get them up to readiness. Sean Bergman is one compelling reason.

Openings: #4-5
Candidates: Steve Woodard, Paul Wagner, Jeff Juden

Hard to believe Woodard, who made such a great first impression when he
came up last year, has to fight for a rotation slot. All the kid does is
throw strikes and go after hitters – and put results on the board; his
3.17 ERA in the Texas League last year was phenomenal. Wagner is still
recovering from June 1996 surgery, and doesn’t seem to be a good roto
bet–but neither does Juden, who has never thrown strikes consistently
for more than a month at a time. Juden’s a great guy to bid up in
NL-only leagues, where owners will only be peripherally aware of his AL
struggles last year.

Openings: #5
Candidates: Jose Silva, Chris Peters,
Jimmy Andersen, Kris Benson

This race is apparently over, with Silva getting the nod for the
rotation, Peters and Andersen battling Tabaka for the last bullpen spot,
and Benson hanging around major-league camp until Lieber shows he’s OK.
Benson will start in Lieber’s place if the latter can’t go, and will go
to AAA otherwise.

St. Louis
Openings: #5, plus Alan Benes‘ and Donovan Osborne‘s slots
Candidates: Manny Aybar, Kent Mercker, Cliff Politte,
Mark Petkovsek

Aybar and Mercker are the best bets to take rotation slots and fight for
them when the injured parties return, although the Cardinals said when
they signed Mercker that he would be used in a swing role. Aybar is a
candidate for blowout, as the former shortstop faced nearly 900 hitters
last year at age 22 after facing only 630 the year before. Petkovsek is
a soft-tosser who poses a clear and present danger to your ERA if he
gets a starting job. Politte is a top prospect who has only 37.2 innings
above A-ball, and while he’s pitched well this spring, this organization
really has no need to rush him.

Openings: #5
Candidates: Omar Daal, Bob Wolcott, Joel Adamson

Adamson is probably the leading candidate at this point, but all three
are likely to see rotation time this year, as the current rotation
includes Andy Benes, who missed time with an injury last year, Jeff
Suppan and Brian Anderson, both of whom have missed time in recent
years, and Willie Blair, who has suffered through long bouts of sucking
in previous years. Daal is a particularly interesting case, as his stuff
has been praised by scouts and officials everywhere, but he couldn’t get
anyone out last year in either league.

Los Angeles
Openings: #5
Candidates: Darren Dreifort, Dennis Reyes

Reyes is a huge blowout candidate, as there’s a ton of innings on that
arm even if you don’t count his winter ball time. He’s also easy to send
back to the minors, since he’s not as established as Dreifort is. For
roto purposes, Dreifort is all upside, and Reyes has a bit of downside.

San Diego
Openings: #4-5
Candidates: Sterling Hitchcock, Mark Langston,
Pete Smith

Langston is reportedly in fantastic shape, and rumor has it that he’s
locked up the #5 spot, leaving an unusual battle for the fourth spot.
Hitchcock has been maddenly inconsistent for his entire career, while
Pete Smith really won over the Pads’ front office with his stint in the
majors last year. This probably won’t be decided until next week, but my
guess is that Hitchcock goes to the pen to work out whatever ailed him
last year.

Closer and Key Setup jobs

Candidates: Oscar Henriquez, Jay Powell,
Felix Heredia, Manuel Barrios

Powell gets first crack–but he’s not necessarily the long-term closer.
Henriquez is a tremendous prospect who posted an 80:27 K/BB ratio in 74
innings last year in AAA, with a 2.80 ERA to boot. He throws in the
upper 90s, and would allow management to show that the Moises Alou trade
wasn’t just a salary dump, but a genuinely smart move. I don’t think
there’s anything wrong with Powell, but he will get exactly one chance
to fail before Leyland tries Henriquez. Heredia will be the LH setup man
if he doesn’t make the rotation, and Barrios should join the pen in RH
short relief by midsummer.

Candidates: Anthony Telford, Shayne Bennett,
Trey Moore, Rick DeHart

Telford has been miserable this spring, posting an ERA of 15 through
yesterday, although Felipe Alou offers no concern. Bennett is perhaps
one of the more overrated pitchers around, as he throws very hard but
has little indication of the strike zone, striking out 29 and walking 21
in 34.1 AAA innings last year, then following up with 8 K/9 BB in 22.2
major-league innings. At 26, he should have already figured some of that
stuff out. Moore and DeHart have also been bad, with DeHart performing
worse, leaving Moore as the likely LH setup man. I usually like to go
after setup men in the hopes of finding cheap saves, but I’ve avoided
this bullpen entirely this spring.

Candidates: Wayne Gomes, Ryan Brannan

Bottalico is obviously locked in as the closer, but he was nearly traded
to Seattle last year, and is one of the Phils’ only remaining
commodities (with Curt Schilling) that might fetch a grade-A prospect or
two in trade. If he goes, his successor might just be Ryan Brannan, a
’96 draft pick who has already reached and pitched well at AA. He’s
still raw, as his command isn’t all there yet, and he really lived hard
off of his mid-90s fastball last year, so AAA time is clearly in the
cards for him. However, if he succeeds there, he should advance quickly
and could hasten Bottalico’s departure. As for Gomes, he has never had a
season where he walked fewer than 5 batters per 9 innings, and while his
strikeout rates have usually been very good, he still is nothing more
than a thrower who, in 5 years as a pro, hasn’t figured out how to

Candidates: Russ Springer, Hector Carrasco,
Felix Rodriguez, Gregg Olson

The closer job is apparently down to Carrasco, he of the fastball that
goes wherever it wants to, and Rodriguez, he of the fastball that moves
not a whit. Neither is a lock to keep the closer’s job for more than two
months, and any of these four guys could wind up taking it. The setup
man is the real roto value here.

Los Angeles
Candidates: Antonio Osuna, Scott Radinsky

This competition might be over, as the Dodgers just signed Osuna to a
two-year deal plus two club options. He’s clearly the better choice, as
Radinsky has historically been less effective against righties, and
Osuna probably hasn’t finished improving, since he’s just 25. He’s
already one of the best relievers in baseball, and should soon join
Trevor Hoffman and Troy Percival as one of the top closers in the game
as well.

You can send email to Keith at

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe