Last month I started a season-long series (continued here, here, and here) devoted to tracking bunts for base hits with the infield shift in effect; this is the fifth installment. To bring you up to speed on the series’ premise and methodology will take but two brief excerpts. Excerpt one:
Teams are shifting more often; they're shifting not only at higher rates against the usual slow-footed, southpaw sluggers who are classic shift candidates, but also against more marginal hitters whom they wouldn't have bothered to defend before, down to and including Ryan Flaherty; the math suggests that it makes sense for an average hitter to attempt a bunt with third base open as long as he has a >=40 percent chance to get it down; and the more common the shift is, the more worthwhile it becomes for a hitter who hasn't had to do it before to invest the time necessary to become a competent bunter (as extreme pull hitter Brandon Moss did this spring).
More and more teams are getting on the defensive positioning bandwagon. At some point, the batters will strike back, using one of the only anti-shift tactics available.
And excerpt two:
Inside Edge tracks defensive shifts and bunts with the shift in effect, so they’ll be supplying the data for this series. According to IE, there were 40 bunts against the shift in 2012, and 50 in 2013. Of those 90 bunts, 56 led to hits, so you can see why the bunt is so smart: At that success rate, it makes sense for any hitter who can get a bunt down to do so with the bases empty, and the worse the hitter and the emptier the left side of the infield, the better a play it becomes.
And now you’re caught up. I took a break from the series last Friday because the week before had been a slow one in the world of bunting to beat the shift, so today we’ll cover the games of May 1–14, with the list of bunts against the shift again supplied by Inside Edge. We have several new bunts to talk about, as well as the important addition of attempted bunts against the shift and BP intern Chris Mosch’s weekly look at whether teams have been adjusting their defensive alignments against batters who’ve burned them before. How’s that for a hook?
This isn’t an extreme shift, but the third basemen is playing over and back, and Hosmer isn’t a habitual bunter. It looks like he planned to bunt the ball toward third but was jammed by the pitch, which was well inside.
Cabrera has laid down three bunts against the shift in 2014, and he has three singles to show for it.
Reddick is also an experienced shift-beating bunter. Here he has almost half the field to work with, so the only question was whether the ball would stay fair.
Nice try, Brian, but you have to get up pretty early in the morning to get a bunt past Bartolo “Quick as a Cat” Colon. Early enough that he’s distracted because he hasn’t had breakfast.
Given Votto’s much-ballyhooed cerebral approach at the plate, you’d think he’d drop down bunts often, but this is the first one we’ve tracked. In this case, there was a runner on first with two outs, which isn’t the best bunting situation. On the other hand, Votto discovered a new way to make people angry about the fact that he’s more interested in getting on base than recording an RBI.
Just like the last time Jones tried it, there was no doubt off the bat that this bunt would be a hit.
Joyce squared around early and directed the ball right out in front of the plate, which made this look more like a sacrifice than an attempt at a hit.
Bunts against the shift in 2014: 24, 15 successful
Bunts against the shift through this date in 2013: 12
Bunts against the shift through this date in 2012: 4
Those totals aren’t typos: bunts against the shift are up 100 percent since last season and 500 percent since 2012, even though I’ve been conservative on borderline cases. I asked IE’s Kenny Kendrena whether it’s fair to make cross-season comparisons, or whether IE’s charting methods have changed enough to make those comparisons suspect. Here’s what he said:
That does seem like a big increase, but we haven’t really changed anything except for our charting software. The new charting app prompts for a shift entry on every play if one is not entered (even if it’s “none”). The old software did not. I’d like to think we nailed all of the bunt-against-shifts in the prior years, though, just based on the emphasis we place on getting all of them.
In other words, this looks like a real trend.
Recently, Inside Edge reconfigured their software to allow the recording of attempted and threatened bunts to beat the shift in addition to those that were actually put in play. This is obviously pretty important; as many of you have pointed out, looking at how often bunts against the shift in fair territory result in hits tells us something, but the rate at which hitters fail to get the bunt down is also an important part of the picture. Yes, players are batting .625 when they drop a bunt down against the shift so far this season, which would seem to make bunting a no-brainer, but to say so for sure, we need to determine how often attempts come up empty.
From now on, I’ll also be including a list of threatened/attempted bunts from the past week that led to fouls or taken balls or strikes. Eventually, we’ll have a large enough sample to say something about how often bunt attempts give birth to bunts.
|5/10||0||David Ortiz||0||0||6||2||Aaron Poreda||Bunt Hit Att.||Taken Strike|
|5/12||0||Anthony Rizzo||1||1||1||1||Tyler Lyons||Bunt Hit Att.||Foul|
|5/13||0||Carlos Gonzalez||1||1||2||0||James Shields||Bunt Hit Att.||Foul|
|5/13||0||Lyle Overbay||1||0||4||0||Gerrit Cole||Bunt Hit Att.||Taken Strike|
|5/13||0||Matt Joyce||0||0||2||2||Hisashi Iwakuma||Bunt Hit Att.||Foul|
|5/14||0||Matt Joyce||1||0||5||0||Dominic Leone||Bunt Hit Att.||Taken Ball|
I also received reports of foul bunts by Brandon Belt, McCann, and Jarrod Saltalamacchia from the previous week, as well as another fake-out by Ortiz, but those came before IE began to record such events. For those of you wondering about the whereabouts of the two successful bunts by Anthony Rizzo on Thursday: we’ll cover those next week. This week’s batch of bunts runs through the day before that. —Ben Lindbergh
There wasn’t much to pull from the rest of that game, and the next day, he hit from the right side except for one at-bat (which I wasn’t able to pull anything from). I have shots of Houston playing Lowrie straightaway on Sunday, but the Astros tend to align their defense differently according to their own pitcher (and both the shortstop and third baseman are playing straightaway), so I’m hesitant to say it was because of Lowrie bunting. Here's a screenshot of Lowrie doubling down the line in his first at-baton Sunday (you can see the second baseman playing straightaway in the next at-bat against the same pitcher with the bases open).
There weren’t really any shots of the infield alignment during Stewart’s first two at-bats on Sunday. During his third at-bat, there’s a shot of Jeter playing in at third base.
During the fourth at-bat, there’s a clear shot of the infield. The Yankees played Stewart similarly during last week’s series. Here’s a shot from Stewart’s first at-bat on Monday.
Here’s a screenshot of David Freese playing on the grass during Cabrera’s next at-bat.
Freese played closer to the line and almost on the grass during Santana’s next at-bat. With Santana’s history of bunting against the shift, it looks like other teams are catching on. [From the left side, Santana has the highest “pull angle” of any left-handed hitter with more than 20 grounders from 2011–14: 24.0, where 0 is straight up the middle and 45 is directly along the right-field foul line.—Ben L.] The White Sox played against the bunt during Cleveland’s next series. During Santana’s third at-bat in game two, the camera shows Marcus Semien moving back to his regular position after the second strike. Here’s a GIF:
I made a GIF of the cat-and-mouse game between Arizona and Gonzalez. Arizona defends against the bunt to start the next at-bat, but after Gonzalez takes strike one, Eric Chavez moves back. Gonzalez shows bunt the very next pitch and pulls back for strike two.
During the third at-bat, Chavez is positioned on the grass (screenshot below) and stays there until there are two strikes on Gonzalez (you can see him jogging over, but it’s in the background when they’re showing a fan’s sign, so not as great a GIF). —Chris Mosch
Thanks to Nick Wheatley-Schaller for making the embedded GIFs.
Thank you for reading
This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.Subscribe now