FOX Sports' Ken Rosenthal has reported that the Philadelphia Phillies have agreed to extend Cole Hamels to a six-year extension in excess of $137.5 million. However, the deal and the amount of money involved have not yet been confirmed. If and when the extension is announced and/or the contract details are finalized, we'll update this post.

Team Audit | Player Cards | Depth Chart

Agreed to a six-year extension worth more than $137.5 million with LHP Cole Hamels. [7/25]

When Cole Hamels and the Phillies avoided arbitration with a one-year, $15 million agreement in January, the lefty’s agent, John Boggs, told ESPN, “At the appropriate time, I’m sure we’ll have dialogue with the Phillies and continue talking about a multi-year deal.” Months passed before significant progress was made in those negotiations, but with only a week to go before the team’s last chance to trade Hamels, the sides have reportedly come to terms on a six-year extension worth more than $137.5 million.

While Roy Halladay and Cliff Lee have spent time on the disabled list and failed to live up to their lofty standards this season, Hamels has ascended to the top of the team’s rotation, logging a 3.23 ERA and 3.60 FIP. He has thrived at one of the league’s most hitter-friendly parks, and—despite battling injuries during his minor-league career—has proven to be one of the league’s more durable starting pitchers, making at least 31 starts in each of the past four seasons.

Thus, general manager Ruben Amaro deemed Hamels worthy of the second-largest contract ever awarded to a starting pitcher, behind only the seven-year, $161 million deal CC Sabathia signed with the Yankees in December 2008. It exceeds by $10 million the six-year hitch Matt Cain signed to stay with the Giants this past offseason, and combined, those two extensions have thinned what previously promised to be one of the deepest classes of free-agent starting pitchers ever.

The Phillies now join the Giants as the two teams with two $100-million men in their rotations, with Lee in the second year of a five-year, $132.5 million deal signed in December 2010. Halladay is also signed for $20 million in 2013, so the Phillies will pay their big three roughly $65-70 million next season.

That’s a steep price to pay for 12 percent of a 25-man roster, but with Chase Utley and Ryan Howard on the downslopes of their careers, keeping Hamels in Philadelphia could help keep the team’s window of competition from closing completely. With a lucrative television deal likely on the horizon for Philly, Amaro probably won’t be sapped of payroll flexibility anytime soon. —Daniel Rathman

The new Collective Bargaining Agreement tied the Phillies’ hands behind their back. Because of the draft-pick compensation changes, the Phillies had to perform scenario analysis. If they were to trade Hamels, then doing so in the 2011-2012 offseason—when the other team could later net a draft pick—made the most sense and maximized the return. Otherwise, keeping Hamels meant at least one of three things: gaining a draft pick, making another postseason appearance, or hammering out an extension. Ruben Amaro, Jr. chose to keep Hamels and go for the gusto—and who can blame him for that? The result, as it turns out, is agreeing to an extension that will keep Hamels in Philadelphia for the near future.

To call Hamels one of the game’s dozen or so best starters might be underselling him. Since 2010, Hamels ranks ninth in ERA+ among starters with 500-plus innings. That’s behind teammates Cliff Lee and Roy Halladay, but ahead of the likes of David Price and Matt Cain. Hamels is well on his way to a sixth-straight season with 180 or more innings pitched and a third straight 200-plus inning season. He has quality, durability, and a knack for ill-advised photos. What more could you want?

Amaro, Jr. might like some more budget room. Only the Phillies know how much they can spend, but adding another top-dollar contract to the pot has to push them closer to the choke point. Something will have to give, and that something might be a combination of Cliff Lee, Hunter Pence, and others being traded. How the Phillies rebuild their roster is to be determined. Just know that Hamels will remain a big part of the puzzle. —R.J. Anderson

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
I was thinking for a minute there "I didn't realize that Lincecum also signed a multi-year extension over $100 million." Then I remembered...
Haha... Exact same thought process ran through my head!
I cringed while writing that sentence.
Hamels through age-35 season, Halladay through age-38 season, and Lee through age-37 season. Phillies better hope they all stay healthy.
They'd be wise to deal Lee. He looks completely uninspired right now and could really step up for a contender. No point in keeping him if he's gonna sleepwalk through the season.
8.5 K/9, 1.7 BB/9, 4.87 K/BB, a 3.60 FRA and a 3.09 FIP. Somebody please inspire this man!

Unless inspiration = better luck, this is bunk.
Well, as someone who actually watches his games, I see a guy who loses focus and makes mistakes in situations where he normally bears down. That's what I have seen. His stuff? Same. But 5 HR's allowed in a span of 11 batters isn't bad luck... he got lazy. I watched it. Could I be projecting? Maybe. But I don't think so. Additionally, the bulk of his great stats came early and over the past 10 starts or so, as the Phils season went into the tank, he got worse.
Simpler: He was excellent and unlucky to start the year. But since mid May, he's been uninspired. So your statistics, which are for the entire season, don't answer my point at all.
You knew this was coming when Amaro started bloating the payroll a few years ago. The only question in my mind is how many seasons of irrelevance this club is doomed to before Amaro or his successor undertakes a teardown.
Has everyone forgotten that BZ has won 8 games (this year)? Someday BP should do a side-by-side analysis of Zito as a Giant vs. Carl Pavano as a Yankee.
That's true, although Zito's peripherals would suggest that he is actually pitching worse than he ever has with the Giants. More walks, fewer strikeouts possibly masked by a .248 BABIP.
The Phillies are at the wrong spot in the competitive cycle to be dropping approximately 150 million dollars (or one entire season roster's payroll) for an ace through his mid 30's. This is particularly so given the 65 million per year that they have tied up in Howard, Halladay, and Lee for a while yet. All the young talent in this division is on the Nats and Braves, and the Mets and Marlins have more young bats than the Phillies do. This contract is a mistake.