In the fielding chapter of Baseball for Dummies, Joe Morgan relates this story while warning readers of the importance of calling for the ball on a pop fly:

"Whenever you see infielders or outfielders collide on a pop fly, you know that someone wasn't paying attention. I always told our outfielders to yell so I could get out of the way if they were going to catch a pop-up. If you both yell for the catch, you won't hear each other. When I was with the Astros, our left fielder, Jesus Alou, and our shortstop, Hector Torres, were both yelling as they went after a pop fly. They collided and Hector nearly choked to death on his tongue. Make sure that you have your signals straight before each game so you can avoid that kind of catastrophe."

As you might guess, this story kind of jumped out at me. A player almost choked to death on his own tongue after a collision in the field?! That couldn't be true – could it?

It didn't take long to find details on the story. The collision occurred on June 10, 1969:

The Houston teammates collided chasing a fly off the bat of Pirates outfielder Al Oliver into shallow left field at the Astrodome.

Alou started in slowly and Torres hurried back. While the ball dropped just behind and to the side of them, their heads banged and they sprawled helplessly on the Astroturf.

The ball went for a three-run homer and gave the Pirates a temporary 4-0 lead.

[Pittsburgh trainer Tony] Bartirome reached Alou first. Noticing that Alou had swallowed his tongue, Bartirome pulled it out, inserted a rubber hose and inflated the hose.

This reopened Alou's throat and restored a normal air flow into the lungs.

"He looked like he was dead," Houston infielder Denis Menke said of Alou. "It was the hardest collision I've ever seen."

Umpire Al Barlick, one of the first on the confused scene, said "Alou's eyes were turning blue. Those trainers did a great job of taking care of him."

Morgan got the name of the injured player switched, but the rest of his story is right. According to the game report, both Torres and Alou were carried off the field on stretchers. Alou suffered a "severe concussion".

Also on the field was Matty Alou, Jesus' brother and the Pirates centerfielder. Matty played the rest of the game for Pittsburgh before he was able to get to the hospital to check on his brother. Neither Torres nor Jesus Alou played in another game for the next month after the collision.

I've never been one to scoff at the danger of on-field collisions in a baseball game, but the threat of choking to death on one's own tongue has never crossed my mind. That's some scary stuff.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
You know who belongs in the Hall of Fame is that Al Oliver.
2700 hits! 500 doubles! Looked great in a yellow hat!
Also, "Scoop." Bonus points for a great nickname.
I was at this game:

when Alex Cora was diving into 2nd base when his head collided with Tony Womack's knee and he was knocked unconscious. It was the scariest thing I've ever seen on a baseball field. It was absolutely surreal when they opened the center field wall at Dodger Stadium and drove an ambulance onto the field. The stadium was completely silent.
You guys ever see the guys knee snap on that American Gladiators knockoff "Battle Dome" in the late 90s? That was gruesome.
Al Kaline was swallowing his tongue after a collision in the late 1960s when Willie Horton arrived on the scene, and it was believed Willie the Wonder saved the Old Pro's life.