Notice: Trying to get property 'display_name' of non-object in /var/www/html/wp-content/plugins/wordpress-seo/src/generators/schema/article.php on line 52

Some weeks the Stash List is a re-shuffle of the previous version, a low-key graduation or two. This is not one of those weeks.

The Graduates: Julio Urias (Previous Rank: 1), Michael Conforto (4), Devin Mesoraco (9), Cody Bellinger (14), Aaron Altherr (17), Dan Vogelbach (19), Kennys Vargas (21)

This is it for Urias, who will pitch tonight and stay with the big league club for good. He threw 14 innings over three starts at Triple-A Oklahoma City, allowing three earned runs and posting a 15-9 strikeout-to-walk ratio. I expect the Dodgers to continue to be cautious with Urias’ innings and pitch counts, which could limit his potential for wins. His teammate Bellinger got the call Tuesday and surprisingly led off Wednesday night. He might only be up for as long as it takes Joc Pederson’s groin to heal, but I’m not ruling out the possibility that Bellinger thumps his way to a permanent job.

Conforto has started the past four games, homering from the leadoff spot in two of them. Yoenis Cespedes is ready to go after taking the past three contests off to rest a balky hamstring. Lucas Duda reportedly will be ready to go when he’s eligible to come off the disabled list this weekend, which should push Jay Bruce back out to right field. What this means for Conforto, I do not know.

I’m jumping the gun a little with Mesoraco, whose 20 days of rehab are up and should be called up prior to Friday. His .170/.291/.255 line in 55 plate appearances at Double-A doesn’t inspire much confidence in his potential for fantasy impact.

Altherr’s started five in a row and was slotted in the second spot in the order for four of them. He should be a regular while Howie Kendrick is out with an oblique injury. With power and speed and, most importantly, a significantly improved contact rate to date, Altherr might not give up the job after Kendrick's oblique injury heals.

Vogelbach was called up over the weekend and looks to be the heavy side of a first-base platoon. I’m not nearly as optimistic as most of the folk around here, but I do think he’ll hit well enough to keep a job. Vargas also got the call in time for Sunday’s action and has started two of three. With an outfield full of young guys that need something close to everyday at-bats and Robbie Grossman mashing out of the DH spot, Vargas’ path to regular playing time is not entirely clear.

The Dropouts: Archie Bradley (18), J.P. Crawford (23), Raimel Tapia (24), Jesse Winker (25)

Bradley has whiffed only five in his past eight innings, which is a bit of a disappointment after watching him strike out out 7-of-14 batters faced in his season debut. He was passed over for a rotation job when Shelby Miller hit the disabled list this week, and it’s unclear if he or J.J. Hoover is in line for the closer’s gig if the Diamondbacks decide to sack Fernando Rodney.

Crawford always has been a guy with a better-in-real-life tag, and opening the season in a 5-for-56 slump temporarily dulls whatever excitement there was for his major-league debut. The Phillies have no reason to rush him, and it’s hard to make the case for near-term fantasy utility given his minor-league stat line at the upper levels.

Tapia and Winker get pushed out by the new blood. They’ll be back soon. In Winker’s case, he now might be behind Phil Ervin, whom the Reds called up after a hot start at Triple A. I’ve never been a Winker fan and now that the Reds have accelerated Ervin’s timeline, I prefer his power-speed combination to Winker’s empty batting average.

1. Yoan Moncada (2B)—Chicago White Sox (Previous Rank: 2)

Moncada was primed to take over the top spot regardless of what happened with Urias. He’s up to .292/.370/.523 with four homers and four steals. There’s not much left to say here except that Moncada is much, much better than Yolmer Sanchez, who is presently drawing the occasional start at the keystone for the White Sox.

2. Jorge Soler (OF)—Kansas City Royals (Previous Rank: 3)

3. Didi Gregorius (SS)—New York Yankees (Previous Rank: 5)

Soler’s smacked a pair of homers during his five game rehab stint at Triple-A Omaha. No official word yet on when we can expect him back in Kansas City. I’m interested to see how the Royals handle Jorge Bonifacio when Soler is ready. Gregorius is also out on a rehab assignment. He’s 6 for 14 in four games at High-A Tampa and will take over starting shortstop duties in the Bronx in a week or so.

4. Lewis Brinson (OF)—Milwaukee Brewers (Previous Rank: Honorable Mention)

5. Bradley Zimmer (OF)—Cleveland Indians (Previous Rank: 12)

6. Austin Meadows (OF)—Pittsburgh Pirates (Previous Rank: 13)

After slow playing Bellinger because I thought he’d be up mid-to-late summer, I’m getting aggressive with these three high-upside outfielders. Brinson is on a tear after missing a week with a minor finger injury. You should take numbers from Colorado Springs with a grain of salt, but Brinson’s 1.079 OPS is absurd, and he’s stolen three bases in twelve games to boot. To say Keon Broxton and Domingo Santana have been underwhelming so far would be putting it mildly. Lonnie Chisenhall is still starting in center field for the Indians, which is to say that I expect to see Zimmer soon. Meadows has been solid after opening the year with one hit in his first 24 at-bats. Jose Osuna is filling in admirably in Starling Marte’s stead, but let’s be honest. He’s just keeping the seat warm for Meadows.

7. Wilson Ramos (C)—Tampa Bay Rays (Previous Rank: 10)

8. Tom Murphy (C)—Colorado Rockies (Previous Rank: 11)

Ramos has begun taking dry swings. He’s not eligible to come off the 60-day disabled list until June, and I suspect he’ll be out longer than that. There’s not much of an update on Murphy and Tony Wolters is hitting .366/.422/.439 while splitting catching duties almost down the middle with Dustin Garneau. It’ll be hard for Murphy to be relevant in a half-time role. This ranking assumes Wolters will back up and Murphy will grab the larger side of that timeshare.

9. Trey Mancini (1B)—Baltimore Orioles (Previous Rank: 6)

Mancini hasn’t started since Seth Smith shook the minor hamstring injury that kept him out of the lineup for nearly a week. Hyun Soo Kim also has started three in a row after playing sparingly in the first three weeks. Mancini appears to be the short side of a platoon at the moment, even though he hit same-side pitching very well throughout his minor-league career.

10. Jose Berrios (RHP)—Minnesota Twins (Previous Rank: 8)

Berrios struck out 10 over six frames in his most recent start at Triple-A Rochester. I’m circling next a week from Saturday for his 2017 major league debut. It’s the next game for which the Twins need a fifth starter, and Adalberto Mejia was optioned after his previous outing.

11. Justin Wilson (LHP)—Detroit Tigers (Previous Rank: Unranked)

12. Jacob Barnes (RHP)—Milwaukee Brewers (Previous Rank: Unranked)

Aaaaaand we’ve reached the point of the season where I’ll start speculating on a few end-game situations we all thought were solid a month ago. K-Rod has kept a clean sheet in only three of his eight appearances to date, and his fastball velocity is not quite 88 mph. Wilson hasn’t allowed a hit, much less a run. The Tigers probably are considering Joe Jimenez to be their closer of the future, but Wilson could fill in capably if the Tigers decide to move on from Rodriguez. Barnes has filthy stuff and has also yet to allow an earned run, while Brewers free-agent acquisition Neftali Feliz owns a 5.19 ERA. Most of that damage came in one ugly outing, so I don’t think his seat is too hot just yet. Miller Park isn’t an ideal setting for a fly-ball pitcher though, and it wouldn’t shock me if Feliz loses his grip with a rough stretch.

13. Matt Duffy (SS)—Tampa Bay Rays (Previous Rank: Honorable Mention)

14. Lucas Duda (1B)—New York Mets (Previous Rank: Unranked)

15. Brandon Finnegan (LHP)—Cincinnati Reds (Previous Rank: 7)

Duffy is taking batting practice but not yet running the bases. Rays shortstops are hitting .240/.277/.365. As mentioned above, Duda is expected back when eligible. Before hyper-extending his elbow, he showed that his power stroke was back after missing much of 2016 with a back issue. No update on Finnegan since his placement on the 10-day disabled list a week ago. Expect him to be out another couple of weeks at minimum.

16. Jorge Alfaro (C)—Philadelphia Phillies (Previous Rank: Honorable Mention)

Alfaro’s never been known for his patience, but he could probably stand to walk more than once in 63 plate appearances. He’s going to strike out a ton early in his major-league career. He’s also going to hit some balls very, very far.

17. Reynaldo Lopez (RHP)—Chicago White Sox (Previous Rank: 15)

18. Mike Clevinger (RHP)—Cleveland Indians (Previous Rank: Honorable Mention)

Aside from one dominant performance, Lopez’s strikeout stuff just hasn’t been there this month. His walk stuff has. Clevinger hasn’t allowed more than one run in any of his four turns, and he’s struck out eight or more in three of the four. Josh Tomlin has a 9.31 ERA. Just sayin’.

19. Ketel Marte (SS)—Arizona Diamondbacks (Previous Rank: Honorable Mention)

Marte is demolishing Triple-A pitching to the tune of a .438/.471/.525 triple-slash, with three swipes in four tries and an equal number of walks and strikeouts. It doesn’t much matter how well Marte plays, as long as Chris Owings keeps doing what he’s doing in Arizona.

20. Blake Swihart (C)—Boston Red Sox (Previous Rank: 16)

Swihart doesn’t have a hit since the previous Stash List. He has thrown out 6-of-10 would-be base stealers this season, though. Perhaps the outfield experiment is dead and buried.

21. Rhys Hoskins (1B)—Philadelphia Phillies (Previous Rank: Unranked)

22. A.J. Reed (1B)—Houston Astros (Previous Rank: 20)

Tommy Joseph is struggling badly and Hoskins continues to lay waste to the minors. Yuli Gurriel is some kinda hot, which means Reed is some kinda blocked.

23. Amed Rosario (SS)—New York Mets (Previous Rank: Unranked)

24. Franklin Barreto (SS)—Oakland Athletics (Previous Rank: 22)

25. Raul Mondesi (SS)—Kansas City Royals (Previous Rank: Unranked)

I get that people are excited about Rosario, and so am I. I just don’t think it makes sense to bring him up now. The only place where he can crack the lineup is third base, a spot at which he has all of one game of professional experience. Mondesi was demoted after posting a brutal .103/.167/.179 line in Kansas City. He did tally five steals, which is kind of incredible considering he was only on base seven times in 14 games. I’m not sure he ever hits enough to get the most out of his wheels.

Honorable Mention: Ozzie Albies, Jeimer Candelario, Delino DeShields, J.P. Crawford, Ian Happ, Phil Ervin, Francis Martes, Mallex Smith, Raimel Tapia, Jesse Winker

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
Think Zimmer's going to remain on the stash list for the duration of 2017. He's only played 55 games in AAA and has major issues with his K%. Doubt Antonetti will start the clock on a defense-only CF with severe issues at the plate.
I'm also concerned about the strikeouts, but I'd disagree pretty strongly with your characterization of Zimmer as a defense-only OF. He has pop and speed that will be useable in fantasy even if they both play down because of the contact issues.
Alfaro really warrant such a high spot? Thought it was (still) very unlikely for him to see any meaningful MLB AB's this year?

(Maybe Asdrubal's dings keep adding up and Rosario finds a place to play. It is the Mets medical staff after all...)
Yeah, it's a good point on Alfaro. Been having some conversations with staff and others who know more about Philly's situation than I do and after hearing them out, I agree that it's unlikely Alfaro will play enough in 2017 to provide meaningful value. Will probably drop him next week.
Though the K% seems to be right in line (~25%) with where he's been the last 5 stops, 1 walk to 17 K's is also concerning. All that OBP being fueled by a crazy hit rate.

If you're stashing a guy to take over Zunino's crap production- who is it: Swihart or Alfaro?
I'd be stashing Swihart out of those two.
How about Sonny Gray? Do you think he'll be in the A's rotation next week?
Wasn't eligible for the list because his ESPN ownership is well over 25%, but yeah, looks like Gray is on track for a return next week. Threw six scoreless in Triple-A last night.
Asdrubal isn't exactly Mr. Rangy out there at SS. Could the Mets move him to 3B and play Rosario at SS?
I don't think the case for a Rosario promotion is so overwhelming that it's worth forcing him into the lineup. He's not going to come up and save the Mets' season, and instead of rushing a 21-year-old, long-term cornerstone to the majors, I think they'd be much better served to let him continue to develop in the minors. As impressive as he's been in Vegas, we're not even to 20 games yet and he had limited Double-A time in 2016. There's just not much to be gained, IMO.
"Robbie Grossman mashing out of the DH spot" LOL
I'm a little surprised you don't have Corey Knebel as the stash for the Brewers' pen. Thoughts on him? Thanks.
Fair point since Knebel is pitching the 8th inning more often that not. Maybe I'm projected a little too much of what I would do if I was the Brewers. I don't think Knebel's walk rate works in a closing role.