Baseball Prospectus Needs Your Help! Check out our call for contributors!

 Another week, another set of names for Value Picks as we move closer to pitchers and catchers reporting.

Gordon Beckham wowed prospective fantasy owners with an excellent season in 2009, during which he hit 14 home runs in just 430 plate appearances. News that he would be moved to second base from third base over the offseason had thoughts of 20-plus home run seasons from the middle infield dancing in fantasy players' heads.

What Beckham returned was a disappointing campaign. By the end of May, he was hitting just .198/.286/.239 in 187 PA. He had just four extra-base hits after putting up a .190 ISO in 2009. Manager Ozzie Guillen stuck with him, however, and was rewarded with a strong second half performance: Beckham hit a much more appealing .310/.380/.497 with six homers in his final 197 PA before his season ended prematurely with a hand injury.

So which of these Beckhams is the real one? As with all things in baseball and life, the answer lies somewhere in between. In his terrible first half, he had a .255 BABIP, which is unlikely to be his true talent level. In his scorching hot season's end, he had an equally unlikely .370 mark. The full season total turned out to be a reasonable .297, which is a good level at which to place him in 2011; PECOTA projects a pretty average .299 BABIP from him next year.

What will be interesting to see will be the trend in his strikeout rates. In 2009, Beckham punched out in 15.1 percent of his PA, while in 2010 that number rose to 18.5 percent. He may have swung outside of the zone more often and setup pitcher counts. Based on linear weights batting run values determined by John Walsh, I broke down Beckham's 2009 and 2010 seasons in terms of percentage of PA in which he ran into favorable hitter's counts (defined as 2-0, 3-0, 3-1, and full counts) and favorable pitcher's counts (defined as 0-1, 0-2, and 1-2). While Beckham drew hitter's counts at virtually the same rate in both years, he saw more pitcher's counts in 2010 (36.7 percent) than in 2009 (32.1 percent). This perhaps means that, by swinging at a few more pitches outside the zone, he sacrificed more neutral counts like 1-0 (9.0 percent in 2009, 7.2 percent in 2010) in favor of situations more favorable to the pitcher.

Will this continue in 2011? Beckham's hot streak actually saw him strike out more than he did in the first half of the season, perhaps showing that this style of play is more indicative of his true talent. If so, then a .290 to .300 BABIP would net him a batting average closer to .265, and PECOTA agrees, pegging him for a .263 AVG next season. Whether his power returns will then be more important than ever; fantasy players may live with a .265 hitter at second base (likely below average for a mixed-league fantasy second baseman) if he hits 20 HR and drives in above average RBI. However, select him in mixed leagues with caution as a late-round upside choice. In AL-leagues, he remains a likely solid option despite the down year provided he plays a full season and reaches the double-digit HR mark.

Asdrubal Cabrera hasn't changed all that much since he started his major league career in 2006. His 2009 season looked like a breakout year until you realize that it was heavily built on a .360 BABIP that seems unsustainable. He was never much of a power hitter, as his 18 home runs and 4.9 percent HR/FB career rate suggest. The power surge up to a .130 ISO in 2009 was not built on home runs but rather on an abundance of doubles. Essentially, he has been Freddy Sanchez with steals and a better walk rate.

Unfortunately, Cabrera's baserunning game is not terribly impressive either. I was surprised to find out that, outside of his 2007 season in Double-A, Cabrera never stole more than 12 bases in a season in the minors. In his minor league career, he was only 55 for 85 on steals, a mediocre 64.7 percent success rate. He has been around the breakeven point in his major league career (69.2 percent) but outside of his 2009 year, the basepaths haven't been kind to him.

Despite all of this, PECOTA projects a .273/.330/.378 line and 12 steals in 562 PA, which as I mentioned before is more than worth double-digit dollars in AL-only auction leagues. The only question then is whether Cabrera will reach 562 PA. He has only hit that mark once in his major league career, once again in 2008. Last season, he was limited to just 425 PA after a collision with a teammate put him on the DL for two months. He also missed a month in 2009 with a separated shoulder. It seems that Cabrera attracts his fair amount of injuries, and betting on a 600 PA season from him is quite the risk. He does not have enough upside to consider him over the other AL shortstops who are more likely to put in a full season's workload.

Paul Janish is a strong defensive shortstop, and that information may help you determine whether he will receive playing time or whether he is worth a look in Scoresheet or other sim leagues. However, for traditional fantasy leagues, his bat is paltry, and one look at his career .226/.308/.326 line can attest to that. Neither GP2011 (projection listed above) nor PECOTA (.238/.308/.351) think very highly of him in 2011, and I would tend to agree. Avoid being stuck with Janish as your shortstop in NL-only leagues.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
For a 7 team keeper league with the choice of Beckham or Martin Prado, who has 2b eligibility, who is the better play in fantasy this year and on a go forward basis?

Good question. I'm going to assume this is a roto league. Let's reference PECOTA:

2011 Beckham: .263/.328/.419, 16 HR/600 PA
2011 Prado: .293/.342/.421 10 HR/600 PA

I'm a little more optimistic about Prado's HR and power numbers in general, as he has hovered closer to a .140-.150 ISO throughout his career, but Beckham is definitely the better power option. For 2011, it's no question you take Prado, as he'll have 2B eligibility and give you an emergency outfielder in case of injury. Beckham is more of an upside selection.

For beyond 2011, however, it is a drastically different story. With Dan Uggla locked up for four more seasons after this one in Atlanta and the Braves assuring him that he will remain in his current 2B position for as long as possible, you have to expect that Prado won't have 2B eligibility for another three seasons after this. Then factoring the age difference, and you have to figure that Beckham could improve enough to make up for his earlier weaker performance.

So this question depends on what you value:

1) Both will have 2B eligibility for 2011, but Prado won't have it for a few years after this upcoming season. Beckham is a mainstay if he plays at his projected level.

2) Prado is the better choice for 2011, as he'll produce close to average power production among second basemen and assist you in AVG and R.

3) Beckham is the better option in the subsequent years, because he isn't so far off in value that he couldn't make it up by being a second baseman as opposed to an outfielder. Plus, he always has the chance to improve, though we cannot count on that until we see the 2011 season.

Long-term value, I'd lean on Beckham but look for another option at 2B. Prado is for the 2011 season.
Thank you very much for the detailed reply. I basically came to the same conclusion. I winded up trading Beckham for a draft pick as I believe Prado gives me the better chance to win this year.

Thank you again.