CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
  
  
Click here to log in Click here for forgotten password Click here to subscribe

<< Previous Article
Fantasy Article Value Picks: Relievers... (08/15)
<< Previous Column
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: ... (08/14)
Next Column >>
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: ... (08/20)
Next Article >>
Premium Article Punk Hits: The Fabulou... (08/15)

August 15, 2012

Transaction Analysis

Mathis for Smart People? *UPDATED*

by Sam Miller and R.J. Anderson

IN THIS ISSUE

American League
National League

BOSTON RED SOX
Team Audit | Player Cards | Depth Chart
Return to Top

Acquired RHP Pedro Beato from the Mets for C-R Kelly Shoppach. [8/16]

So continues Beato’s atypical career path. The Orioles once selected Beato with the 32nd-overall pick in the draft. Beato landed with the Mets via the Rule 5 draft (and made 67 big-league appearances for them). Now Beato is traded to Boston as a player to be named later. Beato is a power arm starter kit. His fastball can get into the mid-90s and he complements the velocity with a cutter and a curveball. Home run and walk issues have plagued Beato, and his stuff rarely translates into good strikeout rates. Beato’s upside is probably in middle relief. Considering the opportunity cost involved, Beato is a suitable return. 

TORONTO BLUE JAYS
Team Audit | Player Cards | Depth Chart
Return to Top

Agreed to an extension with C-R Jeff Mathis for two years, $3 million, with a club option for 2015. [8/14]

The thing about finding a unicorn is you wouldn’t even enjoy it until you believed in it, and it would take a long time before you believed in it. First you would think you had somehow gotten high, perhaps from a gas leak, or from the drugs that you regularly ingest. After a time, you would rule out temporary highness and conclude you had gone crazy. In time, you might come to accept your sanity, and even believe that maybe the unicorn was real, but you would always have some doubt. You would keep turning around, just to make sure it was still there and you could still see it. You wouldn’t expect it to be there. You might not even want it to be there.

Once a month or so, I look up Jeff Mathis’ catcher ERA. When Mike Scioscia started talking about Jeff Mathis’ low CERA, back in 2008, Mathis had been behind the plate for only 1,000 or so innings, and Scioscia’s claims were easily brushed aside. But it’s been four years since, and in four years of monthly check-ups, the doggone thing just keeps sitting there, staying real, or at least looking real. Crapping unicorn turds all over my living room. Real enough.

This year, with a new team, with a new pitching staff, he’s doing it again. Toronto pitchers have a 4.30 ERA with Mathis behind the plate, compared to 4.70 with J.P Arencibia. Can’t really blame it on the pitchers assigned to them; Mathis has had disproportionately few opportunities to catch Brandon Morrow and Ricky Romero, who should be the two best starters on the staff. When paired with the Blue Jays’ five most frequent starters, Mathis’ CERA trumps Arencibia’s with four. Blue Jays pitchers have struck out more batters, walked fewer, and even benefited from a better BABIP when Mathis is catching. This is all a bunch of silliness, except that it’s the same thing that happened in 2009, 2010, and 2011. The strikeouts, the walks, the BABIPs, the individual pitcher ERAs, the staff ERAs.

I find this obnoxious.

***

One of the strangest parts of the Angels’ relationship with Mathis was that they didn’t just think Mathis was a superlative defender, despite some strong evidence to the contrary (which we will get to in a few paragraphs). They also always seemed convinced that Mathis was going to turn a corner as a hitter. No, Scioscia never argued that Mathis’ production—the worst in franchise history, by OPS+—was acceptable. But Mathis usually hit well in spring training, and he had that ridiculous week against the Yankees in the 2009 ALCS, and he started the 2010 season hot before injuring his wrist. Along the way, there was always optimism that Mathis might actually hit well. Like this quote:

"The biggest thing with young hitters is the look on their face," Hatcher said. "Jeff has a different look on his face this spring. You can see that confidence. It's fun to watch. I think this will be a year where he shows what he can do."

That was spring 2009. After that quote, Mathis would hit .193/.245/.282 as an Angel.

But you could still sort of understand. Mathis had been, at age 20 in the California League, a really good hitter. At age 21, too. After that, he never got better. (Using a simple minor league equivalency calculator, in fact, his major-league stats in his mid-20s and his minor league stats at 20 are almost identical.) But he was certainly young enough, and he certainly had some demonstrated talent, way back when. "I think it's going to click for him one of these years and he's going to take off from there. He could be an All-Star catcher,” Darren Oliver once said. There is, strangely, a very real desire among baseball people to see Jeff Mathis as a simmering offensive weapon. (He hit .174/.224/.259 as an Angel after Oliver said that.)

The Blue Jays traded for Mathis before this season. Gregg Zaun forecasted offensive greatness, and you might have picked up the impression that Mathis is having a decent year at the plate, with a .200 isolated power and such. Mathis made some mechanical adjustments, and a month into the season he starred in this article:

But when the backup catcher joined the Toronto Blue Jays this spring, they came up with the quaint notion that he could hit.

With a little help, that is. So throughout spring training, Mathis and hitting coach Dwayne Murphy fiddled with his stance and swing until they found a combination that felt right.

Last season with the Los Angeles Angels, Mathis hit three home runs. On Sunday, he hit his second as a Blue Jay. His batting average – small sample-size alert – is .313.

He switched from a closed to open stance and moved his hands forward.

“We were tinkering with some things,” he said. “This was the final tinker, I guess. It just kind of clicked.”

Since then, Mathis has hit .202/.232/.361. Since Arencibia got injured in July, he has played almost every day with a .167 OBP. I guess what I’m saying is, Jeff Mathis isn’t much of a hitter. This was probably too many words for that point.

***

The other strange thing is that Mathis’ defense, for which he is presumably employed, has never been measurably good. This year he has gunned down 39 percent of baserunners, tops in the American League, but it’s the first time in his career he’s been better than league average. He’s sturdy enough behind the plate, but he’ll also occasionally turn porous for an entire season, as in 2010, when his passed-ball and wild-pitch rates rose. Mike Fast’s metrics like him just fine for framing, but he’s well below elite, probably a little better than average.

So that leaves one of two explanations for this move. One is that two years and $3 million is an appropriate wage for a terrible, terrible backup. While it’s always hard to anticipate salary inflation, that explanation seems wrong. About two-thirds of big-league teams pay less than $500,000 for their backups by finding pre-arb players on their farms or the scrap heap. The few veterans backing up at catcher make $800,000 on the low end (Brian Schneider, Dioner Navarro) and $1.625 million on the high end (David Ross), with no other true back-up making more than Mathis’ $1.5 million. Matt Treanor makes $1 million, Gerald Laird makes $1 million, Kelly Shoppach makes $1.35 million. Jose Molina might be a good comparable, as another glove-first veteran who found an offensive spike in Rogers Centre, but his defensive value is, in contrast to Mathis’, documented and exceptional. He got $1.8 million from Tampa Bay, to start.

So if Mathis isn't better than he seems on the surface, the Blue Jays “overpaid,” or whatever you want to call it. Which leads us to the other possible explanation: the Blue Jays believe in the magic. They believe that Mathis is better than Treanor, better than Laird, better than Schneider, better perhaps than Molina. They believe that he is worth paying more than 28 or 29 other teams will pay their backup catchers, and that this is such a bargain that they want to lock it in for two years, with a team option for a third. The Blue Jays, a seemingly smart team that has little in common with the Tony Reagins-era Angels, has nevertheless made the same conclusion about Jeff Mathis. They believe that they know something we, out here at a distance, still haven’t discovered. The Blue Jays like Jeff Mathis, just like Mike Scioscia always liked Jeff Mathis, just like Jeff Mathis’ pitchers have always liked Jeff Mathis.

Don’t ignore this. This is data. This, in the absence of any data showing Jeff Mathis’ value, might actually be the most important data point of all. The unicorn might actually be real. —Sam Miller

NEW YORK METS
Team Audit | Player Cards | Depth Chart
Return to Top

Acquired C-R Kelly Shoppach from the Red Sox for a player to be named later. [8/14]

Typically, the contending team is the one acquiring the veteran player at this time of the year, but not with this trade. Nevertheless, this is not a complicated swap to understand. The Red Sox wanted to free up playing time for Ryan Lavarnway. They decided that trading Shoppach (who happens to be on an expiring deal) made more sense than carrying three catchers or trading Jarrod Saltalamacchia. Fair enough, as long as they don’t anticipate a significant return.

The Mets were supposedly interested in a few veteran catchers throughout the trade season, including Ramon Hernandez and Kurt Suzuki. Ostensibly, the plan is (and was) to platoon Josh Thole with the new veteran. Shoppach is familiar with the role, as he took part in a timeshares with John Jaso in Tampa Bay and then with Saltalamacchia in Boston. His best offensive skill is his ability to hit a ball a long way; his worst is making contact to begin with. Shoppach isn’t the best defender around, but the overall package makes him a clear upgrade over the Mets' alternatives, like Rob Johnson and Mike Nickeas (although those players are less likely than Shoppach to throw their bats into the stands on a swing).

Consider this some advance scouting on the part of the Mets. Shoppach will become a free agent at season’s end, and now the Mets have about two months to evaluate how he goes about his business. It would not be surprising to see the two sides hammer out an agreement on a 2013 contract if the Mets like what they see. —R.J. Anderson

Sam Miller is an author of Baseball Prospectus. 
Click here to see Sam's other articles. You can contact Sam by clicking here
R.J. Anderson is an author of Baseball Prospectus. 
Click here to see R.J.'s other articles. You can contact R.J. by clicking here

Related Content:  Jeff Mathis,  Kelly Shoppach

15 comments have been left for this article. (Click to hide comments)

BP Comment Quick Links

John Carter

What are the odds that a player's CERA can be so consistently lower than his team-mate's CERA and that not be a real asset (even if it doesn't show up in his framing and passed ball data) - one that certainly would be worth an extra million dollars per season?

Aug 15, 2012 04:17 AM
rating: 0
 
swarmee

Isn't one WAR worth approximately $5 million? And 10 runs saved or gained is worth 1 win?

At the current pace, over a whole season, a pitching staff being caught exclusively by Arencibia would allow 6,852 runs. One caught exclusively by Mathis would allow 6,269 runs. That is a difference of 583 runs! Or 58 additional wins. Therefore, Jeff Mathis is worth $290 million this season, at the market rate of wins. Subtract two wins for his lousy hitting, and he's still way underpaid. ;-)

Aug 15, 2012 13:51 PM
rating: 4
 
craigburley

Sam, saying that Jeff Mathis is better at catching and working with pitchers than JP Arencibia is like saying he's better at running than Bengie Molina.

JPA can't even catch the ball - at this point, umpires who work the plate for Jays games are probably wearing as much body armor as they can scrounge.

Aug 15, 2012 06:04 AM
rating: 1
 
gdragon1977

If they awarded the umpire a base for getting hit he could probably have a higher OBP than JPA.

Aug 15, 2012 10:47 AM
rating: 1
 
ScottyB

For the Mets, I guess it comes down to getting sick of seeing guys with 190 and 206 TAVs suck up at bats. I sure am.

Aug 15, 2012 12:29 PM
rating: 1
 
Richard Bergstrom

Why extend Mathis when you have Arencibia already and d'Arnaud is in the pipeline..

Aug 15, 2012 12:55 PM
rating: -1
 
pobothecat

defensive mentor?

Aug 15, 2012 14:04 PM
rating: 1
 
pobothecat

What I'm saying there is, I don't have much faith in sabre's ability to measure the intangibles of the catcher position. A smart, experienced guy with ability to communicate the nuances of a very nuanced position to a next-generation of talented young catchers is probably a bargain at this price.

Aug 15, 2012 14:11 PM
rating: 2
 
Richard Bergstrom

Well.. can you prove, or at least, provide some evidence that Mathis is smart or that he communicates the nuances well?

Was he really that much better defensively or with clubhouse presence than Mike Napoli, for example to offset Napoli's double digit home runs and "clutch" postseason performance?

If so, why did the Angels acquire Iannetta and let Mathis go?

Why not take someone cheaper like Torrealba?

I mean, we're talking about someone with about 1600 plate appearances, the equivalent of three seasons worth of at bats... there are _lots_ of catchers who fit that profile (or better) and make less.

Aug 15, 2012 14:48 PM
rating: 0
 
SGreenwell

I don't think that Arencibia and d'Arnaud are ever on the same team for that long. They both strike me as clear starting-level caliber talents, so I imagine the Jays will try to move one of them in the offseason, given that teams are always looking for catchers, or guys who can fake it.* For that reason, you still need a back-up, although I agree with Sam that this seems like a lot of cash, even for a unicorn.

* I realize that Arencibia's statistics are actually pretty poor, but those home runs will probably coerce someone into being interested in him, and hey, he improved his BA by 20 points this year! His OBP has amazingly still managed to drop despite this, and his power is done as well, but you know, homers are shiny.

Aug 15, 2012 14:56 PM
rating: 0
 
gdragon1977

I still look at JPA and get worried I'm watching Todd Greene 2.0

Aug 15, 2012 21:16 PM
rating: 1
 
SGreenwell

Greene only ever got a full season of ABs once, but through 750 ABs, JPA has a slash line of 224 / 276 / 444. Green's career slash line through 1,573 AB was 252 / 286 / *drum roll* 444. That's a pretty nice spot by you.

Aug 15, 2012 21:51 PM
rating: 1
 
amazin_mess

Trading one for pitching help this winter, perhaps?

Aug 15, 2012 17:39 PM
rating: 0
 
mattstupp

Can we get a brief analytical update on the Shoppach trade, now that we know that Pedro Beato is the player the Mets sent to the Red Sox? I had liked the trade enough when I thought that the PTBNL would be a low-minors warm body, but Beato, despite his major league underperformances, seems like a high price to pay for a player that's a free agent in November and a team that's not contending this year. Beato does seem to have late-inning relief as a major league upside. He seems to have enough stuff..

Aug 20, 2012 07:06 AM
rating: 0
 
BP staff member Ben Lindbergh
BP staff

This has been added.

Aug 21, 2012 02:04 AM
 
You must be a Premium subscriber to post a comment.
Not a subscriber? Sign up today!
<< Previous Article
Fantasy Article Value Picks: Relievers... (08/15)
<< Previous Column
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: ... (08/14)
Next Column >>
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: ... (08/20)
Next Article >>
Premium Article Punk Hits: The Fabulou... (08/15)

RECENTLY AT BASEBALL PROSPECTUS
Fantasy Article Five to Watch: South Atlantic League Hitters
Premium Article Transaction Analysis: The Uribear Heads East
Premium Article Minor League Update: Games of Wednesday, May...
Premium Article Painting the Black: Stealing Signs
Eyewitness Accounts: May 28, 2015
Premium Article Pitching Backward: Started From the Bottom, ...
Premium Article Some Projection Left: Ask the Industry: Catc...

MORE FROM AUGUST 15, 2012
Premium Article Future Shock: The Bundy Dilemma
Premium Article Sobsequy: What Your Team's Choice of Radio B...
Premium Article Punk Hits: The Fabulous Major-League Basebal...
Fantasy Article Value Picks: Relievers for 8/15/12
Premium Article Collateral Damage Daily: Wednesday, August 1...
Premium Article The Prospectus Hit List: Wednesday, August 1...
What You Need to Know: Wednesday, August 15

MORE BY SAM MILLER
2012-08-17 - Premium Article Pebble Hunting: The Value of Billy Hamilton
2012-08-17 - BP Daily Podcast: Effectively Wild Episode 2...
2012-08-16 - BP Daily Podcast: Effectively Wild Episode 2...
2012-08-15 - Transaction Analysis: Mathis for Smart Peopl...
2012-08-14 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Yankees Find a Spot fo...
2012-08-13 - Premium Article Painting the Black: Same Vogelsong, Second V...
2012-08-09 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Yuni to Get Out of Her...
More...

MORE TRANSACTION ANALYSIS
2012-08-22 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: San Diego Excises Bart...
2012-08-21 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: The A's Acquire Stephe...
2012-08-20 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: The Stars are Re-Signe...
2012-08-15 - Transaction Analysis: Mathis for Smart Peopl...
2012-08-14 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Yankees Find a Spot fo...
2012-08-09 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Yuni to Get Out of Her...
2012-08-07 - Premium Article Transaction Analysis: Busy Week at the Ol' S...
More...

INCOMING ARTICLE LINKS
2012-08-15 - BP Daily Podcast: Effectively Wild Episode 2...