BP Comment Quick Links
![]() |
|
|
The First-ever Baseball Prospectus Futures Guide - now just $6.86 at Amazon ( bbp.cx/fg ) |
|
|
October 1, 2012 Pebble HuntingThe Uplifting, Inspirational YankeesThere is, in the American League East this year, an inspirational story worth cheering for. It is a story of underdogs, of overachievers, of a group of players counted out, of a team of men who didn’t give up. When everything was against them, these men fought harder. I’m almost choking up over here. Not the Orioles. Pfft. Bunch of big-shot millionaires. Nope, I’m talking about a truly inspirational roster: The New York Yankees. I’m serious! Well, I would say that if I were serious, and I would say that if I were being satirical, and I’m honestly not sure which direction this piece will go, so we’re safe either way. But here’s what I know: when you get past your idea that the Yankees are paid a lot and represent systemic imbalance and should win and can’t possibly be an underdog, you can find a lot of reasons to be pretty happy for the Yankees. Start with Derek Jeter. Ugggggggh you're so sick of Derek Jeter, but Derek Jeter overcame a lot. Derek Jeter's parents were of different races, and Jeter had to deal with racism because of it.
|
It's not where they come from that makes us hate the Yankees. It's why the Yankees get to have them - because the team has enough money to buy championships and their fans have grown to expect championships as their birth right. The unearned personal arrogance of many Yankee fans, who've done nothing to contribute to the century-long success of the Yankees, makes me relish every time the team loses. I'll have respect for the individual players, for their ability to overcome these personal challenges, but not the organization or it's fans.
I'm guessing that if one looked at every other team, you'd find mostly guys who had similar challenges. There are not a whole lot of sons of CEOs from pleasant suburban families to start with, and even fewer who chose baseball as their career.
Challenge breeds champions. Someone who has always had it easy is more likely to fold the first time they meet adversity.
It's true. Yankees fans are the only annoying fans in the world. The only fans who brag or feel personal satisfaction from our team's accomplishments. Little known fact is that New Yorkers are the only people ever to chant "We're Number One! We're Number One!" Outside of NY, the chant is always sung "That loose conglomerate of highly-paid skilled athletes that compete under the guise of representing the city which I happen to live in is NUMBER ONE! That loose conglomerate of highly-paid skilled athletes that compete under the guise of representing the city which I happen to live in is NUMBER ONE!"
Thanks for the patronizing inspirational message, too. I'm glad to know that having grown up in a pleasant suburb, I don't have the character to be a champion. Gotta go, I'm off to quit something.
That wasn't at all what he was saying, but way to blow it up randolph
It isn't? What was he saying?
I get it that Yankee fans are annoying. They are. But so are fans of every other team in every other sports everywhere in the world.* Fandom, or fanatism, by its very nature is irrational and annoying. I fail to see why Yankee misfortune is more worthy of schadenfreude than any other team's misfortune.
*Except for Pirates fans, they are delightful.
he's saying all of those things are worse or more obvious with Yankee fans than other teams fans. And thats hard to argue with.
I think that is unfair (and I'm not sure I agree with your interpretation of Navarred's comment). I've lived in NY/NJ, Boston and Chicago and at different times I've found Yankee, Mets, Red Sox, Cubs and White Sox fans all to be utterly unbearable. Nothing in my experience has lead me to believe that Yankees fans deserve more scorn than any other. And I certainly don't see why a team's fans should necessarily prevent some one for rooting for some good guys to succeed.
As with pretty much anything in life, I think a Sloan lyric might help
"If I drink concentrated OJ
Can I think Consolidated's okay?
It's not the band I hate, it's their fans
Three cans of water perverts me"
Consolidated was an activist band in the 90s (way into veganism and lefty politics) but still pretty darn good. Inevitably the most annoying kid in school loved them. It made me dislike the band for ages, but, now, I find it easy to separate the two.
I swear I was already listening to Twice Removed when I came across this comment, and I'm about two weeks away from hearing the whole thing live. Please leave a relevant Sloan lyric in a comment at the end of every future article published at BP. Thank you.
Sloan ref on B-Pro? And "Coax Me" at that? Nice. They're one of my top 5 favorite bands of all time ... and I'm not even Canadian! Go figure.
Sloan is the best. And I mean that much less hyperbolically than I usually do when I say something's the best.
Actually, he is exactly correct. It is worse or more obvious with Yankees fans. Yes, Mets fans are annoying and Phillies fans are bound to start a fight (amongst themselves if no opposing fans are available) but none of them have 25 World Series championships and the arrogance that somehow attaches itself to so many Yankees fans.
Sorry to be responding months later, but I don't often look at the comments.
In my fantasies as a sportswriter - this is exactly what I would aim for - bringing players to life in ways well beyond their baseball skills and stats - with facts not bull, and with the charm of Sam Miller.
Oops. This was meant to be a general comment not a reply to navared.