Tale of the Tape: Miguel Cabrera vs. Justin Smoak Matt Collins January 15, 2019 Share: > Image credit: USA Today Sports Subscribe to Baseball ProspectusCabrera or Smoak? Who wins? Full access to this article is for Premium Baseball Prospectus subscribers. Sign up today to get access to insightful analysis for the discerning baseball fan. Super-Premium - $66.99 / yearPremium - $45.95 / yearPremium Monthly - $6.99 / month Subscribe to Baseball Prospectus In This Article 0 First BasemenJustin SmoakMiguel CabreraTale Of The Tape Related Articles State of the Position 2025: First Base $ by Timothy Jackson 1/13 7 How to Navigate the Desert of Mid-Round First Basemen $ by Elijah Ackerman 1/25 0 Surveying the Deep League Landscape at First Base (AL) $ by Darius Austin 1/27 0 New Opportunities for Unproven Free Agents $ by Mark Barry 8/05 0 Giancarlo Stanton vs. Franmil Reyes $ by Kevin Jebens 1/21 0 Latest Articles Best of BP 2025: Sacrifices Must Be Made by Patrick Dubuque 12/26 0 Best of BP 2025: Speed Watch, featuring Chandler Simpson by Alexandra Whitley 12/26 0 Best of BP 2025: Chuck Dressen, A Man For Our Times by Steven Goldman 12/26 0 Best of BP 2025: Sorry We Missed You by Jeffrey Paternostro 12/26 0 Best of BP 2025: Understanding Swing Processes Through Bat and Pitch Tracking by Stephen Sutton-Brown 12/26 0 more chevron_rightchevron_right Matt Collins More about: First BasemenJustin SmoakMiguel CabreraTale Of The Tape Latest Articles Best of BP 2025: Sacrifices Must Be Made by Patrick Dubuque 12/26 0 Best of BP 2025: Speed Watch, featuring Chandler Simpson by Alexandra Whitley 12/26 0 Best of BP 2025: Chuck Dressen, A Man For Our Times by Steven Goldman 12/26 0 Related Articles State of the Position 2025: First Base $ by Timothy Jackson 1/13 7 How to Navigate the Desert of Mid-Round First Basemen $ by Elijah Ackerman 1/25 0 Surveying the Deep League Landscape at First Base (AL) $ by Darius Austin 1/27 0 You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
