CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
Click here to log in Click here for forgotten password Click here to subscribe
No Previous Article
<< Previous Column
Transaction Analysis: ... (07/28)
Next Column >>
Transaction Analysis: ... (08/04)
No Next Article

August 1, 2000

Transaction Analysis

July 27-31, 2000

by Christina Kahrl

Anyone else remember all of those predictions that this would be one of the most boring trading deadlines ever? Instead, we got one of the best. Take a deep breath, and let's dive into it:


Acquired 1B/OF Chris Hatcher, RHP Mike Heathcott and 2B Brett King from the Cubs for RHP Brett Hinchliffe and IF Keith Luuloa. [7/28]

Acquired LF Ron Gant from the Phillies for RHP Kent Bottenfield. [7/30]

A strange combination of moves. Picking up Chris Hatcher initially makes all sorts of sense. He's a pretty nifty DH for a team that has wasted four months on the non-Clemente as a platoon mate for non-DH Scott Spiezio.

However, it subsequently becomes nothing more than a neat little bit of insurance, as Bill Stoneman makes an overt gesture towards contention. It isn't that Ron Gant is going to be a good enough hitter to help propel the Angels into the wild-card slot. Despite Gant's being a significant upgrade on Spiezio and Edgardo Clemente, he isn't that good: .254/.324/.487 with a .265 Equivalent Average. And it isn't as if this is a salary dump.

While the perfect solution would have been finding a way to make Ken Hill disappear, we don't live in a perfect world, and Stoneman settled for a stunt that might impress season-ticket holders or his corporate masters while helping the Angels score a couple more runs on the season. As gestures go, it's one with more symbolic value than on-field impact, but that's the arena where the Angels have the most ground to gain between now and the end of the season.


Optioned RHP Byung-Hyun Kim to Tucson; purchased the contract of RHP Johnny Ruffin from Tucson. [7/30]

The rhetoric is that Byung-Hyun Kim needs some time to regain his control, but considering that Kim limits right-handed batters to hitting .144/.241/.258, the Snakes have a more basic problem here. By the time postseason rosters need to be set at the end of August, Buck Showalter's crew needs to sort out who's going to be the 11th pitcher. Kim should be in no danger on that front; he's just the convenient fall guy with an option to use. If they're smart, Johnny Ruffin will be the tenth pitcher after posting a 2.98 ERA in Tucson while limiting hitters to 48 hits, four home runs and 25 walks in 57 1/3 innings with 66 strikeouts.

That leaves the fight for the 11th spot between Matt Mantei and his chronic arm problems, carpenter-turned-Taiwan League star-turned-mystery flamethrower Geraldo Guzman (no need for fifth starters in the postseason, and Showalter is unlikely to bump Armando Reynoso) and well-travelled mop-up man Russ Springer. Yes, the answer looks obvious to me, too, but that isn't to say it's going to happen.


Placed OF Reggie Sanders on the 15-day DL (strained hamstring); recalled OF George Lombard from Richmond. [7/28]

Signed RHP Stan Belinda. [7/29]

Acquired 1B/LF B.J. Surhoff and RHP Gabe Molina from the Orioles for C Fernando Lunar, OF Trenidad Hubbard and RHP Luis Rivera. [7/31]

Half-empty or half-full--how do you want it, Braves fans? Sure, bringing in a reliable mediocrity like B.J. Surhoff is exactly what this offense needed to paper over the scar in left field for the rest of the season. Maybe Reggie Sanders will have some value in a platoon role once he comes back; and reduced to a bench role, Bobby Bonilla becomes one of the most fearsome pinch-hitters the Braves have ever carried into the postseason. Hey, when the tradition includes Jorge Fabregas and Greg Myers...

The problems with this move are plenty, and really have me wondering whether we need to page back through time and sort out where John Schuerholz started breaking with the Braves' past (dominated by Bobby Cox and Paul Snyder and the rest of the gang that made this franchise great) and began falling into his own bad habits. Those are the ones that ran the Royals into the ground during repeatedly futile attempts to keep up with the Sandy Alderson/Tony La Russa Oakland teams of the late 1980s.

Surhoff is under contract for two more years, and while Wally Joyner should fade away after this season, that's still a big salary commitment to a player who doesn't deserve anything more than part-time play. The other problem is that if you compare the Surhoff trade to what little the Mariners had to give up to get a better and equally available hitter (Al Martin), you can't help but be a little disappointed. While Surhoff has made himself into a good outfielder, is a nice-fielding old man with plenty of good citizenship awards but barely adequate offensive skills worth a young pitcher with Luis Rivera's talent? At least the Braves managed to get Gabe Molina as well, as he makes for a nice insurance policy in case Skippy Belinda isn't any better with the Braves than he was with the Rockies.

George Lombard isn't hitting that much better than he did in last year's injury-riddled debacle: .259/.347/.400. As a bench player, he's more useful than Otis Nixon, since he can hit that well and run (27 steals versus seven times caught).


Placed IF Mark Lewis on the 15-day DL; retroactive to 7/21 (strained hamstring). [7/27]

Traded SS Mike Bordick to the Mets for RHPs Lesli Brea and Pat Gorman, C/UT Mike Kinkade and UT Melvin Mora; placed RHP Scott Erickson on the 15-day DL (elbow inflammation); released UT Rich Amaral; purchased the contract of RHP Ryan Kohlmeier from Rochester; activated 3B Ryan Minor from the DL; transferred RHP Calvin Maduro from the 15- to the 60-day DL. [7/28]

Traded C Charles Johnson and DH Harold Baines to the White Sox for C Brook Fordyce and RHPs Miguel Felix, Juan Figueroa and Jason Lakman; traded RHP Mike Timlin to the Cardinals for RHP Mark Nussbeck and 1B Chris Richard. [7/29]

Recalled LHP B.J. Ryan from Rochester. [7/30]

Acquired RHP Luis Rivera, C Fernando Lunar and OF Trenidad Hubbard from the Braves for 1B/LF B.J. Surhoff and RHP Gabe Molina; acquired 3B Jose Leon from the Cardinals for 1B Will Clark and cash; recalled 3B Carlos Casamiro from Bowie (Double-A). [7/31]

Well, you don't get a more dramatic repudiation of a team built to accomplish nothing beyond spend Peter Angelos's money than a dumping of five lineup regulars. Toss in trading the closer, putting a rotation starter on the DL, cutting an oddly overpriced utility man and placing the utility infielder on the DL, and it's almost as if this was never the team that only just recently picked up Darren Holmes.

Beyond the overdue trimming of fat, what exactly did the Orioles accomplish? Some of these trades will cost the Orioles compensation draft picks they might have otherwise expected (Mike Bordick and Charles Johnson in particular), so keep that in mind when evaluating the crop of minor leaguers acquired. So what did they get? Gas. Not D.C.-style hot air, but a lot of young pitchers with great fastballs.

First, there's Luis Rivera, the prize from the B.J. Surhoff trade and someone who could have been the best right-handed reliever in the Braves' pen in the playoffs if they'd held onto him. Then there are the three Dominicans. From the Mets, Lesli Brea brings outstanding heat, although his command of his breaking stuff is sketchy at best since he's averaging around six walks per game. He could be an asset in the bullpen in pretty short order. Juan Figueroa also has a good fastball; while Brea has already cracked Triple-A, Figueroa has only just made it to Double-A; both are 21. Miguel Felix isn't pitching well in A ball at the age of 23, but he has good heat, too. Jason Lakman was once a prospect with one of the best fastballs in the minors, but he's had a hard time adjusting to Double-A, and it's symbolic of the strength of the pitching in the White Sox organization that he got pushed into the bullpen this year after hitting his first real rough patch.

While potential is a dirty word when you're talking minor-league pitching, this is a pretty good swag. I don't know which one will get to play a young David Cone to John Parrish's riff on Sid Fernandez, but chances are good that one or two of these flamethrowers turns into somebody useful.

But quantity doesn't add up to quality across the board. Pat Gorman isn't much of a prospect, no matter how well he's been blowing people away as a closer in the Sally League. It's his third year at the level, and for perspective, he's only two months younger than Ryan Kohlmeier. Mark Nussbeck is a 1996 29th-round draft pick out of a small Nebraska college. While he's been solid in Memphis's rotation this year (3.96 ERA), keep in mind that he's one year removed from allowing 100 runs in 102 innings, and he's averaging an extra run allowed per nine this year when you count unearned runs.

The position players the Orioles received don't hold out as much in terms of potential. Several of these guys can be useful spare parts or bench players, but only Jose Leon merits the label "prospect." Melvin Mora should help the Orioles out as a utilityman, but he'll continue to be miscast as a shortstop for as long as there's no one else to consider playing (which should have folks asking why Augie Ojeda was discarded over last winter for no return).

Brook Fordyce is a nice guy to have share the catcher's job with Greg Myers until Jayson Werth is ready. While I think it would be worthwhile to let Mike Kinkade be the team's DH for the next two months, you have to worry about an organization that has tabbed Chris Richard as a prospect and as someone who will be an everyday player next year. He's already 26, and while he's been having a nice season at Memphis (.277/.366/.469), he's too old to be a good prospect. Leon has good power but has continued to scuffle with his command of the strike zone. At the worst, he's a better player than organizational favorite Ryan Minor. Fernando Lunar and Trenidad Hubbard can share a beer with Brian Hunter over the misfortune of going from a bench headed for the postseason to a bench headed for oblivion. All things considered, this is going to be a really bad lineup for the next two months, which isn't a significant break from the recent past.

There's other good news here. Scott Erickson has been the fifth-worst starting pitcher in baseball according to Michael Wolverton's Support-Neutral stats. The four men who've been worse are all out of work: Vladimir Nunez and Roy Halladay have lost their rotation slots, while Sean Bergman and Jaime Navarro have been cut. Replacing Erickson will be Jose Mercedes. While Mercedes isn't as good as his recent hot streak, he'd be hard-pressed to work his way down into Erickson's company. The Orioles ought to take a look at Josh Towers during the last two months instead of wasting their time with Erickson or Pat Rapp anyway, and that will be easier now that they've dumped so many other vets.

After all of this, have the Orioles made any progress? I don't really think so. All of these moves are a year too late. Their extreme reluctance to give opportunities to talented young hitters like Cal Pickering or Jerry Hairston Jr. has already altered both players' careers for the worse. The lineup is going to be ugly for the next two months because there isn't enough talent in the system to quickly replace this many regular position players. While a well-run organization would take this as an opportunity to do some aggressive shopping among minor-league free agents, this is the Angelos Orioles. Expect some high-profile, medium-price mediocrities to be signed to lend ineffable veteran qualities to next year's last place team. Because of the shortage of internal options, don't be surprised at all if Bordick is back: the Orioles won't be signing A-Rod, and they could certainly do a lot worse than Bordick.


Acquired RHPs Rolando Arrojo and Rick Croushore and IF Mike Lansing from the Rockies for RHPs Brian Rose, John Wasdin and Jeff Taglienti and UT Jeff Frye. [7/27]

Assigned PH Sean Berry to Pawtucket. [7/30]

The ongoing slugfest between Red Sox players decrying the Duke's cold-blooded release of veteran players on the one hand, and the Duke's equally cold retort that the goal is to contend on the other, is becoming more and more meaningless as it gets fought out over increasingly feeble players. Mike Stanley's career is pretty close to over, but Sox players decry how he's been treated (conversely, remember how little outcry there was when the White Sox cut a cuttable Carlton Fisk in 1993, and from a division-leading team no less?), as if performance somehow shouldn't the bottom line. But the Duke hardly helps his case when his idea of improvement is to drag in bad players in major tailspins. Sean Berry? Bernard Gilkey? Ed Sprague?

Mike Lansing has been awful this season, hitting .258/.315/.419 overall and .202/.255/.273 away from Coors Field. He's 32, and he isn't going to suddenly get better. He could end up being a worse offensive regular than Sprague, no easy feat. Who cares if Rolando Arrojo is signed to a cheap contract? He was the worst starter in the Rockies' rotation, and has pitched worse than even Ramon Martinez, without the talented brother to excuse his struggles. Rick Croushore might help the Red Sox pen, but he's been smacked around in the PCL, posting a 7.36 ERA. While I've always been sold on the idea that Croushore can help a team as a long reliever, where he can use his screwball to good effect, will the Red Sox instead have him repeat his situational disasters?

The problem isn't one of the talent they gave up, but that this is the talent that the Duke took the time to go out and get. It isn't going to help them catch the Yankees, it isn't going to help them win the wild card, it may not even help them keep up with the Blue Jays and, speaking from experience, the only thing more ignominious than getting beaten by Gord Ash is underestimating Ash's capacity to screw up his team's shot at winning the division three years in a row. When the Duke loses to the Yankees this year, when they were so very catchable, he'll deserve to be held to the same standards he's applied to Stanley or Mark Portugal or Reggie Jefferson or even Kevin Kennedy, because at the end of the day, he didn't get the job done.


Acquired RHP Brett Hinchliffe and IF Keith Luuloa from the Angels for 1B/OF Chris Hatcher, RHP Mike Heathcott and 2B Brett King. [7/28]

Acquired OF Rondell White from the Expos for LHP Scott Downs; acquired 1B Ross Gload and RHP Dave Noyce from the Marlins for LF/1B Henry Rodriguez. [7/31]

While most of the deals that happened as the deadline approached were cases of good teams insuring themselves or adding that needed veteran, the Cubs' July endgame is perhaps the most intriguing of the lot. They're within ten games, and my undoubtedly irresponsible gut feeling about any Tony La Russa team is that they tend to be so tightly wound that if you give them a chance to blow it, they will.

But does that make the Cubs' shot something even remotely within the realm of possibility? Sure, anything's possible, but even if a miracle occurred and the Cubs caught up, the most they can aspire to is a repeat performance as postseason speed bump for the Braves. That sort of prize has been the ignoble goal of the Andy MacPhail/Ed Lynch regime all along, and while you can take the Ed Lynch out of the organization, you can't rid the organization of this kind of "ambition." With a rotation of Jon Lieber, Kerry Wood, Kevin Tapani and...Ruben Quevedo and...and...hmm, well, even that goal is unattainable.

You can interpret MacPhail's failure to negotiate a multi-year extension with Rondell White as a clear statement on White's feelings on becoming a Cub, which is also why you can see how MacPhail managed to get him so cheaply. As a risk, it's still worthwhile for the Cubs. While swapping the Henry Rodriguez/Glenallen Hill platoon for Rondell White is great if you're in some sort of simulation league where injuries don't happen, the fact is White is hurt. He might help the Cubs play a good spoiler role down the stretch, and because it's the Cardinals, that's important for the fans. If White has a fun month or two, and the Cubs creep within five games by season's end, that's a pretty good starting point for MacPhail to work with in trying to coax White to stay beyond the 2001 option that you can expect to be exercised.

There's still the question of what kind of future the Cubs are trying to put together. Now that Damon Buford is in place and looking adequate for this year and next, and White is also under contract through next year and Sammy Sosa is his Sammyness, that doesn't leave a whole lot of opportunity for Corey Patterson to do much more than represent Iowa in the 2001 PCL All-Star Game.

The deal to pick up Keith Luuloa was a pretty good move, as long as they do the next sensible thing and liquidate Jeff Huson. I don't know who I'd rather have between Luuloa and Augie Ojeda, but I know who isn't doing the team much good. Picking up Ross Gload doesn't make much sense unless the Cubs want to build a platoon of Hee Seop Choi and Gload at some point next year. While that's a great idea, it would mean cutting the cord with Mark Grace, and you know that's impossible. If Grace were to somehow disappear, the organization couldn't possibly settle for anyone less than Tom Cruise, or maybe David Hasselhoff. Perhaps Puffy Combs, or a cute Joe Judge impersonator.


Acquired C Charles Johnson and DH Harold Baines from the Orioles for C Brook Fordyce and RHPs Miguel Felix, Juan Figueroa and Jason Lakman. [7/29]

As much as I like Mark Johnson (the one who catches), Charles Johnson is the third-best hitting catcher in the American League behind the now-gone Pudge Rodriguez and the Yankees' Jorge Posada. While he may not be Bob Boone behind the plate, he still intimidates base-stealers and he's still a good receiver. Supported by a Sox staff that's significantly better than the Orioles at holding runners, Johnson will be an asset on defense.

Harold Baines is nothing more than a sentimental pickup, at most around for a weekly spot start in his retired #3 or a pinch-hitting appearance or two for a situational matchups; he's no longer a good enough hitter to want up automatically instead of even Chris Singleton. But he'll get to hitch his worn-out wagon to the White Sox's push into the postseason, and considering how many years he labored in anonymity for the franchise, it's a nice gesture.

They won't miss the pitchers they gave up. Not one of them. Even after the trade, they've got a good half-dozen pitching prospects more than they know what to do with. It's a credit to the organization Ron Schueler has built that he can deal from this kind of strength to support a team that's finally his, and not a leftover from the almost-something Sox of 1993 and '94.


Acquired RHPs Bob Wickman, Steve Woodard and Jason Bere from the Brewers for OF/1B Richie Sexson, RHPs Paul Rigdon and Kane Davis and a PTBNL; acquired OF Wil Cordero from the Pirates for SS Enrique Wilson and OF Alex Ramirez; acquired 1B David Segui from the Rangers for OF Ricky Ledee; purchased the contract of UT Bill Selby from Buffalo; transferred RHP Charles Nagy from the 15- to the 60-day DL. [7/28]

Optioned RHP Tim Drew to Buffalo; designated RHP Jaime Navarro for assignment. [7/29]

The big question here is that if John Hart wanted to do all of this, why wait so long? It isn't as if the Brewers' wild-card fantasies hadn't already died by the end of April. Wil Cordero would have only cost money over the winter, instead of a good young shortstop. Turning David Justice into David Segui might lead to some slender defensive payoff, but it doesn't represent an overall offensive upgrade. Cordero meets a certain level of adequacy, but so would Alex Ramirez if he'd been given the chance. While there's a certain kind of bravura to the performance, at the end of the day, are the Indians really better?

They are, but it isn't because of the hitters they've hauled in. Having Manny Ramirez back will make the real impact on offense during the next two months.

The good news is on the pitching side of things. While Hart has deserved to be taken to task for his many shortsighted shopping sprees for pitching, whether it was John Smiley or Ricky Rincon or Dave Burba, this may be his best trade for pitching in his long career. Bob Wickman will get the glory role as closer, but he hasn't been a significantly better pitcher than Steve Karsay or Paul Shuey or Justin Speier.

Wickman is only the high-profile addition. Jason Bere isn't exactly special, but for a fifth starter, he'll be an adequate fill-in. The sleeper in the deal is the guy who could end up making the biggest difference, Steve Woodard. When his sinker is on, with a tight infield defense he can be dominating. When he's got Mark Loretta bellyflopping after balls heading into short left field, he's bad news. If Omar Vizquel is everything he's cracked up to be, Woodard could easily become the Tribe's third starter, and he's still a couple of years away from free agency.

Nobody else in these deals has that kind of potential. They're all serviceable journeymen, and it's only that Hart added so many of them, and needed so many of them, that made it such a high-profile weekend for the Indians.

The question is whether it's too little, too late. I still don't think the Tribe can catch the White Sox, but because of these deals I expect them to be neck-and-neck with whoever's in second place in the AL West down the stretch for the AL wild card. And in the playoffs, I wouldn't bet against any of the four teams that make it, because I expect three hard-fought, tight series. The costs have been very high, but the short-term payoff is there for the taking.


Acquired RHPs Brian Rose, John Wasdin and Jeff Taglienti and UT Jeff Frye from the Red Sox for RHPs Rolando Arrojo and Rick Croushore and IF Mike Lansing. [7/27]

Placed RHP Kevin Jarvis on the 15-day DL (back spasms). [7/28]

Sold the contract of OF Bubba Carpenter to Hyundai (Korean League); received LHP Sean Fesh from the Phillies to complete the Ed Vosberg trade. [7/29]

Acquired OFs Todd Hollandsworth and Kevin Gibbs and LHP Randy Dorame from the Dodgers for CF Tom Goodwin and cash. [7/31]

Because most of the players Dan O'Dowd picked up in these deals aren't good prospects and have little chance of playing critical roles in the team's future, think instead of most of these moves as maneuvers designed to give him flexibility going into the offseason.

There are some gems in this group. While he's no All-Star, Jeff Frye is good at getting on base (.289/.364/.354), something the Rox sorely need wherever they're playing. Todd Walker probably won't even force his way into a platoon role, which is another good indication of how far he's fallen. Todd Hollandsworth is a better offensive player than Goodwin once you adjust for the difference between Coors and Chavez Ravine, which makes the Dodgers deal all the sweeter when you consider that they got a very interesting pitching prospect in Randy Dorame as well as a good fourth outfielder in Kevin Gibbs.

Brian Rose is the most famous name, but he's also the guy I expect to fizzle. Unlike Dorame or even John Wasdin and Sean Fesh, he doesn't do a very good job of fooling batters very often. Now, I know I've been inclined to downplay the significance of the strikeout as opposed to other kinds of outs within the context of individual games, while saying that strikeouts are useful as a diagnostic tool in assessing a pitcher's future. But what if the Rox were looking at strikeouts against the backdrop of a bigger issue: avoiding balls in play in the most hitter-friendly ballpark major-league baseball has ever seen?

For example, it isn't that Gabe White is a homer-prone pitcher. He is, as is Wasdin. But what if the Rockies were looking at something more basic, like whether or not pitchers who were successful at Coors were more successful at getting batters to swing and miss, or get hitters to hit that two-seamed fastball they wanted them to pop up, or beat that low sinker they wanted them to send on its worm-killing way, or flail at that changeup they never expected? What if the Rockies are looking for guys who go back to the original goal of pitching, to upset the hitter's timing?

There are reasons that I'm beginning to suspect this is Dan O'Dowd's goal, but it's something I'm going to have to chew on a bit more to produce anything more important than this line of speculation.


Placed RHP Dave Mlicki on the 15-day DL, retroactive to 7/23 (sinus infection); recalled RHP Erik Hiljus from Toledo. [7/27]

Released DH Luis Polonia; purchased OF Billy McMillon from Toledo. [7/31]

Billy McMillon has only been ready to take a job from the Luis Polonias of the world for the last five years, so it's nice to see that he finally is getting an opportunity before he turns 30.

In Dave Mlicki's absence, Steve Sparks will continue to fill a spot in the rotation. That won't do much for the Tigers' push to stay out of last place, with only Randy Smith's future hanging in the balance. The organization's only important question is whether or not they'll fire Smith before he signs Juan Gonzalez to considerably more than he's worth, or because of it.


Placed SS Alex Gonzalez on the 15-day DL (sprained knee); recalled UT Chris Clapinski from Calgary. [7/28]

Placed OF Cliff Floyd on the 15-day DL (knee); purchased the contract of SS Mendy Lopez from Calgary. [7/29]

Acquired LF/1B Henry Rodriguez and cash from the Cubs for 1B Ross Gload and RHP Dave Noyce. [7/31]

Almost as fascinating as the Cubs' or the Angels' involvement in prestige politics while pretending to be in the running, the Marlins' decision to add Henry Rodriguez on the cheap is an interesting development. Are they really expecting to knock off the Mets? Do they really think this kind of move will suddenly generate booming ticket sales, or that the uninterested Florida market will suddenly rally to this team?

It would be great if they did, because in a lot of ways this is the kind of team Marlins fans might have expected on the basis of the club's early, patient, development-oriented program. This team, and not the thoughtful gamble of 1997, is the birthright of those fans who've been with this team from 1993 and Scott Pose's first at-bat, through the dim days of the era of Orestes Destrade. There's a lot here to like, and while I superficially believe that picking up Henry Rodriguez is nothing more than a hopeless gesture, in my heart of hearts, I hope that hard-core Marlins fans appreciate it.

It wasn't as if there are that many obvious alternatives. Abraham Nunez is hitting well in Portland, but he's also been DHing all season because of a shoulder injury. As bad as Rodriguez might be in the field, he's still physically able, and it's only John Henry's money we're talking about. If he's comfortable spending it on two months of Henry Rodriguez, and if he wants to pretend it will help him negotiate his way into a taxpayer hornswaggling and new stadium, more power to him.

With Oh Henry! on board, the Marlins have a pretty good platoon in left field between him and Kevin Millar. Unfortunately, John Boles will have to find playing time for all of them come September, and that's going to be a bit of a squeeze now that Derrek Lee has finally broken through.

If there's one sour note to sound, it's good riddance to Alex the Bad Gonzalez. While he managed to just get his nose over the Mendoza line before hurting himself (.201/.233/.320), he's giving tools goofs an even worse name than they deserve. The only man who ought to miss him is Pat Meares, if only because Gonzalez has been the only guy with a better claim than Meares for worst starting shortstop in the major leagues.


Acquired RHP Scott Linebrink from the Giants for RHP Doug Henry. [7/30]

Placed C Mitch Meluskey on the 15-day DL (shoulder); recalled C Raul Chavez up from New Orleans. [7/31]

If the Astros were worried about their draft position, losing Meluskey will certainly help. A job-sharing arrangement of Tony Eusebio and Raul Chavez won't produce runs, but it will create pinch-hitting opportunities for whichever outfielder isn't starting as well as Daryle Ward.

Here's the surprise in this space: that Moises Alou or Ward weren't traded. Expect a snafu involving Alou and a waiver-claim deal in the next couple of weeks, right around the time that Roger Cedeno comes off of the DL.


Purchased the contract of RHP Kris Wilson from Wichita (Double-A); designated RHP Doug Bochtler for assignment. [7/28]

Acquired RHP Brian Meadows from the Padres for RHP Jay Witasick. [7/31]

Talk about bitter pills. The Royals have invested almost two entire seasons in seeing what Jay Witasick can do, and now they have a very good idea. He has not been a good starting pitcher. Sure, he's had his moments of grandeur, but to call him inconsistent would be an insult to flakes everywhere. Nevertheless, he's shown a good fastball, and there are reasons to believe he could be a very effective relief pitcher.

Having punished patient and not-so-patient Royals fans with the experiment of seeing what he could do, what's the payoff? They turn a talented pitcher with a few problems into one of baseball's worst starting pitchers, bar none. Brian Meadows routinely gets hit hard despite pitching in some good pitchers' parks in the non-DH league. I don't care how much of a battler some sportswriters might call you, if you can't strike out four men per nine innings, it means you're getting hit. In the AL, that's a recipe for batting practice. If this is Allard Baird's idea of improvement, then Royals fans may want Herk Robinson's amiable aimlessness back.


Activated C Todd Hundley from the DL; optioned C Paul LoDuca to Albuquerque. [7/27]

Optioned RHP Eric Gagne and LHP Onan Masaoka to Albuquerque; activated RHP Gregg Olson from the DL; added RHP Ismael Valdes to the active roster; tranferred DH Geronimo Berroa from the 15- to the 60-day DL. [7/28]

Acquired CF Tom Goodwin and cash from the Rockies for OFs Todd Hollandsworth and Kevin Gibbs and LHP Randy Dorame. [7/31]

While I'd normally tout Todd Hundley's return as the start of great things, I don't see it unless he manages to maintain his incredible early season production. That's a combination of acknowledging that he won't hit as well as he did with how well Paul LoDuca and Chad Kreuter have done in his absence. Add in the misfortune of having to take Onan Masaoka off of the roster to make room for all of the Dodgers' remaining relief geezers and the pointless acquisition of Tom Goodwin, and you're left with a mishmash of moves that don't look like they add up to anything that will make up ground on the Snakes.

Goodwin's chief asset is his durability. While the Dodgers desperately need a leadoff hitter or something resembling one, this is only the second year in Goodwin's six years as a regular that he's posted an OBP significantly above the league average. Coming down out of Coors isn't going to help him keep it up.


Acquired 1B/LF Richie Sexson, RHPs Paul Rigdon and Kane Davis and a PTBNL from the Indians for RHPs Steve Woodard, Jason Bere and Bob Wickman. [7/28]

Purchased the contract of RHP Bob Scanlan from Indianapolis. [7/29]

Designated OF Chris Jones for assignment. [7/30]

Simply speaking, this was a bad trade. Sure, the Brewers need a right-handed power bat, and sure, Richie Sexson has been known to play one on TV. But he's only hitting .256/.315/.460 with a .250 EqA, a lousy performance for a left fielder or a first baseman. While the Brewers should be able to control the next four years of his career, getting his best seasons, is that really going to help them all that much?

Because they can expect Jeromy Burnitz to bail out at the first opportunity, they're looking at a lineup that will have to be built around Sexson, Geoff Jenkins and Ronnie Belliard. While all three have their uses, and Belliard might eventually develop into a superstar, that's a bunch of guys already in their mid 20s who are good, but not great.

In the absences of the pitchers now traded, the Brewers will do a few things differently. Davey Lopes has correctly identified Curtis Leskanic as his best reliever, which means he'll be limited to the least important role on a bad team, closer. A rotation spot is open, especially since the pitchers they've added are fodder at best. Kane Davis is a minor-league free agent getting more attention than he dreamed possible, and Paul Rigdon is one of those guys who might grow up to be Larry Luebbers.

Bob Scanlan was enjoying a superb year as Indy's closer (1.18 ERA, 26 saves), but he's Bob Scanlan. The open spot in the rotation should belong to Ben Sheets, assuming that the Brewers do the smart thing and call him up to avoid having him fall into Tommy Lasorda's clutches for use and abuse pitching for Team USA.


Optioned OF Chad Allen to Salt Lake; recalled CF Torii Hunter from Salt Lake. [7/29]

Acquired C Danny Ardoin from the Athletics in exchange for 1B Mario Valdez. [7/31]

Chad Allen's audition was brief, which is a good indication of his future with the club. Torii Hunter's future is far more secure. It isn't that anyone expects him to build on his great two months in Utah (.368/.403/.727). His skills are the ones this team seems to want from its fourth outfielder: he's still an outstanding center fielder and he can form a platoon of sorts with Jacque Jones in either center field or left field once Bobby Kielty comes up and takes the other position, perhaps as soon as September.

Picking up Danny Ardoin adds to the Twins' embarrassment of riches in good catch-and-throw catchers. Marcus Jensen is a good glove, as is Chad Moeller. Javy Valentin has his strong points, and Ardoin is another good glove. So whenever they decide Matt LeCroy is ready for good, they'll have a serious battle on their hands for who gets to be his caddy.

What's really stupid about this move is that it means that the Twins never appreciated what Mario Valdez could have done for them. They've already got a bunch of good catching catchers, while Valdez could have been their starting first baseman, with Corey Koskie at third base and David Ortiz at DH.

While I like a lot of what the Twins have accomplished in the last two years as an organization, they just blew an opportunity to have the next Matt Stairs on their hands, and possibly even better, because Valdez can pick it at first base. It's moves like this that lead to comments from Brian Cashman like the one he made last year about so-called small-market teams and their inability to help themselves.


Activated RHP Hideki Irabu from the DL. [7/27]

Returned RHP Hideki Irabu to the 15-day DL (sore elbow); recalled RHP Guillermo Mota from Ottawa. [7/28]

Acquired LHP Scott Downs from the Cubs for OF Rondell White. [7/31]

Jim Beattie may not be calling all of the shots any more, but guilt by association is still guilt. We'll tar the entire organization for turning Rondell White into a nifty fourth or fifth starter. It isn't that Scott Downs is so awful. He could very well turn into Greg Hibbard with time, and for those of you hardcore Bulldog fans out there, that's a happy thing. But White was a top commodity, he's under contract through next season, the commissioner's office had agreed to turn a blind eye to major-league baseball's injunctions against trading players on the DL...and this is all that the Expos could get for him?

The worst-case scenario? Trading White for a player two years from arbitration represents the first step of a decision by Jeff Loria to pull out and leave the Expos to his parsimonious Quebecois partners.


Activated SS Kurt Abbott from the DL; optioned RHP Grant Roberts to Norfolk. [7/27]

Acquired SS Mike Bordick from the Orioles for UT Melvin Mora, C/UT Mike Kinkade and RHPs Pat Gorman and Lesli Brea; recalled 1B Jorge Toca and OF Jason Tyner from Norfolk; acquired OF Bubba Trammell and RHP Rick White from the Devil Rays for Tyner and RHP Paul Wilson. [7/28]

Optioned 1B Jorge Toca and PH Mark Johnson to Norfolk; designated LHP Rich Rodriguez for assignment; activated 3B Robin Ventura from the 15-day DL. [7/29]

It might surprise you to hear that Mike Bordick has been the fifth-best hitting shortstop in the majors this year, but it isn't that shocking. He's behind the Big Three and Barry Larkin, and that's it.

The Mets ended up getting two months of Bordick pretty cheaply. Melvin Mora and Mike Kinkade are nifty bench players in the NL, but no more than that. Pat Gorman is in his third year in the Sally League and Lesli Brea is the lone prospect of the lot, and "pitching prospect" still ends up being an oxymoron more often than not.

Nabbing Rick White and Bubba Trammell for a useless speed goof and the last busted-up "Young Gun" is a steal, pure and simple. White has been one of the best relievers in all of baseball and gives the Mets a pair of durable middle men between him and Turk Wendell. Hats off to Steve Phillips, because he managed to significantly strengthen his team's shot at the NL wild card while only giving up one possible prospect and no good major-league players. While he didn't bring in the starting pitcher that the Mets have needed since discarding Masato Yoshii, he managed to do everything but that, and with a weak hand.

The Mets lineup and bench are shaping up nicely as well. They've got three benchies who can play anywhere even after trading Mora (Kurt Abbott, Lenny Harris and Joe McEwing). They have Bubba Trammell around as a great fourth outfielder, although that term is basically meaningless when there isn't a whole lot of difference among Trammell, Benny Agbayani and Derek Bell. The only thing limiting their playing time is the fact that none of them can play center field, which means Jay Payton will continue to play regularly.

Amidst all of this reshuffling, you could almost miss the return of Robin Ventura. That would be a mistake. With four right-handed-hitting outfielders and a right-handed hitting shortstop with pop, he's the lone lefty in the lineup, and they're going to need him for that, now more than ever.


Activated RHP Ramiro Mendoza from the DL; optioned RHP Darrell Einertson to Columbus. [7/28]

For the time being, Ramiro Mendoza is in the pen and David Cone is still employed. That's just as well, because while the Yankees can string along Cone's future for as long as El Duque is on the DL, they desperately need Mendoza in the pen. They've overused Jason Grimsley and they discarded Todd Erdos. Without Mendoza, they lack an adequate right-handed middle reliever.

What's interesting for the Yankees is the choice they'll have to make once El Duque is ready. As bad as Cone has been, the Yankees would probably have made do with him if Doc Gooden hadn't scuffled in, taken his last shot at being an effective five-inning fifth starter and run with it. While the decision is meaningless in terms of the playoffs (the playoff rotation is some combination of Orlando Hernandez, Denny Neagle, Roger Clemens and Andy Pettitte), it will undoubtedly generate all sorts of Big Apple angst, an unwilling trip to the DL, a frank admission that "this is my last year," and all sorts of speculation about how somebody's career proves that nobody will ever win 300 games ever again. And most of it will be a bunch of hot air, including that last one.


Acquired RHP Jim Mecir and LHP Todd Belitz from the Devil Rays for RHP Jesus Colome and a PTBNL. [7/28]

Transferred DH John Jaha from the 15- to the 60-day DL; designated RHP Marcus Jones for assignment; assigned LHP Todd Belitz to Sacramento. [7/29]

Optioned RHP Ariel Prieto to Sacramento. [7/30]

Acquired 1B Mario Valdez from the Twins for C Danny Ardoin. [7/31]

As good as Jim Mecir is--and he's been one of the five best relievers in the majors according to Michael Wolverton's Reliever Evaluation Tools--I have a really bad feeling about this move. Not quite a Larry Andersen/Jeff Bagwell sort of nausea, more of a Dave Parker/Jose Rijo kind of heartburn, where no matter what the old guy does, I know I'm going to hate this deal a lot more two years from now.

Mecir does give the A's a good third reliever, which is critical considering the divide between Jason Isrnghausen and Jeff Tam on the one side, and Doug Jones, T.J. Mathews and Mike Magnante ("I gave up a first-round draft choice and all I got was this lousy lefty."). But as good as Mecir has been, he's always had freaky bad luck with injuries, and are three good relievers enough? While getting something is better than nothing, they're still going to have to count on Jones or Mathews to have a good couple of weeks sometime soon. I end up liking the Mariners' chances more the more I think about it.

That's the good news. The bad news is that as much as I know, and as much as you know, that there's no such thing as a pitching prospect, Jesus Colome might be the owner of one of the ten best fastballs on the planet. It's worse still to see him go to one of baseball's worst-run teams, and to have to wonder if they'll end up screwing him up so badly that few will remember his talent well enough to give Billy Beane a hard time ten years from now. I'll say it now, with regret for what could have been: I hope Colome has one hell of a career as a Devil Ray almost as much as I hope Jim Mecir ends up being a key player for the A's in the playoffs this year.


Placed RHP Paul Byrd on the 15-day DL (multiple tears - shoulder); recalled RHP Cliff Politte from Scranton/Wilkes-Barre. [7/28]

Acquired RHP Kent Bottenfield from the Angels for LF Ron Gant. [7/30]

Acquired RHP John Sneed from the Blue Jays as the PTBNL in the Ducey deal; transferred Byrd from the 15- to the 60-day DL. [7/31]

You have to hand it to the Phillies; hardly a week goes by without another mixed bag. Getting a pitcher as good as John Sneed for such an easily replaceable commodity as Rob Ducey is a flat-out steal, and now you can add a big (6'6") hard thrower to the growing group of exceptional young pitchers that Ed Wade has managed to assemble out of a season that had started off as a major debacle.

Which can only leave us scratching our noggins wondering where the original weeble-wobble pitcher fits in. Kent Bottenfield is one of the game's better utility pitchers, but what is he doing on this team? He could definitely help out in the bullpen, but will he go back to the pen after last year's 18-win fluke? Now that Paul Byrd is done for the season, the Phillies are better off reserving rotation spots to evaluate guys like Sneed and Cliff Politte and Amaury Telemaco, to sort out who can help and how soon.

All three could help right now, with Sneed preferably in the pen, but a lot still depends on Terry Francona's capacity to learn from his mistakes as a manager. As much as he has been inclined to leave his starters in too long, as Vicente Padilla now knows, that goes for relievers too. If Wade doesn't straighten Francona out soon, then he'll be allowing his manager to waste the organization's few assets on the sort of silly machismo stunts that ought to have been packed up with Curt Schilling.


Acquired SS Enrique Wilson and OF Alex Ramirez from the Indians for OF Wil Cordero. [7/28]

Activated RHP Francisco Cordova from the DL; placed RHP Todd Ritchie on the 15-day DL. [7/29]

Acquired SS Jack Wilson from the Cardinals for LHP Jason Christiansen. [7/30]

Agreed to terms on a two-year contract extension with OF/1B John VanderWal. [7/31]

Cam Bonifay is sort of the Anti-Herk in that while he screws up so many things in his pursuit of mediocrity, every few months or so he shakes down John Hart for something he desperately needs. Heck, maybe he's got a running bet with Jim Bowden on who can get the most talent from Hart while giving up the most thoroughly average guys in return.

While Bonifay was being touted for his genius for bringing in Pat Meares because somehow the Twins were obviously cheap beyond words to not overpay for one of the game's worst all-around shorstops, it wasn't long (roughly ten minutes or so) before the Pirates needed another shortstop. Now, almost two years later, they've got a potential All-Star in Enrique Wilson. He's got an outstanding throwing arm, which he'll finally get to show off on a regular basis, and he's a better hitter than most shortstops, especially in the league where the Big Three ain't.

In a world where you can always excuse multi-year deals for mediocre corner outfielders because you can claim that you might be able to peddle them for talent, Bonifay actually pulled it off. He even capped it by rewarding a better hitter than Wil Cordero, John VanderWal, with a multi-year deal. If ever the Bucs finally find a center fielder, they're set in the corners. Alex Ramirez will end up making a great platoon partner for VanderWal, assuming the Pirates can finally sort through their half-dozen good fourth outfielders and make some decisions on who to keep around.

Now Bonifay just has to get Pat Meares's carcass in some other uniform, but that may have to wait until after A-Rod has chosen where he wants to be next year.

What's funny about the deal with the Indians is that no sooner had Bonifay acquired a major-league-ready regular shortstop than he nabbed one of the other good shortstop prospects around, Jack Wilson. While Wilson's eventual position may end up being somewhere other than shortstop (perhaps center field?), he's an outstanding young hitter (.294/.368/.452 at Double-A Arkansas).

In the meantime, Gene Lamont loses another starter, which allows Bronson Arroyo to continue to improve with each outing. The intended rotation of Kris Benson, Francisco Cordova, Jose Silva, Todd Ritchie and Jason Schmidt may not take the field again this year, but in the meantime the Pirates will have a good opportunity to evaluate Arroyo and Jimmy Anderson. Because I expect really bad news on the Schmidt front, they should have a spot open for one of the kids next summer.


Activated OF J.D. Drew from the DL; optioned 1B Chris Richard to Memphis. [7/27]

Optioned RHP Mark Thompson to Memphis; recalled RHP Gene Stechschulte from Memphis. [7/28]

Acquired RHP Mike Timlin from the Orioles for RHP Mark Nussbeck and 1B Chris Richard. [7/29]

Acquired LHP Jason Christiansen from the Pirates for SS Jack Wilson; optioned RHP Gene Stechschulte to Memphis. [7/30]

Acquired C Carlos Hernandez and UT Nathan Tebbs from the Padres for RHP Heathcliff Slocumb and OF Ben Johnson; acquired 1B Will Clark and cash from the Orioles for 3B Jose Leon. [7/31]

Part of this is reaping what you sow, part of this is just downright silly, and all of it may not be enough to hold off the Reds.

First off, with the exception of J.D. Drew's return, none of these moves do much to make sure the Reds don't get any closer. The Cards never should have gotten themselves into the position of carrying Matt Morris and Alan Benes and Mark Thompson simultaneously. Now, because Tony LaRussa devoted time and roster space to multiple rehabbing starters, he's stuck with Alan Benes down the stretch. Because the Cardinals got all hot and bothered about the great Mike Matheny, they're stuck with him. By acquiring Carlos Hernandez, they not only ended up discarding someone (Heathcliff Slocumb) who was pitching better than new Cardinal Mike Timlin, they ended up getting someone only infinitesimally better than Matheny as a hitter and an undeserving excuse for keeping Eli Marrero off the postseason roster.

For that, they gave up on Ben Johnson, an outstanding young outfield prospect. To get a useful lefty reliever, they gave up Jack Wilson, arguably their best position-player prospect. At least they didn't give up that much to get Timlin and Will Clark. While each of them should be useful, they're not going to be as useful to the Cardinals as a Sean Casey returning to form will be for the Reds.

All in all, the Cardinals have remained true to their basic goal for the year: win at all costs. Their maimed farm system has been pruned some more, and the season still remains in doubt because of the injury to Mark McGwire. If this serves as a bitter reminder for how the organization wasted the previous three seasons with a (usually) healthy McGwire, so be it.


Activated C Carlos Hernandez from the DL; optioned LHP David Maurer to Las Vegas. [7/28]

Acquired RHP Heathcliff Slocumb and OF Ben Johnson from the Cardinals for C Carlos Hernandez and UT Nathan Tebbs; acquired RHP Jay Witasick from the Royals for RHP Brian Meadows; acquired RF/1B John Mabry and RHP Tom Davey from the Mariners for DH Al Martin. [7/31]

Remind me, which team is trying to add veteran arms for its pennant drive? Why in God's name the Padres want Heathcliff Slocumb and Jay Witasick is beyond me. While dumping Brian Meadows makes all sorts of sense, trading Carlos Hernandez to get Slocumb almost looks like the exact opposite of Cam Bonifay's trading Wil Cordero for Enrique Wilson. Hernandez got a big multi-year deal for no good reason when his value was higher than it would ever be again, and Slocumb is a journeyman reliever.

But it's the throw-in that produced the payoff for Kevin Towers. Ben Johnson is probably the only outfield prospect the Cardinals have. He's just turned 19, he's hitting for power in the Midwest League, has reasonable speed and command of the strike zone and doesn't look like he should be in this deal.

On the other hand, he didn't get anything close to value for Al Martin, even if you make allowances for Martin's recent conversion to old-school Mormonism and the resulting legal entanglements. John Mabry is a defensive replacement in right field who isfrequently asked to do things he can't, like hit or play third base, and Tom Davey is earning a reputation for being hard-headed and uncoachable while struggling to regain the prospect status prematurely given to him coming up through the Blue Jays' organization.

Because he's taking Meadows' place on the roster, Witasick will probably be asked to continue to work as a starter. It doesn't help that Stan Spencer had to be shut down on rehab.


Acquired RHP Doug Henry from the Astros for RHP Scott Linebrink. [7/30]

Don't laugh, but Doug Henry immediately goes from being part of the problem in an underachieving Astros pen to the third-best reliever Dusty Baker has to his name. After Robb Nen and Felix Rodriguez, the Giants haven't been getting good innings or work out of anybody. Henry may be tateriffic (with 10 allowed in his 53 innings) and he can't blame Enron Field for his problems, but he is coming to one what may be one of the better pitchers' parks in baseball, and he's been pretty unhittable overall: 39 hits and 28 walks with 46 strikeouts and a 4.42 ERA in those 53 innings.


Acquired DH Al Martin from the Padres for RF/1B John Mabry and RHP Tom Davey. [7/31]

The key issue for the Mariners going into the deadline was whether or not they would have to part with one of their seven starting pitchers to add a left-handed-hitting outfielder. Pat Gillick managed to accomplish the mission, and do considerably better than that.

First, Al Martin, despite his obvious defensive shortcomings, is a better player to have around than B.J. Surhoff if what you want is a bat for the short term. Second, Martin's problems aren't a major problem with the Mariners because he'll be sharing playing time in the outfield corners with Jay Buhner, Rickey Henderson and Stan Javier. Third, addition by subtraction is still addition, and getting John Mabry out of the lineup and away from third base is a good move. Fourth, well, they didn't end up finding somebody to help out at second base or third base, but they still have the seven starters.

That, more than anything else, is the reason why I think they'll be able to hold off the A's down the stretch. Even if Lou Piniella falls back into his old ways and abuses (and loses) one starter or even two starters down the stretch, the Mariners aren't going to have to dig up Salomon Torres or start Frankie Rodriguez. They're covered. Sad to say, but I like their chances of holding the A's off.


Acquired OF Jason Tyner and RHP Paul Wilson from the Mets for OF Bubba Trammell and RHP Rick White; acquired RHP Jesus Colome and a PTBNL from the Athletics for RHP Jim Mecir and LHP Todd Belitz. [7/28]

Recalled RHP Travis Harper from Durham. [7/29]

Acquired 2B Brent Abernathy from the Blue Jays for RHP Steve Trachsel and LHP Mark Guthrie. [7/31]

When it comes to deals, Chuck LaMar is an omnivore. Spit-take laughers or great pickups, he manages to mix them up. In this case, getting Jesus Colome from the A's is a significant coup. It isn't enough to make up for getting raped by the Mets or discarding two useful veteran pitchers for a middling second-base prospect, but it's probably the highlight of the entire season for the organization.

With a fastball that routinely tops 100, Colome has been remarked upon early and often. In one of the toughest hitters' parks in the minor leagues, Midland, he's managed to keep his ERA under 4.00 (3.59) while allowing 99 hits and 50 walks in 110 1/3 innings, with only ten home runs allowed and 95 strikeouts. He's been especially tough on left-handed hitters, who struggle to catch up with his heater, and rarely get any of his stuff out of the infield. He's got a groundball-to-flyball ratio of around 1.5, which I always like to see out of a power pitcher. He wasn't especially hurt by Midland, pitching about as effectively on the road as at home.

That's the good move, and it sticks out like Bill Clinton's unzipped legacy. The other moves? Jason Tyner is a singles-hitting stiff, everything LaMar wanted Randy Winn to grow up to be and more. Having learned nothing from trying to play Winn, LaMar seems determined to keep trying with bad players until he gets himself fired. Paul Wilson doesn't look like a good bet to recapture anything approaching his former gleam as a prospect, since he was scuffling along at Norfolk. To give up a good hitter like Bubba Trammell and one of the best relievers in baseball in Rick White for two guys who may never make it in the majors borders on criminal; combined with getting Colome for one of the other best relievers in baseball it is simply boggling.

As for getting Brent Abernathy, while he's a better player than Miguel Cairo could ever hope to be, and a better second baseman than Russ Johnson, I have a hard time believing that this was really the best LaMar could do for a solid starter and a good left-handed reliever. I'd like to think that it was a salary-driven move made at the deadline, in a scramble. On the other hand, if making the trade with the Mets was the product of lots of prior thought, then the Devil Rays might be better off keeping LaMar under a ten-second deadline to keep him from thinking too much.


Acquired OF Ricky Ledee from the Indians for 1B David Segui. [7/28]

While I'm not one of Ledee's more enthusiastic believers, this isn't a bad move for the Rangers. Ledee's stats (.235/.325/.408) hardly bear this one out, but he's still got his fuzzy prospect glow, and having him (instead of Lee Stevens, let alone David Segui) gives the Rangers a good opportunity to go into next spring with some flexibility and some talent to fix problems.

Set aside the idea of using Ledee as a center fielder. Johnny Oates' first choice was to put Gabe Kapler in center, which was the better option. Set aside fretting about whether or not playing first base could get Raffy Palmeiro hurt; it's a risk they're willing to take, and unless they get hideously unlucky, if he suffers a minor injury it isn't as if anything is at stake. What Ledee gives the Rangers is a solid insurance policy in case Ruben Mateo doesn't heal well over the winter. If Mateo heals quickly and plays winter ball, then the Rangers will have some choices about who and what they can deal: maybe Rusty Greer for top value, maybe Ledee for another prospect, maybe Frank Catalanotto to a team that needs a second baseman. If they can turn any kind of deal into something that includes getting Darrren Oliver's contract and claim on a rotation spot off of their hands, even if they have to eat some of the money, then they really come out ahead.


Placed RF Raul Mondesi on the 15-day DL, retroactive to 7/22 (sore elbow). [7/27]

Acquired RHP Steve Trachsel and LHP Mark Guthrie from the Devil Rays for 2B Brent Abernathy. [7/31]

The trade with the Devil Rays isn't so cut and dried. Unfortunately, Abernathy was the only viable organizational alternative to ending the Homer Bush-Craig Grebeck charade at second. So while bringing in Trachsel plugs the Roy Halladay-sized hole in the rotation and gives the Jays a pretty solid unit for the next two months, they're stuck with Bush and Grebeck the rest of the way. The only reason Trachsel was available for so little was his incentive-laden contract, where the incentives are about to start kicking in with a venegeance. That means the Jays can look forward to an unhappy balance of trying to catch the Yankees while having to cut extra checks, win or lose.

But let's focus on the positive: a rotation of Jumbo Wells followed by Frank Castillo, Steve Trachsel, Kelvim Escobar and Esteban Loaiza gives the Jays a solid rotation, and it wouldn't be unreasonable to expect Chris Carpenter and Halladay to be helpful in the pen. The only concern is Mike Royko's dreaded ex-Cub factor, considering that Castillo and Trachsel used to be the young guns in the rotation of some really lousy Cubs teams in the mid-90s. It only gets worse when you remember Guthrie pitched for the Cubs for a few months.

Replacing Mondesi with a platoon of Rob Ducey and Marty Cordova is never a good thing, but at least the Jays have the happy news that Mondesi should be back within two weeks.

The balancing act for the Jays is whether these recent band-aids for the rotation are enough to paper over major problems, like another weak bench, more offensive zeroes at second at short, and a still-ugly bullpen. Gord Ash played for low stakes while trying to win the AL East, and I can't help but feel he didn't do enough to help his team improve its shot at the postseason for the third year in a row.

Chris Kahrl can be reached at ckahrl@baseballprospectus.com.

Christina Kahrl is an author of Baseball Prospectus. 
Click here to see Christina's other articles. You can contact Christina by clicking here

Related Content:  Fans,  Chicago White Sox,  Oakland A's,  Alex Rodriguez,  Pitching,  Bob Johnson,  Cubs,  Carlos Gonzalez,  Orioles,  Third Base,  Shortstop,  Left-handed Pitcher,  Right-handed Pitcher,  Will Myers,  Jason Parks,  Minor League Baseball,  A's,  Out Of My League,  Left Field,  Right Field,  Corey Hart,  Prospect,  Chris Carpenter,  Designated Hitters,  Starting Pitchers,  Back,  Deal,  Mike Minor,  John Schuerholz,  Designated Hitter,  Dh,  Randy Johnson,  Yankees Prospects,  Best Season,  Worst Seasons,  Keith Hernandez,  Chris Young,  Mark Grace,  Starting Pitching,  Sean Rodriguez,  Bench Players,  Starting Rotation,  C.j. Wilson,  The Who,  Brian Wilson,  White Sox,  Minor League Player Of The Year,  Bench,  Matt Downs,  Chris Davis,  Juan Francisco,  Dan Johnson,  What You Need To Know,  Ed Wade,  Time,  Chris Johnson,  Good Plays,  Mike Schmidt,  One-hitter,  John Jay,  Rotation,  Mark Grant,  David Segui,  Raul Mondesi,  Mark Mcgwire,  J.d. Drew,  Ricky Rincon,  Bad Start,  Position Player As Pitcher,  Scott Downs,  Jeff Loria,  Paul LoDuca,  Melvin Mora,  Frank Francisco,  Hitting,  Francisco Rodriguez,  Jeff Kent,  John Dowd,  Brian Cashman,  Kevin Cash,  John Buck,  Off-season,  John Henry,  Charles Johnson,  Frank Castillo,  Will Clark,  Jason Werth,  David Wells,  Alex White,  Left-handed Hitters,  Kevin Gregg,  Mike Timlin,  Yankees Fans,  All-star Weekend,  Year Of The Injury,  Trade To Dodgers,  Long-term Contract,  Marlins Trade For Carlos Lee,  Astros Trade Carlos Lee,  Fourth Of July,  Korean League,  Alex Ramirez,  Ruben Rivera,  A-rod,  All-star Break,  Off-day,  The Call-up,  Platoon,  Bad Season,  Trading Deadline,  Juan Rivera,  Impact Trade,  Trading,  Henry Rodriguez,  Bobby Jones,  Todd Jones,  Call-up,  Throwing Up,  Left-handed Pitchers,  News,  Best,  Throwing At Batters,  Flamethrower,  Pitchers Hitting,  Jack Wilson,  Team,  Kevin Long,  Stretch Run,  Regular-season Awards,  Manager Of The Year,  Francisco Cordero,  Playoff Rotation,  Steve Johnson

0 comments have been left for this article.

No Previous Article
<< Previous Column
Transaction Analysis: ... (07/28)
Next Column >>
Transaction Analysis: ... (08/04)
No Next Article

Premium Article Minor League Update: Games of August 16
What You Need to Know: The Thin Line Between...
Premium Article The Prospectus Hit List: August 17, 2017
Short Relief: Underappreciated Player Week: ...
Eyewitness Accounts: August 17, 2017
Premium Article Flu-Like Symptoms: Pitching Panacea?
Rubbing Mud: Lineups Are Just a Social Const...

The Daily Prospectus: Too Much Good Stuff

2000-08-09 - Transaction Analysis: August 3-6, 2000
2000-08-08 - The Daily Prospectus: B.J. Surhoff
2000-08-04 - Transaction Analysis: August 1-3, 2000
2000-08-01 - Transaction Analysis: July 27-31, 2000
2000-07-31 - AL Central Notebook
2000-07-28 - Transaction Analysis: July 24-26, 2000
2000-07-25 - Transaction Analysis: July 21-23, 2000

2000-08-11 - Transaction Analysis: August 7-9, 2000
2000-08-09 - Transaction Analysis: August 3-6, 2000
2000-08-04 - Transaction Analysis: August 1-3, 2000
2000-08-01 - Transaction Analysis: July 27-31, 2000
2000-07-28 - Transaction Analysis: July 24-26, 2000
2000-07-25 - Transaction Analysis: July 21-23, 2000
2000-07-24 - Transaction Analysis: July 17-20, 2000