CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
Click here to log in Click here for forgotten password Click here to subscribe

<< Previous Article
A Worthy Tradition (10/20)
<< Previous Column
Premium Article GM for a Day: Milwauke... (10/19)
Next Column >>
GM for a Day: Clevelan... (10/21)
Next Article >>
Premium Article Playoff Prospectus: We... (10/20)

October 20, 2010

GM for a Day

Chicago Cubs

by Ben Lindbergh

the archives are now free.

All Baseball Prospectus Premium and Fantasy articles more than a year old are now free as a thank you to the entire Internet for making our work possible.

Not a subscriber? Get exclusive content like this delivered hot to your inbox every weekday. Click here for more information on Baseball Prospectus subscriptions or use the buttons to the right to subscribe and get instant access to the best baseball content on the web.

Subscribe for $4.95 per month
Recurring subscription - cancel anytime.

a 33% savings over the monthly price!

Purchase a $39.95 gift subscription
a 33% savings over the monthly price!

Already a subscriber? Click here and use the blue login bar to log in.

As GM for the day, I’m setting this article’s agenda. So while it might be poor form, allow me to lead with a table:


Payroll ($)

NL Payroll Rank

Winning Percentage

NL Winning Percentage Rank


























The Cubs’ trajectory over the past several seasons has loosely followed the plot of Martin Scorcese’s Casino: vast sums of money have changed hands, a new family seized power, and a successful operation arose where formerly none had thrived, only to be undone by its own profligacy and poor judgment. Naturally, the proceedings have been punctuated by a few Pesci-caliber meltdowns along the way. If the events of Jim Hendry’s tenure were adapted for the screen, one could easily imagine the world-weary GM narrating, “In the end, I wound up right back where I started,” as “The House of the Rising Sun” reached a crescendo and a bat-wielding Alfonso Soriano flailed away at the broken and bleeding body of a billy goat (which, like most of the intended targets of Soriano’s swings, would lie buried in the dirt).

Hendry inherited a 2002 Cubs team that went on to finish fifth in the National League Central; eight-plus years down the road, he finds himself performing a postmortem on a club that recently finished in an identical position, albeit with a more respectable record. The deceased went 75-87, and was spared the ignominy of cellar dwelling only by the happy circumstance of sharing a division with the Pirates. In between those fifth-place bookends, Hendry built a winner, but he did so at a steep cost that continues to hamstring the organization’s efforts.

During the 2006-07 offseason, Hendry committed nearly $300 million to outside talent, which may or may not have played a role in the angioplasty he was forced to undergo at the ’06 Winter Meetings. Shelling out stacks of cash for pricey wins on the free-agent market isn’t the most elegant way to build a winner, but one can’t deny that it worked: Hendry transformed a worst-place team into a first-place team in the span of a single offseason, while a more gradual rebuilding plan might have taken years.

The 2007 squad that sent the Cubs back to the postseason for the first time since the Bartman debacle in 2003 was deeply flawed, but the 2008 club was unquestionably the class of the National League. The downside of the free-agent fixer-upper approach to rebuilding is the short shelf life of the reconstructed product: even a youth movement eventually gets expensive, but at least theoretically, its building blocks don’t reach the wrong side of 30 until their team has enjoyed ample opportunity to contend. Since recruiting well-established mercenaries inevitably requires payment for past performance, a free-agent-for-all like the one in which Hendry indulged invariably sets the clock ticking at about a quarter to midnight.

Those 15 minutes were fun, but after developing a distinctly orange cast last season, the roster turned full pumpkin in 2010, leaving Hendry with a payroll fit for a winner and a collection of players fit for fifth place. Courtesy of the Cubs bats’ mass disappearance during their last two abbreviated trips to October, Hendry and owner Tom Ricketts are left holding the tab without even a single Division Series victory to show for it.

The Cubs’ 75-87 record was a perfect match for their third-order record, so there’s no way to sugarcoat their lack of success. Were I anointed the Cubs’ GM for a day, I’d spend my first few minutes at the helm creatively cursing my predecessor, since the back-loaded, long-term pacts inked by Hendry have left little room to maneuver. Ricketts would reportedly like to cut payroll before next season (and who could blame him), but he and Hendry won’t achieve that goal by sitting around and waiting for contracts to expire. The Cubs’ roster contains only one free agent—Xavier Nady—and the albatrosses elsewhere on the roster will most likely prove extraordinarily resistant to migration.

The Cubs already have $102.5 million allocated to players in 2011—with a frightening $38 million of that ticketed for Soriano and Carlos Zambrano alone—and that figure is set to rise after arbitration, which should award raises to Geovany Soto, Carlos Marmol, Tom Gorzelanny, Sean Marshall, and Jeff Baker. The Cubs have six players slated for salaries well over $10 million (though Seattle will pick up a sizeable portion of Carlos Silva’s), and the North Siders probably won’t be able to unload any of them without eating the balance or accepting equally undesirable outlays in return (although the Red Sox have been linked to Aramis Ramirez).

Chicago’s bullpen was bad enough to warrant a foray into what’s shaping up to be a fairly rich relief market, but the starting pitching doesn’t qualify as a glaring problem. Zambrano won seven of his final nine starts, posting a 1.06 ERA and striking out 54 over that 59 2/3-inning stretch, although a .218 BABIP hid his 31 walks over the same period. His velocity isn’t what it once was, and his 4.30 SIERA suggests that regression might be looming, but defense-independent statistics have never fully come to grips with Zambrano’s apparent ability to limit hits and homers on balls in play. Of course, even an unlikely return to Cy Young form would be a mixed blessing for his employers, since a first- or second-place finish in next year’s voting (or a top-four finish in 2012) would activate his $19.25 million option for 2013. Beyond Zambrano, the Cubs’ rotation features scant ace potential, but more than enough depth to convince them to lock Jeff Samardzija in the bullpen and throw away the key.

Just two seasons removed from ranking second in the National League, the Cubs’ TAv fell to a 14th-place .253, dragged down by the lowest walk rate this side of the Pirates and Astros. Only Soto and Kosuke Fukudome accepted free passes at a significantly above-average rate; Soto, the Cubs’ best hitter, was often buried near the end of the lineup or benched altogether in favor of the weak-hitting Koyie Hill, a perplexing pattern that reflected either a catastrophic failure in talent evaluation, or an effort to protect an ailing shoulder that required arthroscopic surgery in September. Either way, a healthy Soto in the heart of the lineup would give the Cubs a boost in 2011, as would an expected rebound by Ramirez.

With the departure of Derrek Lee in mid-August, first base became a black hole. Adam Dunn would be one way to fill it, but given his defensive shortcomings and the Cubs’ already extensive collection of high-priced veterans, the team would be wise to go with a one-season stopgap until 2012, when Fukudome, Ramirez, and Silva come off the books just as a number of big first base bats hit the market. Wrigley Field is well-suited for left-handed power, and the likes of Russell Branyan, Adam LaRoche, Lance Berkman, or Lyle Overbay (or even Aubrey Huff or Carlos Pena, if they could be convinced to settle for a single year) might be willing to capitalize until the Cubs can take a shot at convincing Adrian Gonzalez or Prince Fielder to follow suit. With four players competing for three spots and no obvious platoon solution, the Cubbies will have to get creative with their outfield alignments; Tyler Colvin might be stretched as an everyday option, but it would be a shame to condemn him to a Francoeur-like future by denying him potential development time.

Until Tuesday, one more vacancy remained to be filled, since Lou Piniella’s departure left the Cubs’ collection of on-field talent without an officially sanctioned dugout doyen. Like many a freshly minted GM before me, I might have been tempted to succumb to the overwhelming urge to install one of “my guys” in the skipper’s office, thereby consigning Mike Quade to the managerial recycling bin. However, since I’ll be vacating his office at the end of the day, Hendry did well to remove the “interim” tag from the veteran coach, who steered his team to a 24-13 record following Sweet Lou’s swan song, earning the respect of both his players and his general manager in the process.

 Contention isn’t out of the question for the Cubs in 2011, but the overstuffed state of the roster will limit what their GM can do to improve their chances over the next several months (let alone the course of a single day), and help from the farm isn’t imminent. Hendry has little choice but to wait for the passage of time to bail him out of the mess he created, and hope that he’s still calling the shots when the payroll again permits more flexibility. The next presidential term will be nearly half over by the time the team frees itself of the last vestiges of its post-2006 spending frenzy, but if Ricketts’ recent ode to developing from within turns out to be something more than lip service, the organization’s next attempt at Curse-breaking might meet with more success.  

Ben Lindbergh is an author of Baseball Prospectus. 
Click here to see Ben's other articles. You can contact Ben by clicking here

Related Content:  Cubs,  Jim Hendry

17 comments have been left for this article. (Click to hide comments)

BP Comment Quick Links


I'm pretty sure Adam Dunn has been mentioned as a solution in every GM for a Day article so far. I'm far too lazy to go check, but I'm almost certain. I hope his agent has been reading, for his sake.

Oct 20, 2010 06:20 AM
rating: 4
Richard Bergstrom

You want Overbay as left handed power?

Oct 20, 2010 09:18 AM
rating: 1
BP staff member Ben Lindbergh
BP staff

OK, so Lyle Overbay isn't about to make anyone forget Ernie Banks (or Leon Durham, for that matter), but he merits a mention in the one-year rental discussion. Even Overbay's power, such as it is, would likely play up at Wrigley.

Oct 20, 2010 12:31 PM
Ric Size

This GM for a day article had the most lyrical quality of any submitted so far.

Oct 20, 2010 09:43 AM
rating: 2

"...and a bat-wielding Alfonso Soriano flailed away at the broken and bleeding body of a billy goat (which, like most of the intended targets of Soriano’s swings, would lie buried in the dirt"

Love it.

Also concur with CRP13...as we say in architecture circles, Dunn has become the "caulk" solution. If nothing else works, just fill it with caulk.

Oct 20, 2010 10:10 AM
rating: 0
BP staff member Ben Lindbergh
BP staff

Well, for what it's worth, I didn't actually suggest that the Cubs sign Dunn. I mentioned him as an option--I'd be remiss in my GM duties if I overlooked the possibility entirely--but I don't think they'd necessarily be best-served by corralling the Big Donkey.

...Do people keep donkeys in corrals? Well, either way, the sentence stands.

Oct 20, 2010 12:07 PM

Dunn is a great solution for any team in MLB looking for a power hitting 1B. So I'm not slamming your mention of him, just poking fun.

Unfortunately for the other 5-6 clubs mentioned in GM-faD articles, he can only go to one. So thanks for offering up the other options rather than saying, "OMFG THE CUBS HAVE TO SIGN DUNNZORZ!"

Oct 20, 2010 14:01 PM
rating: 0

Adam Dunn has the same number of letters in his name as "Duct Tape".


I think not.

Oct 20, 2010 13:59 PM
rating: 2
BP staff member Ken Funck
BP staff

Nor is it a coincidence that his name is an anagram for "Add'n U, Man"

Oct 20, 2010 14:04 PM


Oct 20, 2010 14:10 PM
rating: 0
BP staff member Ben Lindbergh
BP staff

I'm guessing those of you in architectural circles make sure to emphasize that silent "l" when you discuss the "caulk solution" in social situations.

Oct 20, 2010 15:10 PM
BP staff member Ken Funck
BP staff

Cue up that Daily Show "Cash For Caulkers" talking head montage ...

Oct 20, 2010 15:32 PM

It's even better if you say it with a Southie accent.

Oct 21, 2010 19:05 PM
rating: 0

My potential batting order as GM for a day

Fukudome CF
Castro SS
Soto C
Colvin RF
Ramirez 3B
Byrd LF
Soriano 1B
Baker 2B
I think they must try to keep Snyder too and dump Hill. Castillo seems competent as a backup. The pitching may not be so bad either. I'm trying to be creative here. Wish me luck.

Oct 20, 2010 16:33 PM
rating: 0

You would bat Colvin fourth? REALLY? That post-ASB 246/316/469 line doesn't bother you? How about the 277/316/465 line from 442 minor league games?

You might wanna get yourself checked, you're showing all the symptoms of crazy!

Oct 21, 2010 08:17 AM
rating: 1

I am attempting to balance the order with a lefty. I don't see the Cubs being able to acquire a substantial bat to fill the void and at least Colvin showed signs of development this season that he did not show in the minors. Is it the optimal solution of course not but sometimes you have to do the best with what you have on hand. I also think demoting the vets might be a wake up call that gets them going rather than allowing them to settle into their comfortable mediocrity. I'm not sure it warranted the crazy description since Colvin was placed near that position in the lineup this season at various times.

Oct 21, 2010 11:14 AM
rating: 0

I just have to disagree with everything you said. I don't see that Colvin developed - I see a kid who went gangbusters when he was brought up to the majors then came back down to an expected (below-average) level once the league adjusted. It's a story told a thousand times. He may turn out to be a late bloomer or a decent starter, but in no way has he earned the right to hit cleanup instead of guys like Ramirez, Soriano, or even Byrd.

Dropping Ramirez and Soriano in the order serves no purpose except to give less at-bats to the most proven hitters in their lineup.

I do appreciate the creativity of your solution though, I just think it would make the Cubs even worse than they already are.

Oct 21, 2010 19:44 PM
rating: 0
You must be a Premium subscriber to post a comment.
Not a subscriber? Sign up today!
<< Previous Article
A Worthy Tradition (10/20)
<< Previous Column
Premium Article GM for a Day: Milwauke... (10/19)
Next Column >>
GM for a Day: Clevelan... (10/21)
Next Article >>
Premium Article Playoff Prospectus: We... (10/20)

Premium Article The Prospectus Hit List: July 1, 2015
Fantasy Rounders: The Slump Buster
Premium Article What Scouts Are Saying: July 1, 2015
Premium Article Going Yard: Futures Game: USA Bats
Premium Article Minor League Update: Games of Tuesday, June ...
Premium Article What You Need to Know: July 1, 2015
Premium Article Notes from the Field: July 1, 2015

Playoff Prospectus: ALCS Game Four
Premium Article Playoff Prospectus: Fear and Loathing from t...
Premium Article Playoff Prospectus: NLCS Game Three: Basebal...
Premium Article Playoff Prospectus: Wednesday LCS Game Proje...
Premium Article Playoff Prospectus: Wednesday LCS Pitching M...
A Worthy Tradition
Premium Article On the Beat: Reviving The Rangers

2010-11-08 - Premium Article GM for a Day: Chicago White Sox
2010-10-28 - Premium Article Overthinking It: Ex-Pitching Coach Managers
2010-10-21 - Premium Article Playoff Prospectus: NLCS Game Four
2010-10-20 - Premium Article GM for a Day: Chicago Cubs
2010-10-15 - Overthinking It: The Magic Touch?
2010-10-08 - One-Hoppers: Andy Pettitte's Game Two Starts...
2010-10-05 - Premium Article Playoff Prospectus: ALDS Preview: Rays vs. R...

2010-10-26 - GM for a Day: Toronto Blue Jays
2010-10-25 - Premium Article GM for a Day: New York Mets
2010-10-21 - GM for a Day: Cleveland Indians
2010-10-20 - Premium Article GM for a Day: Chicago Cubs
2010-10-19 - Premium Article GM for a Day: Milwaukee Brewers
2010-10-18 - Premium Article GM for a Day: Washington Nationals
2010-10-15 - Premium Article GM for a Day: Baltimore Orioles