CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
  
  
Click here to log in Click here for forgotten password Click here to subscribe

Happy Labor Day! Regularly Scheduled Articles Will Resume on Tuesday, September 2.

No Previous Article
No Previous Column
Next Column >>
Aim For The Head: Expe... (05/16)
No Next Article

May 9, 2001

Aim For The Head

Good-hitting Pitchers

by Keith Woolner

(Ed. note: Today marks the debut of Keith Woolner as a featured columnist here at Baseball Prospectus. Each Wednesday, he'll be answering a statistical or sabermetric question from one of our readers. Click here to submit a question to Keith.)

This week's question comes to us from Thomas Berman, who asks:

Mike Hampton hit his first career home run recently. Seeing as how Hampton has been the best hitting pitcher in baseball for a while, I would imagine he has a shot to join the pantheon of pitchers who had a historic year with the bat (Don Newcombe comes to mind) now that he is in Coors Field. How well would Hampton have to hit to have an all-time great season?

Thanks for writing, Thomas. Hampton has indeed been one of the better hitting pitchers of recent times. In fact, his 1999 season (.311/.373/.432) stands as the best pitcher hitting season of the 1990s (minimum 50 PA). In addition, he holds two of the top 40 batting seasons by a pitcher since 1978 with his 1999 and 1998 seasons (676 OPS). The top 40 seasons happen to correspond to a 650 OPS or better, and given that there have been 1,030 pitchers who had 50 or more plate appearances over that span, that puts a 650 OPS in the top 3.8% of such pitching hitting seasons since '78. That's quite an accomplishment.

However, there are some recent pitchers who are ahead of him. Tim Lollar and Rick Rhoden each have three of the top 40 seasons, while Bob Forsch, Randy Lerch, Don Robinson, and Mark Portugal match Hampton's two seasons. Portugal has had the highest OPS in a season over that span of time, with a 860 OPS in 1994.

Looking back before 1978, there have been a few pitchers who've posted a 1000 OPS, with Carl Scheib topping the list with a .396/.418/.623 performance in 55 PA for a 1041 OPS. There are a couple of Hall of Famers in the list who were pretty good with the stick as well as being fair pitchers, but it's probably not who you're thinking of:

YEAR NAME TEAM PA AVG OBP SLG OPS
1951 Carl Scheib PHI-A 55 .396 .418 .623 1041
1925 Walter Johnson WAS-A 101 .433 .455 .577 1033
1955 Don Newcombe BRO-N 124 .359 .395 .632 1028
1930 Red Ruffing NY-A 106 .374 .415 .596 1011

Red Ruffing actually went 3-for-11 with the Red Sox in 1930, and for the season missed a 1000 OPS (finishing with "just" a 984 OPS), but we'll give him the credit anyways.

As far as lifetime stats for pitcher hitting, Hampton has a long way to go. Looking just at seasons in which a player was primarily a pitcher, and with a minimum 250 PA, Babe Ruth still leads the pack with a .302/.359/.479 lifetime performance.

NAME PLAYED PA AVG OBP SLG OPS
Babe Ruth 1915-1917 382 .302 .359 .479 837
Wes Ferrell 1929-1938 1273 .282 .353 .446 799
Bob Caruthers 1885-1891 1038 .280 .388 .410 799
Jack Stivetts 1889-1896 1750 .294 .338 .438 776
Erv Brame 1928-1932 408 .306 .326 .429 755
Doc Crandall 1908-1915 625 .279 .346 .399 744
Clint Hartung 1947-1950 271 .250 .292 .445 737
George Uhle 1919-1934 1433 .289 .338 .382 720
Schoolboy Rowe 1933-1949 967 .266 .332 .388 719
Fred Klobedanz 1896-1898 329 .278 .307 .408 715
Don Newcombe 1949-1960 971 .271 .338 .367 705
Red Ruffing 1925-1945 1971 .272 .309 .394 703

Note: I tried to select players who were primarily pitchers, and looked at the years in which they were primarily pitchers. Players who split time within a season between pitching and a regular position were excluded, as were the years after a player moved away from the mound (e.g., Ruth).

Also, I excluded pre-1893 pitchers, other than to call attention to Bob Caruthers's great offensive performance in the late 19th century.

Wes Ferrell was a fine pitcher in his own right, with a 193-128 record and a 4.04 ERA during a high offense era (1927-41). He led the league in wins in 1935 with 25 (one of his six 20-win seasons), and in innings pitched three times. He may fall just short of the Hall of Fame on his pitching merits, but does he get enough extra credit for being arguably the best-hitting full-time pitcher ever to push him over into induction-worthiness? So far, the Hall says no, but there's an interesting case to be made.

Keith Woolner is an author of Baseball Prospectus. Contact him by clicking here.

Keith Woolner is an author of Baseball Prospectus. 
Click here to see Keith's other articles. You can contact Keith by clicking here

Related Content:  Baseball Ops,  Ops,  OPS+

0 comments have been left for this article.

No Previous Article
No Previous Column
Next Column >>
Aim For The Head: Expe... (05/16)
No Next Article

RECENTLY AT BASEBALL PROSPECTUS
Premium Article What You Need to Know: August 29, 2014
Premium Article Pebble Hunting: This Article Mentions Fehlan...
Premium Article The Prospectus Hit List: Friday, August 29
Premium Article The Call-Up: Dilson Herrera
Premium Article Minor League Update: Games of Thursday, Augu...
Prospectus Feature: Roast A Parks
Premium Article Raising Aces: Mis-Priced

MORE FROM MAY 9, 2001
Transaction Analysis: May 3-6, 2001
The Daily Prospectus: Around the NL

MORE BY KEITH WOOLNER
2001-06-07 - Aim For The Head: Temperature and OPS
2001-05-23 - Aim For The Head: Barry Bonds and the Three ...
2001-05-16 - Aim For The Head: Expected vs. Actual Wins
2001-05-09 - Aim For The Head: Good-hitting Pitchers
2001-03-07 - Albert Belle
2001-02-06 - From The Mailbag: Special Edition: Pitching ...
2001-01-29 - Counterpoint: Pitching and Defense
More...

MORE AIM FOR THE HEAD
2001-06-07 - Aim For The Head: Temperature and OPS
2001-05-23 - Aim For The Head: Barry Bonds and the Three ...
2001-05-16 - Aim For The Head: Expected vs. Actual Wins
2001-05-09 - Aim For The Head: Good-hitting Pitchers
More...