BP360 now on sale! A yearly subscription, '23 Annual & Futures Guide and t-shirt for one low price

Much like first baseman, second base is a destination, as
opposed to a place where prospects begin their career. Many of the prospects
on this list started elsewhere on the infield, and many of the top shortstop
prospects in the game will be eventually joining them, as second basemen
drafted in the first-round like Todd Walker and Rickie Weeks are
the exception and not the norm. Just a clarification: when choosing these
prospects, the pool of players to select from is defined as players in the
minor leagues right now who have played the majority of the year at the

1. Howie Kendrick, Angels

Age: 23.0 Hitting: .369/.407/.627 in 68 G

An obvious choice. Kendrick is the best pure hitter in the
minor leagues right now, threatening .400 at various times throughout the year
and showing unprecedented power–43 of his 106 hits have gone for extra bases,
including 13 home runs in 287 at-bats. He’ll never be more than an average
defender, but his hitting skills in no way warrant criticism. His hand-eye coordination
is off the charts and he can hit any pitch, anywhere. He doesn’t walk much,
but it’s hard to walk when nearly every pitch you see is one you can drive.
See Guerrero, Vladimir. A lot has been made of late about the failures of
former uber-prospects Casey Kotchman, Jeff Mathis and Dallas
, and people are now questioning if Kendrick is next in line to
dissapoint. I don’t think so. While they are admittedly a minority, I can
find scouts who were just so-so on Mathis, I can find scouts who thought
McPherson’s swing was just too long, and I even know of one scout who was never
high on Kotchman. As far as Kendrick goes–I’ve looked long and hard, and I can’t find
a scout who doesn’t love him.

2. Blake DeWitt, Dodgers

Age: 20.9 Hitting: .273/.352/.427 in 82 G (A+)

The Dodgers first-round pick in 2004, DeWitt hit
.283/.333/.428 last year in the South Atlantic League, and while his numbers
are highly similar, he’s moved up a level and gone from a hitter’s league to a
pitcher’s league, so this is a slight step forward. Still, and this might
sound odd for a guy ranked second overall, DeWitt has yet to really live up to
scouts’ expectations, or his own reputation as the best high school hitter in
the 2004 class. Scouts still project him to hit for
average and power when all is said and done. Drafted as a third baseman–where
he played last year–his transition to the middle of the diamond hasn’t been
perfect, as scouts have called him unpolished at his new position, but he does possess
the athleticism to become at least average there.

3. Alberto Callaspo, Diamondbacks

Age: 23.2 Hitting .323/.398/.439 in 80 G (AAA)

As a middle infielder, Callaspo was in the wrong system with
the Angels, but one would think they could have gotten more for him in a trade
than Jason Bulger, who admittedly has power stuff, but is also 27 years
old with a history of injuries and control problems. The most contact-oriented
hitter in the minor leagues, Callaspo has struck out 128 times in his career,
which now spans 2,527 at-bats. After batting just .222 in April, Callaspo has
hit .360 since, and in the month of May–when he hit .371 in 116 at-bats–he
whiffed only once. Expressed as a ratio, that’s one strikeout for every 116
at-bats–and you guys thought I was just the scouting guy with no statistical
skills. The best defensive second baseman on this list, Callaspo was moved to
second base by the Angels in deference to Erick Aybar, but he has the
skills to play on the left side of the infield and has even seen time at third
base this year. Adding to his prospect status is 43 walks, which is already
just four off his career high with seven weeks remaining in his season. Where
he fits into Arizona’s plans is up in the air, but he could be an inexpensive
upgrade over Orlando Hudson.

4. Elliot Johnson, Devil Rays

Age: 22.4 Hitting .301/.353/.512 in 80 G (AA)

Johnson has had a breakout campaign in 2006, already
establishing a new career high in home runs (13) and leading Double-A
Montgomery in nearly every offensive category. While his power and speed make
him an intriguing prospect, Johnson still has some work to do in his approach,
as he can get too aggressive at times and his newly-found power has created some
pull-conscious moments, leading to 76 strikeouts in 322 at-bats. He’s also a
little rough defensively, particularly on his double-play turn. The rarest of
rares, Johnson went undrafted out of high school, but instead of playing at a
college or JUCO, he signed as a free agent on the recommendation of scout Craig
Weissmann, who deserves mad props for finding this diamond in the rough.

5. Tony Abreu, Dodgers

Age: 21.7 Hitting: .285/.353/.415 in 86 G (AA)

Abreu won the Florida State League batting title last year,
and has put together a solid campaign at Jacksonville in 2006, including a .339
mark since June 1st. Abreu’s greatest strength is his lack of weaknesses. He
hits for a good average, has gap power, is a good defender, and runs well. At
the same time, his greatest weakness is a lack of that one tool that grades out
more than just above-average. The cliché here is solid but unspectacular.

6. Alexi Casilla, Twins

Age: 22.0 Hitting: .326/.385/.398 in 77 G (A+)

I admit I’m sticking my neck out on this one, but there are
some people out there who have my back, as he received surprisingly strong
reviews from some scouts in Florida. Like Callaspo, Casilla was buried in the
Angels’ ridiculous infield depth, and the team seemingly had no idea what to do with him,
as he played at every level in the system in his first three years, but hit
.325 with 47 stolen bases in 78 games for Low Class A Cedar Rapids once they let
him stay in one place. Traded in the offseason for J.C. Romero, Casilla
has continued to rake in the Florida State League, showing off a line drive bat
and plus speed. A switch-hitter who is equally adept from both sides, Casilla
has no power (three career home runs), and will never develop any, but he’s
beginning to draw comparisons to Luis Castillo. Increasing his value as a
prospect is the fact that the Twins have moved him to shortstop this week,
where the reviews remain glowing.

7. Eric Patterson, Cubs

Age: 23.3 Hitting: .279/.338/.418

Patterson was the Cubs’ minor league player of the year in
2005, and while he hasn’t approached the success of last year’s .325/.400/.517
campaign, that wasn’t necessarily a realistic expectation, as he was far older than
most of his Low A brethren last year. While he’s nowhere near the athlete that
his brother Corey is, he’s fundamentally a far better baseball player who has a
more patient approach and is a superior base stealer (28 SB) despite being
a step slower than his brother. Taking advantage of young pitchers’ mistakes
to hit 13 home runs last year might have been the worst thing to happen to
Patterson, who needs to recognize that his future is as a top-of-the-order
hitter and eliminate his tendency to overswing. While not especially rangy,
he’s a solid defender who has made only 20 career errors in over 200 games.

8. Hernan Iribarren, Brewers

Age: 22.0 Hitting: .316/.359/.391 in 69 G (A+)

If you take away Iribarren’s month-long slump, when he hit
.247 in May, he has hit .354 in 50 games, including a .404 mark in his last
24 contests (36-for-89). He’s similar to Casilla in that he has plus speed, a
great feel for contact and nearly zero power, but Casilla’s approach and
defensive abilities (not that Iribarren is any kind of stiff with the glove)
give him the edge.

9. Yung-Chi Chen, Mariners

Age: 23.0 Hitting: .335/.379/.478 in 76 G (67
A+/9 AA)

Chen broke out this year, leading
the California League with a .342 average before earning a promotion to the Texas League
at the All-Star Break. He’ll need to maintain that kind of average to project
as more than a utilityman, as he doesn’t offer much in the way of power or
patience, but his slightly above-average speed has allowed him to swipe 22
bases this year. California League explosions should be understandably treated
with some trepidation–we’ll know much more after seeing how he fares in the
Texas League during the second half.

10. Kevin Melillo, Athletics

Age: 24.2 Hitting: .271/.343/.414 in 87 G (AA)

A fifth-round pick in 2004 out of South Carolina as a
college senior, Melillo led the Oakland organization with 24 home runs in his full-season
debut, but his first season in an advanced league has proven more difficult. Melillo
has plus power for the position, projecting to 15-20 home runs annually while also
drawing his far share of free passes. He’s not a great athlete, doesn’t run
well, and is no more than an average fielder, so his bat will have to carry
him, as he doesn’t have the option of developing into a utility player.

Honorable Mention:

  • Emilio Bonafacio, Diamondbacks: In many
    ways, Bonifacio is the California League’s version of Casilla, as his game
    depends almost entirely on speed. He doesn’t have Casilla’s defensive
    skills or his contact abilty, but his last name loosely translates as
    “good face” and how can you not like that?
  • Kevin Frandsen, Giants: While Frandsen reached
    the majors less than two years after being drafted, he has to be a .300+
    hitters in the majors to have starter-level value, as he doesn’t hit for
    much power, and he doesn’t draw many walks. Add in the fact that nothing
    about his tools offer any kind of projection, and you’re looking at a
    solid, valuable utility guy.
  • Jeff Natale, Red Sox: His .467 on-base
    percentage makes him a favorite with the statistically-minded crowd, but
    he’s nearly 24 and hasn’t reached Double-A yet. Will the approach work
    against better pitching? The jury is still out, but his numbers have
    already taken a pretty strong dip since moving from Low to High A.
  • Danny Richar, Diamondbacks: Nobody saw his
    2005 total of 20 home runs in the California League as an indication of
    real power, and they were right, as the 22-year-old Dominican has just
    five home runs in 316 at-bats this year. Mitigating that is the career-high
    .310 average and much improved plate discipline.
  • Luis Valbuena, Mariners: The 20-year-old
    Venezuelan has pedestrian .278/.365/.390 line at Low Class A Wisconsin,
    but he also has good tools, more walks than strikeouts and is hitting .322
    since June 1.

Next Thursday: Third Basemen.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe