Baltimore Orioles

Billy Rowell, 3b, Bishop Eustace Prep (New Jersey) – 9th overall

Pedro Beato, rhp, St. Petersburg (Florida) JC – 32nd overall

Ryan Adams, ss, Jesuit HS (Louisiana) – 58th

Zach Britton, lhp, Weatherford HS (Texas) – 85th overall

Blake Davis, ss, Cal State Fullerton – 115th

Overall, this is a nice set of picks. The O’s got what they feel is the top prep hitter in Rowell, and they got a first-round arm in Beato at 32. Beato could have gone higher, but most teams were convinced that the Mets were going to sign him as a draft-and-follow, and so the big scouts didn’t see him, leaving teams afraid to take him on reputation as opposed to their own reports. To a smaller extent, the same could be said of Adams, who has battled hamstring problems the last two years, limiting his looks. Scouts like his bat
more than his glove, and he’s probably a second baseman in the end. Britton is
yet another nice find in the third round. Very few prep lefthanders can match
Britton’s velocity (he touched 95 mph this spring), but his lack of a good
secondary pitch creates a large gap between what he is and what he can be. Davis will quickly become a fan-favorite for fans of the Orioles system. He’s a Lenny Dykstra-type gamer who makes up for average tools with an all-out style and terrific fundamentals. It’s scouting director Joe Jordan’s second straight impressive draft.

Best pick after these five: 10th-round
pick Emeel Salem is an outstanding defensive center fielder with plus-plus speed and good contact skills. 17th-rounder Tony Watson
is a top 100 pick on talent, but is considered a very difficult sign as a
draft-eligible sophomore.

Boston Red Sox

Jason Place, of, Wren HS (South Carolina) – 27th

Daniel Bard, rhp, North Carolina – 28th

Kris Johnson, lhp, Wichita State – 40th

Caleb Clay, rhp, Cullman HS (Alabama) – 44th

Justin Masterson, rhp, San Diego State – 71st overall

While the BoSox lacked a premium pick, they did have two
late first-round picks and two more in the supplemental first, allowing them to
take advantage of a draft’s depth. Place transformed himself from a
budget-minded first round pick to a legitimate one in pre-draft workouts. He’s
big, athletic and toolsy, but his overall game is a little rough around
the edges. Bard was one of the big droppers in the first-round thanks to
inconsistency and a reported $4 million price tag, but he could be a steal at
No. 28 if he and the Red Sox can agree to reasonable terms. Johnson is a
draft-eligible sophomore who missed 2005 with Tommy John surgery, but pitched
better and better as the season went on, with one scout telling me that with
one more month in the season, he could have pitched himself into the first
round. Masterson was hyped when he transferred from a tiny Indiana school to San Diego State after an impressive Cape Cod League stint, and he held his own
at the higher level, but didn’t blow a lot of people away. At 6-foot-6 and 250
pounds, and armed with a low-90s fastball that can get into the 94-95 range,
Masterson has surprisingly good control. The fastball is his only plus
pitch and will likely mean a move to the bullpen.

Best pick after these five: The Red Sox took a
number of players in the teens with top 100 talent, including first baseman Matt LaPorta and outfielder Lars Anderson, but as far as players that will almost certainly sign, keep an eye on sixth-round pick Zach Daeges from Creighton–a lefty bat with power and patience.

Chicago White Sox

Kyle McCulloch, rhp, Texas – 29th overall

Matt Long, rhp, Miami (Ohio) – 73rd

Justin Edwards, lhp, Olympia HS (Florida) – 105th

Tyler Reves, c, Texas Tech – 135th overall

John Shelby, 2b, Kentucky – 165th overall

It was surprising to see the White Sox spend their first two
picks on starting pitching, which is one of the strengths of their system.
McCulloch is a safe pick who effectively mixes a deep repertoire and throw
strikes–much in the mold of current starter Jon Garland. Long is a Tommy John survivor who closed for the Redhawks this year, and could move quickly with his plus fastball-curve combination if they keep him in the bullpen. Edwards is a short, fringy lefty who rarely touches 90 mph, and I’m also not crazy about Reeves, who does give the team some catching depth, except he can’t catch very well. The team makes up for it with
Shelby, who started the year in a horrible slump but finished strong. He’s the
son of former big leaguer John Shelby and projects as an offensive second baseman with good speed and surprising power.

Best pick after these five: Ninth-round pick Chris
has tons of power, but his bat will have to carry him as he lacks the athleticism to play third base and probably a corner outfield slot as well.

Cleveland Indians

David Huff, lhp, UCLA – 39th overall

Steven Wright, rhp, Hawaii – 56th overall

Josh Rodriguez, if, Rice – 57th overall

Wes Hodges, 3b, Georgia Tech – 69th

Matt McBride, c, Lehigh – 75th overall

The Indians made up for having no true first-rounder by
having five picks between No. 39 and No. 75, which they spent exclusively on
college talent. Huff was expected by some to go in the first round, but he
lacks the ceiling of a pick that high. He has an outstanding changeup, and
should be able to eat up plenty of innings, but with an 85-89 mph fastball,
there is little star potential. How many cross-checkers and scouting directors
were thrilled to hear that they had to go see the kid at Hawaii? Wright’s a
good one too, and while he’ll probably begin his career as a starter, he might
be more suitable for the pen with a nice fastball-slider combination and
fantastic command. Rodriguez slipped a little bit since the beginning of the
season, as elbow problems limited him defensively. He has good on-base skills
and average power, but he lacks the speed to play shortstop and the reflexes
for third, leaving him as a strong-armed second baseman for whom the
development of his bat will be key. Hodges has a pretty swing and a great
approach, but he’s slow and soft-bodied, leaving his future at first base or
left field. While he can smoke line drives all over the field, his stroke is
just not designed for power, making him a bit of a misfit for a first baseman. The system is desperate for catching, and McBride is one of the better college options in what was a weak draft for backstops.

Best pick after these five: Fifth-round pick Chris
is a lanky righthander who has touched 95 and offers plenty of

Detroit Tigers

Andrew Miller, lhp, North Carolina – 6th

Ronald Bourquin, 3b, Ohio State – 50th

Brennan Boesch, of, California – 82nd

Ryan Striebly, 1b, Kentucky, — 112th

Scott Sizemore, 2b, Virginia Commonwealth – 142nd

Look, they picked sixth and got who was generally considered
the best player in the draft–that’s a win, end of story. After Miller,
scouting director David Chadd surprised nobody by focusing on college talent,
not taking a prep player until the 11th round. Bourquin seems like
an overdraft, but it’s an understandable one considering how much of a dent
Miller is going to make in the signing budget. Both he and Boesch have plenty
of power projection, but both are also far more projection than reality at this
point, and nobody thinks Borquin can stay at third base. Speaking of power,
Striebly is built more like a defensive end than a baseball player, and led the
Wildcats in home runs (19) this year. He’s surprisingly athletic for his size,
but it’s hard to start your career with no defensive flexibility. Sizemore is
one of those classic polished college players who should get there, but offers
little star potential.

Best pick after these five: In a draft extremely thin
on catching, sixth-round pick Jordan Newton could be a steal. He can hit, and while his defensive skills are lacking, his plus athleticism gives reason for optimism.

Kansas City Royals

Luke Hochevar, rhp, Tennessee (’05) – 1st

Jason Taylor, of, Kellam HS (Virginia) – 45th

Blake Wood, rhp, Georgia Tech – 77th

Derrick Robinson, of, Yonge HS (Florida) – 107th

Jason Godin, rhp, Old Dominion (Virginia) – 137th

Hochevar is the big prize here, and again, the Royals had so
many different ways to screw this up and they didn’t, and they should be
praised for it. Neither Taylor or Wood belong where they went, but like Detroit, the Royals need to manage their budget with the expected Hochevar signing. Robinson is a nice find in the fourth round. He’s the fastest player in
the draft, but he’s more than just a Joey Gathright-type. While he needs to refine his approach and refine his swing, he at least has gap power and wiry strength. He’s a top-level running back committed to Florida, but expected to sign. Godin put up some big strikeout numbers at Virginia but he did it with control and a four-pitch mix as opposed to blowing hitters away.

Best pick after these five: Seventh-round pick Brett
is a classic leadoff man who hit .356 and drew a ton of walks (.456 OBP) at UC Riverside, but his lack of power will have him seeing far more
strikes as a pro.

Los Angeles Angels

Hank Conger, c, Huntington Beach HS (California) – 25th overall

Russ Moldenhauer, of, Boerne HS (Texas) – 102nd

Clay Fuller, of, Smithson Valley HS (Texas) – 132nd overall

Kenny Herndon, rhp, Gulf Coast CC (Florida) – 162nd

Robert Fish, lhp, Miller HS (California) – 192nd

As I stated before, I still don’t understand why Conger
wasn’t more in the 15-20 range, and I think a lot of teams who went with a high
school position player before him are going to regret it. With no second round
pick, the Angels had to sit around for a while before selecting again, and
scouting director Eddie Bane stuck with high school players until taking a chance on UCLA outfielder Jarrad Page, who was also selected in the NFL Draft, in the 7th round. Moldenhauer was announced as an outfielder, which means the Angels are betting on his bat. He played mostly infield or catcher in high school, and could move back behind the plate if the Angels think it will help him get to the majors. Fuller is a burner and a lefty bat that the Angels are betting will come around while Herndon is a projectable righty who can touch 95 mph and do little else well. Fish is a nice sixth-round find as an aggressive lefthander with an average fastball, good breaking ball, and potential for an improvement in velocity. Bane favors ceilings over safeness in his picks, and nothing changed this year.

Best pick after these five: Tenth-round pick Leonardo
has little idea of what he’s doing out there, but lefties who can get it into the 93-94 mph range don’t grow on trees, and the Angels are betting on his ability to transform from thrower to pitcher.

Minnesota Twins

Chris Parmelee, of, Chino Hills HS (California) – 20th

Joe Benson, of, Joliet Catholic HS (Illinois) – 64th

Tyler Robertson, lhp, Bella Vista HS (California) – 96th overall

Whit Robbins, 1b, Georgia Tech – 119th

Garrett Olson, 3b, Franklin Pierce College – 126th overall

Parmelee disappointed a lot of scouts this year, but his stock skyrocketed in the final week as he impressed every team that he worked out for. Benson was a surprise pick in the second round–scouts are universal in their acclaim for his tools, but he’s a little too raw at the plate to be taking that high unless you are the Twins, who like pure athletes. Robertson is a long-armed lefthander with average velocity, a good curve, and a good understanding of the pro game, as he’s the son of Jay Robertson, who works in the Rangers front office. Robbins was Georgia Tech’s best hitter this year, but his all-or-nothing style turns off some scouts. Olson’s bat is his only plus tool, but if you are only going to be good at one thing in baseball, hitting is a pretty smart choice.

Best pick after these five: Like Benson, tenth-round
selection Jared Mitchell has big time athleticism but is still a bit of a project when it comes to being a baseball player. He could be an absolute steal if the Twins can sway him away from football.

New York Yankees

Ian Kennedy, rhp, Southern California – 21st

Joba Chamberlain, rhp, Nebraska – 41st

Zach McAllister, rhp, Illinois Valley Central HS –
104th overall

Colin Curtis, of, Arizona State – 134th

George Kontos, rhp, Northwestern – 164th

After singing the praises of scouting director Damon Oppenheimer in the past, I find little to be enthused about here. After heavily criticizing the Kennedy pick yesterday in print and on radio, I still feel it’s a mistake after sleeping on it. His numbers this year pale in comparison to his freshman and sophomore seasons, and college pitchers who pitch well for two years and then get drafted high despite disappointing junior years have a pretty ugly track record. Chamberlain’s track record resembles Kennedy’s, but his disappointing junior year is more of a result of injury than ineffectiveness. Medical reports that showed some concerns about his knee didn’t help as Balky Knee + History Of Weight Problems + Short Track Record = Out Of The First Round. At 6-foot-5 and 230 pounds, McAllister is a power righty who needs to learn how to pitch but has a nice ceiling. Like the two pitchers at the top, Curtis had a disappointing season, but a larger concern than the mediocre stats is the fact that his tools took a step backwards as well. Kontos is big and throws hard, but I don’t understand how a team can have faith in a Big-10 pitcher who went 3-10, 5.29 this year while allowing 107 hits in 95.1 innings.

Best pick after these five: Ninth-round pick Mark
was one of the top college relievers available before missing the last two months of the season with a strained elbow ligament. Doctors don’t
think he’ll need surgery, and once he’s healthy, he’ll move quickly.

Oakland Athletics

Trevor Cahill, rhp, Vista HS (California) – 66th

Matt Sulentic, of, Hillcrest HS (Texas) – 98th

Chad Lee, rhp, Barton County CC (Kansas) – 128th

Jermaine Mitchell, of, UNC Greensboro – 158th

Andrew Bailey, rhp, Wagner College – 188th overall

The A’s had to be patient in this draft, and their first
pick, Cahill, was a bit of a surprise. He’s not especially big, and he doesn’t have much more than an average fastball, but his curve is a true out pitch, and his makeup–like most Oakland top draftees–is outstanding. Like Cahill, everyone raves about Sulentic’s intangibles. He’s almost like a high school version of an old school A’s draftee, where the tools (other than the bat) are average at best. His numbers bordered on historic in the Dallis Metroplex this year, possibly the most competitive high school conference in the nation. Lee shot up charts early in the season when he pitched at 94-95, but he hurt his arm in the second half and only pitched out of the bullpen, where he struggled
mightily. If the A’s believe in his health, it’s a great pick. While the
first three picks alone is enough to make the few still out there who think
Moneyball is about drafting college players more than a bit nauseated, add in the fact that Mitchell, the first four-year college player they took, is a pure
tools guy. Bailey isn’t pretty and has already undergone Tommy John surgery,
but he has two plus pitches with a 95 mph fastball and a downer curve, the kind
of stuff that isn’t easy to find in the sixth round.

Best pick after these five: Eighth-rounder Angel
was the toolsiest player in Puerto Rico with plus-plus speed and a good idea at the plate.

Seattle Mariners

Brandon Morrow, rhp, California – 5th

Chris Tillman, rhp, Fountain Valley HS (California) – 49th overall

Tony Butler, rhp, Oak Creek HS (Wisconsin) – 81st

Ricky Orta, rhp, Miami – 111st overall

Nathan Adcock, rhp, North Hardin HS (Kentucky) – 141st overall

I’ve made no secret of my support for Morrow. After the
Hochevar/Miller pair, I think he was the best player in the draft, and I’d
rather have Morrow for what he’s going to cost ($2.5 million or so?) than Miller
for double or even triple that. The front office had to be happy to nab
Tillman in the second round. Tillman began the season as one of the top high
school arms, but his performance didn’t match his stuff. He nonetheless was
not expected get past the sandwich round. Butler is a risky pick–he’s tall,
lefthanded and has a plus fastball, but that’s about all he has going for him,
making him a bit of a project. Orta is another raw arm strength guy who had an
ERA over six at Miami. I’m not a big fan of college statistics as an
indicator of pro performance, but that’s an ERA over six, folks. Adcock
could be an interesting sleeper. He’s gained 3-4 mph in the last 12 months,
and there’s still room for more.

Best pick after these five: Ninth-round pick Justin
has plus velocity and a feel for a breaking pitch, but a small frame
and a history of shoulder problems.

Tampa Bay Devil Rays

Evan Longoria, inf, Long Beach State – 3rd

Josh Butler, rhp, San Diego – 47th overall

Nick Fuller, rhp, Kell HS (Georgia) – 79th

Alex Cobb, rhp, Vero Beach HS (Florida) – 109th

Shawn O’Malley, ss, South Ridge HS (Washington) – 139th

Longoria was unquestionably the top position player in the
draft and, while there were several pitchers who are better overall prospects,
the Devil Rays felt that he was one of the few with a potentially star-level
bat. It will be interesting to see where he starts defensively, as he can play
second or third with big league proficiency. Butler has a first-round body and
first-round stuff, but his results were too inconsistent to get him into the
first 30. Fuller got into the third round on arm strength and the ability to
get two-plane break on his slider but, like Butler, scouts didn’t always see
him at his best, and his mechanics got bad grades. The opposite of Fuller is
Cobb, who throws strikes with an effective three-pitch mix, but doesn’t project
to blow hitters away. O’Malley is a good defender with loads of speed, but his
bat doesn’t leave anybody thrilled.

Best pick after these five: 11th-round
pick Heath Rollins played both ways at Winthrop, and while he has plus command of marginal stuff, Tampa hopes that stuff can take a step forward once he dedicates himself to one skill.

Texas Rangers

Kasey Kiker, lhp, Russell County HS (Alabama) – 12th overall

Chad Tracy, c, Pepperdine – 88th overall

Marcus Lemon, ss, Eustis HS (Florida) – 118th

Chris Davis, 1b, Navarro JC (Texas) – 148th

Jake Brigham, rhp, Central Florida Christian Acadamy
– 178th overall

For Kiker, it depends on how you feel about his size. If
the fact that he’s not much bigger than Tim Lincecum bothers you, it’s a
reach–otherwise he’s got more than enough stuff to merit where he was
selected. With no second-round pick, Texas used their third-round pick on
Tracy, the best hitting college catcher available who dropped because of a well
below-average arm. Lemon is Chet Lemon‘s kid, and like his dad, he’s a defensive standout, only in the middle infield. He’s a switch-hitter with some ability as well, and one of my favorite fourth-round picks. Davis has the always-valued left-handed power; again, as a first baseman, you better really mash if you want to make it. Brigham is a classic power righty from Florida without much of a breaking ball and a heater that lacks movement.

Best pick after these five: Ninth-round selection Brennan
pitched just 13 innings this year at Northern Colorado, but he whiffed 24 with a plus fastball.

Toronto Blue Jays

Travis Snider, of, Jackson HS (Washington) – 14th

Brandon Magee, rhp, Bradley – 120th

Luke Hopkins, 1b, New Mexico State – 150th

Brian Jeroloman, c, Florida – 180th

Jon Baksh, of, Florida Tech – 210th

Even though Rowell was taken five picks ahead of Snider, several teams considered the latter as the best pure prep bat following his pre-draft workouts, where he impressed both with his batting practice and his much improved conditioning. The Blue Jays didn’t pick again until the fourth round, so much of the draft’s success will depend on Snider, and Toronto did get the one player available with the best chance of being an impact bat. Magee is a solid senior sign who shouldn’t cost much, but at 23 he’ll need to move quickly. Hopkins put up big numbers at New Mexico State, but that came at one of the friendliest hitting parks in college baseball, and he’s a bit pudgy. Jeroloman, on the other hand, could be a sixth-round steal if his bat comes around. Even if it doesn’t, he’ll get to the big leagues as a backup based on his top-notch defensive skills. Baksh is a left-handed hitter who put up big numbers against weak competition in Division II–and being Canadian didn’t hurt, either.

Best pick after these five: Eleventh-round pick Matt Lane got plenty of eyeballs as Tim Lincecum’s catcher every Friday, and scouts walked away impressed with his power potential from the left side. He still has plenty of work to do behind the plate.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe