Image credit: USA Today Sports

I have now completed two prospect list cycles. A national prospect list isn’t really something that comes with an industry guidebook. We all have our own processes and predilections. I’ve often remarked that I regret a few rankings with 24 hours of locking down my lists. The number and particulars of the dudes varies over time, but now more than a full year removed from my first list, there seems to be a bit of an overarching problem. My top arms appear to have well underperformed on aggregate. So I want to consider my 2017 list one more time to see how we got here and what I may or may not have learned since.

1. Alex Reyes

Why he ranked here

Reyes had the best arsenal of any pitcher in the minors going into the 2017 season: A true 80-grade fastball—triple-digit velocity with movement—and two potential plus-or-better secondaries in his curve and change. He had already thrown 44 good major-league innings. Everything had looked right so far, and Reyes was a near lock to break camp on the major league team. I had multiple team sources tell me they had him as an OFP 80. I didn’t go quite that far—in hindsight that was overly conservative—but I was very comfortable with Reyes as the top pitching prospect in baseball. The top overall prospect debate was a bit more spirited, but he was placed at number one early in the process and remained there after every subsequent conference call and email thread.

Full access to this article is for Premium Baseball Prospectus subscribers.

Sign up today to get access to insightful analysis for the discerning baseball fan.

Super-Premium - $66.99 / yearPremium - $45.95 / yearPremium Monthly - $6.99 / month
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe

Comments are closed.