Baseball Prospectus Needs Your Help! Check out our call for contributors!

Los Angeles Angels
First Three Rounds
1. (17) C.J. Cron, 1B, Utah
3. (104) Nick Maronde, LHP, Florida
Who They Are: As a bat-only college product, Cron is not your standard Angels pick. At the same time, some thought he was the best pure college bat on the board. He can't run, he can't field, and he can't throw, but he has bat speed, hand-eye coordination, plus-plus raw power, and shouldn't take long in the minors.

Maronde is a left-handed power pitcher with serious heat, and the Angels have a history of favoring velocity, then leaning on their development staff to teach the secondary offerings, which Maronde will need.
Later Picks Of Note: Fourth-round pick Mike Clevinger is another hard thrower who could cruise through the system as a power reliever. Same goes for sixth-round pick Austin Wood, who has a first-round body and first-round velocity, but struggles with his command and never found a breaking ball.
Analysis: While Cron went in the range that was expected, it was a surprise that the Angels selected him. It may have been a response to Kendry Morales' continued inability to play. From there, it was pure power arms.

Oakland Athletics
First Three Rounds
1. (18) Sonny Gray, RHP, Vanderbilt
3. (105) B.A. Vollmuth, 3B, Southern Mississippi
Who They Are: Gray is a bit undersized, but he has pure power stuff, with a 92-94 mph fastball than he can dial up to 97 when he needs something extra, to go along with a fantastic curveball. Those that like him compare him to a right-handed Scott Kazmir (the good version).

Vollmuth sounds like a character from an ‘80s action TV series, but in reality he has a classic third-base profile and a long track record of hitting for power.
Later Picks Of Note: The A's drafted a pair of toolsy outfielders in the fourth and sixth rounds with Bobby Crocker and Dayton Alexander. Crocker is especially impressive from a physical standpoint; he's a 230-pound beast with power and at least average speed.
Analysis: The A's must have been pleasantly surprised to see Gray still on the board at 18th overall, and while they focused on college talent in the early rounds, it was clear that tools played as much of an influence on their choices as performance.

Seattle Mariners
First Three Rounds
1. (2) Danny Hultzen, LHP, Virginia
2. (62) Brad Miller, SS Clemson
3. (92) Kevin Cron, 1B, Montain Pointe HS (AZ)
3s. (121) Carter Capps, RHP, Mount Olive College
Who They Are: Hultzen has been among college baseball's best and most consistent performers all year, with a 1.41 ERA in 17 starts and 157 strikeouts in 115 innings with just 23 walks. More of a skilled surgeon than a dominating power arm, his 92-95 mph fastball, two-plane slider, and diving changeup are all plus pitches and play up due to his command. He doesn't have the kind of ceiling most second overall picks do, but he should be in Seattle very quickly and is the best bet in the draft to be a productive big-leaguer.

Miller isn't loaded with tools, but he can really hit. That said, he's not a shortstop, Dustin Ackley is the big-league second baseman, and Kyle Seager is already blocked at the position.

Cron is the younger brother of the Angels’ first-round pick, and a similar talent. He's massive, slow, limited to first base, and can really rake.

Capps is huge and throws hard, and could move quickly as a reliever if the Mariners decide to go that route.
Later Picks Of Note: Fifth-round pick Tyler Marlette could cost a little extra money, but he projects as an offense-first player with enough defensive ability to not be a liability behind the plate. Ninth-rounder Cavan Cohoes is maybe the most fascinating player in the draft, as he plays for a high school in Germany on an American base. He's impressed European scouts with the kind of athleticism normally reserved for soccer players on that side of the pond, but he's quite raw.
Analysis: The Mariners tore apart everyone's mock draft with the Hultzen selection, but his ability to move quickly gave him an edge over Anthony Rendon's concerning junior year and shortstop Francisco Lindor's youth.

Texas Rangers
First Three Rounds
1. (33) Kevin Mathews, LHP, Richmond Hill HS (GA)
1s. (37) Zach Cone, OF, Georgia
2. (83) Will Lamb, LHP, Clemson
3. (113) Kyle Castro, RHP, Pleasant Valley HS (CA)
Who They Are: The Rangers went off the board with Matthews, who was not expected to be drafted on the first day due to his size and a strong Virginia commitment. His combination of plus velocity and command is something Texas brass has always coveted.

Cone is a difficult player to wrap one’s head around, as he's a college product with fantastic tools, but the performances have rarely been there.

Lamb is a 6-foot-6 lefty and fantastic athlete who often played center field in college. His fastball is above average, but he'll take some time to develop due to so-so secondary pitches and a lack of command.

Castro is a more traditional high school pitching prospect with length and tons of projection.
Later Picks Of Note: Fourth-round outfielder Desmond Henry is a pure burner who is considerably rawness. Sixth-round pick Derek Fisher has plenty of hitting skills and raw power, but he threw out a big number before the draft and could be a tough sign. Fifth-round right-hander Brandon Woodruff is another tools bet with big heat but a rough delivery.
Analysis: The Rangers have added so many small pitchers with good stuff and command that one is forced to wonder if they see it as some kind of market inefficiency.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
I like Maronde, but I don't see him as anything other than a relief pitcher. You make it sound like the Angels have other ideas, is that true?
One thing I've been somewhat confused about all along and never had a chance to get an opinion from a writer before the draft, but maybe here's my chance. I live in the same general neighborhood as the Cron bros. in Phoenix so I've followed their careers since high school.

Kevin is a much, much better player at this point in his career than CJ was. CJ was a 44th round pick out of MPHS is just one of many data points that support this. Kevin on the other hand, just mashed in HS, and owns several AZ HS records, and justifiably went quite high in the draft and also has a scholarship from a good baseball program in TCU.

So since both are a few years away from The Show anyways and from what I can see Kevin has a higher ceiling, why wasn't he chosen ahead of his brother? The obvious reason would be that CJ could arrive to The Show a few years earlier, but really, is that such an important consideration when you look at the length of a career? As an Angel fan, I'd be much more excited about Kevin, even though he's younger. Thanks.
Higher ceilings also come with higher risks. Kevin is less developed and thus has more of a chance of stalling out or even going backwards, while CJ is more of a sure thing.

Not saying the Angels made the right choice, but it makes some sense, especially for a perennial contender. Then again, considering the position (1B/DH), they should really be looking for high-ceiling players. You don't see many playoff teams with merely average first basemen.
I'd say the openly stated avoidance of small pitchers by most teams would be a clear market inefficiency. Especially if there is no data to prove that larger pitchers are healthier or worth more except in a speculative way (ie, trade value).
Excellent point. With all the guys 6' or so that are effective starters, it's amazing how much scouts still covet the big bodies.
Taijuan Walker or Danny Hultzen? Is it even close either way?
Totally different types of pitchers, vastly different polish and I am positive Kevin prefers Hultzen still.