Baseball Prospectus’ Pre-season Projection: 79-83, fourth place
Current record: 77-84, fourth place

Dusty Baker sure wouldn’t mind having Barry Bonds at the fourth slot in this lineup.

Buster Olney of’s Take

What went wrong: Edinson Volquez appeared poised to lead the Reds‘ staff into the future, but he lasted just nine starts before requiring reconstructive elbow surgery. This set the tone for the Reds, who hovered around .500 before a total collapse after the All-Star break. Willy Taveras was brought in to make an impact at the top of the Cincinnati lineup; instead, he mustered just a .275 on-base percentage. Jay Bruce missed two months and struggled to get on base in the months that he did play. The Reds had major problems producing runs against left-handed pitching; only six teams had a lower OPS against left-handers than Cincinnati’s 712.

Biggest puzzler on the drawing board: Simply put, how do they get better given their budget dynamics? The Reds opened the 2009 season with a payroll of $73 million, and presumably Bob Castellini is not going to go all Steinbrenner and pump in another $20-25 million. The Reds already have enormous obligations to four veterans: Francisco Cordero ($12 million), Aaron Harang ($12.5 million), Bronson Arroyo ($11 million), and Scott Rolen ($11 million). That’s $46.5 million to players who are not presently high-impact types, which leaves little wiggle room for the Reds as far as next year’s budge. Their best chance for improvement might be in the powerful right arm of Homer Bailey, who had a tremendous year of progress in ’09, getting better and better; he went 3-1 with a 2.41 ERA in the month of September. Maybe he could be what Volquez was supposed to be. “I think they might be as far away from seriously contending as the Pirates, or maybe even farther,” said one scout who watched Cincinnati as it closed out its season.

The Baseball Prospectus Take

The Reds haven’t posted a winning season since 2000, but they came into the year with a PECOTA forecast that gave them around a 20 percent shot at the playoffs (12.1 percent division, 7.6 percent for the NL Wild Card). That modest projection acknowledged what most observers already knew-this team would feature a nucleus of promising young talent and older mainstays, but also a few gaping holes. On the offensive side, Joey Votto and Edwin Encarnacion both projected to rank among the majors’ top 50 in EqA. Alas, they both missed significant time with injuries. As a result, the Reds’ offense currently ranks 15th in the league in batting average, OBP and EqA, and a park-aided 11th in scoring at 4.1 runs per game.

Despite an acceptable 4.5 runs per game allowed-which owes something to a much-improved defense-Baker’s harrowing reputation with young pitchers reared its head. Volquez wound up undergoing Tommy John surgery after just nine starts and Johnny Cueto fell apart. Arroyo and Harang rebounded, though the latter was a victim of miserable run support (3.4 per game).-Jay Jaffe, Baseball Prospectus

Key stat: .245 AVG/.301 OBP/.354 SLG

That’s the combined showing of all Reds batting in the top two lineup spots, constituting 24 percent of the team’s total plate appearances and proving that Baker’s ideas about what make an offense work are completely out of touch with reality. During a ghastly stretch in which the team lost 45 out of 68 games, Taveras batted an appalling .216/.230/.243, and the lineup’s production shriveled to 3.6 runs per game. Once Taveras mercifully went on the disabled list with a quad strain in mid-August, Baker reacted by locking rookie Drew Stubbs (.260/.313/.438 overall) in the leadoff hole and weak-hitting shortstop Paul Janish (.215/.297/.308 overall) in the second slot. Despite this rather appalling second act of managerial malfeasance, the Reds have gone 26-15 since Taveras went down, though that performance has more to do with a pitching staff that’s held opponents to 3.8 runs per game via strong finishes from Arroyo, Bailey, and Cueto.-Jay Jaffe, Baseball Prospectus Rumor Central

Depth Chart: Reds fans are convinced the team needs to acquire a big bat-and GM Walt Jocketty said recently he’ll keep an eye out for one-but they need to consider what remains in-house if people are healthy. Bruce missed more than 60 games and Votto nearly 40, and Rolen has been dinged up, and regardless of what you think of Jonny Gomes, he’s hit 20 homers in just 278 ABs. In a full season, each could slug 30 homers (especially in this park), and that’s without mentioning Brandon Phillips. Rumor Central thinks the Reds will be quiet. Look for them to turn to their system or bench for solutions, with guys like Paul Janish, Drew Stubbs, and Ryan Hanigan helping at short, center, and catcher.

Free Agency: We mentioned Gomes, a guy with 20 homers and no idea where he’ll land next year. Well, he’s arbitration-eligible, and the Reds simply need to tender an offer to keep him around. Expect them to.

Who 2 Watch 4: Drew Stubbs, CF

The most surprising aspect of Stubbs’ big-league debut has been the power. One of the best all-around athletes in the game, Stubbs had shortened his swing in order to cut down his disturbingly high strikeout rate-and that led to just three home runs in 107 Triple-A games this year. The power (and the strikeouts) have returned, with his home park helping, but he does so many other things well, including drawing walks, stealing bases and playing a Gold Glove-caliber center field.-Kevin Goldstein, Baseball Prospectus

Draft recap

Signed: 33 of 51
Spent: Just under $5 million.
Hit: Brian Pearl, RHP (269th overall): Pearl signed for $90,000 and has reportedly touched 96 mph in the Pioneer League. He was a potential first-round pick when the spring began, and ranked 56th on Keith Law’s Top 100.
Miss: Not that it was a horrible pick, but Mike Leake was not the best player on the board with the eighth overall pick. He may not have even been the best college arm who might have signed for near-slot money and was available at the time, with right-hander Alex White and lefty Rex Brothers still up for grabs.-Jason A. Churchill,

The Bottom Line

With Votto, Phillips, Bruce, Stubbs, Cueto, Bailey, and a rehabbed Volquez, the Reds can still claim a promising young nucleus. Alas, Baker’s work this year shows that he may be the biggest obstacle to the team’s success, and with one more year on his deal, he’s not going anywhere. Trading either Arroyo or Harang is certainly an option; the two players have about $28 million remaining on their deals via 2010 contracts and 2011 buyouts, so moving one of them might create an opportunity for a midlevel signing. Still, it’s difficult to envision this team breaking out of the middle of the pack without keen vision and bold steps.-Jay Jaffe, Baseball Prospectus

A version of this story originally appeared on ESPN Insider Insider.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
"Still, it's difficult to envision this team breaking out of the middle of the pack without keen vision and bold steps."

Well said... we haven't made any bold steps here in Cincy since Marge Schott was the owner. Maybe we need is someone crazy running things again. Does anybody know if Glenn Beck wants to own a Baseball team?
Not sure the criticism of Baker for sticking Stubbs and Janish at the top of the order is really fair. This wasn't done until they were out of the race. Given the budget situation, they probably start next year. Better now to figure out if/where they fit than to wait until it "counts" in 2010.
I think both Janish and Stubbs have earned first shots at their respective jobs next year, just not their spots in the batting order. I could live with Stubbs at leadoff if he really is adjusting and he starts taking more walks. Janish certainly looks like a dead bat, but I was surprised to find out he hit 21 doubles this year in only 292 PA. With his glove he only needs to be replacement level with the bat to be worth it.
Agreed. Janish may belong in the lineup - he's a good part of the reason for the Reds' defensive turnaround, particularly during their pitching staff's strong late-season showing, but there's nothing in the guy's track record to suggest he belongs anywhere near the top of the lineu; his EqOBPs from his PECOTA card show he hasn't been above .300 at any level for any meaningful length of time since reaching High-A.

Stubbs does have speed and draws walks, but his contact issues depress his batting average, making him a less-than-stellar choice to lead off at this juncture.
Times like this I wonder if Baker would still have a job if he hadn't been lucky enough to have Barry Bonds on his team, who was the prime (and perhaps sole) reason the Giants were competitive in the late 90s and early aughts.
Baker must have really had to grit his teeth though through all those infuriating .400+ OBP seasons. Barry sure clogged the bases a lot with those incessant walks.

As an old Reds fan, I'd like to see them hold on to Gomes and see what he could do in a full season.
It wasn't just Bonds. There have only been six men in history who hit 600 or more home runs in their careers. Do you realize that this past year was the FIRST year in Baker's managerial career (spanning 16 years and 3 different teams) that he didn't have one of those 6 men on his team!

Kinda makes filling out a line-up card a little easier.
Though I don't think he had Sosa for his last year with the Cubs, your point is well made.