Baseball Prospectus’ Pre-season Projection: 86-76, first place
Current record: 61-88, fifth place

To make matter worse, Charlie Sheen has made himself a bigger star with Two and a Half Men than he ever did with Major League. Can Cleveland catch a break?

Buster Olney of’s Take

What went wrong: Start with the reality that for a mid-market or small-market team like the Indians, everything pretty much has to go right-and then realize that everything went very wrong in ’09. Fausto Carmona hasn’t been able to control his adrenaline, command his fastball, and return to his 2007 form; Travis Hafner has been a bust since signing a four-year, $57 million deal (which runs through 2012); Jake Westbrook missed the season with elbow trouble; Grady Sizemore was hurt even when he did play; and all of this happened at a time when the Ohio economy declined precipitously. Because of the budget projections for 2010, the Indians had to trade off Cliff Lee and Victor Martinez a year ahead of schedule, and now the team has been thrown back into the early stages of a rebuilding cycle.

Biggest puzzler on the drawing board: The Indians desperately need to develop some frontline pitching, which is always the secret formula for small-market success. That’s why, in every trade they made this summer, they asked for good arms in return. Justin Masterson might be another version of Westbrook-a steady mid-rotation ground-ball guy-and the Indians have high hopes for Jason Knapp, the centerpiece of the Lee trade with Philadelphia (although Knapp already has come up sore and required surgery). It may be a long time before the Indians will be able build on a several talented young pitchers, as they had with CC Sabathia, Lee, and the ’07 version of Carmona. The one lasting reason for hope is that they play in a mediocre division.

The Baseball Prospectus Take

Our projections forecast the Indians to win the AL Central, albeit with a meager 86 wins and a 38 percent chance of making the postseason-the lowest of any division favorite. Despite injuries to Sizemore and Hafner and the departures of Mark DeRosa, Ryan Garko, and Martinez via mid-season trades, the offense has essentially lived up to expectations; projected to rank fourth in the AL in scoring, they actually rank fifth, with an EqA which is fourth in the AL. It’s the pitching that has been a brutal disappointment: projected to rank seventh in the league in runs allowed, they’re instead second-to-last, with both the rotation and bullpen ranking dead last in their respective win expectancy-based categories, SNLVAR and WXRL. The bullpen’s wretched early-season showing drove the team 10 games under .500 by mid-May, a hole the Tribe never escaped.-Jay Jaffe, Baseball Prospectus

Key Stat: 5.75

That’s the ERA of the starting pitchers aside from Lee, who was traded to the Phillies on July 29. The only starter besides Lee with at least 10 starts and an ERA below 4.92 is Aaron Laffey, for whom the team didn’t even have space in the rotation until the season was already going down in flames. Laffey’s also the only starter this side of Lee with a Support-Neutral Winning Percentage above .500. For all of the bullpen’s woes, the starters simply didn’t give the Indians a chance to win; aside from Lee, their combined SNWP is just .431.

In retrospect, it’s clear that the cast that GM Mark Shapiro assembled behind Lee offered too much risk. Shapiro’s plan hinged on rebounds from mostly-lost 2008 seasons by Carl Pavano, Anthony Reyes, and Carmona-with a comeback from Tommy John surgery by Jake Westbrook supposed to provide a mid-season lift. None of those pitchers miss many bats, so it’s not terribly surprising that the Tribe staff is last in the league in strikeouts. Pavano was erratic and homer-prone; the team eventually dealt him to the Twins in early August. Reyes made just eight starts before needing TJ surgery. Carmona put up a 7.42 ERA through 12 starts before being sent all the way down to A-ball to iron out the mechanical problems which first took hold last year. Despite an initially promising return, he’s been pummeled for a 10.72 ERA over his last five starts. To that unhappy brew, add a parade of lefties (Zach Jackson, Jeremy Sowers, David Huff) each more hittable than the last, and rough introductions for a couple of mid-season acquisitions (Justin Masterson, Carlos Carrasco), and you’ve got a rotation whose ERA bests only Baltimore’s, but without the high-upside prospects which mitigate the Orioles‘ showing.-Jay Jaffe, Baseball Prospectus

Rumor Central

Trades: After gutting their roster of All-Star level players, the Indians could walk into next year with a payroll of under $60 million, impressive since it was over $80 million heading into the season. Why not finish the reclamation project and trade Kerry Wood and Grady Sizemore? Well, in the case of Wood, the Tribe is already looking for a taker, according to several sources. As for Sizemore, it just doesn’t make sense. The Indians have re-stocked their system with a ton of arms because in Lee, V-Mart, and CC, they traded high. Sizemore’s value hasn’t been lower in three years. He’s hurt, and he hasn’t hit. Expect the team to move Wood and send a check with him if they can, but Grady won’t move unless a huge offer comes along.

Depth chart: While the last week of the season for most Indians players will be a sleepwalk, Andy Marte‘s future as a member of the Indians-or as a potential free agent-could be decided then. According to local reports, GM Mark Shapiro will be meeting with players this week regarding their future with the ballclub. Marte is an odd case. Long considered a great prospect-even a potential All-Star-his production at the big-league level hasn’t lived up to that billing. He’s hitting .227 (27-for-119) with five homers and is mired in a 4-for-36 slump. Expect to see somebody willing to bring him into camp next year with a shot at making the team, but one has to question if the Indians, even in their rebuilding mode, will be that team.

Who 2 Watch 4: Catchers Lou Marson and Carlos Santana

It was interesting to see the Indians acquire Marson from the Phillies in the Lee trade when they already had Santana, the top prospect in the system who won Eastern League MVP honors with a .290/.413/.530 season at Double-A Akron. Marson is an athletic, big league-ready catcher with nice on-base skills, but he’s merely a placeholder for Santana, the real catcher of the future for the organization. Still, Marson’s a nice asset to have, so don’t be shocked if he gets moved to fill a more pressing need by midseason in 2010, if not earlier.-Kevin Goldstein, Baseball Prospectus

Draft recap

Signed: 28 of 50
Spent: Just under $4 million.
Hit: Austin Adams, RHP (155th overall). Adams played at Faulkner U., an NAIA school in Alabama, but touched the mid-90s with his fastball regularly. He has more room for development than most college prospects, since he lacks extensive experience.
Miss: Alex White, RHP (15th overall). White wasn’t a bad choice, but club execs are already talking as if his future is in the bullpen. Winding up with a reliever with the fifteenth overall pick isn’t typically seen as wise, particularly with better talents available. Many scouts, however, believe White can start games and fit somewhere in the second or third slot in a big-league rotation.-Jason A. Churchill,

The Bottom Line

The Indians have approached the last several seasons with an eye on contending. In three of those four years, though, they’ve stumbled out of the gate, dooming their chances of playing meaningful games after June. In the process, they’ve had to make deals, including shipping away the past two AL Cy Young winners. They’ve brought back some quality prospects, but it’s clear that they’re in no position to contend in 2010, mainly because they haven’t had much success with their high draft picks in recent years. Given their penchant for underachieving on skipper Eric Wedge‘s watch, they’re almost certainly better off with a new manager, too.-Jay Jaffe, Baseball Prospectus

A version of this story originally appeared on ESPN Insider Insider.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
As far as I can tell, the only real happy note for the Tribe this year was Shin-Soo Choo establishing that his great half-season in 2008 wasn't a fluke. He ranks a shocking 6th in the AL (21st in MLB) in WARP.

How many more years of Cheap Choo (tm) do the Indians get? If it's less than 3, they probably need to trade him immediately to a team that appreciates OBP and defense and has some high-risk high-return arms they could swap.
Asdrubal Cabrera has been a happy note for the Tribe as well.
True enough; I forgot about him.
I recall last off-season reading that Choo has a military obligation he will have to fulfill, so unless that has changed (and I recall it was potentially 2 or even 3 years), that's problematic for the Tribe.

Yeah, i was hoping they'd mention choo on his breakout season. I fully expect him capable of hitting this well in the future. He finally got a full season of at bats and played very well.
This Indians season has been an awful nagging pain. Now the good players are scattered across the country to make the contenders better, the expensive players are unable to play due to injury or not very good, the rotation is filled with young players who don't have much promise, and the minor leagues (we hope) is now stocked with the players other teams drafted who can make all of this right again someday.

I want to believe, but it's difficult right now. Attendance next year is going to be bleak.
One thing that has been crippling to to tribe is their failure to develop the players they draft. I might be forgetting some, but over the past five or so years the only position players they've produced from the draft are Garko-average, and two 4th outfielders in Fransisco and Crowe. The pitching side is a bit better with Laffey, Sowers and Huff, but at this point none of them are impact players. Sipp is the first good reliever they've produced in a while.

When I see they only spent $4 million on the draft (compared to $7-8 million from the royals and pirates respectively) I can't help but wonder if they're going to continue to struggle to get much out of the draft. If Shapiro wasn't so fine at trading for prospects, or if they had less success in Latin America, who knows where this team would be.
Some incorrect information. White is not moving to the bullpen. That was initially discussed but later changed since they have such a big need for SP.

It's not all doom and gloom. The Aero's won the Eastern league championship and have some very promising prospects moving up to Columbus and Cleveland soon.
The name you'll want to remember from the Martinez trade is Nick Hagadone. He's just coming back from TJ surgery (last year) and he should be expected in the Cleveland pitching corps within a year.