keyboard_arrow_uptop

Baseball Weekly recently
ran a Bob Nightengale column
that focused on some of Scott Boras’s ideas for improving competitive balance. Buried at
the end of the article was an interesting quote from a major-league general
manager that cited the most oft-repeated mantra of the small-marketeers.

As part of the argument, Nightengale quotes Kansas City GM Allard Baird
(hardly a bastion of credibility these days) as saying, "Let’s face
it, Montreal has done as good a job as anyone in the game as far as
producing legitimate impact players, but once they developed the players,
they’ve had to move them. That’s why there has to be a restructuring of the
economic system of the game."

Is this really true? Everyone loves to talk about how Montreal has
had to deal all of its top talent away, but in reality, Montreal
didn’t lose that much of value. Let’s look at the 1994 Expos’ top players:

C  Darrin Fletcher
1B Cliff Floyd
2B Mike Lansing
3B Sean Berry
SS Wil Cordero
LF Moises Alou
CF Marquis Grissom
RF Larry Walker

SP Ken Hill SP Pedro Martinez SP Jeff Fassero SP Kirk Rueter SP Butch Henry

RP John Wetteland RP Mel Rojas

Larry Walker and Pedro Martinez were clear losses for the
team. John Wetteland was never as effective after he left as he was
in 1993-94 but he has had over 200 saves since then, so it’s hard to argue
that that wasn’t a loss for the team as well. Beyond those guys, though,
the record is mixed. Here are some of the stats of the other players on
that team (and the 1993 squad) since they left Montreal:

Name             Yrs    G    AB    R  HR  RBI   SB  CS    BB   OBP   SLG
Darrin Fletcher   3   361  1235  128  47  190    1   0    71  .336  .470
Mike Lansing      3   327  1233  169  27  141   20   5    84  .312  .397
Wil Cordero       5   476  1799  268  58  258    8   7   111  .321  .447
Marquis Grissom   6   883  3520  476  91  387  136  57   243  .317  .404
Moises Alou       4   435  1576  274  91  353   23  11   206  .396  .563
Delino DeShields  7   884  3209  488  49  333  243  74   387  .348  .386

Delino DeShields, Wil Cordero, Mike Lansing, and
Marquis Grissom have all been lousy since leaving, and both Cordero
and DeShields had to move to the outfield because of defensive woes.
Fletcher, who wasn’t a farm system product in Montreal (he came up with the
Dodgers in 1989), has been good since his departure, but that’s largely the
product of his superb 2000 season. A catcher with a .336 OBP is hardly the
kind of loss that breaks a team.

That leaves us with Moises Alou among the departing hitters, and
while his stats above are excellent, they come with one caveat. Alou missed
one entire season, 1999, due to a pair of weird knee injuries, and he has
missed enough other games so that his average number of games played since
he left Montreal is only 109. His 1997 season wasn’t particularly special
either, so since he left, he has had two spectacular seasons, a mediocre
one, and one lost to injury. How much is that worth to most teams? Few but
the highest-revenue teams could absorb that kind of four-year performance
from an $8 million-per-year player.

You’ll notice that I omitted Cliff Floyd. Floyd’s future was still
in doubt at the time that the Expos finally gave up on him before the 1997
season. In exchange for Floyd, the Expos received Dustin Hermanson,
who proceeded to give the team four years of generally good pitching and
who garnered Fernando Tatis in a trade this winter. Floyd,
meanwhile, has played in just 414 games in those four seasons, and didn’t
crack a .500 slugging average until 1999. Of course, the Expos got
something of value when they dealt DeShields as well.

Name           W   L   SV    IP      H    ER    HR     BB    SO    ERA
Ken Hill      53  55    0   939   1005   482    95    449   557   4.62
Jeff Fassero  42  43    0   745    810   387   105    283   576   4.67
Kirk Rueter   56  36    0   770    829   361    95    230   398   4.22
Mel Rojas      5   8   17   157    168   111    30     75   144   6.35

The record of ex-Expo pitchers is even worse. Ken Hill had a great
won/lost record in 1994, but his peripherals weren’t sound, so moving him
when they did was the right move for the Expos. Jeff Fassero had
been worked pretty hard, and while he gave the Mariners about a year and a
half of good pitching, he fell apart in 1999 and hasn’t been the same since
he left Montreal. Mel Rojas‘s disaster is well known and
unsurprising. Of the pitchers on this chart, Kirk Rueter is the only
pitcher who has had any success beyond Montreal, and he was the least
expensive of the bunch by far. The Expos moved him because it looked like
the magic of his 8-0 rookie year was gone, as his ERA had gone well over
4.00 (back when that was a bad thing).

So the breakup of the good Expos teams of the early 1990s wasn’t
necessarily the reason for the team’s downfall, as most of the expensive
players who got away did little after leaving. One could argue that the
Expos did more damage to themselves by letting go of cheaper players like
Kirk Rueter and Jeff Shaw (a reliever for the 1994 team who didn’t
distinguish himself until he arrived in Cincinnati in 1996) than they did
via their "salary dumps."

This isn’t to say that the Expos are inept in the player-development
department. Vladimir Guerrero is on the short list of candidates for
best player in the game. Javier Vazquez is a huge BP favorite who
looks like he’s on the cusp of several All-Star appearances. Jose
Vidro
came out of nowhere last year to become a doubles machine.
Ugueth Urbina had been among the game’s better relievers until elbow
surgery knocked him out last year. Milton Bradley and Brad
Wilkerson
are both nearly ready for the majors, as is Donnie
Bridges
. And this ignores the prospects acquired in deals, like
Peter Bergeron and Britt Reames.

However, the claim that Montreal was on the verge of a championship or a
dynasty, only to be felled by a labor action and baseball’s economic
structure, seems spurious at best. The overachieving 1994 team would
probably have gone to the playoffs, but after that season, the team’s
fortunes would probably have taken a turn for the worse anyway as the
veterans came back to earth. That’s just a matter of the natural cycles of
the game. Blaming every small-market team’s demise on money just won’t work.

Keith Law is an author of Baseball Prospectus. You can contact him by clicking here.