I hadn’t watched much of the MLB Network since its launch on January 1, mostly because I haven’t been home much since then. Yesterday, however, I had the channel on all day, catching a replay of the Mexico/Puerto Rico game, and then most of the Tuesday Caribbean Series doubleheader, with an edition of MLB Hot Stove between the two games. I’ll spare you a review of the coverage, as I wasn’t really watching for that purpose. It was just good to see baseball in February, even if the rosters were a bit watered down due to the upcoming World Baseball Classic. There were some great pitching performances, and a couple of huge hits. The studio show had former players. Lots of them.

My takeaway from the day, however, was names. Every few minutes, the scroll at the bottom would show the remaining free agents. “Orlando Hudson, Mark Grudzielanek, Ray Durham…” “Ben Sheets, Randy Wolf, Braden Looper, Tom Glavine…”

After a while, I started playing games with them. “You could platoon Jim Edmonds and Andruw Jones and fake center field.” “Hey, an all-Orlando double- play combination would be funny. Lots of Strat-tournament teams did that last year.” “I wonder if those six guys would make a better bullpen than half the teams in baseball have.”

I wonder…

So let’s say something happened. I don’t want to say what-I don’t want to verbalize a horrible thought-but let’s say that MLB needed a 30th team to complete the schedule. Or maybe a 31st to satisfy the result of some lawsuit. Could you take the available players and build a team from them? How much would it cost, and how good would the team be?

Here’s what I came up with. The prices paid reflect the reality that, in this situation, a team wouldn’t just be able to sign guys to minor league deals with NRIs, but they’d have to spend a few bucks to lock up the player.


Ivan Rodriguez, one year, $3 million
Paul Lo Duca, one year, $1 million

I lost Javier Valentin to the Brewers overnight, which was disappointing. This leaves the team with two very similar catchers: right-handed batters who hit the ball on the ground, don’t walk much, and don’t hit for power. Rodriguez still throws well enough that his defense is a plus, and if this were the tandem, I think you’d ride him and hope that his physical condition allows him to play 135 games, hit a relatively empty .280, and be a +5 or so defender.

First Base

Adam Dunn, two years, $11 million per
Kevin Millar, one year, $2 million

Yes, I know: Adam Dunn wants to play left field. As you’ll see when we get to the outfielders, though, there’s no room for him there, and 30 other teams seem to be uninterested in signing him to play the outfield as well. With a number of left fielders still available, Dunn is going to have to be more flexible about his position, and I’m willing to overpay him to get him to do so. OBP is going to be an issue for this team, as is lineup imbalance; Dunn addresses both problems. Millar is a pinch-hitter and spot starter against southpaws. He might also be asked to fake third base on occasion.

(I’m assuming this will be a National League team, but having a DH slot would clearly be an asset given the players available on the market.)

Second Base

Orlando Hudson, two years, $7 million per
Ray Durham, one year, $2 million

Hudson has a broad skill set, and while I’ve pointed out his flaws, getting him to play second base for this team would be a boon. In fact, it’s the presence of him and the next signee that makes this project possible. There’s probably never been a double-play combination this good available this late in any year other than 1995. Durham, like Millar, is a good bat off of the bench with limited defensive skill.


Orlando Cabrera, one year, $6 million

As with Hudson, Cabrera is a somewhat flawed player who is nonetheless above average for his position, and who contributes across the board. Like Hudson, the first-round draft pick attached to him has raised the cost of signing him beyond what most teams care to pay; my fake team doesn’t care about the 2009 draft.

Alex Cintron would have been a perfect fit to back up all three infield positions, and in fact, he was the only major league free agent left who had that ability. Unfortunately for my guys, he signed a minor league deal with the Brewers yesterday. As the roster is currently constructed, Hudson is the backup shortstop. The full execution of this plan would certainly involve the generous use of minor league free agents. As of this morning, I don’t have a list of those.

Third Base

Joe Crede, one year, $2 million

He’s really the only option. If Crede’s back doesn’t hold up, Millar or my imaginary minor league free agent ends up playing a lot of third base. The saving grace here is that the up-the-middle defense is so good that you might get away with sacrificing some on the corners.


Manny Ramirez, two years, $25 million per
Bobby Abreu, one year, $10 million
Jim Edmonds, one year, $4 million
Andruw Jones, one year, $1 million
Jay Payton, one year, $1 million

That offer should be the best available to Ramirez right now, though given his importance to this plan, a one-year deal for $30 million would also be an option. You need to get him to make this work. Abreu plays right field and does his OBP-and-doubles thing. Between them, Jones gets a lot of playing time to cover the gaps, with Edmonds playing 70 times against right-handed pitchers. If Jones really is done on both sides of the ball, Payton could play more, but he’s primarily around to be Ramirez’s legs.

The lineup? Abreu, Hudson, Ramirez, Dunn, Cabrera, Edmonds, Crede, and Rodriguez. I don’t hate it. Edmonds probably has to play more than Jones to keep the bottom of the lineup from being five straight right-handed hitters with OBP issues. You could bat Cabrera second and Hudson fifth, but that’s a minor swap.

Starting Pitchers

Ben Sheets, two years, $11 million per
Randy Wolf, one year, $6 million
Braden Looper, one year, $5 million
Pedro Martinez, one year, $4 million
Livan Hernandez, one year, $2 million
Jason Jennings, one year, $1 million

It’s a mix of innings guys in Looper and Hernandez, and upside-if-healthy guys in Sheets and Martinez. Wolf and Jennings split the difference between the two.

Relief Pitchers

Juan Cruz, two years, $5 million per
Joe Beimel, one year, $3 million
Jon Lieber, one year, $3 million
Will Ohman, one year, $2 million
Luis Ayala, one year, $2 million
Julian Tavarez, one year, $1 million

Relievers bounce around so much that it’s hard to predict what any group will do. You can see where Cruz in the ninth, maybe used as a four- or five-out guy, with Beimel and Ayala playing matchups in front of him, Ohman spotting against lefties, and Lieber and Tavarez in multiple-inning roles, could be an average, or maybe a little above average, pen. You can also see it as an unmitigated disaster.

I think what surprises me is just how expensive the roster is: $120 million, with another $59 million committed to 2010. There’s no way this team will return that kind of value on the field, and in going through this exercise, you begin to understand why these guys are free agents. Why pay $2 million for Joe Crede when you can pay $400,000 for the same likely performance with more upside? Lather, rinse, repeat for many of the guys on this team. Perhaps that means the prices that I’m offering are a bit high, but understand that if any team has to overpay to attract talent, it’s the one that didn’t exist on Groundhog Day.

I suspect that even a three-week head start would have made a difference, as a number of solid bench and bullpen options have been snatched up recently. More importantly, I love the idea of actually doing this, but while mixing in some available free talent from other pools. I’m signing players to $1 million and $2 million contracts in this exercise, and I think that a lot of those can be turned into $400,000 deals without any negative effect on the team’s performance, and maybe even some improvement. There have to be better relievers than Ayala and Tavarez, a better third baseman than Crede, a good utility infielder, a better backup catcher than Lo Duca… the top 18 guys on this roster and the top seven minor league free agents would make a team that can win 80 games for about $80 million.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
For both Valentin and Cintron: yesterday both signed minor league deals with spring training NRI\'s with the Nationals, not Brewers.
I think this exercise also reinforces how little value is returned on free-agent investments as a whole.
It\'d be really neat to know how many wins this team would project based on pythag using PECOTA.

I am not surprised at the cost. Free Agents cost a lot of $$ and there is definitely a premium built in as compared to the cost per win of the rest of the league.
I will be ASTOUNDED if Braden Looper settles for one year at $5M, after what Oliver Perez just got.
Who\'s your manager?
Why not do this kind of article again, but include NRIs and/or non-rookies who are signed to minor league contracts? Basically, expand the scope beyond free agents to \"free talent\".

Also, you could forget about Manny and insert Dunn in left, then grab some \"free\" first baseman or attempt a first base platoon from some combination of Jones/Edmonds/Crede/Durham/Millar.
Given that this \"team\" has NO access to pre-arb players, it\'s not surprising in the slightest that the payroll is so high. In fact, it shows exactly why the Yankees have paid so much for teams that were clearly not elite over the last several years. If you want to field an affordable team, you have to develop much of the talent yourself - rinse and repeat.
clearly not elite? yankees? last several years?

i\'ll take 97 wins in 06 and 97 pyth wins in 07 as elite. call it over performing in 05 and 04, i\'ll still take 95 and 101 wins any day of the week. looking at 02 and 03 and i see a clearly elite team with over 100 wins both years. going back much further than that and the payroll issue approaches \"moot\".

perhaps you accidentally included the word \"several\" because that was the first year in a long time the yanks were clearly not elite. and even then it was primarily due to back loaded contracts and injuries (though, admittedly truly elite teams don\'t have excuses).
If some team could actually swing Manny and Dunn in the middle of the order (I\'d prolly do Dunn-Manny) That would be sweet.
Joe, you could also break the collusion and sign Bonds to a conditional contract for an extra win or two! :-)

My friends and I used to do a similar exercise every off-season, but we tried to make it a bit more realistic, and in doing so, could make a fairly decent team at much lower costs, by using a real team\'s current farm system (but none of the pre-arb players currently playing).

We would typically do two teams - one, using an average farm system, and one, using one of the worst.

It would be cheating to cherry pick the farm that is light on outfielders and has studs at Catcher and 3rd Base, just because that is where the free agent market is worst, but, just have Goldstein tell you who he rates as the 15th, and 28th best farm systems in baseball, and repeat the exercise, but using the minor league talent you have from that same farm system.

This makes it a little more realistic - no team is built entirely from scratch, every team has a farm system to draw cheap talent from. I think you could produce a team that could contend, and possibly win, in the AL West and NL West, using just the free agents and the talent from the 15th best farm system, and I don\'t think you\'d break $85 million.

What that tells us about the state of baseball, I don\'t quite know.
If you need another left-handed bat, Garrett Anderson is also still available.
Millar signed a minor league deal with the Blue Jays a few days ago, didn\'t he?

Maybe you can get Sean Casey to come out of retirement.

You\'re not signing Bonds? You, Sir, are colluding.
That\'s a really good point. Bonds needs to be on this team.

I will note that he (correctly) didn\'t sign Griffey.