Each year, the White Sox graciously host a University of Chicago alumni event, where Christina Kahrl and I speak to 150 or more nerds in the U.S. Cellular Conference & Learning Center. The group gets tickets to the game too-which usually means a contest against the Orioles or the Royals, or perhaps a thrilling interleague tilt against the Pirates; clubs that don’t motivate many Chicagoans to give up an afternoon from their short summers to come out to the ballpark.

This year’s matchup, booked months in advance, was against the Devil Rays, presumably about as irrelevant as it gets. But, of course, it turned out to be one of the best baseball games of the year, not just because of the blown interference call that allowed A.J. Pierzynski to remain on base and score the winning run in the bottom of the 10th (a run without which the White Sox would have missed the playoffs), but also because of the caliber of teams involved. Yes, PECOTA saw the Rays coming (and no, it didn’t see the White Sox). But this was one year where karma played nice, rewarding two smart clubs with a little bit of luck to help propel them into the playoffs.


White Sox               AVG/ OBP/ SLG   EqA   VORP
SS-R Orlando Cabrera   .281/.334/.371  .253   20.1
LF-L Dewayne Wise      .249/.293/.450  .265    4.3
RF-R Jermaine Dye      .292/.344/.541  .293   38.8
DH-L Jim Thome         .245/.362/.503  .293   34.4
1B-R Paul Konerko      .240/.344/.438  .272   11.4
CF-L Ken Griffey Jr.   .249/.353/.424  .265    3.7*
2B-R Alexei Ramirez    .290/.317/.475  .266   20.7
C-L  A.J. Pierzynski   .281/.312/.416  .252   15.4
3B-R Juan Uribe        .247/.296/.386  .235   -3.3
*: AL only VORP

Rays                    AVG/ OBP/ SLG   EqA   VORP
2B-L Akinori Iwamura   .274/.349/.380  .264   16.0
CF-R B.J. Upton        .273/.383/.401  .291   32.1
1B-L Carlos Pena       .247/.377/.494  .306   32.0
3B-R Evan Longoria     .272/.343/.531  .302   34.8
LF-L Carl Crawford     .273/.319/.400  .262    7.1
DH-L Cliff Floyd       .268/.349/.455  .286   12.6
C-S  Dioner Navarro    .295/.349/.407  .268   17.8
RF-L Gabe Gross        .238/.336/.414  .271    3.9
SS-R Jason Bartlett    .286/.329/.361  .255   12.9

The White Sox scored 811 runs to the Devil Rays’ 774, a small difference essentially mitigated by the teams’ respective home ballparks. That is not to suggest, however, that these teams are equally well equipped for the playoffs. The White Sox scored those 811 runs while having Carlos Quentin and Joe Crede in their lineup for most of the year, two players who combined for a 59.2 VORP (the vast bulk of that coming from Quentin), but who are injured and remain out of the ALDS. The Rays, meanwhile, scored their 774 without the services of Carl Crawford and Evan Longoria for long portions of the season, but not both of whom are ready to go, although Crawford will be returning without having played in the last seven weeks of the regular season.

So indeed, the difference in offensive firepower is rather stark. Apart from the reliable Dye-Thome combo, and the plucky contributions of Alexei Ramirez in the seven hole-he’s emerged as a sort of mini-me version of Alsonso Soriano-there isn’t a whole lot to like in the White Sox’ lineup. Orlando Cabrera is, on his good days, an adequate leadoff hitter, and on his bad days something less than that. Dewayne Wise and his .293 OBP will start in left field rather than Nick Swisher (at least against right-handed pitching), a decision I find hard to fathom. Ken Griffey Jr. has yet to re-adjust to American League pitching; Paul Konerko had a down year (though an excellent second half); Juan Uribe was a replacement-level bat at shortstop, and now he’s starting at third base. Expect a lot of solo home runs and not much else; the White Sox are going to need to keep this a low-scoring series if they want to win it.

The Rays, by contrast, have perhaps only one easy out in their lineup, in the form of Jason Bartlett, who nevertheless managed to post numbers nearly identical to those of Cabrera, the Sox’ leadoff hitter. Otherwise, theirs is a fairly classically-constructed lineup, with on-base guys at the top, power in the middle, and whatever is left at the end. The one saving grace for the White Sox is that the Rays are significantly weaker against left-handed pitching, having hit just .246/.330/.396 against southpaws this year as a club, which means trouble against Mark Buehrle and John Danks, two of the better lefties in the league.


White Sox               AVG/ OBP/ SLG   EqA   VORP
OF/1B-S Nick Swisher   .219/.332/.410  .260    4.2 @ 1B
3B/LF-R Josh Fields    .156/.229/.188  .129   -3.8 @ 3B
CF-R Brian Anderson    .232/.272/.436  .243    1.1
OF-L Jerry Owens       .250/.250/.250  .195   -1.2
C-R  Toby Hall         .260/.304/.331  .224   -1.3

Rays                    AVG/ OBP/ SLG   EqA   VORP
RF-L Eric Hinske       .247/.333/.465  .281   13.6
OF-R Rocco Baldelli    .263/.344/.475  .286    4.0 @ DH
INF-S Willy Aybar      .253/.327/.410  .262    5.2 @ 3B
UT-S Ben Zobrist       .253/.339/.505  .294   14.7 @ SS
CF-S Fernando Perez    .250/.348/.433  .290    3.9
C-R  Michel Hernandez  .200/.200/.200  .075   -1.5

Granted, they didn’t have great years-and most of Fields’ was spent in Charlotte-but the White Sox bench looks stronger than it “should” be because both Swisher and Fields arguably ought to be in the starting lineup. Still, they are relatively good bats to have coming off of the bench, while Brian Anderson is an outstanding defensive replacement in center. What’s a bit unusual, though, is that the Sox are not carrying a natural middle-infield backup. This is principally because Juan Uribe can slide over to play shortstop or second base if needed, with Fields taking over at third, but it does limit the White Sox’ tactical flexibility some, and if there’s a 14-inning game and Paul Konerko ends up playing third base or something like that, don’t say you weren’t warned.

The Rays, meanwhile, have at least four quality bats off the bench, and an abundance of positional flexibility, having made the (smart) decision to carry 10 pitchers rather than 11. Expect Gabe Gross and Cliff Floyd to be platooned aggressively, and for Joe Maddon to have little reluctance to pinch-hit for Jason Bartlett. This is everything you want in a playoff bench, simply put, although backup catcher Michel Hernandez is perhaps the least likely of any of the 200 players who made postseason rosters to actually realize playing time.


White Sox               IP      ERA SNLVAR   SNW%
RHP Javier Vazquez     208.1   4.67   3.3   .429
LHP Mark Buehrle       218.2   3.79   4.9   .556
LHP John Danks         195.0   3.32   6.1   .571
RHP Gavin Floyd        206.1   3.84   3.3   .680

Rays                    IP      ERA SNLVAR   SNW%
RHP James Shields      215.0   3.56   5.4   .636
LHP Scott Kazmir       152.1   3.49   4.8   .600
RHP Matt Garza         184.2   3.70   4.9   .550
RHP Andy Sonnanstine   193.1   4.38   3.0   .591

The pitchers are listed here in the order in which they’re expected to appear in Games One through Four, but there is an important asterisk: in Game Five, the Game Two starters will be able to pitch on normal rest. Chicago has already hinted that Mark Buehrle would start a Game Five, allowing the Sox to deploy three left-handed starters against the Rays in five games, by far their weaker side of the plate. And one would probably expect Joe Maddon to do the same with Scott Kazmir.

The White Sox’ rotation is somewhat under-appreciated. Danks just won the biggest game of his life, and is the sort of player who could become a household name in the postseason. Javier Vazquez is a considerably better pitcher than his ERA suggests, having placed fourth in the American League in strikeouts (though, like Shane Reynolds or Eric Milton, he may be one of those pitchers who is cosmically fated to underperform his peripherals). Gavin Floyd combined a lucky first with a legitimately good second half. And Mark Buehrle is Mark Buehrle. Chicago’s rotation is not as glitzy as Boston’s or Los Angeles’s, but it is not giving anything up to them.

Still, the Rays have the trump card in Kazmir, who is by some margin the best pitcher on either roster. Kazmir’s flaw is that he can be wild, but the White Sox have a tendency to chase pitches, so he’s not a good pairing for them. Indeed, patience will be the key against Kazmir, as he can rack up high pitch counts and does not throw particularly deep into games; that is, in fact, why the Rays have slotted him second-so that they can churn through their bullpen on Friday if needed, in advance of Saturday’s off day. If I’m Ozzie Guillen, I’m giving my hitters the take sign a lot against Kazmir in the early going and hoping he pitches himself out while Mark Buehrle holds the damage down. To the extent that the Rays have a real vulnerability, it is probably Sonnanstine, who can give up a fair number of extra-base hits and who will have to pitch in Game Four at the Cell.


White Sox                IP     ERA  WXRL    FRA
RHP Bobby Jenks         61.2   2.63  4.46   2.39
LHP Matt Thornton       67.1   2.67  1.30   3.37
RHP Scott Linebrink     46.1   3.69  1.85   3.52
RHP Octavio Dotel       67.0   3.76  1.09   4.33
RHP D.J. Carrasco       38.2   3.96  0.98   3.69
LHP Clayton Richard     47.2   6.04 -0.01   6.53
RHP Adam Russell        26.0   5.19  0.07   5.10

Rays                    IP     ERA   WXRL    FRA
RHP Dan Wheeler         66.1   3.12  2.09   2.94
LHP J.P. Howell         89.1   2.22  4.64   2.78
RHP Grant Balfour       58.1   1.54  3.43   0.96
LHP David Price         14.0   1.93  0.09   2.47
RHP Chad Bradford       19.0   1.42  0.77   2.65
LHP Trever Miller       43.1   4.15  1.67   3.32

This is just a guess on the Rays’ bullpen; Joe Maddon has intimated that there may be some surprises. What we think we know is that Troy Percival will miss the series, that Edwin Jackson was squeezed out by the numbers game, and that David Price will definitely make the roster. Missing Percival is no big deal, since he was probably no better than the fourth-best member of this bullpen, the stars of whom are really Howell and Balfour, who like Scott Kazmir, should find plenty of success in getting the Sox to chase pitches. Price is a neat wild card-the White Sox have never faced him (in fact, none of the playoff clubs have), and virgin matchups like that tend to favor the pitcher.

One could gripe about the inclusion of Clayton Richard and Adam Russell in the White Sox’ bullpen as opposed to a 15th position player or perhaps a pitcher like Boone Logan who is a bit more of a specialist, but those guys are only going to pitch in blowouts anyway. The action, rather, is from the Jenks/Thornton/Linebrink/Dotel quarter, all of whom had excellent seasons, and each of whom confront their hitters with a different type of challenge. To the extent that there’s a weak link in the group, it may actually be Jenks, whose strikeout rate has deteriorated significantly to the point where it was below league average. Instead, Jenks is a command-and-control guy, one who knows how to pitch to the situation and how to keep the ball down, masquerading in a power-pitchers’ body. It’s a neat trick, but if the Rays do a good job of advance scouting, he may be exploitable.


The White Sox’ defense checked in at 18 runs below average on the year. A lot of that was from Alexei Ramirez, who registered a -16 but whose defense I actually like a lot personally, even if it’s a bit unorthodox and sandlot-ish at times. The left side of the infield ought to be quite good, with Cabrera and Juan Uribe, who is overqualified for third base (if not quite as crisp there as Joe Crede). There is a major liability, however, in center field, a position that Ken Griffey Jr. shouldn’t have been playing five years ago, and certainly shouldn’t be playing now at the age of 38. With Brian Anderson on the roster, Ozzie Guillen should be considering making a defensive substitution as early as the sixth inning should the White Sox hold the lead.

The Rays, meanwhile, made what may have been the greatest year-over-year defensive turnaround in major league history, going from an unfathomably bad -117 FRAA last year to a superlative +59 this year. Longoria, Crawford (if healthy), Pena, Navarro, and Bartlett are all considerably above-average defenders, and B.J. Upton has made significant progress in center field, with the skills finally catching up to his tools. Only right field and second base are modest liabilities. Expect to be very impressed with the Rays defense; if they advance to the World Series, there is an excellent chance that at least one win will have been buoyed by an outstanding defensive play.


Joe Maddon is almost certainly going to win the AL Manager of the Year award, and it is well deserved, as the Rays outperformed their Pythagorean record by 5 games en route to their unexpected division title. The Rays led baseball with 142 steals, which has caused some to assume that Maddon is a small-ball guy. But make no mistake: he’s a Moneyball guy at heart, merely one who knows how to take advantage of his team’s strengths. Expect a fair dose of creativity too. In the August 24 game that Christina and I witnessed, Maddon brought B.J. Upton all the way in from center field on the final at-bat, giving the Rays five infielders. Of course, it didn’t work-Alexei Ramirez lackadaisically hit a bloop single to right field with nobody within 20 yards of the ball-but Maddon is no slave to orthodoxy.

Ozzie Guillen does not over-manage, as you might have been tempted to infer from his playing career, and is particularly adept (with an assist from Don Cooper) at managing his pitching staff. The price is that he can be stubborn, and can stick with his guys a little too long; hence, the decision to play Dewayne Wise rather than Nick Swisher. But the Sox have a 13-1 record between their 2005 post-season run and their two de facto playoff games on Monday and Tuesday, and at some point you have to give him the benefit of the doubt.


With the White Sox missing Quentin and Crede, the Rays are simply the better baseball club. Their principal vulnerability is their comparative weakness against left-handed pitching, but they hedge against that well by having Scott Kazmir lined up to duel Mark Buehrle. I expect the Sox to make a series of it-especially if they can steal Game One, which would seem to present the most favorable matchup for the Rays on paper (home game against a righty). But the percentage play is Rays in five.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
The name is Clayton Richard, not Chris Richard.
I would disagree that Kazmir is the best pitcher \"by some margin\" on either roster. I\'d likely take Shields over him. He has better control, induces more ground balls (although this year Kaz had an inordinate amount of fly balls that I wouldn\'t expect to continue), and seems to be far more durable.

At the very least, it\'s close. I just don\'t see Kaz as unequivocally better.
I would argue that Andy Sonnastine is the best pitcher on either club, with Shields a close second. Sonnastine\'s had some bad luck this year with fielding outcomes, but his raw batted ball inputs (flyballs, groundballs, linedrives, popups) have been superior to the other pitchers.
Wait - check that. I was assuming no one on the Sox was good enough to be in the discussion. I was wrong.

Vasquez is better than any Rays pitcher by this measure. So is Danks.

Silly me - I just put Vasquez on my IBA Cy Young ballot - I should have remembered.
I realize his peripherals are great, but the man gave up a ton of runs this year. How does he deserve a Cy Young vote?
\"Griffey Jr. has yet to re-adjust to American League pitching\" Seriously? He had a .787 OPS in Cincy and now has a .752 OPS in Chicago. That\'s not a failure to re-adjust, that\'s just a failure to hit.
Javier Vazquez gave a disappointing performance today but Clayton Richard did not. If this series goes five games, I expect the Sox to start Buerhle in game 2, Danks in game 3, Floyd in game 4 and then Buerhle again in game 5 (on four days rest, due to the travel days). My question is this -- given the Rays\' difficulties with lefties and given Richard\'s performance today, will Richard have a higher profile than we might have expected for the remainder of this series? If Buerhle and Danks pitch well during the next two days, I can see the Sox having Richard ready to back up Floyd in game 4 and hopefully that won\'t happen until the 6th or 7th inning.

One more question -- any report on the status of Carlos Pena and his availability during the remainder of tghis series?