A lot of my mail today has been asking about or offering opinions on the
status of next Monday’s schedule Oakalnd/Tampa Bay game. People want to
know whether the A’s will have to play the game if they and the Mariners
have already clinched playoff spots, even if the game would decide the AL
West title.

To be honest, I don’t know right now, although a few BP staffers are
looking into it. What I can tell you is that making the A’s fly 3,000 miles
to play what amounts to a seeding game would be a hardship on them, and
that no gain–from wild-card to division champ–would be worth the trip.

More stathead, never-played-the-game nonsense? Nope. We have a great
example of how real teams would act in a situation in which a division
title–but not a postseason slot–was on the line.

On September 29, 1996, the last day of the 1996 season, the Padres and
Dodgers were in a flat-footed tie for first place and scheduled to play
each other at Dodger Stadium. The winner of that day’s game would be the
National League West champion, while the loser would be the NL wild card.
Both teams were guaranteed to play beyond that afternoon, but they were
still playing for a division title.

So what did they do?

The Padres passed on letting #2 starter Joey Hamilton start on three
days’ rest, instead using #4 starter Bob Tewksbury, who hadn’t
started since September 17. The Dodgers, on the other hand, started their
nominal ace, Ramon Martinez…and pulled him after one inning for
their #4 starter, Pedro Astacio.

The teams traded 42 outs without scoring. In a tie game in the eighth
inning, with a division title on the line, the Padres brought in Dario
, who had 26 innings of major-league experience at that point.
Keep in mind that the Padres had a deep bullpen in 1996; both Doug
and Tim Worrell had ERAs around 3.00 with good
peripherals, and Trevor Hoffman was devastating in the closer role.

Two innings later, the Dodgers removed the runner-up in that season’s MVP
voting, Mike Piazza, with the game still scoreless. With the game
still tied, the Dodgers inserted rookie middle reliever Chan Ho Park
in Piazza’s lineup spot.

Division title on the line, scoreless game, extra innings…two
tenth-pitcher-and-beyond arms in the game.

The Padres would go on to win the game and the division. 2-0. Both teams’
seasons would end less than a week later in the Division Series, with the
two combining for one win.

Should the Indians fall from the picture and both AL West teams clinch
playoff spots with the division crown in doubt, ignore all the talk about
how important a division title is and watch their actions. As the Padres
and Dodgers showed four years ago, a division title means nothing in the
wild-card era. It’s just another playoff slot.

Joe Sheehan can be reached at

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe