It’s fair to say that Pedro Martinez has locked up the American
League Cy Young Award. I’d like to think of it as a small feather in our
cap: at midseason, our informal poll gave all ten votes to Mr. Martinez,
while many other polls gave some votes, even the award at that point, to
David Wells.

In the National League, though, an interesting contest has seemed to
develop, as the overwhelming midseason favorite, Randy Johnson, has
fallen from grace while a few other pitchers have performed very well.

Now, after last night’s Diamondbacks/Braves game, you’re going to hear and
read a lot about how Tom Glavine is right there with Johnson, even
possibly ahead of him, in the NL Cy Young race. Just for fun, here are the
two pitchers’ lines, along with those of two other top NL starting pitchers.:

                 ERA      IP   SNPct.  SNWAR   VORP  OOPS
Randy Johnson   2.45   216.2   .740     7.32   74.9   614
Tom Glavine     3.61   207.0   .594     3.66   43.7   669
Pitcher X       3.35   212.1   .622     4.50   55.1   656
Pitcher Y       2.62   196.0   .697     5.91   64.1   595

The "SNs" you see above are Michael Wolverton’s
figures. VORP is Keith Woolner’s Value Over Replacement, available at
Keith’s site, and included as an additional data point. It
does not include last night’s starts for Johnson and Glavine.

Johnson, to this point, is still so much better than any of the competition
it’s not even funny. Glavine, in fact, isn’t the best Cy Young candidate on
his own team: Greg Maddux, played by Pitcher X, has thrown a few
more innings with a better ERA. That performance is reflected in the
additional value he’s added, as measured by SN stats and VORP.

And Maddux isn’t even the top challenger to Johnson. Kevin Brown has
been the second-best pitcher in the league this year by far, even after
accounting for Dodger Stadium. If anyone deserves to be mentioned as a Cy
candidate, it’s Brown.

Of course, the truth is that none of these guys are close to Johnson.
Glavine’s "19" under the W header is the reason there’s a debate,
and while Glavine has pitched well this season, he’s not the best pitcher
in the league, the second-best or even the fifth-best. If he steals the Cy
Young Award from Johnson, it’s a travesty of the highest order.

Joe Sheehan can be reached at

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe