When we looked back at the first-half performances, we led with the
American League, so we’ll start this segment with the National.
I’ll start with the easiest call: the Cardinals are going to win the NL
Central. Even if Mark McGwire‘s knee injury restricts his playing
time, there is no team in the division capable of challenging the Redbirds.
Only the Reds are even a contender, and their shaky pitching makes them
unlikely to improve in the second half. While I still think the Astros will
get out of the cellar, they’re not going to make up 21 games. The Pirates,
Brewers and Cubs aren’t a part of the discussion any more than they were in
The interesting thing about the Cardinals is how good a team they could be
in October. As we’ve seen in the past few postseasons, a team can win a
series on the strength of just a couple of effective relievers, and the
Cardinals’ Matt Morris and Alan Benes give St. Louis exactly
that. Morris, in particular, could become a Mariano Rivera circa
1996 or Derek Lowe circa 1999 for this team, a thought that should
scare their postseason opponents.
Moving west, we stumble upon what looks like a four-team race, with the
contenders separated by less than seven games. Of this group, the Dodgers
have the most talent overall; that doesn’t make them the favorite, though,
as they start the second half 6 1/2 games behind the Diamondbacks.
Really, none of these teams looks that impressive. For all the positive
press they’ve received, the Rockies lack power and aren’t all that good
offensively–they rank next-to-last in the majors in EqA. While their bad
players have a different shape, as Dante Bichette and Vinny
Castilla have given way to Tom Goodwin and Darren Bragg,
they’re still bad. Yes, the defense is better, and that has helped
the pitching staff, but a .239 EqA isn’t going to win anything.
The Giants are the division’s darlings right now thanks to a hot streak
before the break, and they have the division’s best bench and best lineup.
What they don’t have is a pitching staff that’s going to make it through
the season unscathed. Kirk Rueter is an innings sponge coming off
his best half in years, and you’ve heard enough of our bleatings about
Dusty Baker’s treatment of Livan Hernandez and Shawn Estes.
There’s no reason to expect this rotation to be as effective as its been.
GM Brian Sabean is the X factor. The Giants need at least one more pitcher
to stay in the race, probably two, and Sabean has shown a willingness to
trade the Giants’ future to win in the present. While there aren’t any
solutions for the rotation on the market, Sabean could add some relief help
if he wants to trade someone like Kurt Ainsworth. If the Giants can
upgrade the pitching, they can win the NL West in 2000.
Realistically, though, this race is between the Diamondbacks and Dodgers,
with the D’backs having a 6 1/2-game lead. Arizona is in first place
despite suffering a number of injuries to power hitters Matt Williams
and Erubiel Durazo, and the collapse of the starting rotation behind
Randy Johnson and Brian Anderson. Their great bullpen and a
two-man offense of Luis Gonzalez and Steve Finley have
Even after some ill-advised trades the past year or so, the Diamondbacks
have some talent in the minor leagues, and they have an owner with a desire
to win now and the resources to back that desire. The D’backs will add at
least a hitter between now and the break, and may also pick up a starting
pitcher. It’s who they shore up the lineup and the rotation with that will
determine if they can hold off the Dodgers.
It’s not like the Dodgers have a great team. They are terrible up the
middle, save Todd Hundley, and have a weak bench after Dave
Hansen. They have the deepest rotation of the contenders, though, and
you might be surprised to know they have the second-best offense in the
league, behind the Giants. They also have a major chip, starter Eric
Gagne, that they can burn to add a top-of-the-lineup shortstop or
center fielder, the key missing piece.
I think the Dodgers will ride their offense past the three teams in front
of them and win the West.
Finally, the NL East shows signs of being a race, but does anyone really
expect the Mets to catch the Braves? They’ve gotten some good pitching from
an old staff and may have the league MVP in Mike Piazza and another
candidate in Edgardo Alfonzo. While I pan their offense, the fact is
they’re fourth in the league in EqA and of their current starters, only
Jay Payton is hitting at a below-average level for his position.
And yet… Al Leiter and Rick Reed are old, and Reed always
seems to be fighting some minor aches and pains. The fifth starter spot has
been a hole all season, and last year’s good bullpen has given way to a
much more flammable one this season. As with the Giants, picking up a good
pitcher or two would make a significant difference in the Mets’ chances,
and in fact, I think they’re in the best position to win the wild card.
But they’re not going to catch the Braves.
Aside from the races, there are some other interesting things that will be
The Expos and Marlins have been great stories, but the teams have both been
lucky, especially the Expos, and neither has the wherewithal to add payroll
to make a wild-card charge. And bully for them: the Expos are a leadoff
hitter from being a 90-win team, and the Marlins aren’t far behind them;
neither should spend one whit of their future to chase something this season.
(Side note. As I write this, I’m watching the Angels/Dodgers game. As many
times as I’ve seen the desperation "five infielder" alignment,
I’ve never actually seen it work. It just did in the tenth inning, as
Darin Erstad, in roughly the shortstop position, snagged a grounder
by Kevin Elster, held the runner at third base and threw Elster out.
No small feat, considering Erstad throws left-handed.)
The Astros will have to make some decisions: do they dump the villains of 2000’s
crime story, or chalk it up to a bad year and bring everyone back in 2001?
Jose Lima, Moises Alou and Ken Caminiti are all in the
spotlight. Assuming they remain together, for the most part, I think
Houston will be one of the league’s better teams in the second half, moving
up a few spots in the Central, getting to 75 wins or so and setting a nice
base for a return next year.
The Phillies are really coming together. With Bobby Abreu, Scott
Rolen and Pat Burrell, the core of a championship lineup is
there. Bruce Chen and Randy Wolf are the beginnings of a
top-notch rotation, if someone can get Terry Francona away from Dallas
Green. They should have an impressive second half. The NL East, in fact,
has five teams that could win the NL West next season.
Joe Sheehan can be reached at email@example.com.
Thank you for reading
This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.Subscribe now