For all the conventional media focus on the so-called "major
markets," we’ve always tried to have a balance of coverage here at
Baseball Prospectus. But sometimes the biggest baseball stories do
occur in the largest cities, and for the past few days, no city has
made more baseball news than the Big Apple.

On Thursday, the Yankees made the first major trade of the season,
acquiring outfielder David Justice from the Indians for left fielder
Ricky Ledee and two minor-leaguers to be named later. Justice is a
minor upgrade on Ledee as a left fielder, not as good on defense and
unlikely to maintain his .262/.357/.575 pace, especially the power. Over
the course of the second half, a reasonable estimate is that he could be
one win better than Ledee, and I’m not convinced that there will even be
that much difference between them.

The immediate reaction from all quarters was that this ended the Yankees’
pursuit of Sammy Sosa. Now, I don’t pretend to know what Brian
Cashman is doing at any moment in time–although I’m willing to bet Tums
are involved–but I don’t see why this trade precludes a Sosa deal.

First of all, with the exception of Ledee, all the players the Yankees were
offering the Cubs are still on the table. The two minor leaguers will not
be top-tier; the Indians have already gotten the best player they’ll get in
this deal. They’ve lopped Justice’s two-plus years and $18 million off the
payroll, which is their big gain.

Secondly, the Yankees still need another hitter. As long as Shane
is the everyday DH, the team will be underpowered against
right-handed pitchers. And as pointed out above, Justice isn’t going to
magically add a run a game to the Yankee offense.

It’s hard to tell what the relationship between Sosa and the Cubs is at
this point. As I pointed out earlier this week, the team doesn’t have to
trade Sosa right now, and might be best served to wait until the winter in
an effort to get more teams involved. It is possible, however, that having
gone this far with it the Cubs may feel it necessary to send Sosa
elsewhere. If that’s the case, the Yankees are still the most likely

Of course, as everyone in New York knows without a doubt, the real
reason the Justice trade happened was to undercut the coverage of the
Mets/Braves series that began at Shea on Thursday. There was some ruckus
that day involving a Braves reliever, but he pitched well and nothing
happened, so it couldn’t have been a big deal.

But Friday night…Friday night was a reminder of why you never, ever, ever
leave a baseball game early. Carrying an 8-1 lead into the bottom of the
eighth, the Braves watched in horror as Don Wengert helped the Mets
get to 8-3, then as Kerry Ligtenberg threw balls four, eight and 12
to move the Mets to 8-5.

With John Rocker and Mike Remlinger unavailable due to minor
injuries, the Braves were forced to bring in Terry Mulholland with
the bases loaded and Derek Bell, Edgardo Alfonzo and Mike
due up.

Now, conceding that Ligtenberg had walked all three batters he’d faced,
this was an odd decision by Braves manager Bobby Cox. Ligtenberg wasn’t
Mark Wohlers wild; he was just missing with his fastball on pitches
that, with a different umpire, could and would have been called strikes.
Swapping Ligtenberg for Mulholland, against whom the league is hitting well
over .300 and against whom the average right-handed batter hits about like
Javy Lopez, just in time to face three fair-to-excellent
right-handed hitters, is questionable at best.

It didn’t work, either. Bell walked, Alfonzo singled and Piazza hit a line
drive that would have landed in Lot 1A at LaGuardia had it not been stopped
by the second deck in left field, capping the 10-run eighth.

You can call this hindsight and I won’t argue. Cox was put in an
unfortunate situation last night by some bad timing and bad breaks, and if
he didn’t make the perfect decision, it wasn’t as if he had a lot of good
options. The sequence illustrated just how much the Braves miss Rudy
and Luis Rivera, particularly now that the early-season
reliance on Remlinger has caught up to the left-hander.

The solution may be to give more high-leverage innings to Bruce Chen
while trying to acquire a right-hander for the seventh and eighth innings
who can handle pitching on back-to-back days. The Braves don’t need an
expensive "closer" as much as they may need a Terry Adams
or a Doug Brocail, someone who they’re not trying to rehab or
develop at the same time they’re trying to win games.

Joe Sheehan can be reached at

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe