There has been a push over the past decade or so to get former baseball
greats into upper management in the game, especially in high-profile
positions. Some of these appointments have worked well: Hank Aaron in
Atlanta has done a fine job as a visionary and public relations lightning
rod for one of the more controversial franchises in the game. Mix Ted
Turner with John Rocker, an obnoxious (and stolen) chant and an offensive
logo, and there’s a lot to keep ironed out every day. I could say glowing
things about the efforts Willie Mays has made in San Francisco, George
Brett in Kansas City, and on and on.

Maybe someday I’ll be able to say the same things about Frank Robinson and
how he’s helped the game. So far, I can’t. His visibility has been limited
to two "you-hit-me, I-hit-you" incidents, and he’s badly mangled
the aftermath of both.

Exhibit A

Comiskey Park, April 22, Tigers at White Sox. The Tigers’ Jeff
, he of the noted even temperament, was behind 5-1 and soon to be
picking a shampoo for his post-outing shower when he hit the White Sox’s
Carlos Lee with a pitch. Lee’s sole offense was batting behind
Chris Singleton, who would end up 5-for-5 on the day. Weaver was
promptly yanked, but exchanged some choice words with Lee on his way to the

Since imitation really is the sincerest form of flattery, Jim Parque
introduced a baseball to Dean Palmer‘s back to start the top of the
seventh, and the rugby scrum was on. There were some notable cheap shots,
with five or six Tigers laying out Bill Simas and Bobby
taking a flying sucker punch at Keith Foulke. That
shot resulted in a remarkably hockey-like scar for Foulke. Tigers’ coach
Juan Samuel was out there too, but, just as in the last year of his career,
couldn’t hit anything to save his life. Weaver, for his part, didn’t just
leave the dugout to join the fight: he left the clubhouse.

The scene repeated itself later in the game after the Sox hit two more
Tigers, including, for those paying attention, the guy that replaced Palmer
after the first fight. Despite the cheering from the Robert Fick fan
club out by the bullpen, Round 2 was relatively sane.

So, how did the suspensions work out after this fracas? Here’s the
scorecard (number of games in parentheses):

Detroit: Samuel (15), manager Phil Garner (8), Palmer (8), Higginson (5),
Fick (5), Doug Brocail (4), Juan Encarnacion (4), Luis
(3) and Karim Garcia (3, if he ever makes it back to the
majors to serve them).

Chicago: Jerry Manuel (8), Magglio Ordonez (5), Parque (3), Foulke
(3), Bobby Howry (3), Lee (3) and Tanyon Sturtze (3).

Pay particular attention to the suspensions the pitchers received.

Exhibit B

Jacobs Field, April 30, Red Sox at Indians. Einar Diaz spends his
first two at-bats diving into Pedro Martinez pitches and is rewarded
with a clean double and another double off Nomar Garciaparra‘s
glove. In the time-honored tradition of Don Drysdale and Bob Gibson,
Martinez sends a message to Diaz in his third at bat, subtly implying that
Diaz shouldn’t get used to fishing for off-speed pitches on the outside
corner. Apparently, that message was misinterpreted, as Charles Nagy
hit Jose Offerman, after which Martinez hit Roberto Alomar
the next inning. No fights occurred, no blood was shed, no stitches were
needed. Thirty years ago, this would’ve been passed off as "major
league hardball" and nary a second thought given.

But this is 2000, the time of New Enlightenment. How many games was
Martinez suspended for? One more than sucker-puncher Doug Brocail, and two
more than any other pitcher involved in the not one, but two ugly brawls.
Indeed, the man who started the whole nasty business, Jeff Weaver, wasn’t
suspended at all, despite covering the approximately 26.2 miles from the
clubhouse to short right field to participate in the fruits of his labors.

Huh? Are we really sending the message that it’s better to precipitate a
half-hour love fest on the infield than to react professionally, using the
recourse the game has developed over the last century?

Some people need to be beaten senseless with a clue stick before they
figure out what it is they’re supposed to be doing. Here’s hoping Frank
Robinson is not one of those people.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe