Rk Team Proj. W-L Comment
1 Red Sox 99-63 Preparing their title defense on the assumption that
the Curse of the Minky won’t last 86 years.
2 Yankees 95-67 Snagged the Big Unit, but spent big dollars on
imperfect pitching solutions at the expense of shoring up glaring weakness in
CF. The best team $200 million can buy?
3 Cardinals 93-69 Starting pitching is functional, not flashy, but
this team has too many big bats for the rest of the league to get past.
4 Cubs 90-72 With Sosa now a bittersweet memory, health of Prior,
Wood and Zambrano is everything to this club, and everything is a bit shaky
right now.
5 Phillies 90-72 Should fare better under low-key manager Manuel than
Explodable Head Bowa, and with upgrades like groundball-friendly Lieber over
homer-happy Milton.
6 A’s 88-74 Despite fears for life after the Big Three,
organizational depth and front-office smarts feed plenty of optimism.
7 Twins 86-76 Santana and Radke could be league’s top 1-2 punch,
and full years of Morneau and (hopefully) Mauer should boost offense.
8 Dodgers 85-77 Penny, Perez, Lowe, Weaver, Erickson, Alvarez,
Jackson–spot the reliable, healthy starter and win a prize.
9 Indians 85-77 Up-and-comers could make the Twins sweat if they
stick to blueprint and let young talent mature; Juan Gone in RF and Grady
Sizemore in Buffalo calls their resolve into question.
10 Padres 84-78 Led by Cy candidate Peavy, these NL West vultures
could swoop in if Dodgers falter and Bonds sits.
11 Angels 83-79 Controversy over name change overshadows so-so
offseason. McPherson should provide much-needed injection of youth at
3B; similar boldness at 1B with Kotchman over Erstad would be a plus.
12 Braves 82-80 PECOTA begs to differ, but after 13 division titles
in a row, there’s little sense picking against them until they prove
13 Marlins 81-81 Full seasons from Beckett and Burnett could make for
an exciting Fish tale.
14 Mets 81-81 High-profile signings Pedro and Beltran offer
improvement, as will a full season of David Wright.
15 Giants 81-81 Barryless will be perilous; assume 10 runs (one
win) lost for every 14 games with Feliz and Tucker in LF.
16 White Sox 80-82 Speed’n’defense makeovers don’t pan out often, nor
does cornering the market on fragile Cuban refugee starters.
17 Rangers 79-83 Runs will be scored in Arlington, lots and lots of
runs–many of them by the Rangers, but not enough of them.
18 Astros 79-83 B’s not so killer without Beltran and (for April)
Berkman, but a healthy Pettitte to go with Clemens and Oswalt ought to help.
19 Orioles 78-84 Slammin’ Sammy Sosa joins bomb-prone offense;
pitching is already thin without Punchin’ Ponson’s antics–bar fights and
big butt to the contrary, Boomer Wells he ain’t.
20 Mariners 77-85 Big Beltre and Sexson signings will propel this team
upward, not far enough.
21 Reds 76-86 Dunn, Griffey, Kearns, Pena provide nice outfield
depth, but they need to push the fences deeper to help Milton and company
keep the ball in the park.
22 Tigers 76-86 Beware the Plexiglass Principle: big leap back to
respectability sure to be offset by returns to earth by Pudge, Guillen, Inge.
23 Diamondbacks 76-86 78 million for Ortiz and Glaus? We’re still
24 Brewers 74-88 Talent on the farm offers promise for the post-Selig
era, but they’ll take their lumps for a while yet.
25 Nationals 74-88 High profile signings of Guzman and Castilla will
surprise lots of people. Especially Jim Bowden, and not in a good way.
26 Rockies 73-89 Proof that a winning altitude is a necessary
ingredient in building a champion.
27 Blue Jays 73-89 Koskie signing emblematic of a regime in danger of
losing the plot.
28 Pirates 72-90 Beautiful ballpark. Rudderless team.
29 Royals 69-93 Lima Time may get the headlines, but Greinke Time is
the team’s best hope to avoid Royals Blew epitaph.
30 Devil Rays 68-94 Hordes of young talent means they’re no longer
hopeless; deploying that young talent correctly will make all the difference.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe