As teams close in on the 100-game mark, enough pitches have been thrown and
enough starts have been made that we can begin to draw significant
conclusions from the
Pitcher Abuse Points
data. But before we get to that, here’s a demonstration of how PAP differs
from looking at average pitch count totals:
1- 91- 101- 111- 121- 131- Name GS PAP PAP/S Pit Pit/S 90 100 110 120 130 140 141+ Garcia 18 269 14.9 1843 102.4 5 1 4 3 5 0 0 Daal 18 217 12.1 1948 108.2 0 3 10 3 2 0 0
Omar Daal has averaged more than 108 pitches per start, Freddy
Garcia barely 102. Daal ranks 11th among all starting pitchers in
average pitches per start, while Garcia ranks behind him: 42nd. Yet
despite the huge difference in their pitch counts, Garcia has the higher
A breakdown of the pitch counts explain this: while Daal has thrown more
than 90 pitches in every start, Garcia’s total is lowered by throwing fewer
than 90 pitches on five occasions. But to compensate for that, he has
thrown at least 120 pitches in a start five times, and that is where the
real damage is done. For two pitchers with a comparable number of total
pitches thrown, the one with greater variance in his outings will have a
higher PAP score. Buck Showalter has kept Daal’s workload very consistent
from start to start, while Lou Piniella–not surprisingly–has been erratic
Pitchers 30 and Older
Here’s the list of highest PAP scores, through the All-Star Break, for
pitchers 30 and over, along with where they ranked in our last update:
Name Team Age PAP GS PAP/S Rk 5/31 Randy Johnson Arizona 35 743 20 37.2 1 Curt Schilling Philadelphia 32 523 19 27.5 2 Scott Erickson Baltimore 31 359 19 18.9 NR Mike Mussina Baltimore 30 352 19 18.5 NR Al Leiter New York (NL) 33 338 17 19.9 3 Jamie Moyer Seattle 36 281 19 14.8 6 Tom Glavine Atlanta 33 271 19 14.3 9 Dave Burba Cleveland 32 262 18 14.6 8 Steve Sparks Anaheim 33 250 16 15.6 4 Mark Gardner San Francisco 37 248 15 16.5 NR Jeff Fassero Seattle 36 248 19 13.1 7
Dropping out of the top ten: David Cone (5th to 12th) and Kevin
Brown (10th to 16th).
There’s been little significant change since the end of May, with the
glaring exception of pitchers sporting an ornithologically-correct bird on
their caps. The Inner Harbor Zoo shows no signs of closing its doors, and
now Ray Miller is desperately putting even more strain on his best starters
to shoulder the load. We really don’t care that much about Scott
Erickson, but Mike Mussina has been put through this before, and
historically has not taken well to being overworked, going back to the days
when Johnny Oates was his manager.
The rest of the list is more or less the status quo, though it’s nice to
see David Cone dropping out of our rankings. As almost any baseball
fan will tell you, he’s pitched much better in the second half so far. Much
The 26-29 Group
Name Team Age PAP GS PAP/S Rk 5/31 Pedro Martinez Boston 27 547 18 30.4 1 Pedro Astacio Colorado 29 447 19 23.5 2 Wilson Alvarez Tampa Bay 29 371 16 23.2 4 Rick Helling Texas 28 342 19 18.0 6 Orlando Hernandez New York (AL) 29 305 18 16.9 NR Jason Schmidt Pittsburgh 26 301 18 16.7 NR Shawn Estes San Francisco 26 260 17 15.3 5 Brian Bohanon Colorado 29 244 18 13.6 3 Jose Lima Houston 26 238 19 12.5 9 Omar Daal Arizona 27 217 18 12.1 8
Dropping out of the rankings are Mike Sirotka (7th to 14th) and
Aaron Sele (10th to 13th).
We should keep our mouths shut and pay attention to the data. In
Baseball Prospectus 1999, we commented that despite his PAP score,
Kerry Wood didn’t appear to be in any imminent danger of serious arm
injury. And in our last PAP update, we reasoned that despite Pedro
Martinez‘s enormous PAP total, there was good reason to think that he
wasn’t in harm’s way. Now, despite the fact that his average PAP score
dropped from 38.7 to 30.4, he’s going to miss at least one start with a
"tired shoulder", after getting bombed by the Marlins, of all teams.
In fairness, this does appear to be just a tired shoulder, and he may be
back in a week or two without any lingering effects. Then again, the
urgency of a playoff chase trumps the concern for Pedro’s chance at 300
career wins in the minds of many Red Sox fans. This team has a small enough
margin of error as is; losing Pedro for any period of time would end their
The Red Sox have been patting themselves on the back for taking extra care
of Pedro’s arm by keeping him in a strict five-man rotation all year, even
when off days gave them the opportunity to move him up a day. Pedro made
only 18 starts before the break, and, were he to not miss a start, would
finish with only 33 starts for the season. But despite one fewer start, he
still racked up more PAPs than anyone in his age class, and it’s extremely
likely that letting him throw fewer pitches per start would do him a lot
more good than having him make fewer starts.
Remember, it’s not the number of pitches, it’s the pitches thrown beyond a
pitcher’s endurance level. There’s plenty of evidence that pitchers on
three days’ rest are no less fit than they are on four days’ rest. Their
stamina may be lessened, but that can be corrected by limiting their pitch
counts even further.
Imagine, if you will, a manager savvy enough to put his pitchers in a
four-man rotation, and wise enough to keep them on a strict 100-pitch
limit. The typical pitcher throws around 15 pitches per inning, so
conservatively that’s an average of six innings per start. Pedro Martinez
throwing 41 starts at six innings a pop comes out to 246 innings. By
comparison, to throw that many innings in just 33 starts, he would need to
average just less than 7 1/2 innings per start. He might throw less often,
but as we’ve seen this year, his pitch regularly soar well past 100. And
even with four and sometimes five days’ rest, his arm wasn’t able to last
the season without taking some additional time off.
The moral is this: to protect pitchers, don’t restrict how often they
pitch. Restrict how much they pitch.
The Young and the Rest-less
The ten hardest-working pitchers 25 and under:
Name Team Age PAP GS PAP/S Rk 5/31 Livan Hernandez Florida 24 596 18 33.1 1 Russ Ortiz San Francisco 25 549 18 30.5 2 Freddy Garcia Seattle 22 269 18 14.9 5 Jose Rosado Kansas City 24 265 18 14.7 10 Ismael Valdes Los Angeles 25 207 18 11.5 7 Bartolo Colon Cleveland 24 177 17 10.4 4 Chris Carpenter Toronto 24 164 14 11.7 3 Sidney Ponson Baltimore 22 156 17 9.2 NR Carlton Loewer Philadelphia 25 147 12 12.3 6 Jaret Wright Cleveland 23 147 18 8.2 NR
Dropping off the list: Kelvim Escobar (8th to 11th) and Odalis
Perez (9th to 12th).
You have to admire his persistence: Livan Hernandez is as tough to
get rid of as Joe Sheehan’s can of spray-on hair. His average PAP score has
actually increased since the end of May, from 30.1 to 33.1. Is there
something about the humidity in south Florida that makes managers think
they’re in a pennant race when they’re 20 games under .500?
Thank god that Hernandez has finally been traded away…straight into the
arms of Dusty Baker. In addition to managing Shawn Estes and Mark
Gardner above, Baker has actually increased Russ Ortiz‘s
workload from 25.3 PAPs to 30.5 PAPs per start. I can’t help but pity
Hernandez; he’s like a child abandoned by an abusive father, only to have a
new stepdad come in and hit him some more. Now, finally taken away by
Social Services and adopted by a well-to-do, respectable family, he’s about
to find out that abuse happens on both sides of the tracks.
Baker’s Giants lead all of baseball in PAP, with or without adjusting for
age. You think Baker won’t have some explaining to do if the Giants fold in
September? Of course he won’t–everyone will just pin the blame on Barry
The rising star here is Jose Rosado, who has finally been done in by
what just might be the worst bullpen of all time. An ancillary benefit to a
deep bullpen is that it makes it much easier for the manager to pull his
starters after six or seven innings, even when they’re pitching well. With
options like Marc Pisciotta and a really bad Jeff Montgomery
imposter out behind the bullpen gate, it’s hardly surprising that Tony
Muser has stepped up the pitch counts of his best starter.
Hardly surprising, but hardly forgivable, either. The Royals aren’t winning
anything this year, and it would be a crying shame if their playoff hopes
in 2000 take a hit because Rosado loses his effectiveness much the same way
he did the last time he was overworked. As it is, he’s thrown between 120
and 125 pitches in five of his last six starts, with the outlier being a
game delayed by rain after he had thrown 83 pitches. Like Pedro Martinez,
he got bombed in his first start after the break.
The Freddy Garcia Train in Seattle shows no signs of being derailed
by common sense, and Sidney Ponson joins the list along with his
Bird brethren. Gee, there’s a good idea: take the only positive
development of a lost season and run it into the ground.
While Carlton Loewer is out indefinitely with a stress fracture in
his arm, his place in Phrancona’s Philly Phollies has been taken by
Randy Wolf, who in only six starts has picked up 104 PAPs. Speaking
of Wolf, let’s run our final list of the 12 highest age-adjusted workloads
(Min: 5 starts) in all of baseball. Keep in mind that this list ranks
pitchers by their workload per start, whereas the previous charts ranked
pitchers by their total workload.
Name Team Age PAP GS PAP/S AAW Rk 5/31 Livan Hernandez Florida 24 596 18 33.1 77.3 2 Russ Ortiz San Francisco 25 549 18 30.5 66.1 3 Pedro Martinez Boston 27 547 18 30.4 55.7 1 Randy Wolf Philadelphia 22 104 6 17.3 46.2 NR Freddy Garcia Seattle 22 269 18 14.9 39.9 8 Randy Johnson Arizona 35 743 20 37.2 37.2 4 Pedro Astacio Colorado 29 447 19 23.5 35.3 10 Wilson Alvarez Tampa Bay 29 371 16 23.2 34.8 6 Jose Rosado Kansas City 24 265 18 14.7 34.4 NR Jason Schmidt Pittsburgh 26 301 18 16.7 33.4 NR Shawn Estes San Francisco 26 260 17 15.3 30.6 5 Rick Helling Texas 28 342 19 18.0 30.0 NR
Lucky enough to have dropped out of the rankings: Chris Carpenter
(7th to 15th), Curt Schilling (9th to 14th), Bartolo Colon
(11th to 23rd) and Brian Bohanon (12th to 30th).
Midway through the season, with the Red Sox backing off on Martinez a
little, the path is clear for Livan Hernandez to do the unthinkable: repeat
as winner of the Most Abused Pitcher award. Best of luck to him, and a few
words of advice: get your agent talking to Brian Sabean about a long-term
contract now. And start paying attention to those commercials for worker’s
compensation lawyers. Remember, there’s no fee unless you collect.
Thank you for reading
This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.Subscribe now