"Tuesday? Oh, I Guess I’ll Go Fishing…"

60 players will divide 18 innings and, if recent history is any indication,
about six hits among them during Tuesday night’s All-Star Game in Boston.
With the brouhahas over players being snubbed or backing out already fading,
let’s take a look at a handful of guys who were, well, just outside the
periphery of All-Star discussions. Keeping in mind the
"one-player-per-team" rule, here are the worst players in the AL
East this year:

5) Jorge Posada, New York. Hey, I don’t understand it, either, and
the Yanks are puzzled enough to have sent Posada to have his eyes checked.
Posada has followed up his .825 OPS of 1998 with a terrible .203/.299/.358
performance so far in 1999. He has not progressed defensively and save for a
mild hot streak in mid-June, hasn’t shown any sign that this is just a

Posada’s disappointing play has been one of the keys to the Yankees’ return
to the pack in the AL East. With the bottom of the lineup not producing,
their offense has slid to the middle of the league. For the Yanks to score
enough runs to repeat, Posada will have to return to his 1998 form.

4) Trot Nixon, Boston. Like many poor players, Nixon is a great
story, having fought off back problems that threatened his career and
advanced to the majors. He has spent much of the year as the Sox’ right
fielder. The problem is, he’s not hitting. His good plate discipline has
been completely overshadowed by his lack of power: just 16 extra-base hits
and a .365 slugging average.

It’s probable that Nixon will keep his job, as he’s an organizational
favorite, and frankly, the Sox have no one better. Unless he can locate the
lost power, though, he’ll continue to be among the worst right fielders in
the league.

3) Scott Erickson, Baltimore. Erickson ranks ahead of Posada and
Nixon due in part to his cost: he’s in year one of a five-year, $32-million
contract extension. That’s a stiff price to pay for a 6.34 ERA and abysmal
peripherals, especially given Erickson’s penchant for blaming that
performance on everyone around him. His claim that his rough start was
caused by "too much rest" was a welcome bit of levity in the
dreary Oriole season.

2) Randy Winn, Tampa Bay. In a very close race, Winn is just barely
edged out by someone whose performance is even worse. Scary, given Winn’s
.261/.301/.343 effort, with a matched set of nine stolen bases and times
caught stealing. This isn’t a fluke: it’s about what you can expect from
him, and with Tampa Bay lacking other options in center field, he’ll be
playing every day. By the end of the year, he may well be the worst player
in the division.

Before we unveil that honor, we should toss out a few honorable mentions.
Any and all Yankee left fielders, take a bow. Hey, you Blue Jay DHs! All of
you! Stand up and be recognized. And if you’ve started on the mound for
Tampa Bay this year, well, now’s your chance to be acknowledged for your

But it’s another indoor starting pitcher who tops the list today. New to the
American League, he went on the disabled list after two starts with an ERA
of 19.29. And to his credit, he’s managed to cut that by more than half (!)
since coming back in late May. The league’s hitting about like Mike Sweeney
(.349/.408/.516) off him, and like Erickson, he recently signed an expensive
long-term deal. Ladies and gentlemen, the worst player in the AL East so far
in 1999…Joey Hamilton!!!

So when you’re watching that parade of 1-2-3 innings on Tuesday night, and
basking in the greatness of Ron Coomer, take a second to remember these
guys. On an empty stomach, please.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe