None of us ever thought that PECOTA's 72-win projection for the Royals would go quietly—it's just too rich to ignore when writing about Kansas City's two-game lead in the World Series. About a month ago, I performed a review on that projection for Fox Sports' JABO. It went like this:

There was something about the number 72 that seemed perfectly appropriate, an echo from Baseball Prospectus history. Our forecasting system PECOTA's most famous projection, if a projection can ever be really famous, came in 2007, when Nate Silver'€™s machine spit out a 72 for the Chicago White Sox. They were coming off a 90-win season, which had itself followed a World Series title. Oh, did people fume –€“ a Chicago Tribune response was so angry it earned a Fire Joe Morgan fisking, while Kenny Williams snarked that the projection was "€œa good sign for us because usually they're wrong about everything regarding our dealings."€ And then the White Sox won … 72 games.

So on the night before we released our PECOTA projections at Baseball Prospectus this winter, and I saw with terror that we had put a 72 on the Royals. PECOTA keeper Rob McQuown and I went over every detail of that projection to make sure it wasn'€™t a mistake, and I was also amused. Maybe we'€™d hit another 72?

Nah. The Royals passed 72 in mid-August and are on pace to win 95. Once again, a 72 has become one of our most famous projections — €”drawing, once again, snark from team execs, this time justified. What happened? Let's perform an autopsy.

There are three foundations to a projection system:

To read the rest of this article, click here.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
"While PECOTA aspires to be perfect..."

What actual changes have you guys made to the algorithm in this aspiration toward perfection? As far as I know, while the rest of the baseball world has made incredible advances over the past five years, PECOTA has stood still. So being wrong on a team is not as surprising as you appear to think it is.