The use of a four-man starting rotation was firmly established in the major
leagues by 1925. In the 1970s, teams started tinkering with five-man
rotations, and by about 1980 all clubs had switched over to it. Last year,
Mets’ manager Bobby Valentine implemented a six-man rotation in
late-July, which he used up until the last week of the season. Was this
some type of revolutionary forward thinking on Valentine’s part? As it
turns out, probably not. It was more of a change forced by circumstance.
Mother Nature had wreaked havoc with the Mets schedule the first six weeks
of the season, forcing eight postponements. The doubleheaders required to

1998 Overall Pitcher Use Patterns
Days rest -> 2 3 4 5 6+ Totals
Starts 2 2 50 68 40 162
QS 0 1 33 37 22 93
%QS .00 .50 .66 .54 .55 .57
BQS 0 0 5 7 0 12
%QS+BQS .00 .50 .76 .65 .55 .65
Avg # pitches 84 90 100 99 97 98

make up those games, combined with a surfeit of pitchers accustomed to
starting, is most likely what prompted the unorthodox maneuver, rather than
any burning desire to keep the pitching staff fresh for the stretch run.
Regardless of the cause, the result of all the rainouts and the six-man
rotation was that Mets’ starters made 108 starts on five or more days’
rest, 31 more than any other team looked at so far. Whether it was
Valentine’s genius or an example of a blind pig finding an acorn, the Mets’
staff posted a superb 65% Quality Starts + Blown Quality Starts (QS+BQS).
Another possible side effect of the extra rest was that none of the
starters suffered arm injuries, despite working into the late innings of
games. A close examination of the individual pitchers may reveal who
benefited the most from this unique work schedule:

Al Leiter escaped last year’s atrocities in Pro Player Stadium when
he was acquired by the Mets after the ’97 season. A regular visitor to
surgery tables around the country, Leiter flourished under the decreased
workload, with an incredible 25 QS+BQS in 28 starts, including a perfect
six-for-six QS when he had at least six days’ rest between starts. Despite
Leiter’s brilliant pitching, Valentine resisted temptation and never
shifted him up in the rotation, until going to the whip for the last two
weeks of the season. The extra off-days and a three-week respite in July
for a torn patella tendon (knee) helped Leiter endure the high pitch counts
that Valentine placed on his fragile left arm. Ironically, the four starts
Leiter missed because of his knee injury may have both cost him a shot at
the Cy Young Award and kept him in contention for it.

In 1998, Rick Reed established himself as the best #2 starter in the
Senior Circuit outside of the state of Georgia, posting an excellent 81%
QS+BQS. Likely due to his pinpoint control, which in turn reduces the
number of pitches thrown which preserves his good health, Reed was
occasionally tabbed to move up in the rotation for an injured or
ineffective teammate. Even though the effects of this additional work were
minimized because of the early season rainouts and the six-man rotation,
Reed faded in August and September, logging only four QS in his last nine

Although he was on the mound for the Mets on opening day, Bobby
performance was as average as his surname. He finished the
season with a 9-9 record and a Support Neutral Record of 10.6-10.6. Jones
pitched 195 innings for the third time in the last four years (the other
year he totaled 193). His %QS+BQS was essentially unaffected by the number
of days between outings. His longest streak of quality starts was three;
his longest streak without a quality start was three. Yawn… zzzz.

Thirty-three year-old Masato Yoshii left the Yakult Swallows and
joined the Mets for the 1998 season. A little background on the Japanese
Leagues is in order, because it sheds some light on Yoshii’s results. The
Japanese League season is only a week shorter than the Major League
campaign, but about 25 fewer games are played. Usually, a strict five-man
rotation is used, which means that a starter pitches about once a week.
Because of the rainouts and Valentines’ six-man rotation, the Mets’ season
was divided into three general usage patterns. The first pattern lasted
through the end of May, and most of the starts were made on five or six
days’ rest due to the rainouts. The second pattern lasted until late-July
and the majority of the starts in this period were on four days’ rest, as
cancelled games were being replayed. The six-man rotation began in
late-July and was used until the last week of the season, creating the
third usage pattern, where five or six days of rest again were the norm.
Since Valentine always kept Yoshii in his spot in the rotation (never
moving him up), Yoshii’s usage patterns mimicked the team’s. During the
first and third usage patterns, which are similar to what Yoshii was used
to in the Japanese Leagues, he pitched well, logging 15 QS+BQS in 20
starts. However, during that second usage pattern in June and July, he had
only two QS+BQS in nine trips to the mound. It appears that Valentine was
wise to drop Yoshii from the rotation when he changed to a four-man staff
the last week of the season.

The careers of Dave Mlicki and Hideo Nomo crossed paths,
presumably somewhere over Kansas, when they were traded for each other in
early June. After a promising 1997 season, Mlicki opened the year as the
fourth starter in the Mets’ rotation, whereupon he self-destructed with
only two QS in ten tries. His failure certainly wasn’t due to overwork:
Valentine never asked him to pitch on less than five days’ rest. When Nomo
arrived, he assumed Mlicki’s spot in the rotation. Unfortunately, he also
imitated Mlicki’s performance on the hill, with seven QS in 16 starts.
Valentine handled Nomo’s surgically repaired elbow with care by keeping his
pitch counts low, but he may have been better served by starting Nomo more
frequently, as he was 5 of 6 in quality starts on four days’ rest. With the
Mets in a three-way battle for the wild card, Valentine dropped Nomo from
the rotation in mid-September.

For Armando Reynoso and Brian Bohanon, Shea Stadium’s turf
was covered with four-leaf clovers in 1998. Both hurlers were free agents
following the season and parlayed a handful of good outings into
multi-year, big-money contracts with free-spending teams in the Mountain
time zone. After missing the first three and a half months of the year with
a strained elbow, Reynoso and his battered right arm emerged from the
disabled list and joined the club for his annual twelve-start cameo in
late-July. It was Reynoso’s improved health and impressive pitching (four
QS in his first five starts) that cemented Valentine’s switch to a six-man
rotation. Consistently working on at least five days’ rest, Reynoso kept
pitching fairly well until Valentine included him in the quartet selected
to work the last week of the season. In the four-man rotation, Reynoso got
lit up like Ted Kennedy on St. Patrick’s Day, including a 48-pitch disaster
on the last day of the season, which eliminated the Mets from the playoffs.
Bohanon did a commendable job as the emergency starter/long reliever before
he was dealt in mid-season to an even better pitcher’s park (Chavez Ravine)
in which to continue his trek to the pot of gold.

Even though he already had six starters, the Mets picked up Willie
from the D-Backs at the trading deadline. Valentine probably
should have immediately plugged Blair into Nomo’s slot in the rotation, but
instead he primarily used Blair in long relief until mid-September. Bill
was rewarded with what is known as a "courtesy start"
for being named International League Pitcher of the Week in early June, and
for working his way back from a myriad of arm injuries. At the trading
deadline, the Mets further rewarded him by shipping him to Milwaukee for a
lead-gloved third baseman and a case of PBR.

Bobby Valentine headed into the ’98 season with a capable group of
experienced starting pitchers. Because the Mets’ middle relievers were
erratic, Valentine often had the starters work deep into games, which led
to 12 BQS, including four for each of the staff workhorses, Leiter and
Reed. It also caused some high pitch counts (especially for Leiter), but
that didn’t prove to be a problem for a staff whose average age was 31. The
early season rainouts and Valentine’s unconventional six-man rotation
provided plenty of recuperation time between starts, and probably was at
least partially responsible for the fact that no starter suffered an arm
injury. While two-thirds of the team’s starts were on five or more days’
rest, the rotation was actually more successful on four days’ rest, with
76% QS+BQS. In fact, for the ten teams examined so far, the average starter
had 56% QS+BQS on four days rest and 52% QS+BQS with at least five days
rest. So, based on the success of the Mets’ 1998 rotation, are other teams
going to follow Valentine’s lead and institute a six-man rotation? Probably
not anytime soon. It’s difficult enough to assemble five decent starters,
and there is no clear evidence that there is a performance benefit from the
additional down time between starts.

A. Leiter          Days rest                  Reed               Days rest
                     4    5    6+   Totals                         4    5    6+   Totals
Starts              10   12     6       28    Starts              11   16     4       31
QS                   6    9     6       21    QS                   9    9     3       21
%QS                .60  .75  1.00      .75    %QS                .82  .56   .75      .68 
BQS                  3    1     0        4    BQS                  1    3     0        4
%QS+BQS             90  .83  1.00      .89    %QS+BQS            .91  .75   .75      .81
Avg # Pitches      116  110   121      114    Avg # pitches       97  100    96       99

B. Jones           Days rest                  Yoshii             Days rest
                3    4    5    6+   Totals                         4    5    6+   Totals 
Starts          1   10   11     8       30    Starts              10   11     8       29
QS              0    6    7     4       17    QS                   5    5     4       14
%QS           .00  .60  .64   .50      .57    %QS                .50  .45   .50      .48
BQS             0    1    0     0        1    BQS                  0    3     0        3
%QS+BQS       .00  .70  .64   .50      .60    %QS+BQS            .50  .73   .50      .59
Avg # pitches 101  103   99   101      101    Avg # pitches       89   91    86       89

Nomo               Days rest                  Reynoso            Days rest
                     4    5    6+   Totals                         4    5    6+   Totals 
Starts               6    6     4       16    Starts               1    5     5       11
QS                   5    2     0        7    QS                   0    4     3        7
%QS                .83  .33   .00      .44    %QS                .00  .80   .60      .64
BQS                  0    0     0        0    BQS                  0    0     0        0
%QS+BQS            .83  .33   .00      .44    %QS+BQS            .00  .80   .60      .64
Avg # pitches      102   86    81       91    Avg # pitches       48  110   102      100

Mlicki             Days rest                  Bohanon            Days rest
                          5    6+   Totals                         2    4    6+   Totals
Starts                    7     3       10    Starts               1    1     2        4 
QS                        1     1        2    QS                   0    1     1        2
%QS                     .14   .33      .20    %QS                .00 1.00   .50      .50
BQS                       0     0        0    BQS                  0    0     0        0
%QS+BQS                 .14   .33      .20    %QS+BQS            .00 1.00   .50      .50
Avg # pitches            97    93       96    Avg # pitches       85   81    76       80

Blair              Days rest                  Pulsipher          Days rest
                          3     4   Totals                                    2   Totals 
Starts                    1     1        2    Starts                          1        1
QS                        1     1        2    QS                              0        0
%QS                    1.00  1.00     1.00    %QS                           .00      .00
BQS                       0     0        0    BQS                             0        0
%QS+BQS                1.00  1.00     1.00    %QS+BQS                       .00      .00
Avg # pitches            78    92       85    Avg # pitches                  83       83

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe