Everything was going San Francisco's way as the teams prepared to begin Game Three of the NLDS between the Nationals and Giants. The orange-and-black had defeated the two-headed monster of Strasburg and Zimmermann on hostile ground, and were sending their top starter to the hill in front of the home crowd with hopes of a series sweep for the underdog Giants. The Nats, on the other hand, were in survival mode, just hoping to force another game of baseball as they faced elimination.

For six innings, Madison Bumgarner and Doug Fister traded zeroes. Bummer was a bit more dominant, running the fastball up to 95 mph as he continued to pump playoff adrenaline. His average velocity has been higher over the past two starts than at any point of the regular season, and he came out firing 95 mph bullets in the first inning of Game Three. Bumgarner punched out six Nationals and didn't walk a batter for the first six frames, carrying a pitch count of just 70 as the seventh inning got started. To top it off, both pitchers had to deal with a roving strike zone, as home plate umpire Tom Hallion was defying the tracking systems and getting dirty looks from the mound due to his unpredictable calls.

Fister was not quite as economical, with a higher pitch count to go with three strikeouts and a trio of walks (one of which was taken by Bumgarner), but Fister's particular brand of weak-contact induction had been equally effective for the first two-thirds of the game. He got some help in the bottom of the fourth when Brandon Belt took off on a hit-and-run attempt, only to be thrown out easily by catcher Wilson Ramos when the hitter left the bat on his shoulder. Fister is extremely quick to the plate, and only one base runner had even attempted a steal against him this season, so Belt was essentially a dead duck when Crawford failed to execute his portion of the hit-and-run.

In the top of the seventh inning, the Nats got something going. Ian Desmond led off the frame with a single to right, and Bumgarner followed by issuing his only walk of the game, putting Bryce Harper aboard for the two on, no out situation. It was the best opportunity that Washington had garnered all game, but as the slow-footed Ramos strode to the plate, the biggest thought on everyone's mind was the possibility of a double play.

Ramos squared on the first pitch but pulled back, only to watch strike one. He squared again and took a ball, and then pulled the same trick as he watched strike two. The Nats catcher appeared indecisive, which makes sense for a player that had not successfully laid down a sacrifice in more than three years, but he was undeterred. Ramos squared again with the threat of a two-strike foul looming, and though bunting might be the most mundane of baseball plays, this particular bunt would spark bedlam:

The Nats didn't just avoid the double play with a productive out, they plated two runners and had another in scoring position with no outs, all thanks to Bumgarner's attempt to nail the lead runner at third base. The damage included a 2-0 deficit and a wounded third baseman, as Pablo Sandoval was crumpled on the ground after the play (though he would stay in the game and make a tremendous diving catch moments later). Asdrubal Cabrera's RBI single the next at bat made it 3-0, and though his hit would have plated both runners in a scenario where Ramos merely had a successful sacrifice, the mental anguish associated with the Giants' self-inflicted wound was palpable.

Bryce Harper hit a monster homer in the top of the ninth, his second blast of the series, which gave the Nats a cushion when San Francisco plated one in the bottom half, but the turning point in this ballgame was surely the bunt gone wrong. The sac bunt has been a focal point this postseason, thanks in part to the success of the Royals and their bunt-o-holic manager Ned Yost, and the Ramos play temporarily put the sac at center stage. For the team with the best record in the National League, whose season was founded on excellent pitching and a deep lineup, it's poetic justice that their survival was made possible through a small-ball tactic (with questionable utility) that was executed by the least likely player in the lineup.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
As a Nationals fan that has been suffering this series (and watched all 18 innings of the Saturday game) it was great to see them catch a break. I'm a little baffled why Bumgarner threw to third instead of going for the guaranteed out, but I can't argue with the outcome (though I hope Sandoval is okay since he stretched in ways that people weren't meant to stretch to try and field that).
This reflects how I felt about the game; to take it a step further, the plate umpiring in this series has been simply awful. I was at Games 1 and 2, and both HP umps were wildly inconsistent. Both teams were complaining frequently, capped by Cabrera's justified explosion in the 10th inning. The pitch he was called out on was on the absolute outside corner but his frustration was generated by the previous call, which was higher, and outsider. (Those two calls took him from 3-1 to out...of the game...)

Of course, they shouldn't have been playing at that point, since in the 9th with two out, Zimmermann had thrown 4 strikes to Joe Panik, who was mysteriously awarded first base as a result. I think Williams took Zimmermann out because the umpire was in his head, and Matt didn't want his starter to feel compelled to lay a pitch in the center of the zone just to see if any strikes were available; that would enable Posey to get something to drive. I suppose that was Storen's destiny.

And I thought Laz Diaz was bad in Game 1.

So the Nats should be resting for Game 1 of the NLCS, but will have to do it the hard way. By the way, I take nothing from the Giants pitching, which has been outstanding, and put equal or more blame on the Nationals' free-swinging ways. At least they haven't been passive. But they made Yusmeiro Petit look like Walter Johnson.

According to the pitch tracker, the Panik walk was legit, though some of those pitches had been called strikes earlier. I think part of the reason that Williams pulled Zimmermann was that the one pitch everybody agrees was a strike, Panik clobbered foul down the right field line. When a slap hitting infielder pulls a ball with authority, it plants the seeds in a manager's mind that his pitcher is done, even if the hitter just happen to get lucky.