keyboard_arrow_uptop
Baseball Prospectus Needs Your Help! Check out our call for contributors!

While looking toward the future with our comprehensive slate of current content, we'd also like to recognize our rich past by drawing upon our extensive (and mostly free) online archive of work dating back to 1997. In an effort to highlight the best of what's gone before, we'll be bringing you a weekly blast from BP's past, introducing or re-introducing you to some of the most informative and entertaining authors who have passed through our virtual halls. If you have fond recollections of a BP piece that you'd like to nominate for re-exposure to a wider audience, send us your suggestion.

In separate pieces in 2000 and 2004, Derek Zumsteg wrote the following features on the difficulty of rooting for players we might despise. In the first piece, he writes about the Mariners signing an accused wife beater. In the second, he revisits that move after the Mariners signed another player with a violent past. Both pieces, and the conclusions he ultimately draws, are still relevant in the wake of this week's NFL news.

A Fan's Quandary, 8/2/2000

Can you love a team and hate the players?

I've long maintained that following your local club is like being overly interested in the Kinko's on the corner, knowing too much about the height, weight and varying abilities of the different clerks. The Kinko's corporation doesn't really care about you in return, and neither, really, does your baseball club.

Despite living in Seattle for 20-some years, I gave up on the Mariners during the dark Woody Woodward years and started following the Astros, other clubs and a lot of minor-league ball. I got interested again when Safeco Field opened, and now I have to face the question of whether I want to support a business that's just traded for Al Martin.

Al Martin, for the record, now denies all charges against him, but for those of you who have been living in a magical world of nuts and berries where there's no TV, no radio, no newspapers and no Internet hook-ups, here's a brief rundown:

  • 1991: Martin marries his first wife, who becomes Cathy Martin.

  • 1998: Martin marries his second wife, Shawn Haggerty, who becomes Shawn Haggerty-Martin.

  • 2000: Martin and Haggerty-Martin are arrested for beating on each other in a fight that started when Shawn got frustrated that Al wouldn't divorce his first wife.

Al Martin, as far as we know, has not yet divorced either wife. He may yet be prosecuted for bigamy in Las Vegas, and he has not yet been to court for his two misdemeanor charges of "assault-physical injury and threatening or intimidating."

It doesn't matter if Haggerty-Martin punched Martin first or not. Al Martin is six-foot-four and listed at 214 pounds. Even if she did punch him, Al didn't leave or call the cops–he beat her up until she called 911. I don't know what Haggerty-Martin's vital stats are, but judging solely by the pictures, she's not anywhere near six-foot-four and 214 pounds. Martin is a great, strong man.

He could have killed her.

I like going to Safeco Field. It's a great park and a great time. I enjoy spending time with my friends watching Mark McLemore get thrown out stealing second base. I like a lot of the Mariners; Alex Rodriguez is a joy to watch and a cool guy to boot; Edgar Martinez is a hitting wonder; I think the world of Jay Buhner as a person…and so on. And while I wouldn't hire Al Martin to sweep my driveway, and I understand that the Mariners are in this to win, not protect women, I find it laughable and offensive that the Mariners sponsor a campaign against domestic violence–they gave out "Refuse to abuse" T-shirts at a game recently–and then acquire an accused wife-beater and bigamist.

This is like Exxon asking me to keep my motor oil out of the groundwater system in 1989. And just as I've yet to buy a drop of gas from an Exxon station, it is my great hope now that I will be able to be even stronger and refuse the Mariners my support.

A New Low, 6/15/2004

I don't get along with my team. We've disagreed over how the team's been run, from who's been put in the lineup to who's being drafting. Since the ownership group bought the team to save it from possibly moving, they've seemed eager to support Bud Selig and MLB in whatever crazy scheme they come up with. I would bet there are many baseball fans with similarly strained relationships with the teams they support.

The Mariners have made it clear in the past that they're interested in acquiring only character guys who are good in the clubhouse, even at the expense of the on-field product. Someone ran some numbers and said "Lovable sells." So the clubhouse troublemakers, the lawyers and the quiet smart guys are all purged once the team takes a dislike to them.

The problem is that the M's are willing to do almost anything to get rid of players that fans perceive as having negative qualities or being a problem, while at the same time they're willing to pick up good clubhouse guys with baggage if they think they can get away with it. The Mariners will pick up a guy like Al Martin, who got into a nasty tussle with his backup wife in Arizona, resulting in a lot of counseling and a pinch of jail time. Martin, for his potential legal and character issues, was and remains known for having a great work ethic, an easy guy to get along with on a team, and a good clubhouse presence. The Mariners brought in a bigamist who'd bust up a much smaller secondary wife while running their "Refuse to Abuse" campaign against domestic violence…because they wanted a left-handed bat.

They won't, however, so much as ask about an angry guy like Milton Bradley, gifted with 20 times the talent of Martin but a handful to manage, his burning competitive drive paired with an equally volatile temper. Not a good clubhouse guy, you see. His anger's directed outside the home and sometimes demonstrated on the field for everyone to see.

It's easy for me to write all that, though, to criticize the Mariners for lying about why beer prices are so high or pretending they have an organist, or passing employees off as fans on those between-inning "Ask the Mariners" segments. I don't have to run their business after all, and maybe if I was in charge I might see that the line item "Honesty" has a cost of $30 million and decide to cut it.

I think that I might do the same thing, because as fans we make the same kind of moral distinction when watching games about what we view as fair play and what we don't. I cheered Mike Cameron in Seattle for years when he'd break up double plays by taking out whoever was unlucky enough to get the transfer at second. But like much of what we accept as the grittier side of the game–blocking the plate to prevent a run, targeting batters instead of the strike zone–these are plays where people get hurt. We applaud actions that have a good chance of injuring players on the receiving end.

In 1999 I saw then-Athletic Tony Phillips get into a rundown and then seemingly intentionally scissor Carlos Guillen's knees as Phillips fell to the ground. It shredded Guillen's ACL and took him out for the season. I thought Phillips meant it, and I was appalled, but I think many people who saw the play didn't see it that way. My point, though, is if that happened intentionally, where we could be sure, there's not a fan who wouldn't condemn Phillips for doing it.

We're drawing an arbitrary moral line at "deliberate crippling," but crippling as part of trying to prevent an out is OK. We accept that through hard slides into second someone's knee may get torn up, and we applaud the act. Eventually we'll applaud, only to later learn that a player's career was ended as a result.

Which brings me to this Mariners transaction, which has stuck in my head for two weeks now:

05/26/04
Signed RHP Ben Christensen to a minor league contract and assigned him to Double-A San Antonio.

Yes, that Ben Christensen.

Who, as you probably know already, felt that an opposing batter in the on-deck circle, Anthony Molina, was timing his pitches. Christensen then beaned Molina with a pitch. Molina, who wasn't looking (which is odd, if he was timing pitches and all). Molina never fully recovered–the last time anyone bothered to talk to him (when Christensen settled Molina's lawsuit) Molina was still suffering vision problems. The odds were long that Molina would make the majors, as they are for any college player, but we'll never know, because Christensen ended that speculation. Molina, when he could play, was never the same player he was in college.

After years in the Cubs system being injured and ineffective between injuries, the Cubs released him and the Mariners jumped on the chance to sign one of the most notorious bums in all of baseball if it might help the organization out.

One of my readers, knowing I'd get worked up about this, showed me the angry e-mail he sent to the Mariners when they signed Christensen, expressing his disappointment and threatening to drop his season tickets, and their reply was:

Thanks for your e-mail. We appreciate you being a ticket holder for so long. I'm sorry about your feelings toward Ben Christensen. He did make a mistake several years ago at Wichita State University. People do make mistakes. It's been very hard for him because of all the negative press. Ben is a good person and is a good person in the clubhouse. Again, thanks for your e-mail.

Now, you're probably going to have the same reactions I did:

  • A mistake is sure an understated way to put it

  • "People" don't make mistakes that involve deliberately putting a fastball in the face of a guy in the on-deck circle. They make mistakes like forgetting where they parked at the supermarket.

  • Yeah, damn those media guys, covering a story where a college pitcher nearly killed a poor guy for no good reason and then the team said it taught its pitchers to do it, and only later started to offer even insincere apologies. If only the media had ignored this despicable crime and let Christensen get on with his life.

  • Do good people attempt to do what Christensen did?

I don't think the Mariners thought anyone would notice. It was years ago, after all, and the guy was brought in on a minor league deal. Who pays attention to these things? I couldn't find anything in either of the Seattle dailies about it, either, perhaps by intentional omission at the team's request or, more likely, because they shared the team's opinion of the public's interest. The only substantial article was from a Tacoma paper, which blasted the team.

I want to talk for a second about the good person part. Christensen's life is made of uncountable interactions with people and the world. All most of us really know is that he did something we can't understand. Maybe pumped up on his coaches' take-no-prisoners bean-them-all-let-God-sort-them-out training for years, he felt that in that moment his duty to his team was to carry out what it wanted him to do, and in that decision he erred in obedience over compassion, and hurt someone.

Christensen may still live with guilt. His peace must be made with Molina through an apology and just compensation, and who knows what that would look like. I doubt the lawsuit they settled provided it. Christensen's curse–and this may be what whichever Mariners functionary answered my reader's e-mail meant–is that his act was public and grave. That this has all been so public may have meant that his apologies to Molina by press proxy came off as more hollow and not as substantial as anyone would like to have heard, because that's a hard way to have to apologize to someone. And who am I to judge the sincerity of an apology, anyway?

I don't think that the Mariners should have brought Christensen on and trotted him out for the cameras to go through the questioning again, but…well, maybe I do. Isn't it reasonable to expect the team, when it makes such a strange move, to provide some kind of explanation as to why it did it? When the M's picked up Al Martin, they told us about a call Pat Gillick had with Martin and Martin's primary wife that convinced them he was a good guy. Would it have been so hard to say "Here's Ben, Ben's going to talk a little about why you know him, and what else you should know about him to make a complete judgement." Or even to have Christensen answer the same questions to see if time and reflection have given him perspective on what happened?

Of course not. But the Mariners figured that no one would notice, and if they did, they wouldn't care. They figured that doing anything, even an open and honest press conference that, if Christensen was a good guy and had worked past his mistakes, would have helped clear his reputation, would only draw attention to the "M's pick up killer pitcher" story they didn't want written.

Think about that for a second: It's a pretty awful decision to come to, and speaks perhaps even more about the state of the organization than its decision to welcome Christensen in. It may say a lot about Christensen himself that the Mariners don't want to revisit the story, that the team knows it wouldn't go well.

The reader, on receiving the response from the Mariners, asked: "What do I do now? I don't want to have to follow through on my threat."

I think they're counting on him not following through. The Mariners, like every team, know me and everyone like me, through the wonder of modern demographics. They could probably make a frighteningly-accurate guess as to which potato chips I've been snacking on while writing this column for the last couple hours, what kind of beer I had at the game on Sunday. They know at the end of the year, we'll look at their horrible record, their inept management, their lies and spinning moral compass, and we'll sigh and send in our deposit checks for next season's tickets.

I feel sick that the Mariners signed Ben Christensen. But more than that, I feel guilty. I am complicit in their signing of Christensen, in their constant low-level dishonesty and chicanery. I applaud the hard slide at second, and it's the same hard-nosed, win-at-all-costs baseball that cost Anthony Molina a chance at a career. I fume when the Mariners lie to play down the insane amount of money they make, but I open my wallet and hand them more.

By failing to act individually to support what is right, I have acted with everyone else to support what is wrong. I'm sorry.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
cmellinger
9/09
I don't remember reading this the first time around. Thanks for re-publishing it. The Christensen incident still makes me very sad and very angry. Perhaps we need more articles from Derek.

Lindemann
9/09
"...Alex Rodriguez is a joy to watch and a cool guy to boot..."

Man, 2000 was a long time ago.
rawagman
9/09
You could have easily trotted out these articles in the wake of the M's picking up Josh Lueke from the Rangers.
http://seattletimes.com/html/mariners/2012784518_lueke02.html
therealn0d
9/09
I was under the assumption that this was dug up in the wake of the Ray Rice situation.
edman8585
9/09
Al Martin's Wikipedia page has a "controversies" section. The above incident, which I didn't know about, is listed third of the three, implying that it is the least important (they are not in chronological order).

The first is that he lied about playing football at USC. The second is that he spit out a bunch of sunflowers and offended some people because it looked like he vomitted. The last is that he beat his extra wife.

What this boils down to is that the only people who come across this stuff are the people like us who are already fully invested in the sport. Joe the Plumber or Karen the Accountant aren't going to know the stadium their family is spending hundreds of dollars to attend is paid for by taking tax money from things that actually help the public or that the left fielder beat his wife. If they can keep it from those people, that's what matters.

I've struggled with this as a Tigers fan, who was probably one of those Joe the Plumber types before I got the internet in 1999. It wasn't until Dmitri Young returned from his domestic abuse/drug issue in 2006 that I really felt this conflict. Then Miguel Cabrera had his demons come to life and I feel like a giant hypocrite calling out any athlete. Before having the information, I didn't know Luis Polonia had hooked up with a 15 year-old when I cheered him on, I didn't know Tony Phillips had major drug demons when I imitated his batting stance in T-ball. And then there's that Ty Cobb elephant in the room...

A lot of rambling there, it's a unique issue. Thanks for posting, as I had completely forgotten about the Martin and Christensen issues.
edman8585
9/09
And holy #$*#, Anthony Molina pulled a Chad Curtis now?!?!?! Maybe he deserved with Christensen did!
fawcettb
9/09
Okay, I'll bite. What's a "Chad Curtis"?
edman8585
9/09
http://espn.go.com/mlb/story/_/id/9764732/chad-curtis-sentenced-7-15-years-prison

http://qctimes.com/news/local/molina-sentenced-to-prison/article_87c63329-5ae3-5737-8cd2-091eb891b6a6.html