On Thursday evening, we hosted our first mock draft with a 15-person group of industry folks going 23 rounds deep to fill out a standard roster of C, C, 1B, 2B, 3B, CI, MI, 5 OF, DH, and 9 P of any kind. Couch Managers hosted the event. I randomized the draft order just before game time and here’s how it came out:

Brent Hershey [Baseball HQ]

Paul Sporer [Baseball Prospectus]

Jason Longfellow [Razzball]

Nick Raducanu [FantasyTrade411]

Ryan Carey [Mastersball]

Cory Schwartz [MLB]

David Gonos [Sports Illustrated]

D.J. Short [Rotoworld]

Alex Kantecki [Baseball Prospectus]

Jake Ciely [RotoExperts]

Tim Heaney [KFFL]

Derek Carty [DFSEdge]

Zach Steinhorn [MLB]

Jeff Zimmerman [Fangraphs]

Nick Shlain [Rotowire]

I’m worried I’m using all of my good draft order luck in mock season!!! This is my second draft with a top-two pick and third straight with a top-four pick. I just know that once they count, I’ll be saddled with a bunch of sixth and eighth slots. The ideal spots for me this year are top three or bottom two—I just want to stay out of the middle. I was able to get Paul Goldschmidt with the fourth spot in that one draft, which is exactly who I wanted, but he’s moved up as the consensus no. 3.

The First Round


Brent Hershey

Mike Trout


Paul Sporer

Miguel Cabrera


Jason Longfellow

Paul Goldschmidt


Nick Radancu

Andrew McCutchen


Ryan Carey

Clayton Kershaw


Cory Schwartz

Carlos Gonzalez


David Gonos

Robinson Cano


D.J. Short

Hanley Ramirez


Alex Kantecki

Ryan Braun


Jake Ciely

Bryce Harper


Tim Heaney

Adam Jones


Derek Carty

Chris Davis


Zach Steinhorn

Prince Fielder


Jeff Zimmerman

Jason Kipnis


Nick Shlain

Jacoby Ellsbury

The top four was chalk and I’d be surprised if there was much change (outside of maybe the order of Trout/Cabrera or Goldy/Cutch as pairs). It gets really interesting at five and Carey wasted no time making a statement with Kershaw. The timing couldn’t have been better as I had just spent the day on an email discussion with the Flags Fly Forever crew regarding Kershaw as a viable pick in the 5-7 range. My main point regarding the situation is that the opportunity cost to your offense is nowhere near as great as it was 5-10 years ago, so you can get a significant leg up on your pitching without severely damaging your offense.

The glob of offensive talent from the middle of the first round to, say, the fourth (maybe even fifth) round just isn’t that disparate. Meanwhile, Kershaw—even accounting for the fact that he’s unlikely to throw down another 1.83 ERA—is still a reasonable amount better than his peers and perhaps more importantly, he’s also markedly more stable. Betting on pitching is scary, I understand that, but we’re talking about a guy with five straight seasons of sub-3.00 ERAs. First round picks are suspect as a whole with their success rate. Baseball HQ showed in the fantasy forecaster that just 36 percent of first round picks have delivered top-15 value that season since 2004. Starting pitchers are 3-for-3 in the last three seasons with Roy Halladay, Justin Verlander, and Kershaw.

Moving on, the rest of the first round contains some names you’ll see in every first round (Cano, Ramirez, and Davis), but also ones that are part of that amalgam of talent I was talking about so they are just as likely to be mid-second rounders (Fielder and Kipnis) depending on the preferences of your leaguemates. If there is one thing I would have changed, it’s that I would’ve taken Edwin Encarnacion ahead of both Davis and Fielder at first base. Expanding it out to all positions, I would’ve taken him ahead of Jones, Kipnis, and Ellsbury, too.

Draft Trends
The first trend I noticed was how consistently starting pitchers went in rounds three through seven. I used to consistently wait until the seventh or eighth round to get my first pitcher years ago, but that is no longer a strategy that can work unless you just hit on every sleeper you select. By the eighth round, every team had at least one starting pitcher while eight had a pair, including me (The Coles: Hamels and Gerrit).

The last one to join the party was Schwartz when he took Jordan Zimmermann at 7.96 (first number is the round, second number is the overall pick). Zimmermann was actually as his second pitcher, as he took Trevor Rosenthal the round before. Compare his staff to Carey, who selected the first pitcher with the fifth-overall pick.


Clayton Kershaw


Trevor Rosenthal


Greg Holland


Jordan Zimmermann


Mike Minor


David Robertson


Hyun-Jin Ryu


Julio Teheran


Danny Farquhar


Hiroki Kuroda


Drew Smyly


Jarrod Parker


Alex Wood


Tyson Ross


Dan Straily


Jose Veras


Kevin Gausman


Jonathon Niese

Whose do you like better?


Next I noticed that my cohorts were catcher crazy! Or maybe I was just catcher lazy. I believe the position is deep, so I didn’t mind waiting a bit, but all of a sudden nine were gone after seven rounds. Five more—including two of my favorites, Wilson Ramos and Yan Gomes—would go before I finally got in on the action and took Josmil Pinto, a guy who could start the season in Triple-A, something I was unaware of when I took him. At least I don’t do this for a living.


Schwartz and his longtime podcast partner Mike Siano have long advocated the power-closer route, a strategy that encourages getting in early on the position and even breaking the seal if necessary. With Schwartz and MLB colleague Steinhorn in the draft, it was all but guaranteed that one of them would get Craig Kimbrel. Steinhorn made the move at 6.78 and the floodgates opened up. I was prepared to jump in that same round with Rosenthal or Greg Holland, but the latter went right after Schwartz took Rosenthal. With my two favorites off the board, I decided to wait.

Eleven closers would fly off the board in a 50-pick span in the sixth through ninth rounds, plus another eight in just the 10th and 11th rounds alone. After seeing Glen Perkins sail by in the eighth, I knew I could wait a while until I finally landed Addison Reed at 11.152. True to form, Schwartz had two of those first 10, landing David Robertson at 9.126.


Outfield is not deep. At all. I feel like it’s mischaracterized as such yearly because those doing the ranking underestimate the effect that every team needing five will have on the pool. I can definitely see it evolving into a steady position and possibly even a deep one, but as it stands right now, it’s thin on bankable talent. After the top 30-35, there are a lot of question marks. Here are a few among the next 20 OF selected:

These are just the second- and third-outfielder types.

Best/Worst Picks by Team
You can go here to look at the draft as a whole or here if you prefer the color-coded board. Instead of listing everyone’s team here, I will just cover some of their finest and not-so-hot moments. I didn’t invite a bunch of my friends to draft just to cut up their work, but there are some spots where I just wouldn’t have picked a guy for whatever reason. Obviously if we all agreed on everything, this game wouldn’t be any fun.


  • Best: Brian McCann (7.91): I have him as the fourth-best
  • Worst: Jim Johnson (10.150): There were closers available that I liked more, including my own, Reed, selected two picks later


  • Get real, I don’t make bad picks. Unless you count your top catcher possibly starting the season at Triple-A as bad. Oh, you do? Well okay, then.



  • Best: Jose Bautista (3.34): Bautista is a good example from the glut of bats I was talking about earlier
  • Worst: Michael Wacha (7.94): I just need more to make him the 20th SP off the board


  • Best: Aramis Ramirez (10.146): He was the 14th third basemen off the board; Carey got more than an adequate discount for the huge upside
  • Worst: Danny Farquhar (14.206): I think he might’ve missed the Rodney signing by Seattle


  • Best: Hunter Pence (4.55): The upside of first-round (finished 13th last year) production with the downside of a fifth-round pick; insane value here
  • Worst: Zimmermann (7.96): I’m actually a huge JZ fan, but I’d have preferred someone like Mat Latos (7.100) for his ace




  • Best: Joey Votto (2.22): I’d have taken both second-round 1B (Encarnacion went a pick before) over the late-first guys (Davis and Fielder)
  • Worst: Brandon Phillips (7.99): I like the next six 2B more, especially Chase Utley at 9.121


  • Best: Latos (7.100): Easily a fantasy ace, possibly an MLB one, taken after four less-deserving pitchers, including my pick of Gerrit Cole (but I’m betting big on Cole and didn’t see him getting back to me)
  • Worst: Clay Buchholz (18.261): I’ve just never been a fan


  • Best: Alex Rios (3.41): Another example of the talent glob—with three $30 seasons in his last four, would it be outrageous to take him in the late first?
  • Worst: Jered Weaver (10.140): Less about Weaver and more about several names drafted after


  • Best: Alex Cobb (10.139): Why isn’t his stock through the roof? He was better than Wacha in more than two times the innings, plus he has five times his count for his career
  • Worst: Matt Wieters (9.132): Sinking value as he insists on switch-hitting at a deep position


  • Best: Alfonso Soriano (12.168): Age scares the fantasy community
  • Worst: Tommy Hunter (17.253): Super nitpicky because I liked most of Zach’s draft; just don’t see Hunter closing


  • Best: Brian Dozier (16.227): A repeat is fine, but upside is available with even modest improvement versus RHP
  • Worst: Koji Uehara (7.104): Maybe I should be heartened because Jeff is an injury guru, but I don’t trust him to stay upright again


  • Best: Tim Hudson (23.345): Nice gamble with the last pick in the draft
  • Worst: Evan Gattis (7.105): I don’t see enough upside for a seventh-round pick and a repeat certainly doesn’t earn that slot

This draft doesn’t even count, it’s a mock so I should probably wrap this up, but I’ll close with a look at my team by itself:


Josmil Pinto


Welington Castillo


Adrian Gonzalez


Aaron Hill


Miguel Cabrera


Ian Desmond


Chris Johnson


Alcides Escobar


Jay Bruce


Leonys Martin


Austin Jackson


Will Venable


Dayan Viciedo


Marlon Byrd


Cole Hamels


Gerrit Cole


Andrew Cashner


Chris Tillman


Corey Kluber


Nathan Eovaldi


Addison Reed


John Axford


LaTroy Hawkins

Now, that is a squad.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
Yep - totally missed the Rodney signing, so Farqhuar was a blown pick. It was a direct result of getting cute and pushing Khris Davis up a round and trying to sneak Feliz around. Should have went Feliz when I had opportunity.

I did take Gausman late over some other arms since I think there is a better chance that the O's pull a Rosenthal with him closing out games this year at some point.

I think as a trio, the Mastersball gang is higher on SMyly, Wood and Straily than the field, which explains my ability to roster all three in this draft.

With respect to Kershaw - I didn't take my second starter until RD 9 and think I got great value on both Minor and Ryu to back him up in my rotation.
I loved backing up CK with Ryu and Minor!
Totally agree with you on Alex Cobb. Dude should be way higher. Him and Gerrit Cole.
Paul, thanks again for organizing, and for recapping. I don't mind critiques but I think you are off base on Zimmermann vs. Latos. They are about as close comps as you can find; here are their last three year averages:

JZ Player ML
13-9 W-L 12-8
3.13 ERA 3.37
190.0 IP 205.0
146 SO 186
1.13 WHIP 1.18
6.92 K/9 8.15
18.8% K% 21.9%

Latos puts up a few more innings and a clear-cut edge in strikeouts, but Zimmermann has the clear edge on ratios. Plus, Zimmermann pitches in the better pitchers' park, and Latos is coming off offseasonn elbow surgery ("cleanup", but still....). Latos is two years younger but both can be considered in their primes.

So, outside of personal preference for Latos, I don't see how you can call him an ace and a clear-cut better choice than Zimmermann, especially considering that they went within four picks of each other.

Frankly I would've expected the "worst pick" tag on the Rosenthal/Robertson tandem, given how early I went for a pair of unproven closers, no matter what their K rates are.

All that said, thanks again for putting together this valuable exercise!
Rosy and D-Rob are two of my favorite closers. I find them entirely proven, even with their small samples of doing it. I have zero worries about either.

I think it's my strikeout whore-dom that leads me to the Latos>JZ thing, but your point is well-taken especially in the context of your team wherein the aforementioned closers MORE than make up for JZ who isn't even *strikeout-deficient* like say Bartolo Colon.

I also happen to believe Latos has MLB ace capability in him as an upside where I believe JZ is content to be a 7 K9 bc he'd rather GB the shit out of everyone. I believe he has the stuff to be a K-per-IP guy if he wanted, but he finds it too pitch inefficient.

Thanks for being part of it. I love discussing strategies and thought processes of all of this.
In my leagues an extra 40Ks a year (Latos) makes a significant difference not only in the obvious categorical advantage but also Roster flexibility. Yo.
so, if you don't see tommy hunter closing in Baltimore, who do you see closing there? Darren o'day? matusz? jemile weeks?
Perhaps I should've said, while he MAY close, I certainly do see him being successful.
Re: Gattis, 30 homers at catcher not enough upside for a 7th round pick?

I wrote about my entire team at Rotowire:
About the same uoside as downside for a player that got sent to the minor leagues last year during a slump - and a player whos background and lack of experience shout RISK. 7th round is a reach. Yo.
In the Schwartz vs Carey pitchers table, someone has rounded the 'decimals' of overall draft position
You're right, my bad. I made that chart before I caught the rounding. You can click the draft link to see the exact pick numbers.
Jason Kipnis in the first round? Hahahahahahah. What? These are those so called fantasy experts that wait until the 4th round to take their first pitcher unless it's Kershaw. HanRam in the first round? My advice is to do your own drafting research. You'll be fine.
Really helpful comment.

You know I have been playing fantasy for years and in just about every draft people make head-scratching picks at times. Maybe you missed the part that this was a 15-team draft. I am certain Jeff doesn't need me to defend his picks - and while I wouldn't have taken Kipnis at that spot - a quick look at the following bats selected shows it isn't a ridiculous bump to the 1st round. Jeff avoided CI's and OF's and went for the MI he liked best, and Kipnis was the top MI on my board at that point, since I don't want to draft Tulowitzki there either. Jeff came away with Rizzo and Sandoval at the corners (with Butler at UT)and grabbed a young OF of Fowler, Calhoun, Eaton, Arcia and Saunders with picks late. He skinned the cat in an unorthodox way - which is in the end the reason we mock in the first place, isn't it?
Ryan- I appreciate the response. I like Zimmerman's next 2 picks of Darvish and Scherzer. J. Upton would have been better in the first round. Then get Kinsler in the 4th instead of Mauer. Thats another major issue. Mauer in the 4th.
For my money Mauer is non draftable. No bounce back year for him.
No prob - and thanks for responding back - and taking my first comment in stride. Now see - now we can discuss , and have some fun with it. You say Justin Upton in the first, which believe me, to many is more funny than Kipnis. And that is the point, your picks may be my pans and vice versa. For me, Upton is a third rounder at best, albeit with 1st round upside.
Ryan- No problem. I like debating fantasy baseball. Remember J. Upton's age. He's 27 and that's the magic age. He also has the pedigree of a real life first rounder. 35 to 40 home runs. 100 runs. 20 SBs. 310 average. Thats his line for 2014 according to me. 1st round return. Also, when was the last time he has been hurt? 2nd year with the new team. He should never get past the second round in even a 12 team mixed. I'm not a Braves fan or necessarily an Upton fan but this is the year for him.

On a side note, do you do any radio?
Mauer playing 1B full time - one of best pure hottees we have seen come up in last 10 years ...gets his chance to Hit. Kipnis would have to earn his top round pick status by running alot ...again. personally I think we have seen his peak SB's.
Typo...And a humerous one. SHOULD READ BEST PURE HITTER. Not hottee. #smartphone
From Jeff, the guy who took Kip -

Sorry but I currently don't have a BP account, so Paul will need to respond.

First, drafting at the end of the 1st round is by far the weakest position. Pick #1 & #30 will generate more value than #15 & #16

I had Kipnis rated as the as the 11th best hitter with Posey and Tulo still on my board and rated higher.

I took him because:
1.I had him rated higher than Cano and like to get him in the 2nd round, but my position means he would not make it back.
My Projection:
Kipnis: 0.270/17/27/89/75
Cano: 0.299/23/4/87/93

2. With SS, I planned on waiting to get Everth Cabera. I have his value as the 25th hitter and he ADP is 83rd pick, so I planned on getting him later as a good value (he got taken a few picks ahead of me). Because of this, I passed on Tulo.
3. There was a huge drop off at 2B after Kipnis and not at C. Also, using ADP, I knew there was a good chance Mauer would be around the next time around.

With Darvish, I like getting him late 2nd round, early 3rd round. With my draft position, I figured he wasn't going to be around so I picked him up.

With starting pitchers there are 5 tiers (hopefully I will get to writing on these later this week at FG)
Tier 1: Kershaw
Tier 2: Darvish
Tier 3: Four Pitchers which Scherzer leads (reason i picked him up)
Tier 4: A group of 12 pitchers grouped together
Tier 5: Everyone else
I really appreciate the reasoning. I read it twice. I have a feeling that you really like Kipnis' stolen bases. Lack of power for the first rounder is concerning. Good power for a second basemen. But maybe not for a first rounder.