Some managers might have attempted it, but not Weaver. Weaver would have thought the thing through and figured out that, even if you try to have a lineup with nine Frank Robinsons, you're just shooting yourself in the foot. 

1. Frank Robinson, RF. Career .294/.389/.537 hitter, 12-time All-Star.

2. Brian Frank Robinson, SS. Career .227/.325/.306 hitter in five minor-league seasons, 1983-1987.

3. Franklin Tyler Robinson, C. Career .290 hitter in three Class-D seasons with Danville Dans and other teams, 1950-1952

4. Frank Robertson, 1B. Statistics unknown, Atlanta Crackers, 1917.

5. Frank Robison, CF. Unknown. 

6. Francis Robbins, LF. Career .104 hitter for Class-D Marion Presidents and Sandusky Sailors. 

7. Frank Roberson, 3B. Slugged .333 for Class-D Middlesboro Athletics, 1953. 

8. Francis Robertson, 2B. Statistics unknown, 1924 Oakland Oaks, 1926 Quincy Red Birds.

9. Franklin Robinson, P. 2.87 ERA, South Atlantic League, 1950.

Manager: Frank Robinson, 58-50, Class-D Marion Marauders, 1952. 

That lineup would be terrible. Weaver was right. Weaver was usually right. 

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
Definitely not as good as a lineup of nine Bugs Bunnys...
I'd rather take my chances with nine Frank Robinsons than nine Mordecai Browns.
I would think you could just allow the real Frank Robinson to player-manage this bunch, no? That would solve a huge oh nevermind.
Could have at least let him have Brooks. People always got them confused anyway :)
Nine Jose Oquendos wouldn't be that bad, at least from a positional flexibility standpoint
I'll bet that the Robinson 9 would not fare so well against a team made up of people named Bill James. You'd have a lot of Bill Jameses who struggled playing catcher or outfield in B thru D ball, but the staff would be led by 2 big league pitchers from the dead ball era (one from the 1914 Braves!). And they would get a ton of strategic help from their head statistician.