Baseball Prospectus Needs Your Help! Check out our call for contributors!

Most of our writers didn't enter the world sporting an address; with a few exceptions, they started out somewhere else. In an effort to up your reading pleasure while tipping our caps to some of the most illuminating work being done elsewhere on the internet, we'll be yielding the stage once a week to the best and brightest baseball writers, researchers and thinkers from outside of the BP umbrella. If you'd like to nominate a guest contributor (including yourself), please drop us a line.

Matt Sussman retired from the game of baseball after hitting .247 in third grade, walking away from potentially dozens of dollars. For the last seven years he has contributed to various websites and newspapers but mostly likes to make jokes on Twitter at @suss2hyphens.

In 2013 the Detroit Tigers will remain a team stocked with talent, stars, and some extra pounds they'll be happy to tuck snugly into their polyester pants. But the important part is that they won’t be awful. The front office will extol the goal of winning a World Series, and that's fine, because at least they'll be in the conversation.

See, next year they'll be 10 years removed from being the worst squad in AL history—and it's one that every young scholar of Tigers fandom had best study and memorize. It ought to be a law and there should be ScanTron tests. That way they'll never take "only" a playoff appearance for granted.

As the history books grimly dictate, the 2003 Detroit Tigers finished with a record of 43-119, 47 games out of first place in the AL Central. The lineup was basically Dmitri Young and a casino buffet of Triple-A players. The pitching staff was comprised of several starry-eyed 20-somethings who tried to keep their ERA below five, and a couple of them succeeded!

Naturally, with a lack of talent, losses happened early and often. Four games in, they’d already fallen to last place, where they'd remain all season. They began 0-9, then 1-17, 3-25, and so on. In my formative years (the ’90s), the Tigers were never really competitive, but these were new levels of badness. It was intriguing, not unlike how moths are captivated by buzzing bright lights.

They won a total of eight series. Eight! They were shut out 15 times. They finished worst in the AL in runs, hits, errors, OPS and strikeouts (batted and pitched). Their pitching staff: mercifully, only second worst at preventing runs. (Bless the Texas Rangers’ pitchers and the hitter’s park they played in.)

When the Yankees came to Detroit on June 1, 2003, Roger Clemens got the start with the hope of earning his 300th win. His opponent: Jeremy Bonderman, a 20-year-old pitcher who had no business being on a major-league roster. (In many ways, he wasn't.) The stars appeared aligned for that milestone to be reached, so I drove up to Comerica Park for the festivities.

The Yankees took a 7-1 lead into the bottom of the fifth inning, with a history almost certain to be made, only for the Tigers to somehow force extra innings. No win for Clemens. The game actually lasted 17 innings, with bonus ball turning into a battle of extra starting pitchers: Steve Sparks threw 7 2/3 innings of sparkling knuckleball relief while David Wells threw 5 2/3 innings. The Yankees eventually broke through, winning 10-9, proving once again: they couldn't even lose correctly.

I saw one other game that year, later that month vs. the Diamondbacks. A rain delay made it look like Detroit averted defeat in the most natural and logical way possible, but alas, the precipitation was temporary and Brandon Webb went the distance in a 7-0 D-Backs victory.

You can swing a bat at the Tigers’ schedule and find a weird loss. For example, they were one-hit by the Devil Rays and Joe Kennedy, whose ERA that year would finish above six. Then there was the game against the Indians wherein the game-winning run was scored by 38-year-old Omar Vizquel stealing home on Steve Avery, who didn't even attempt a throw.

The team also shattered the concept that records in one-run games mean something. They were 19-18 in such situations. (That same year, the 101-win Atlanta Braves were 17-25 in one-runners.)

Some of us may remember that Mike Maroth became the league's first 20-game loser in over 20 years. But Bonderman also lost 19 and… well, we'd need Dean Wormer to read off the rest of the rotation's record and ERA. But my favorite stat: saves. The Tigers team leader in saves was a tie between Franklyn German and Chris Mears with… five. Five saves. That same season, Eddie Guardado recorded five saves through the Twins' first six games. (Three of them were against the Tigers.) This was Mears' only major-league season, and he can say he led his team in saves. And he should say that, routinely, to everybody around him.

Weeks of head hanging and finger pointing later, a 12-6 loss to the Royals on September 22 put the Tigers at 118 losses, a new AL record. They were in dire danger of losing 120, tying the overall record owned by the expansion 1962 Mets. Avoiding this colossal fate required five wins in their final six games against the division champion Twins and actually-not-terrible-whoa-what-happened Royals. Around baseball, most playoff spots were locked up. With few other regular season mysteries left, I recall this becoming a national fascination.

As it turned out, they won five of their last six games. The starting pitcher in their finale: Maroth.

And with the sweet release of Game 162, the healing was able to begin. By healing I mean, of course, acquiring actual MLB players. Out of nowhere, Ivan Rodriguez signed with the team. The Tigers brought in Fernando Viña, Jason Johnson, and Rondell White and traded for Carlos Guillen. Not worldbeaters, but not Quadruple-A players either. They improved to 72-90. Hey, progress!

Some major players on that 2003 team remained key contributors on the World Series squad in 2006: Brandon Inge, Ramon Santiago, Craig Monroe and Omar Infante played in the field. Bonderman was one of their top pitchers; Mike Maroth also gave positive contributions during the regular season, as did Wil Ledezma, Jamie Walker, and Fernando Rodney. Others found success elsewhere: Cody Ross and Andres Torres later became important players on the 2010 Giants team that went all the way.

The death tarot card comes to mind regarding this terrible team. Typical thoughts of death invoke an actual loss of human life, but in the tarot world it's supposed to symbolize the end of an era, a rebirth, or a new chance. In the case of the Tigers, a raging tire fire was eventually doused, bulldozed, and salvaged for scrap—a less beautiful metaphor, but the thought behind it works. It's no shock that 2003 marked the first full season of Dave Dombrowski as their general manager, working to undo the gnarled remains left behind by exiled GM Randy Smith.

Further case in point: by virtue of losing 119 games, the Tigers earned the second overall pick in the following year's amateur draft. And that's how Justin Verlander joined the organization.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
This article brings back wonderful memories in a way. At the time in 2003, I was not following baseball at all (I had been a Tigers fan as a kid thanks to Mark Fidrich), but my father-in-law, Keith, lived in Michigan, and he was a lifelong, devoted Tigers fan, born in Detroit. (By the way, a relative took him to Tigers Stadium as a boy just so that he could see Babe Ruth in his last season, a fact which I learned only a year or so ago, before he died.) During that season, Keith watched almost every game on TV, every day a game was on, despite the wretchedness of it all, like he did every year, and usually to the end. I would talk to him regularly on the phone, and he would update me on the Tigers as to whether they would break the MLB loss record. He was so happy with that last 5-for-6 win streak, and that they avoided the ignominy of 120+ losses! Thanks to him (and his pretty daughter, also a big Tigers fan), I got back into Tigers baseball in 2006, and baseball as whole. A wonderful sport, and I thank him for getting me into it!
Ok, I'll bite and show my ignorance of MLB draft procedure: How did the Padres get the first pick ahead of the Tigers in the 2004 draft?
I think the old rule was that American League and National League rotated the #1 pick. Padres had the worst pick in the N.L. so they picked first in 2004. To bad the Tigers missed out on Matt Bush that probably would have put them over the top in 2006 :)
Great article. I to was at that Yankees game where Clemens was going for his 300th victory and the game ended up going on forever. Some of my other favorite memories from the 2003 season. Going to a game against the White Sox where fans routinely sprinted across the field without repercussions. Jon Bois could have written an epic 20 part series detailing all the fan interference that afternoon. I also had Shane Halter call me and my friend an unkind term referring to female anatomy because we had made a sign critical of Dean Palmer and finally trying to convince everyone I knew that Wil Ledezma was the second coming of Pedro Martinez because I saw him dominate the White Sox until stupid Chris Spurling and his giant gold #48 necklace came in and blew the game. I agree 100% that any Tigers fan who was a fan of the team in 2003 will always appreciate the team being in the playoffs or hell within shouting distance of .500
Fun article, but don't forget Nate Robertson - a very significant contributor to the 2006 team.