BP360 is Back! One low price for a: BP subscription, 2022 Annual, 2022 Futures Guide, choice of shirt

Joe Girardi understands the numbers. That humongous binder that sits beside the manager in the Yankees' dugout isn't a collection of the great volume of copy turned out by the scribes that cover the Bronx Bombers on a daily basis.

Girardi studies the statistics and is as prepared as any manager. That is part of the reason why the Yankees have kept on winning since Girardi replaced Joe Torre, owner of four World Series rings, four years ago.

It helps that one other number works in Girardi's favor—the Yankees' payroll is annually among the highest in the game. Yet, Girardi also knows that winning goes beyond numbers and high-priced players, especially as the season heads into the final month.

"I don't think you can put a number on the value of experience," Girardi said. "When you have guys who have been playing for a long time, guys who are battle-tested in pressure situations, it does make a difference when you're in a pennant race and in October. I don't think anyone would deny that."

Thus, Girardi is not concerned that the Yankees have had what was a once a 10-game lead in the American League East on July 18 reduced to 3 1/2 games over the Orioles. The Yankees are 22-21 since then, but Girardi knows the numbers are still in his favor.

The Baseball Prospectus Playoff Odds Report gave the Yankees a 95.1 percent chance of winning the division and a 99.3 chance of making the postseason going into Wednesday's games. What gives Girardi greater comfort is that he has a roster filled with players who have been here before, from Derek Jeter to Robinson Cano to CC Sabathia.

"The biggest difference in having a team that has been through it is that there is no panic," Girardi said. "Nobody starts having doubts if you don't play well for a week or so. They don't let anything outside the clubhouse cause them to question themselves. Our guys know how to stay focused every day. If somebody beats us, it's not going to be because we were distracted by something, it's going to be because somebody was better than us on that particular day."

Because they always have the game's biggest payroll, the Yankees often appear indestructible. They always seem to have another big-dollar replacement at their disposable or the financial wherewithal to go get one when needed. However, the Yankees have been able to weather quite a bit of adversity this season, including losing their top offseason acquisition, right-hander Michael Pineda, to shoulder surgery in spring training; having baseball's all-times saves leader, Mariano Rivera, suffer a season-ending knee injury while shagging fly balls in early May; and having underrated left fielder Brett Gardner being limited to 34 plate appearances before undergoing elbow surgery. Furthermore, left-hander Andy Pettitte and third baseman Alex Rodriguez are on the disabled list, and first baseman Mark Teixeira hasn't been completely healthy all year.

Rafael Soriano has stepped in as the closer, two years after leading the AL in saves while with the Rays, and has 34 saves in 37 opportunities with a 2.48 FIP in 53 2/3 innings. Yankees co-chairman Hal and Hank Steinbrenner went against general manager Brian Cashman's wishes and signed Soriano to a three-year, $35-million contract during the 2010-11 offseason, and the move has paid dividends.

The Yankees also traded with the Mariners for Ichiro Suzuki to replace Gardner in left field. Though the 38-yar-old icon has played below replacement level for the Yankees— -0.3 WARP in 34 games since the trade—Girardi still believes "he can make a difference." The Yankees have also acquired some lesser lights, like lefty-mashing first baseman/outfielder Steve Pearce from the Astros. They plugged him into the lineup in the cleanup spot and then beat the Blue Jays on Tuesday night.

Girardi was the National League Manager of the Year in 2006, his rookie season as a major-league skipper and had a lone season in South Florida because of a rift with owner Jeffrey Loria. Yet he will likely never get many plaudits while managing the Yankees because of the franchise's financial wherewithal.

"Joe does a great job," said a front-office type from another AL East organization. "It's not easy managing in New York because the expectations are higher for this franchise than anywhere else, but he does a great job of managing those expectations. They've had some really key injuries this season but have gotten through it. A lot of it comes from them having a veteran group of players, but a lot of it also comes from Joe. He's done a great job of managing through adversity. Everyone says the Yankees win every year because they have money. But look at the Red Sox and how they've just blown their team up. Joe does a great job managing his team and getting the most out of it. They haven't played great ball lately, but they still have a firm hold on first place."

A few minutes with Brewers manager Ron Roenicke

On why he thinks reliever Francisco Rodriguez and starter Shaun Marcum would be good acquisition for teams in contention: "AlI know is if I were a contender and I wanted a guy who was a big-game pitcher out of the bullpen, I'd want a guy like Frankie. I have confidence in him, tons of confidence in him, even was he was going bad earlier in the season. I think the way he's throwing now, someone should grab him. And Shaun Marcum? You've got to be kidding. He could help any team. Every time he is able to step on the field and pitch, he is beneficial. As much I want to win every game we can, I'd never begrudge someone a chance to be part of a pennant race. Hopefully, if we do trade them, we'll get something good back to help us for the future and everyone would benefit."

On being out of contention this season after winning the NL last year: "It's difficult and quite different, but it's one of those things you go through in baseball. We're in the process of looking at younger players and seeing what we have for next season. The positives are that we're still playing hard and we're seeing the young players we need to see. But it's hard to be in this position, especially having the type of season we had last year and having very high hopes coming out of spring training."

On left fielder Ryan Braun having more home runs than during last year's NL MVP season despite not having Prince Fielder hitting behind him: "He has a good mind for what he needs to do to produce and help his team win. Really, it just comes down to the fact that he's that good. He's just that good. You watch him do stuff and (the media) asks if I'm amazed. Well, after managing him for nearly two seasons, I'm not amazed by anything he does anymore. He truly is capable of doing anything."

On why he believes there is such a thing as a clutch hitter and how third baseman Aramis Ramirez exemplifies it: "It's personality. It's something in your makeup that allows you to come through in the clutch. I played with a lot of really good hitters but when it was on the line they weren't as good hitters. Rami is just one of those guys who wants to be up there with the game on the line. Prince was certainly that way. It's like basketball. You here about guys who want to take that last shot but there aren't a lot of them. It's the same way with RBI guys in baseball. There aren't a lot of guy who truly want to be at-bat in big situations and relish being in those situations."

Scouts' views

Red Sox closer Alfredo Aceves: "It's fairly safe to assume he won't be in Boston next year, huh?"

Cubs shortstop Starlin Castro: "I think the Cubs got a helluva deal at seven years and $60 million for him. I know people like to knock him for making mistakes, but he's 22 years old and already an established star in the big leagues at a difficult position to find star players. You're talking about someone who, when he is at his best in a few years, could be one of the top five to seven players in the game."

Rockies right-hander Tyler Chatwood: "It's all about command with him. When he's locating his fastball, it's good enough to get anybody out. It's just a matter of him gaining experience and continuing to learn and I'll think he'll be a fine big-league pitcher."

Reds right-hander Johnny Cueto: "What makes him so tough is that all his pitches come out of the same arm slot. You really don't know what's coming. He doesn't tip his pitch even in the slightest."

Pirates infielder Josh Harrison: "It's easy to write him off as nothing more than a bench guy because he's small and doesn't have any plate discipline. But there's something there. I really think if he works at it and keeps developing that he could be an everyday player."

Mariners right-hander Hisashi Iwakuma: "He's been quite the bargain at one year and $1 million. The Mariners took a shot when everyone else was scared off because they thought he was hurt, and the gamble has paid off."

Braves right-hander Kris Medlen: "This guy has a Cy Young in his future"

Cardinals catcher Yadier Molina: "Maybe this is just an outlier season for him, we'll see, but I've been impressed with his power this season. He's really learned to turn on some pitches."

Athletics first baseman Brandon Moss: "He's quietly been one of the real surprise stories in baseball. I figured we'd never see him again in the big leagues, and he's bounced back to play a role on a contending team. Good for him battling back from Triple-A."

Royals third baseman Mike Moustakas: "He's still inconsistent, which can be expected from a young player, but you can see the talent is there. He has a lot of raw power for a guy who isn't all that big, and I believe it will manifest itself in time."

Rangers right-hander Roy Oswalt: "With so many teams needing starting pitching, I'd be surprised if someone doesn't trade for him. The Rangers aren't asking much for him from everything I'm hearing."

Astros outfielder Jimmy Paredes: "The Astros made the right move by getting him out of the infield and he really thrived in Triple-A this year. I could see him and Jose Altuve forming a nice 1-2 punch at the top of the order in Houston for a long time."

Angels first baseman Albert Pujols: "He needs to have a big September. I know he's turned it around after a bad start, but the Angels paid huge money for him and he's got to earn it and get them into the postseason. If the Angels don't get to the postseason, then the season has to be considered a failure, and Albert has to take some of the blame."

Blue Jays center fielder Colby Rasmus: "Getting away from Tony La Russa was supposed to solve all his problems. Well, it seems to me, Colby Rasmus' problem is Colby Rasmus. He has the talent, but he doesn't know how to unlock it."

Marlins center fielder Justin Ruggiano: "I've always liked him but I was afraid he had been forever lumped in that "4-A" category. He can really hit, and he'll pop some balls out of the ballpark."

Rays right-hander James Shields: "He's back to being Big Game James again. If the Rays get to the playoffs, he's got to be my Game One starter."

Orioles right-hander Chris Tillman: "He's still a young pitcher, even though it seems like he's been around forever. The Orioles have been patient with him, and it's starting to pay off. He hasn't completely turned the corner yet, but he's getting there, and I think he's going to end up being a good one."

Tigers right-hander Justin Verlander: "I'll qualify it by saying it would be darned near impossible to repeat what he did last year, but he hasn't looked the same this year. He hasn't been as sharp, and his pitches haven't been as crisp."

Dodgers left fielder Shane Victorino: "He doesn't look like he's completely settled in with the Dodgers. He especially looks tentative in left field. It's easy to say that he should be a good left fielder because he was a good center fielder, but they are two different positions."

Phillies right-hander Vance Worley: "For me, he's starting to look like a reliever. He doesn't have the type of stamina you need to be a starting pitcher. He starts to fade by the second time through the order, sometimes before that."

Padres left-hander Andrew Werner: "This is why you scout players at every level of the game. He was in the Frontier League two years ago and now he's in the major leagues and getting guys out consistently. You just never know, which is why you look everywhere for players."

Front-office types' views

Diamondbacks: "They're probably not going to make the playoffs this year, but they're really well set for the future with all that young pitching. The Dodgers and Giants are going to be tough to beat in the NL West over the next few years, but I wouldn't count these guys out with those young arms."

Giants: "Bruce Bochy really sets the tone with that club. They lost Melky Cabrera to a drug suspension, and that would have devastated some clubs. But Bochy just stays on that even keel, his players follow suit, and it's been business as usual."

Indians: "I just hope Manny Acta gets a chance to manage a good club at some point. He's a really good manager, a really good strategist, and is always prepared. If he takes the fall for what's happened in Cleveland this year, it would be a shame. Very little of it is his fault."

Mets: "Their lack of depth finally caught up with them, but I can still see them finding a second wind up and finishing up strong. Terry Collins won't let that team mail it in in September."

Nationals: "I wouldn't worry one bit about the shouting match Mike Rizzo and Davey Johnson had in Philadelphia last weekend. Those guys are on the same page, and the whole organization is on the same page because Rizzo is so passionate and people love working for him."

Twins: "I'm really curious to see what they'll do this winter. They're going to have to shake up, make a big trade, or do something. This is a bad team, and status quo isn't going to cut it."

White Sox: "I love their team. They don't wow you with many style points but they have a lot of grinders who get after it every day. They give the type of effort day-in and day-out that you really appreciate, especially over a long, 162-game season."

In this week's Must Read, Adam Felder and Seth Amitin of explain how baseball broadcasters favor American players over foreign players in a subtle way.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
Pirates infielder Josh Harrison: "It's easy to write him off as nothing more than a bench guy because he's small and doesn't have any plate discipline. But there's something there. I really think if he works at it and keeps developing that he could be an everyday player."

There's something there. What is the something? The pretty girlfriend thing? If Josh Harrison turns out to be a useful everyday player, this scout gets to feel like a big shot. If Harrison doesn't, no one remembers, including the scout himself. There's "something there" with almost every major leaguer. That's the point.

Braves right-hander Kris Medlen: "This guy has a Cy Young in his future"

Almost certainly not.

Angels first baseman Albert Pujols: "He needs to have a big September. I know he's turned it around after a bad start, but the Angels paid huge money for him and he's got to earn it and get them into the postseason. If the Angels don't get to the postseason, then the season has to be considered a failure, and Albert has to take some of the blame."

That's what you call some expert analysis right there.

Blue Jays center fielder Colby Rasmus: "Getting away from Tony La Russa was supposed to solve all his problems. Well, it seems to me, Colby Rasmus' problem is Colby Rasmus. He has the talent, but he doesn't know how to unlock it."

More great analysis, the kind only a seasoned expert can "unlock".

Tigers right-hander Justin Verlander: "I'll qualify it by saying it would be darned near impossible to repeat what he did last year, but he hasn't looked the same this year. He hasn't been as sharp, and his pitches haven't been as crisp."

Verlander has been almost exactly the same pitcher this season. He's saying this about a pitcher coming off of a season for the ages, a guy whose ERA has risen from 2.40 to 2.80, and whose rate stats are just about the same as last year. No one can keep this up forever, and once Verlander inevitably falters I'll bet this scout will feel as though he was really onto something earlier than anyone else. This is nonsense.

Let's try to prevent MLB from becoming the NFL, where post facto rationalizations and non-specific, cold reading-like faux expertise go unquestioned.

I'm sorry, and I'm sure I'll be dismissed as a curmudgeon, but someone has to say it. If you're one of those people who is thinking of responding "Oh, I don't know, I like the scout's views. They bring a new angle to the game that statistical analysis doesn't..." go ahead, but first go back and read a few weeks worth of scout's views with a critical eye.
I agree that the Verlander comment is a little too panicky.

While he's not QUITE at the same level he was last year, he's still on the (extremely) short list for Cy Young candidates. If he were getting a little more run support and were, say, 14-5 or 15-4 instead of 12-7, no one would be saying a word.

I remember watching one of his outings against Cleveland earlier in the year where in his last inning (I believe it was the 7th), he struck out the side on 10 pitches, where his second to last pitch was a 102 MPH fastball.

Yeah, I think he's gonna be OK.
While everything you're saying is true, NYYanks826, that isn't really my point. My point is that the scout can never be wrong. Verlander will not throw 101 mph forever, and like every pitcher in baseball history who has run teh table of pitching statistics and is in his dominant prime, he will inevitably fall on comparatively hard times.

This is how psychics bilk people out of money, basically.
My two cents, since I really WANT to like the scout's views section: it might be more helpful and fun to see a variety of scout views on a few players, rather than one per. That way you could see some context for whether one scout is an outlier or if they all say the same thing. Probably too much work, but I like John's contextual writing and want to like the scouts views, but do find them often mystifying and vague.
I would agree with some of this. I wish the scouts would be identified. I know it won't happen, but its hard to take them seriously. Especially with they refer to Kris Medlen as a future Cy Young winner.
On the other hand the Cueto comment was useful, the type of comment a scout would pick up on and I would not.
So the idea is that almost every other pitcher tips his pitches in a perceptible way, and in a way that batters can pick up on in time to make the necessary adjustment? I seriously doubt that's true.

If it is true though, that scout may be better utilized by training the major league hitters how to look for this sort of thing, except for when they're facing Cueto, of course, and the scout can then take the day off.

While the comments can be interesting (or can be generic scout speak), when I read the columns, I find it more important to know who is being talked about.
Where to start?

To be honest, the regular moaning about the scouts' comments is getting a little tedious. If people don't like them, they really are not compelled to read them, especially if you don't believe that scouting adds any value to statistical analysis.

Also, you aren't going to get major league scouts to do a back and forth discussion on the merits of a player, knowing that it could end up in print. It's totally unrealistic, as are the pointless complaints that come up every so often that the scouts are anonymous.

Obviously, most of the comments are not desperately deep, and some of them say very little at all when you boil them down, but they tell you what some baseball professionals think of various players. I find that interesting, especially when someone is willing to step out of the consensus on a player. Will Medlen win a Cy Young - probably not, but it's at least interesting to me that an intelligent observer who is being paid by a big league team thinks he might. Similarly with Harrison. On the Cueto comment, I think it's very unlikely that all major league pitchers avoid tipping any of their pitches at all in any way. Do you really think that?
I'll tell you what I believe. I believe that it's an over-complication, like a lot of the stuff so-called baseball scouting experts say. Many pitchers may or may not technically tip their pitchers, but I'd be willing to bet that the overwhelming majority of them do it in a way that is not perceptible enough to do anything about it. It's happening, typically, as the pitcher is in his delivery, and there really isn't much time to do anything about it at that point, given the time constraints a batter is dealing with.

When we talk about a pitcher that is REALLY tipping his pitches, what we probably mean is that he is tipping his pitches so badly that hitters are able to do something about it. This type of pitcher will get completely pummeled in the Majors and will thus be shipped out in short order, so yeah, I do believe that almost no one is tipping his pitches in any meaningful way. It's something that scouts are saying to make themselves sound smart, and it doesn't amount to much. I believe that Cueto is doing well because he has a lot of ability, and he's doing a great job of executing his pitches.

If it were true that tipping your pitches in some minor way made that much of a difference, wouldn't we see fewer effective two-pitch pitchers? After all, when a guy has two pitches, say a big lefty with a fastball and a slider, wouldn't a lot of the guesswork be gone, especially if batters know that that pitcher starts with a fastball 2/3 of the time? Yes, it helps to know what pitch is coming if you can avail yourself of that information, but it doesn't help as much as just about everyone seems to think it does. The reason it doesn't is that hitting is difficult.

Great hitting or pitching happens when tremendous ability and focused execution intersect. Guys hit homers not so much because they've been given a day off, or because it's their birthday or because some big guys is batting behind them in the order. It's because they are doing a good job of executing this thing that they already know how to do but have a hard time doing consistently. As to why they get hot and do it well for a while and then cold for a while and back and forth, well, I'd imagine that there are a lot of variables involved, few of which are easy to grasp or explain the way these scouts pretend that they can, and on top of it you'll notice that they often hedge by doing most of the "explaining" after the fact.

I'm not saying people shouldn't read the scouts' views, and I'm not saying that you aren't supposed to get some personal enjoyment out of them. I just want to point out that we shouldn't stop reading them with the critical eye that they deserve, just because, after years of being ridiculed for using more empirical approaches to gain insights into the game, we feel pressure to give credence to old school scouting. When a bunch of pointless comments by scouts appear in Baseball Prospectus, whether I choose to read them or not, I feel that the pendulum has probably swung a bit to far in the other direction.
I looked all at Aramis Ramirez' stats over at baseballreference, and I can't see anything indicating a clutch performer. All his situational stats are close enough to league average that the difference can be explained by randomness. And his career postseason line of 194/299/433 ain't clutch by any definition.

Still, the guy's a damn good player, and I don't want to call "BS" on Roenicke based on my limited b-ref search skills. Anyone know if there's any stats backing up Roenicke's perception?
You only bring up clutch for guys you want to talk up, and it doesn't mean much. I mean you never hear anybody say, oh that guy blows it in big situations.
It's either a backhanded compliment for Ramirez, with a suggestion that he isn't coming through in non-clutch situations, or an indirect insult to the majority of his other players, who evidently don't have what it takes to come through in the clutch.
That front office type talking about the Mets obviously hasn't watched them the last two weeks.
Has anyone in here actually dug in and watched Kris Medlen pitch during the last 3 weeks? He is locating his fastball with movement like someone else that used to wear a Braves uniform.

He is "unlocking his talent" - should he stay healthy and be able to consistently pitch the way he is now, the Braves have a top of the rotation starter.

I would take him over the ballyhooed Tommy Hanson in a heartbeat right now.

Verlander is great but not last year great - that is also clear to observers .... Kate Upton might be keeping him up too late at night.