As the trading deadline approaches, teams are open to any and all moves that might make them better. Some clubs have sought upgrades at positions where they’ve already received decent production, but the higher the bar that the trade target has to clear, the fewer the potential fixes, and the greater the price. The path of least resistance for a contender hoping to improve is often to patch a particularly weak position with an average player who can give them more than they’ve been getting, without costing too much in any other area.

The weakest performance by a collection of players at any position on a contending team this season has been at second base in Detroit, where seven players—notably Ramon Santiago, Ryan Raburn, and Danny Worth—have played at replacement level or below, combining for a total of -2.2 WARP. It’s no coincidence that the Tigers traded for a second baseman on Tuesday, filling what had been a gaping hole with Omar Infante, who should be at least average for them the rest of the way. We can see the same pattern on display in other acquisitions: the Dodgers traded for Hanley Ramirez because their shortstops—notably the injured Dee Gordon—had combined for -0.6 WARP.

Although some positional holes have already been plugged, several more remain. The teams that manage to find fixes for their most obvious flaws might be the ones that emerge from the pack of contenders with a playoff berth, so with five days left until the deadline, few GMs will be far from their phones. The following are the most glaring positional weaknesses that contenders are still trying to fill, as well as a potential fit (or fits) for each team.

Dodgers, 1B (-1.5 WARP)
The Dodgers filled one hole in their infield when they added Ramirez, but an even worse one remains at first base, where James Loney and Juan Rivera haven’t hit all year. It sounds like an exaggeration to say that anyone would be better than Loney, but it isn’t: of the 29 first basemen who’ve had at least 200 plate appearances this season, only the recently demoted Justin Smoak has a lower TAv than Loney’s .218. According to Jayson Stark, Justin Morneau is the bat the Twins are most likely to move, and he might make an excellent fit for the Dodgers. While he hasn’t recovered the offensive form he showed before his concussion problems, he has stayed in the lineup. Even if he doesn’t improve at the plate, he’d represent a sizeable upgrade for LA.

Giants, 2B (-1.3 WARP)
Orioles, 2B (-1.1 WARP)
White Sox, 2B (-0.8 WARP)
Athletics, 2B (-0.8 WARP)

The Tigers aren’t the only contending team that has had problems at second base. The Giants (Ryan Theriot, Emmanuel Burriss), Orioles (the injured Robert Andino and Brian Roberts), White Sox (Gordon Beckham), and A’s (Jemile Weeks) have all had their own issues at the keystone. Infante is off the market, but a few semi-attractive middle-infield options remain, including the Rockies’ Marco Scutaro, the Cubs’ Darwin Barney, and the Diamondbacks’ shortstop Stephen Drew, who has struggled since his return but is unlikely to remain in Arizona beyond this season. The Blue Jays’ Kelly Johnson is another intriguing option who might be on the move. The A’s will likely stick with Weeks and hope he recovers his rookie form. Across the bay, the Giants were too strapped for cash to bring in a bat over the winter, but with the Dodgers retooling, a little offensive help would go a long way for San Francisco. At this point, the O’s would benefit from the addition of almost any warm body.  

Athletics, 3B (-1.3 WARP)
The A’s have been unable to find a fit at third since Scott Sizemore’s season-ending injury— their late-April pickup of Brandon Inge predictably bombed—but the next few days might lead to a more lasting solution. Oakland was reportedly in on Hanley Ramirez, but with Hanley now spoken for, the A’s will have to look elsewhere. Another name they’ve been linked to is Chase Headley, who would make a lot of sense for Billy Beane’s team. Headley’s offensive prowess has always been disguised by Petco Park; the 28-year-old has mustered an impressive .279/.378/.488 line away from San Diego this season, which would be a major improvement over the .185/.230/.332 showing by Inge, Josh Donaldson, and the rest of the A’s miserable hot-corner crew.

Rays, C (-1.2 WARP)
The Rays have been sitting on the fence between buying and selling for some time, but recent indications are that with Evan Longoria on the comeback trail, they may decide to stay in the race. If they do, catcher is one area at which they could improve without breaking the bank. Even in a typically terrible offensive season, Jose Molina has done enough with his glove to hold onto a job, but his backups’ bats have been no better. The Rays could take the struggling Kurt Suzuki off the A’s hands and hope he rebounds, allowing Derek Norris to take over in Oakland. If they want to get really adventurous, they could deal from their strength—young, homegrown starting pitching—and send Jeremy Hellickson to Cleveland for Carlos Santana in an exchange of promising players who haven’t yet turned into stars.

Pirates, SS (-1.1 WARP)
Clint Barmes has been the James Loney of shortstops in 2012: no one currently playing the position has hit worse. He has helped on defense, but on the whole, his contributions have hurt the team. Backup Josh Harrison has hit well enough to be an upgrade, and the Pirates might not have much left to spend after assuming the remainder of Wandy Rodriguez’s contract, but if they want to go outside the organization in search of a solution, Brendan Ryan might make sense. Ryan’s bat hasn’t been much better than Barmes’, but his glove is good enough to make him an asset anyway. Pirates fans have already lived through the end of Jack Wilson’s tenure with the team, so they’re used to the sight of a defensive whiz with a weak bat at short.

Nationals, LF (-1.0 WARP)
Tigers, RF (-1.0 WARP)
Reds, CF (-0.7 WARP)
Pirates, RF (-0.5 WARP)

Roger Bernadina has been a pleasant surprise in center, and Mike Morse’s bat has been better of late, so the Nats probably won’t make a move for a starting position player. And, according to Detroit GM Dave Dombrowski, the Tigers are done dealing. However, the Reds and Pirates might still make a move for an outfielder. The Reds reportedly turned down a Shane Victorino-for-Logan Ondrusek offer, which—if true—seems like a strange decision. If the Twins can be persuaded to sell, maybe Denard Span would be more to Cincinnati’s liking. Justin Upton, Josh Willingham, and even B.J. Upton might be beyond the Pirates’ means, but if Boston decides to sell, impending free agent Cody Ross could solve Pittsburgh’s corner conundrum.

​A version of this story originally appeared on ESPN Insider Insider.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
I wonder if the Giants couldn't upgrade at 2nd by just promoting Brock Bond. He has never been seen as much of a prospect but all the guy has done is get on base at every level in the minors, even in the Eastern league where most Giants 'prospects' have struggled. With a career minor league OBP of .408 and .418 at Fresno this year, could he really be that much worse than Theriot? On the other hand, he hasn't been playing much 2nd base since getting smacked in the head by a line drive and losing most of a year to a concussion, so maybe that is the issue.
Is Stephen Drew a possible upgrade for the Pirates at SS? The Diamondbacks have certainly made it clear they aren't happy with him and will move him if possible.
Stephen Drew is a mystery wrapped in an enigma inside a riddle... whatever. He has to be a very serious disappointment to himself and the Snakes. Is he as fragile as his brother? Just a career underachiever? At this stage, he could be a Change of Scenery candidate for breakout, his talent is still there, but the hard facts don't give you much to hang that dream on.
I don't see how a Santana for Hellickson trade helps the Indians. Even with Santana's batting average woes he has a WARP of 2, while Hellickson is actually at negative value this year while his swinging strike rate has dropped to below average.
He may not be Major League Baseball's most loveable GM, but Dan Duquette is in an unfortunate jam. Baltimore's fundamental pitching, hitting and fielding numbers -- all near the bottom of the league -- don't portend well for the Orioles' ability to sustain their tilt at contention. If anything, Duquette should be shopping Wilson Betemit and Luis Ayala (and praying for a bounce from Brian Roberts). Thanks to a win-starved fan base and meddling ownership, though, it won't be surprising to see him have to make one more (and more prospect-costly) Jim Thome-type deal before the chariot turns back into a pumpkin.
No matter what the underlying numbers show, the Orioles are 2.5 games out of a wild card spot as I write this, and it would be politically untenable for the Orioles to go into selling mode. And on occasion the chariot does not turn back into a pumpkin.

That said, it would be smart for the O's to be realize they are playing over their heads at least a bit, and plan any last minute acquisitions accordingly.
This is terrific! From this article, I infer that the Indians have no weaknesses to address!

(Wait, what do you mean, "wrong message?")
Fair point on Barmes' good glove and weak stick and, while it's true Jack Wilson could fairly be described the same way, Wilson nearly always hit well enough to carry that glove. Both bat and glove, most years, were better than what Barmes has brought this year. That said, I don't see the Pirates replacing Barmes with anyone other than his understudy, Jordy Mercer, who hit pretty well in AAA and has done well with the glove in his limited play.
Let me try to solve the A's 3B problem:

Trade Dan Straily, Sean Doolittle, and Fautino De Los Santos to the NY Mets for Daniel Murphy, Jon Rauch, Tim Byrdak, and whatever money it takes to pay off Rauch.