What a difference a year makes? Last offseason, the Brewers traded top prospect Brett Lawrie to the Blue Jays for Shaun Marcum. This offseason, the Jays had the opportunity to flip Lawrie to the Mariners for Michael Pineda—and, according to Jeff Blair of The Globe and Mail, they turned it down.

Pineda was later traded to the Yankees in a four-player deal also involving Jesus Montero, Hector Noesi, and Jose Campos. But the more interesting fallout here appears to be the change in Lawrie’s value. Marcum is a nice pitcher, to be sure—he was worth 2.9 WARP last season—but he does not have Pineda’s upside, and while Marcum came with just two years of control remaining at the time of the trade, Pineda still has five.

The Brewers’ decision to trade Lawrie was driven partly by a feeling within the organization that a “bad attitude” would prevent him from reaching his sky-high potential. Lawrie silenced many of those critics by hitting .293/.373/.580 in 171 big-league plate appearances as a 21-year-old last year. He also showed improved defense at third base, enough to make scouts who previously projected a move to right field believe that he may stick at the hot corner long-term.

All of that contributed to Lawrie’s newfound status as one of the most untouchable players in the league. Of course, before Brian Cashman turned ninja to pull off the aforementioned deal with the Mariners, most assumed that Pineda was as tethered to Seattle as Lawrie was to Toronto.

Hindsight is 20/20, but after committing $36 million over three years to Aramis Ramirez, it’s easy to wonder if Doug Melvin regrets dealing Lawrie for Marcum. Assuming the change of scenery is not what fueled Lawrie’s improvement, those resources could have been used to improve other parts of the Brewers’ roster. Or, Lawrie could have been used to acquire a controllable pitcher like Pineda, to anchor Milwaukee’s rotation if Zack Greinke leaves in free agency next winter.

In the end, this looks more like a shrewd decision by Alex Anthopoulos to buy low on Lawrie, coming off a 797 OPS campaign in Double-A, than an obvious mistake by Melvin. Marcum’s contributions last season helped the Brewers win their first division title since 1982, though that memorable run now comes at the cost of one of the best young players in the game. 

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
Far too early to call it a mistake by Melvin. It's too early to know whether Lawrie will be as much of a star as .953 OPS at age 21 usually would portend. But even if he does turn out to be brilliant, Melvin can only be judged by what he could know at the time of the trade, and what his biggest needs looked like. 3B looked like it would be OK with McGehee for a couple of years, and the outfield corners were also set. The rotation was very needy. the need to win immediately lowered the value of prospects to Milwaukee. Even if a trade works out poorly in the long run, it doesn't mean it was a bad decision.
Lawrie's star is brighter now than it was at the time of the trade. At the time, he looked very good but not yet great offensively in AA, his defense at 2B was in question (and he didn't want to play there), with many observers anticipating a move to a corner OF position, and there were doubts about his makeup.

Obviously, a great job by AA to see Lawrie's promise and to make what was a pretty bold move at the time (one-for-one deal, no other prospects to turn to if Lawrie failed to pan out).
It's a trade: you don't get something without giving something up. Acquiring Marcum looked great at the time. Marcum pitched well before the break and faltered in September. Lawrie broke out. We'll see what 2012 holds.
I'm going to take all the playoff games I went to last year instead of Lawrie in a Brewer's uni. I had way too much fun.
I say the same thing. Oh wait, I'm a Mets fan. I'm going to take, uh, this pile of coupons and Victor Zambrano Cy Young trophies for Scott Kazmir's lifetime WARP