When writers make lists of the best pitches in baseball, the list usually goes something like this:

1. (Go-to pitch of best pitcher in baseball)
2. (Mariano Rivera’s cutter)
3. (Go-to pitch of second-best pitcher in baseball)
4. (Go-to pitch of third-best pitcher in baseball)
5. (Go-to pitch of fourth-best pitcher in baseball)

Sometimes the order gets scrambled, but the premise stays the same. There’s nothing wrong with this. If you were doing a list of the best swings in baseball, you’d end up with five of the best hitters. Otherwise, what would be the point? If you were doing a list of the best handclaps in pop music, you’d end up with super awesome songs by famous artists, not some forgettable band with truly spectacular handclapping. What I’m saying is, it’s not a surprise that “Javier Lopez’ drop-down delivery” doesn’t show up on these lists.

It shows up on my list, though. My list isn’t the best pitches in baseball. It’s just Three Pitches That Are Interesting To Talk About.

1. Javier Lopez’ drop-down delivery.
Javier Lopez doesn’t have much to work with. He throws 88 mph. His changeup is lousy. He controls his slider well, but it doesn’t have the sort of bite to get swings and misses. Right-handers have a .379 OBP against him in his career. But what Lopez can do is throw the ball from, roughly, the Doggy Diner Grill Cart behind section 105. This is Javier Lopez’ 2011 release-point chart, via Joe Lefkowitz:

Lopez’ average release point—about four feet above the ground, and four feet from center—is the most extreme for any left-hander who got significant playing time in 2011. But that average release point isn’t what I love about Lopez. It’s that whole subset of pitches that are off the PITCHf/x chart entirely. Like this one:

Thirty-five times this year, Lopez’ release point was at least 3.95 feet away from center and within 3.5 feet of the ground. He threw 57 such pitches in 2010. (He dropped down before that, too, but not as far, according to PITCHf/x.) Obviously, 92 pitches isn’t anywhere close to enough to be drawing conclusions. It’s the equivalent of about 25 batters, or one start. Javier Lopez’ drop-down delivery has made one start. So take this in the spirit of amusement, not analysis, a disclaimer that you should add to every sentence of the rest of this piece. Here is how Javier Lopez’ drop-down-delivery start went:

  • In the equivalent of one start, Lopez allowed 20 balls to be put in play: 18 outs (11 groundouts, six flyouts, one lineout) and two singles (both grounders).
  • In the equivalent of one start, Lopez got 47 strikes, whether called (16), fouled (22) or whiffed (nine). And he threw 25 balls, including one hit batsman.

On a per-pitch basis, here are his results compared to Roy Halladay’s cutter, a commonly cited Best Pitch In Baseball.

Two things: Holy cow Roy Halladay’s cutter. And holy cow Javier Lopez.

I would never argue that Lopez’ pitch is as good as Halladay’s. If I did argue that, I would do it with letters cut out of magazines, like a ransom note, so nobody would know it was me. The sample doesn’t give us nearly enough evidence to conclude anything, for starters. And if Lopez’ pitch was that good, he’d be able to throw it more than once per outing. If Lopez’ pitch was that good, Lopez would be a lot better. It’s effective precisely because he goes to it once per outing. It’s crazy effective, though.

2. Brad Lidge’s slider.
Over the past four seasons, one thing has happened to Brad Lidge, and another thing has, surprisingly, not happened to Brad Lidge.

His fastball velocity has done this:

While his strikeout rate has done this:

He’s been able to do this by throwing sliders 72 percent of the time, according to both Baseball Info Solutions pitch classifications and PITCHf/x. Or, I should say this, he has been able to do this while throwing sliders 72 percent of the time, and maybe those facts are related, but I’m not going to go all the way there. Seventy-two percent is the highest slider rate that BIS has recorded in its decade of classifying pitches; only Jeff Nelson in 2005 topped 70 percent. (Coincidentally, David Gassko in 2010 used game theory to try to calculate how often Lidge should throw his slider and came up with 50 percent. But that was without factoring in Lidge’s deteriorating skills.)

In September, Lidge threw 77 percent sliders, according to PITCHf/x. On September 4, he threw 12 sliders in a row. That’s just amazing, whether it’s a good strategy or not. It just shouldn’t be possible, and yet Lidge struck out more than a quarter of the batters he faced in September and allowed one run that month.

Throwing so many sliders has also, as you would expect, cost him a lot of walks, because his slider is a high-whiff pitch that is mostly thrown outside the strike zone. And, as you would also expect, throwing so many sliders has coincided with each individual slider being less effective. Compared to 2008, when he threw his slider about half the time, Lidge’s slider is more often taken for a ball (35 percent in 2011; 33 percent in 2008), less often missed when swung at (41 percent to 51 percent) and less often converted into an out when it is hit (66 percent to 74 percent). Of course, his slider has also lost four mph of velocity, so it could just be that it’s not as good as it used to be. Or it could be that we’re talking about a pointlessly small sample. For entertainment purposes only!

3. Henry Rodriguezchangeup.
Since 1989, around the time relief specialism took over, 13 pitchers—mostly lefties—have faced 60 left-handers in a season without allowing an extra-base hit. Henry Rodriguez, a right-hander, did it in 2011. The 127 left-handed batters he faced are the most of any of the 13. Which is why this is about Henry Rodriguez’ changeup, not Henry Rodriguez’ fastball, which is already famous.

Rodriguez had a pretty typical platoon split as a prospect. Righties hit about .195/.300/.290 against him in the minors. Lefties hit about .265/.390/.420. Rodriguez has had a changeup all along—Kevin Goldstein noted he had a good feel for it as far back as 2007—but when he came up to the majors in 2009 and 2010, he almost never threw it. In 2011, he used it a ton—every fourth pitch to lefties, a total of 117. Of those, the batters swung at 67. Of those, they whiffed on 36. That’s a higher whiff rate than Tim Lincecum and Cole Hamels get on their changeups; about the same as Ryan Madson. (He threw it just three times to right-handers, according to PITCHf/x. All for balls.)

Here’s a choppy GIF of Rodriguez facing Joey Votto in August. The at-bat lasted three pitches:

Those are all changeups.

He doesn’t control it so well, though, so a) he doesn’t get a great strike rate on it, despite all those swings and misses and b) he actually wasn’t all that dominant against left-handers this year. Despite an isolated power of zero, lefties hit .238/.370/.238 against him, with 20 walks and 19 strikeouts. If I had started this piece by saying I was going to talk about Henry Rodriguez’ changeup, which helped lefties post a .370 on-base percentage, you wouldn’t have read this far. You may not have actually read this far anyway. You may still be listening to those handclap songs. What the heck, here’s another.

Sam Miller also writes for the Orange County Register.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
This was a fun article. I know that Henry Rodriguez frequently touches triple digits with his fastball. Is it safe to assume that he has the fastest changeup in the majors?
Way fun article indeed. Thanks. I enjoy the mixed media and the kind of discovery I couldn't/wouldn't make on my own time. I'd enjoy another couple/few of these.
What he said.
Yeah, it looks like Sam is now a regular here - not just a special guest writer. Three cheers!
Yes, Sam is one of us now. One of us, one of us!
Thoroughly enjoyable article.
Yes, more please. [sound of applause clap]
I'm posting to add to the praise.
Great article.

I kind of hate Tom Petty, but on the other hand (oops) it seems a little odd to do a survey of hand-clapping in songs and leave out "Jack and Diane."
And "Jack and Diane" is actually by John Mellencamp. I don't really like him either, but I guess I'm a moron.
Tom Petty has some fine hand-clapping, too. American Girl, for instance.
This reminds me of that time I did that funny thing and my grandpa took me aside and said, "Son, you ain't no Sam Miller." Sure, he was drunk and referring to his cocker spaniel of the same name pooping in the cooler, but the point still stands.
I'm fascinated to know about the outlier point of Lopez that looks like he may have thrown the ball with his right hand.