When folks discuss Game 4 of the Rays/Rangers Divisional Series in 10 years, the three main points of discussion will be, in some order: 1) the Rangers advancing to their second-straight Championship Series with a victory, 2) Adrian Beltre hitting three home runs, and 3) Matt Harrison borrowing Cliff Lee’s strikeout rate. 

Postseason experience is supposed to be vital, but in reality, it is nothing more than an example of the availability heuristic. Because something has happened before, you can imagine it happening again. Beltre had the opportunity to pull off the home run hat trick in a playoff game before, but he only had four games of playoff experience coming into the series, and that was back in 2004. The world is an unjust place, and as such, none of the six Octobers since have featured Beltre. Until Beltre assaulted the Green Monster and pitching alike, the general perception of him included the term “tease”. This because Beltre seemingly reached his career’s apex during that 2004 season when he belted 48 home runs while playing a Glove Glove-worthy third base and hitting inside of a pitcher’s paradise. At least, that was Beltre’s reputation when people thought rationally of him, and people stopped thinking about him after he signed with the Mariners and disappeared into the Seattle mist.

Not all reactions were rational, and some were downright malicious, like the steroid accusations and the various ugly terminology thrown his way during his time in Seattle. Why is it that a baseball player perceived as an underachiever brings out the worst in people? Is it the pursuit of statistical porn, of a fantasy baseball messiah, or just the hunt for the next generational talent? Whatever the reasoning, Beltre’s world-conquering tour in 2010 created a new set of slams against him. Now, he was not a cheater but simply a player who would not get into shape or maintain focus throughout the season unless his contract expired at season’s end. Appropriately, the people who lobbed those attacks disappeared once Belre posted the second-highest True Average of his career in 2011, and to think, he will not be a free agent until after the 2015 season at the earliest. 

There was a moment during Game 4 where one could detect a perceived slight. After Beltre hit his first home run, one of the announcers suggested his role was to serve as a good complimentary player to the likes of Michael Young and the other good hitters the Rangers possess—the four Longorias, if you will. Beltre then hit another home run and nobody made the comparison. After Beltre’s third home run on the day, the only comparison being made was to a select group that includes Babe Ruth, George Brett, Reggie Jackson, and Adam Kennedy—the only other players to hit three homers in a postseason game. Beltre had an opportunity at a fourth home run, but for the first time all day took a swing that did not end with a trot. As impressive as the quantity was the quality of pitches Beltre took out. The chart below sheds more light on the pitch details, but each came on a home run at various speeds, locations, and sequences during an at-bat. This was not a situation where Beltre just waited for an unsuspecting pitcher to toss a fastball into a designated zone but rather a good display of plate coverage and striking the ball well.

Home Run Number


Pitch of the At-Bat


90 mph fastball up-and-in



91 mph fastball middle-away



93 mph fastball middle-up


The final score read 4-3 Texas but not before Beltre added one more defensive gem to his expansive collection. The Rangers, with all their firepower and good hitters, needed every one of Beltre’s home runs to ensure victory in their biggest win of the season—fittingly, perhaps, since Beltre was on the cusp of becoming a household name the last time he danced with October, and with this latest waltz, he is.

  • As for Harrison, he only lasted five innings but struck out nine and allowed two runs. Elvis Andrus, Jarrod Saltalamacchia, and Neftali Feliz get more attention—and in most cases, rightfully so—but Harrison had a nice season himself.
  • Also worthy of praise is Ian Kinsler. Although Beltre stole the show, Kinsler homered on the second pitch of the game—a hanging Jeremy Hellickson changeup—to give the Rangers an early 1-0 lead.
  • Baseball’s new whiff kid Matt Moore made his second appearance of the series. This time, Moore went three innings, fanned two, walked one, and allowed a home run to Beltre.
  • Meanwhile, the Rays old new whiff kid Jeremy Hellickson lasted just four innings, yielding three runs on three home runs. Game 4 marked the first time in Hellickson’s career he allowed three or more home runs in a start.
  • Outside of the home runs, the highlight of the game will be Sean Rodriguez scoring from first on a Matt Joyce hit by colliding with Mike Napoli and jarring the ball free. There is some question as to whether Rodriguez ever touched the plate, but the Rangers did not seem to notice.
  • While the Rangers are the first team to advance to the League Championship Series, they could find out who their opponent will be as soon as tonight, as the Yankees and Tigers will play Game 4 of their series at 8:30 PM. The scheduled starting pitchers are Rick Porcello and A.J. Burnett, and TBS will televise it.
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
Am I a party pooper if I argue that nobody will discuss this series in 10 years?
10 years? I wont be discussing it tomorrow
I'll be discussing it in ten years, so yes - you are a party pooper. :-)

Baseball Prospectus uses cookies on this website. They help us to understand how you use our website, which allows us to provide an improved browsing experience. Cookies are stored locally on your computer or mobile device and not by BP. To accept cookies continue browsing as normal. You will see this message only once. Privacy Policy

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. See the BP Cookie Policy for more information. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.