Baseball Prospectus Needs Your Help! Check out our call for contributors!

Yesterday, the Braves, Indians, and Diamondbacks took an important first
step towards advancing by winning the opening game of their respective
series. How big a step? In the 24 Division Series played to date, the winner
of the first game has gone on to win 16 times. That’s two-thirds of the
time, 66.7%.

The biggest story, of course, is the Indians, who upset the 116-46 Mariners
in Seattle behind Bartolo Colon‘s eight shutout innings. The Braves
also won on the road, thanks to a Chipper Jones three-run home run.
thought the Indians had a shot to steal their series
, and winning yesterday
puts history on their side: teams that open the Division Series with a road
win are 7-3.

Looking back a bit further, teams that opened with a win in the five-game
League Championship Series (1969-1984) were 22-10. Teams that opened with a
road win were 11-4.

Let’s put those together to see, independent of team quality, how the
Mariners/Indians (and Braves/Astros) series changed yesterday. The following
table covers all MLB five-game postseason series (save the 1981 first

                 Road Team            Home Team
               Wins Game One        Wins Game One

1969-1984 11-4, .733 11-6, .647 1995-2000 7-3, .700 11-5, .688

Total 18-7, .720 22-11, .667

Had the Mariners won yesterday, history would give them a two-thirds chance
of winning the five-game series. Now, having lost, they’re staring at
bucking a serious trend: more than seven times out of ten, a home team that
loses the first game goes back home to stay within a week.

This isn’t a perfect tool–I mean, teams that win at least 114 games are 1-0
in Division Series play–but it does indicate just how important that win
was for the Indians.

Joe Sheehan is an author of Baseball Prospectus. You can contact him by
clicking here.

Thank you for reading

This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.

Subscribe now
You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe