With the major-league trading deadline right around the corner, it is safe to say that we are going to soon find ourselves immersed in rumor after rumor, proposed trade after proposed trade, and we will love every single minute of it. Cliff Lee can no longer be had after the Rangers executed what felt like the baseball equivalent of a last-second eBay sniping, but there are still a bevy of potential playoff contenders with starting pitching improvements on their radar. Even though Lee is off of the table, these teams can still bolster their starting staff, be it through impact toward the middle in the form of Ted Lilly, or the removal of waste at the back end by adding the likes of Jeremy Guthrie.
One name that remains rather interesting is Roy Oswalt, the beleaguered face of the Astros, who has seemingly reminded everyone listening each and every week that he would waive his no-trade clause to join a team that matters either now or into the future. I half-expect to wake up each morning to find out that Oswalt is now willing to accept a trade to Japan, the independent leagues, or whatever softball team Eric Byrnes currently rakes for, just to get out of the miserable situation in Houston. But will he actually be traded this year?
He needs to be traded this year, to really help his current employer, but it is a wonky situation for sure. The Astros are in dire straits as far as their farm system goes, and they lack impact talent at the major-league level capable of netting minor-league depth in a fire sale. In other words, they don’t even have what it takes to start the rebuilding phase they needed to start four years ago. In Oswalt they have an asset that could conceivably extract a good amount of talent from an acquiring team in return, but a huge roadblock apparently exists in the mind of owner Drayton McLane, who still values the righty as if this was the 2005 season.
Contractually, Oswalt will make $15 million this year and $16 million next, with a club option worth $16 million for the 2012 campaign that comes attached to a $2 million buyout. Given that the season is past the halfway point at its current juncture, an acquiring team could be responsible for $24-25 million, given the remainder of his 2010 salary, the entirety of what he is owed in 2011, and the buyout prior to the 2012 season. If it decides to hold onto Oswalt, we are talking about a potential $40 million commitment over the next 2 1/2 seasons. On top of that, because of the situation in which the Astros currently find themselves, you can see how they'd expect a good amount of minor-league talent to be sent their way to make the trade worthwhile.
Put yourselves in the shoes of one of the contending teams looking to improve their rotation. Do you really think it prudent to absorb that hefty a financial commitment for Oswalt and part with potential major-league talent of the future? It seems to me to be one of those one-or-the-other type of trades, where the acquiring team either gives up plenty of talent while the Astros pay a decent portion of Oswalt’s salary, or the acquiring team takes on all of the remaining salary but does not part ways with much in the talent department. I would find it very hard to believe that too many teams are going to line up to trade away their talent and pay that salary.
McLane could help matters by kicking in enough of Oswalt’s salary to entice a return more commensurate with how he values Oswalt, but he has previously alluded to the idea that such kick-ins went against his grain. Perhaps the dire nature of the situation has helped to change his mind recently, because the Astros are not going to improve themselves without a very good return, which will not be achieved if a team has to pay Oswalt’s entire remaining salary. One thing to keep in mind is that Oswalt is still a very good pitcher, and if his first-half resurgence is any indication, he could certainly have an impact on the playoff picture down the stretch.
But here is where the situation gets even more interesting: the teams that could utilize his services the most do not necessarily have what it would or should take to pry Oswalt away. To that end, I tried to identify several teams who might be in the hunt, in order to propose some potential trades. This way, we can more readily visualize what could be heading the Astros' way as opposed to the blanket suggestion that they trade the pitcher for prospects. The teams that could use another front-of-the-rotation pitcher but could also conceivably make a move are the White Sox, Twins, Mets, and Red Sox. Resisting middle-relief jokes, with who would these teams have to part with to get Ed Wade to pull the trigger? Assume that the Astros would add $8-10 million to the deal.
White Sox trade Dayan Viciedo, Brent Morel, and David Holmberg: Ken Williams might be the most creative general manager in the league, what with his absorption of Alex Rios’ contract for nothing tangible in return, or with the blockbuster deal involving Jake Peavy that seemingly came out of nowhere. A month ago the White Sox would not even have been mentioned in the same breath as a trade to sure up a potential playoff rotation, but after going 26-5 in their last 31 games the Sox are atop the AL Central. They may have been playing over their heads, but an acquisition of Oswalt could serve as a counteractive measure against regression.
Viciedo would be the centerpiece of this deal from the Astros' point of view. The Cuban defector had a mediocre rookie season in Double-A last season, but a .290/.329/.525 showing at Triple-A Charlotte this season proved worthy of a major-league call-up toward the end of June. Since entering The Show, he isn’t lighting the world on fire, but he has become a regular in the lineup at the hot corner. Realistically, he isn’t good enough in the field to man the position, and likely has a shift to first base in his future. At just 21 years old, he could blossom into a very nice hitter, and while he won’t make Astros fans forget Jeff Bagwell, he could certainly make them forget that they actually used Pedro Feliz at the position for part of the season. This deal would be contingent upon the Sox re-signing Paul Konerko; if the veteran departs, Viciedo would make a ready replacement.
In Morel the Astros would get a third baseman who can play the position in case the Chris Johnson experiment fails. He is a good hitter with gap power who gets good marks for his makeup. He won’t make a huge impact in the major leagues, but he is still a worthwhile piece, as he has very few weaknesses, even if his strengths aren’t that strong. Holmberg was drafted in the second round last year out of high school and what the lefty hurler lacks in pure stuff he is known to make up with in polish. He has a plus curveball and consistently hits the low 90s with his heater. His rookie league numbers over the last two seasons have not been insanely impressive, but the potential is there.
Mets trade Fernando Martinez, Kirk Nieuwenhuis, and Reese Havens: Martinez is one of those prospects given a free pass due to several caveats, such as consistently being three or four years younger than his competition or suffering from injuries, but as our comment in the most recent annual suggests, at some point, the guy has to start hitting, excuses or not. He is still young enough to make an impact in the majors, but his .258/.320/.429 line pales in comparison to the .290/.337/.540 he displayed before suffering a knee injury last season. He is only 21 years old, so it would be premature to say he will never work out, but if the Mets are starting to sour on the speedy outfielder, it would behoove them to try and use his past reputation in an Oswalt deal.
Nieuwenhuis, appropriately nicknamed Captain Kirk, has good range in the outfield even if his future isn’t necessarily as a center fielder. Scouts say he has a big-league body, which is to say that when you look at him, he has the look of a major-league player. After a .282/.364/.479 showing at Hi-A St. Lucie and Double-A Binghamton last year, he has put up a .306/.348/.541 line in Binghamton this year. Add the hitting skills to the defensive chops, and you have an outfielder perhaps without the upside of Martinez, but with much less of the downside.
Havens entered the system as a shortstop but has since shifted to the keystone. That isn’t the only aspect of his game that has changed, as he has also altered his swing, leading to improved results. He is currently hitting .312/.386/.592 overall, with a .338/.400/.662 line since being promoted to Binghamton. Havens isn’t very fast and his defensive skills are nothing to write home about, but solid plate discipline in addition to the power at what is perceived to be a less powerful position earns him extra points.
Red Sox trade Lars Anderson, Ryan Kalish, and Drake Britton: While I immediately think of the character Lars from the film Heavyweights whenever I hear the name of the first prospect listed above, Anderson has fallen quite a bit since being labeled the Red Sox's top prospect entering the 2009 season. A back injury and perhaps nerves led to a sub-par second half, and while his .261/.354/.449 line represents an improvement from a year ago, it does not exactly scream big-league success. After all, when a first baseman hits like Lyle Overbay in Double-A, what can be expected in the majors? He wasn’t touted so highly for no reason, however, and would be a worthwhile acquisition for the talent-sapped Astros.
In Britton the Astros would be taking on risk with upside, as he is a southpaw currently rehabbing, but who can dial it up to 96 mph on the radar gun. Kalish is a much more polished player, and after hitting .302/.384/.561 in the second half of last season, he has split time at Double-A Portland and Triple-A Pawtucket this season, hitting a Willingham-like .307/.405/.502. A very solid base-stealer, Kalish could turn out to be a 20-20 player with more upside than Hunter Pence.
Twins trade Ben Revere, Joe Benson, and David Bromberg: It’s easy to suggest that the Twins could offer a package centered around Wilson Ramos to extract Oswalt, given that the Mauer-blocked catcher was reportedly the centerpiece of a purported Cliff Lee deal, but the one position at which the Astros have a decent prospect is behind the plate with Jason Castro. As the Rangers have shown recently, you can never have enough catching prospects, but the deal above would leave Ramos in the system while offering the Astros a variety of talent.
Revere is a very raw outfielder, with plenty of speed and range, the ability to hit to all fields, and plate discipline good enough to avoid strikeouts while sustaining a high on-base percentage. He hasn’t offered much in the power department lately, but at worst he could turn into a Michael Bourn clone when the current Astros center fielder becomes too expensive for what he brings to the table.
Benson is another center fielder with tools aplenty, but one who comes with question marks. The biggest question has been answered with his performance so far, as scouts were unsure of his power. Currently hitting .266/.354/.553 combined between time spent at Double-A New Britain and high-A Fort Myers, power has certainly been on display. Much as is the case with Martinez and Nieuwenhuis with the Mets, one member of this duo has much more upside than the other, while the other member offers much less downside.
Bromberg, despite leading just about every league in which he has pitched in strikeouts, is another of the prototypical Twins pitching prospects, someone armed with deception, solid off-speed offerings and pitching savvy to make up for a lack of pure stuff. Regardless, pitchers don’t consistently miss bats without reason and, again, to a system devoid of talent, even a pitcher that projects as a third or fourth starter is appetizing.
Where Will He Go?
Which of the above deals would make you pull the trigger? Are there other teams or players that could be included?
Thank you for reading
This is a free article. If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to Baseball Prospectus. Subscriptions support ongoing public baseball research and analysis in an increasingly proprietary environment.Subscribe now