keyboard_arrow_uptop

Last weekend, I posted a few trivia questions on Twitter, the type that anyone could look up but which would be more fun to answer without the help of a statistics site. The one that went unanswered for a longer than expected period of time involved naming the only National League hitter who, at the time, had 100 or more plate appearances, a slugging percentage above .500, but an on-base percentage south of .300. Forgive the slight tangent, but we need to come up with the OBP version of batting average’s Mendoza Line. Would the “Jacobs Line” work?

Anywho, the answer was none other than Mets legend Rod Barajas. On June 5, Barajas boasted a .261/.283/.529 slash line, displaying plenty of power while rarely reaching base. As of June 9, the catcher’s numbers sat at .261/.282/.521, with 11 home runs and four walks. Four. That isn’t a typo. His odd slash line got me wondering about how often a player finishes a season as a member of the .300/.500 club, while receiving a decent amount of playing time. Players with such poor rates of reaching base are unlikely to remain in the lineup for an entire season, but if they can absolutely mash, 400 or more trips to the plate isn’t exactly out of the question.

From 1954-onward, there are only six players to match these criteria:

 

 

NAME

YEAR

BA/OBP/SLG

TAv

Dave Kingman

1976

.238/.286/.506

.283

Mike Jacobs

2008

.247/.299/.514

.272

Tony Armas

1985

.265/.298/.514

.270

Cory Snyder

1986

.272/.299/.500

.267

Jesse Barfield

1983

.253/.296/.510

.260

Tony Clark

1996

.250/.299/.506

.256

 

Without even running the query I could have guessed both Dave Kingman and Mike Jacobs, but the other four would have been tougher to nail down. For his career, Kingman hit .236/.302/.478, coming eerily close to becoming a career member of the club. Jacobs is infamous around these parts for exemplifying the disconnect between the old-school and new-school ways of evaluating players, as his home run numbers look impressive but cannot compensate for the lack of skills elsewhere. Tony Armas finished his career with 251 home runs, hitting .252/.287/.453 over 14 seasons. Cory Snyder played in nine seasons, most of which were spent with the Cleveland Indians, finishing at a .247/.291/.425 clip. Given their career numbers, it really should not surprise anyone that their names surfaced in such a query.

Tony Clark and Jesse Barfield are a bit more interesting, as neither was an on-base luminary, but they managed career rates of .339 and .335, respectively. Scanning their career lines one can see that Clark came very close to appearing on this list multiple times despite sporting the highest career OBP of the club. In 2003, he hit .232/.300/.472; the next year, .221/.297/.458; and in 2003, .249/.310/.511. Barfield’s career told a different tale, as he joined this club in his second full season, and then proceeded to hit .264/.348/.476 over the next six seasons.

Curiously enough, even though only six players are members of this club given their single-season production, there are currently three major leaguers vying for membership at approximately the one-third mark of the season. Aside from Barajas, teammates Alex Gonzalez (.262/.297/.502) and John Buck (.250/.288/.500) of the Blue Jays are also in the hunt. It’s no wonder that such a high percentage of the Jays runs this year have come via the long ball. Both Gonzalez and Buck also have more homers than walks, which segues into a different look at the same situation: how many batters with 400 or more plate appearances have walloped more home runs than they walked?  That query produces a pretty penny in the results bin—107 players since 1954, to be exact. The table below shows the top 10 to achieve this feat, sorted by plate appearances.

 

 

NAME

YEAR

PA

HR

BB

Alfonso Soriano

2002

741

39

23

Garret Anderson

2001

704

28

27

Vinny Castilla

1998

697

46

40

Kirby Puckett

1988

691

24

23

Andres Galarraga

1996

691

47

40

Jeff Francoeur

2006

686

29

23

Alfonso Soriano

2005

682

36

33

Garret Anderson

2000

681

35

24

Tony Armas

1984

679

43

32

Vinny Castilla

1996

673

40

35

 

Only two of those players out-homered their walks total in 700 or more plate appearances: Alfonso Soriano, who had 39 homers and just 23 free passes in 2002, and Garret Anderson, he of the 28 home runs and 27 walks the year before. In fact, both players appear twice on this leaderboard and are ironically right next to each other each time. Castilla also shows up twice, and Armas reemerges from the prior list. Looking at some of the differences between the homers and walks, it is clear that a few barely made the cutoff. Anderson, for instance, only hit one more home run than free passes received in that 2001 campaign, and I suppose my interest in this regard lies more with players in Barajas’ current shoes; Rod has almost three times as many homers as walks.

Phrasing the question a bit differently, has anyone in the Retrosheet era amassed home runs at a rate meeting or exceeding twice the number of walks accrued, while stepping to the plate at least 400 times? The answer is a big fat no, as zero results were returned in the query. Lowering the HR/BB requirement to 1.5 times more dingers than slow trips to first, 13 player-seasons surfaced:

 

NAME

YEAR

PA

HR

BB

Alfonso Soriano

2002

741

39

23

Andre Dawson

1987

662

49

32

Dante Bichette

1995

612

40

22

Bengie Molina

2009

520

20

13

Bob Horner

1979

515

33

22

Shawon Dunston

1997

511

14

8

Juan Uribe

2006

495

21

13

Fred Whitfield

1965

492

26

16

Carlos Baerga

1994

469

19

10

Miguel Olivo

2006

452

16

9

Andres Galarraga

1994

449

31

19

Cory Snyder

1986

433

24

16

Wayne Nordhagen

1980

428

15

10

 

We still have another two-thirds of the season left in the tank, but as it currently stands a record-setting three players could join the .300/.500 club in the same season. And, to top it off, both Buck and Barajas are currently members of the 1.5 HR:BB club. It is very rare for players so relatively inept in terms of reaching base to consistently be given playing time, just as it is rare for players given so much playing time to consistently flirt with either of these clubs. In some cases it holds predictive value, and in others, like with Clark and Barfield, it could either be a random bad season or the start of a career. What makes things even funnier is that on base percentage counts home runs as times reaching base, meaning that players like Barajas, Buck and Gonzalez are truly boom or bust this year. Only time will tell if they can sustain their current clips all year, but at least this writer is pulling for them!

You need to be logged in to comment. Login or Subscribe
dianagramr
6/11
Over the weekend, I happened to notice this same quirk amongst the Jays, and did some research on their season. Going into Saturday's game, their gaudy, majors-leading .476 slugging percentage was tempered by a 23rd-best .248 team batting average. Their resulting ISO of .228 would be the highest season total for a team in at least 20 years.
fluffy
6/11
And how about people who have more triples than walks? I note that Julio Borbon (Texas) has three triples this year, and just nabbed his third walk on Thursday. Has anyone ever had more triples than walks with a substantial number of plate appearances? (Say 300 or so).
dianagramr
6/11
Only 2 players since 1900 had 300+ PAs, 3 or more triples and 3 or less walks in a year: http://bbref.com/pi/shareit/UQe9R
dianagramr
6/11
And here's the group with 300+ PAs, 10 or more 3Bs and 10 or fewer walks in a season: http://bbref.com/pi/shareit/kknNV
ckahrl
6/12
In other words, it's all pre-integration silliness, which makes Borbon's run at the feat all the more impressive.
acarlisle
6/11
You know, with all his swinging, Vlad Guerrero has never had a season (in which he had more than, say, 30 PA) with more HRs than walks. He hits a lot of home runs, too. I looked because I was surprised to not see him in the lists. This year, however, he has more HRs than walks. A lot of that is due to his walk rate plummeting over the last two years. Last year, he had a power drop that kept the numbers from flipping. This year, he's gotten his muscles back (or responds well to the new park), but he seems to have actually lost patience with age. scope, PA, HR/FB%, BB% career, 8070, 17.1, 8.6 two years ago, 600, 16.1, 8.5 last year, 407, 11.5, 4.7 this year, 204, 16.3, 4.1
taylorcp
6/11
I wonder if what was an undervaled skill OBP has now become an overvalued skill, relative to SLG, that is...
philosofool
6/11
I doubt it. Most crude evaluators use OPS these days, and OPS over-values slugging about 80%. 1.8*OBP+SLG gets you enough accuracy to be in the margin of error for tAV or wOBA.
rawagman
6/11
John Buck and Alex Gonzalez - two Jays. Rod Barajas - a former Jay. In fact, Buck was signed as Barajas' replacement, as J.P. Arencibia is not yet ready (and may be a great candidate for this list in years to come). Being a Blue Jays fan can be a strange and wondrous thing.
Kongos
6/11
Edwin Encarnacion (202/304/511) is just a strikeout or two from joining the club. I wouldn't be at all surprised to see the Jays with three of 'em at the end of the season.
dianagramr
6/11
More interesting about the Jays is the fact that for all the talk of the free-swinging ways imparted from their new hitting coach (Dwayne Murphy), Murphy's WORST BB% rate was 11.3% (rookie year) and his average rate was 14.3%.
rawagman
6/11
Do as I say, not as I did.
AutomatedTeller
6/11
An interesting way to view this might be to figure the league leaders in difference between SLG and OBP every year.
sensij
6/11
A new stat... OP-S?
onegameref
6/12
I would guess Big Cat and Vinny preferred to take their chances hacking in thin air than accepting more free passes. They liked to returns and increased pay.